Podchaser Logo
Home
The Comstock Act and Abortion

The Comstock Act and Abortion

Released Wednesday, 6th March 2024
Good episode? Give it some love!
The Comstock Act and Abortion

The Comstock Act and Abortion

The Comstock Act and Abortion

The Comstock Act and Abortion

Wednesday, 6th March 2024
Good episode? Give it some love!
Rate Episode

Episode Transcript

Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.

Use Ctrl + F to search

0:05

Hey, this is Anny and Samantha stuff.

0:07

I never told you production of iHeartRadio, and

0:19

today we are doing

0:21

an episode that was originally a Monday Mini

0:23

but it just got too big about

0:26

everything that's going on. Are some specific

0:28

things that are going on, excuse me, with abortion

0:31

in the United States recently in reproductive

0:33

rights in the United States, and a lot of it is changing

0:35

very rapidly. So today,

0:38

as we record this, the day is March

0:40

fifth, twenty twenty four.

0:43

I did write a lot of this about a week ago because again

0:45

I thought this was going to be a Monday Mini,

0:48

but I updated it today.

0:50

So is today sleeper Tuesday? Does

0:52

that mean things?

0:54

Does mean things? Oh?

0:57

Dear? Apparently get donuts.

0:59

But I think it's really important that I remember this voting

1:01

season, y'all, and this this should

1:03

impass. I think most of

1:05

our listeners already are on point, but just

1:08

a reminder.

1:09

This shows why it's so important because

1:12

a lot of this happened because Trump appointed

1:14

judges that did what he said.

1:15

They were going to do.

1:16

He's pretty much out ban abortion.

1:19

So YEAP voting

1:21

does matter. As frustrating as it can be

1:24

to hear that quick content warning,

1:27

there's going to be nothing to in depth but mentions

1:29

of rape and suicide. Also, this is a

1:31

very US focused episode,

1:34

but we would love to hear what is going on in

1:37

the US and around the world, because

1:39

you know, we're focusing kind of on

1:41

something pretty specific here, but

1:44

there's a there's a lot of ground that

1:46

we have been meaning to talk about and haven't.

1:49

Yeah, it's because of just scheduling and stuff. So

1:51

just let us know what's going on for you where you

1:54

are. And also, this is

1:56

a primer since it

1:58

was originally going to be a mini There's

2:01

a lot more we could go into with

2:04

all of this, because originally

2:06

I wanted to talk about the Comstock Act, but

2:10

it just became difficult to separate

2:12

that from everything else that's going

2:14

on and why we need to talk about the Comstock

2:17

Act. Okay, So, as

2:20

many of you probably heard, in February twenty twenty

2:22

four, the Alabama Supreme Court ruled that

2:24

frozen embryos count as children

2:27

essentially, Therefore, if

2:29

they are destroyed for whatever reason, people

2:31

can be tried for wrongful death of

2:34

this embryo. This decision obviously

2:36

has huge ramifications, and

2:38

it is part of a larger push for so

2:41

called fetal personhood.

2:44

I'm sorry that title just oh

2:46

my god. Yeah, it's so ridiculous

2:49

that you can't help, but like just scoff.

2:53

Yeah, Yeah, there's been a lot

2:55

of like you know, in the darkest

2:57

this dark time, there's been a lot of like those

3:00

that mean I can ride the carpool like

3:02

a lot.

3:03

Videos have been pretty priceless of like treating

3:08

little little embryo slash peachtree

3:11

dishes as as children.

3:14

Yes, right, but

3:17

states are going forward with this. Fourteen

3:20

states have introduced fetal

3:22

personhood pushes or

3:24

laws, and at least two have been enacted.

3:28

After this decision, Alabama's

3:30

fertility clinics were sent into

3:33

absolute chaos. Like legally, no one

3:35

was sure what was going on here. The

3:38

decision did use a lot of Western Christian

3:40

religious language, which is no surprise.

3:44

Companies have already stopped shipping

3:46

frozen embryos and multiple places have stopped

3:49

all IVF services

3:51

after this. And just

3:53

a reminder, all kinds of things

3:56

might cause someone to seek out IVF, including

3:58

infertility caused by cancer or a

4:01

bunch of other stuff, which I think is getting left

4:03

out a lot of some conversations,

4:05

but really it shouldn't matter that should just

4:07

be available to people. The case

4:09

was brought after some frozen embryos were

4:11

dropped and the potential parents in question

4:14

alleged that it constituted wrongful death. Essentially,

4:17

the parents in question had stopped

4:19

pursuing IVF,

4:22

but they wanted their embryos to stay frozen.

4:25

The patients somehow got into the freezer,

4:28

touched something and got like freezer burned

4:31

and knocked over some embryos.

4:32

And so the.

4:34

Parents' parents in this question

4:37

were suing

4:40

for wrongful death because of that.

4:42

Oh, so they themselves

4:44

over because they're not going to be able

4:46

to get the service at all. Yeah,

4:49

Oh,

4:51

they didn't.

4:52

They get through a lot of people didn't think things

4:54

through.

4:54

Which I feel like should be the tagline for

4:57

any of these flaws,

5:00

just saying they

5:02

didn't think this through. No, even

5:05

people haven't warned them, but they didn't.

5:08

No, sorry,

5:12

yes, Well, and then

5:15

it was so unpopular after this happened, and

5:18

people were freaking out rightfully so about

5:21

what it meant that even

5:23

Trump denounced it. A bunch

5:25

of other Republicans did too,

5:27

but these were like Trump appointed

5:30

judges that made the decision. Amy

5:33

Cony Barrett is on record supporting an organization

5:35

that agreed that embryo's constituted his people,

5:38

so again appointed by Trump. And

5:40

the sad fact is almost every Republican

5:42

supports IVF for certain

5:44

reasons. But they

5:47

allowed for this to happen and voted

5:49

for this, like they created the situation with

5:52

their extremist anti abortionarytoric,

5:54

like they the

5:56

environment they've been cultivating allowed

5:59

for this. And one

6:01

of the big issues, other than stripping people's rights

6:03

is just again, legally, how does this

6:05

look? Because

6:07

yeah, that means there's a

6:09

whole freezer of children, I guess,

6:12

And this means

6:14

that people have to pay to store

6:16

them forever.

6:18

Like, so what happens if I are

6:20

not viable?

6:21

We have to you have to keep them

6:24

so even.

6:24

Though they can never actually successfully

6:26

be Yes, true

6:28

fetuses like just women

6:30

are all going to be like we're all

6:33

about to be arrested.

6:35

I mean yes, because you and I were when we

6:37

were discussing this. We were talking

6:39

about which we'll talk about a bit more in a second. There's

6:43

already this push about using

6:46

contraceptives is killing

6:49

children. This could be

6:51

applied to so many other things.

6:55

And yes, from what I understand,

6:58

at least, how the law is now, which

7:00

they are trying to change

7:02

because they're all panicking again.

7:04

Didn't think it through that even

7:07

if you can't, you just can't throw away a

7:09

frozen embryo, it doesn't matter whatever

7:12

the case. So

7:14

that means that, yes, you have to pay for the storage

7:16

forever like it will pass on to the kids

7:19

like actual living kids around

7:22

their kids, And they

7:24

don't have an answer for what happens if the entire family

7:27

line dies out. If like that means the government has

7:29

to pay for them.

7:32

Yes, there have been

7:34

a lot of viral clips of conservatives who

7:37

championed this ruling realizing in real

7:39

time when they are saying that they

7:41

want more kids that A, I guess you have

7:43

them already a frozen embryos

7:45

count and that be This directly

7:47

negatively impacts IVF for people who are

7:49

actively trying for and desperately want kids.

7:52

So that's awful,

7:55

But that is only one piece of the damage here. There

7:58

are genetic tests that could be affected to some

8:00

providers will probably stop engaging in IVF

8:02

altogether because there is a risk of damaging embryos

8:05

in the process. And we are now talking about

8:07

a level of control and extremism that reveals

8:09

that, yeah, they don't know what they're talking about,

8:11

Like we've already known this, but this is very clear. But

8:14

apparently they're still realizing it, and

8:18

they they are

8:20

with the ones enabling this, and

8:23

they'll never change their tune because that's

8:25

just the problem with American politics, Like especially

8:28

for conservatives who have like held hands

8:30

with so many dangerous sex to get power,

8:32

even if their stances are largely

8:34

unpopular, right like, even if this

8:37

is largely unpopular.

8:39

You know, I'm wondering because we've talked about it in our Surrogacy

8:42

episode a little bit, but a lot

8:44

of these clinics are money makers, Like

8:46

this is, yeah, this is gonna hit

8:49

some businesses pretty

8:51

hard. I can't imagine

8:54

as pro capitalists, pro

8:57

money, pro corporation, that most

8:59

of these are publics are that

9:01

they're not going to get some real big like

9:03

pushback. Yeah the

9:06

money they're taking away.

9:08

Yeah, And we definitely are going

9:10

to talk about another example of that that is happening.

9:13

So I mean, don't

9:15

get me wrong, they are scrambling right now, but they're

9:17

trying to like they're

9:20

they're trying to walk this fine line of like,

9:22

oh well IVF for you know,

9:25

heterosexual couples

9:28

only for them, because then that's

9:30

good.

9:31

But otherwise no, But then.

9:35

What about the embryo though, because now you said

9:37

they're all people, they're all children.

9:40

Yeah,

9:52

all right, So one thing is IVF,

9:55

yes, is very expensive for

9:57

people who are seeking it out and really shouldn't

10:00

paused unless

10:02

that is what the patients want, like, but

10:04

if you want it to succeed, then it should be

10:07

paused, which is what is happening right

10:09

for people in Alabama.

10:10

Right as from MSNBC,

10:12

they say as a result of IVF, there are as

10:15

many as one point five million frozen

10:17

embryos in the country. The Alabama

10:19

decision might mean that some of these embryos

10:22

need to remain frozen forever, at

10:24

least until someone uses them. Otherwise,

10:28

anyone who destroys the embryos or even

10:30

uses them for research could face

10:32

claims for wrongful death and be

10:34

liable for millions of dollars

10:36

in damage.

10:38

Yeah, and infertility

10:40

impacts about fifteen percent of US couples,

10:42

So that's that's pretty big. As I said, infertility

10:46

is not the only reason people use IVF,

10:48

but that's still a pretty big number. And

10:51

yes, I have as I said, I did see a bunch

10:53

of quote like lighter questions of this

10:56

ruling, like if embryos count as

10:58

dependence now, like it just so many

11:00

impacts that clearly we're not considered.

11:03

So I mean, at what point can they

11:05

be charged? Can people be charged with abandonment?

11:07

And it's never going to be men? So right

11:10

then? Also it kind of says men are useless because

11:12

we can't even have children.

11:14

That's true, so men for

11:19

I'm sure that was not what they wanted.

11:21

That's what I'm going to take away from it. That's

11:23

the that's the highlight.

11:28

Well, as we've been mentioning, there has been

11:30

a really big pushback to this, including measures

11:32

proposed to protect IVF and Alabama like

11:35

this is ongoing right now, including

11:37

one that would quote provides civil and criminal

11:40

immunity to persons providing goods and services

11:42

related to in vitro fertilization except

11:44

acts or emission that are intentional

11:47

and not arising from or related

11:49

to IVF services, But

11:51

it does not correct the fundamental underlying

11:54

problem of fetal

11:57

personhood. I guess there's

12:00

states are following suit with this, including

12:02

Florida, but Florida's Paul's theirs. After

12:04

what happened in Alabama, and

12:07

it's really showcased just how tenuous access

12:09

to reproductive rights have been

12:12

after the overturning of Roe v. Wade, which

12:14

is what we were scared of, which is what we were saying.

12:18

This is part of that, and

12:20

now we are seeing something

12:23

else, and it is

12:25

the return of the Comstock Acts.

12:29

Yes, which I just remember today. A

12:31

villain in one of my favorite video games is named Comstock

12:34

and he's kind of like this, and now I'm.

12:36

Like, probablyless purposeful, probably

12:39

was, probably was.

12:41

The world he created was very bad. I

12:44

should tell you something. He

12:46

should be right up there together. I'm just kidding.

12:50

So, Yes, one of the chilling implications

12:52

of this and of

12:56

this conversation and conservative push

12:58

that has been going on for a while around productive

13:00

rights concerns the abortion pill and the

13:02

Comstock Acts, which some ultra conservatives

13:05

believe bans abortion on a federal

13:07

level already. So

13:09

what is the Comstock Act. It

13:11

is a nineteenth century anti vice

13:14

law that has now become the center of

13:16

an anti abortion push to ban the mailing

13:18

of abortion pills like mifipristone,

13:20

which is currently used in about half of all abortions

13:23

in the US. It was passed in eighteen

13:25

seventy three and was named after

13:27

a deeply religious anti vice crusader,

13:29

Anthony Comstock, who was reportedly

13:32

a serial masturbador and

13:34

definitely a racist, homophobic,

13:37

misogynist, And it was designed to prevent

13:39

the mailing of contraceptives quote

13:41

obscene, lewde, lascivious, indecent,

13:43

filthy or vile article, matter, thing,

13:46

device, or substance, and any quote

13:48

instrument, substance, drug, medicine, or

13:50

thing that could aid in an abortion, which

13:54

was expounded on in nineteen oh nine.

13:56

Right, I feel like this is one of those the calls coming

13:58

from inside the house, Joyce.

14:00

Yeah, but you know, okay.

14:03

So Comstock believed that the mere

14:05

existence of these things, and even nudity

14:07

and art was behind all

14:10

of society's ills. Again, he seems

14:12

to be flaming victims because he

14:14

yes, never mind and his own

14:16

perceived shortcomings. Yes, so they

14:19

made me sin. He had been quote

14:21

horrified by the amount of porn and

14:23

alcohol he saw his fellow soldiers

14:25

consume. As a Union

14:28

soldier, so he wanted it all

14:30

band to sanitize America.

14:34

But even at that time he was seen as

14:37

extreme. This was the Victorian

14:39

era. Just as a reminder, they

14:42

even had a word to make fun of

14:44

his intense views, Comstockery.

14:48

Yeah, so just to reiterate even

14:50

at that time they thought he was much.

14:52

Serial masturbator, which

14:54

they probably witnessed. Let's just be real

14:57

clear.

14:59

Yeah.

15:00

So this term consackery was first popularized

15:03

by George Bernard Shaw, and

15:05

it was sort of used by a lot of Europeans

15:07

to mock what they saw is American backwardness

15:09

and puritanical nature. So it was at first it

15:12

was like, what are those Americans doing

15:14

with their comstockery? But then people

15:16

start to use it in the US too.

15:19

So that's I wonder if he has family.

15:21

I hope they are ashamed. Oh no, I'm sorry. I don't

15:23

want but I don't know them. They're

15:26

sure, they're nice people, but I'm wondering they're like, why

15:28

the did he have to do this? And now our names?

15:31

Yeah, like caught up in this anyway. So

15:33

Comstock wrote in his book Traps

15:36

for the Young quote, the most infamous

15:38

scoundrel may send the violens matter

15:40

to the purest boy or girl. And this

15:42

is being done systematically, Oh

15:45

dear.

15:47

Yes, he was allegedly largely

15:49

influenced by the death of his mother and childbirth,

15:52

but he had no knowledge of women's

15:54

bodies, reproductive health, medicine,

15:56

etc. Uh So yeah.

16:00

Also of note, given some

16:02

of his previous quotes, not that I

16:04

think we should be putting too much stock in Comstock,

16:06

but he actually wouldn't have been opposed to legal

16:08

abortion. It was the quote

16:11

back alley heavy quotes abortions

16:13

he wanted to stop.

16:14

When he won abortions because if childbirth

16:17

was the reason she died, right,

16:20

not having a child.

16:21

I'm pretty sure he did

16:24

write about it, So I like, again, he

16:27

was not against abortion person

16:29

at large, just

16:32

what he viewed as.

16:35

Yeah again, heavy quotes back after abortion.

16:37

But however, he was against

16:39

the women's suffrage movement, surprise,

16:42

surprise. And this was a time

16:44

when a lot of things around gender rolls

16:46

in the US were in flux. Women

16:48

pressing for the fight to vote, fighting marital

16:50

rape and drunkenness with temperance, seeking

16:53

financial rights, all things that scared

16:55

people like Comstock when it came to

16:57

the stability of the family right.

17:01

Another big factor in this was that

17:03

generally speaking, abortion was legal in the US

17:05

until quote quickening are

17:08

when the pregnant person could feel a fetus move,

17:10

which was around four or five months. Prior

17:13

to that, it was generally accepted that pregnant folks

17:15

could make their own decision, usually

17:18

involving a midwife who was a woman. This

17:21

didn't sit well with typically

17:23

male physicians who wanted

17:25

that money, so they

17:27

wanted to drive women out of their profession and

17:29

consolidate their business make more

17:32

money. Another was another

17:34

fact is that Anglo Saxon women

17:36

white women weren't having as many babies, so you get

17:38

Comstock coming out of the woods, like, whoa,

17:46

that's my impression of Comstock, right.

17:48

Yeah.

17:49

Still, that didn't stop Comstock

17:51

from convincing Congress with a collection of

17:53

quote obscene items and materials that he

17:55

called his Chamber of Horrors

17:58

to pass the COMPS Acts,

18:00

and he was granted the role of special Agent at

18:03

the US Post Office so that he could

18:05

monitor the mail legally. Thousands

18:08

were prosecuted, subject to fines, jail

18:10

time, or labor. It could be for something

18:13

like a letter that you sent to your spouse. Some

18:15

died by suicide and one hundred

18:17

and sixty tons of literature was confiscated

18:20

and destroyed. This was something

18:22

he bragged about before he died. In nineteen

18:24

fifteen of notes towards like obscenity

18:27

were not defined and left to people like Comstock

18:29

to determine. Which is great, That's

18:32

just great.

18:32

I feel like this is a similar story to what's happening

18:34

with the Florida governor. Like

18:37

he's having to backtrack a little bit, and this

18:39

is his legend because he's the one that's doing the same

18:41

nonsense today.

18:45

You know what I'm saying, Like Desantas is doing

18:47

like we got to make sure

18:49

we were protecting our children. There's so many

18:51

obscenities, and now he's having to back up. We're like, well,

18:53

wha what It didn't mean this much. I'm just kidding because

18:55

he knows he's about to be placed in history

18:58

at this level.

19:00

Right, right, I mean

19:03

I hope so. But Comstart seemed

19:05

real proud of it.

19:06

Right. Maybe he's learning,

19:08

but but h.

19:22

In eighteen seventy eight, Comstock had

19:24

Madame Restell, a well known abortion

19:26

provider, arrested. She died by suicide,

19:30

and to do all this he worked with the police and

19:33

the YMCA, which formed the New

19:35

York Society for the Suppression of Vice

19:38

in part in order to enforce this act

19:40

and their logo literally features some man burning

19:42

books.

19:44

Again, I feel like that could be also

19:49

representation. So in nineteen

19:51

fifteen, reproductive rights activist

19:53

Mary where Dennett was charged with

19:55

violating the Comstock Act after distributing

19:58

pamphlets about sex education, even

20:00

though she included this quote. At

20:02

present, unfortunately, it is against

20:05

the law to give people information as to how

20:07

to manage their sex relations so that no

20:09

baby will be created. This

20:11

was overturned in a historic landmark free

20:13

speech case. Kind of good.

20:15

I want to come back to that because I was surprised.

20:18

I thought it was going to be a worse outcome. But yeah,

20:21

I want to come back to that. But just a note,

20:23

famous artworks and books like Ulysses were

20:25

subject to this act, and so Ulysses Americans

20:28

would like get it contraband from Europe

20:31

because it was like a hugely popular book and you couldn't

20:33

get it in the US because of this Comstock Act.

20:37

So it had a far reaching impact,

20:40

but it hasn't

20:42

really been enforced since the nineteen thirties

20:44

when judges argued that the language was way too

20:46

broad and could literally ban things like

20:48

surgical gloves. And then

20:51

in nineteen thirty six it was further

20:53

specified that the Comstock Act referred

20:55

only to illegal items used

20:57

for an abortion. In the seventies,

21:00

contraceptives was removed from

21:02

the language of the Acts.

21:03

And the passing of Roe v.

21:04

Wade basically rendered it inert. The

21:07

nineteen sixty five case Griswold

21:09

versus Connecticut had previously weakened

21:11

it, ruling that contraception was legal

21:13

for married couples because before

21:16

they could technically get prison time forgetting

21:18

it. So now

21:21

Roe v. Wade has been overturned and

21:23

a lot of these protections went away again.

21:26

Dobbs versus Jackson Women's Health Organization,

21:28

which led to rose overturning, was

21:30

mentioned in the Alabama court ruling about

21:33

IVF fifteen times.

21:35

Now, anti abortion crusaders are

21:37

looking to use Roe v. Wade not being

21:40

there to bring the Comstock

21:42

Acts back. In fact, after

21:44

Rose overturned, the Biden administration officially

21:47

released a memo saying the Comstock

21:49

Act does not apply to abortion bills,

21:51

which it doesn't like even as it is now

21:54

because they've updated it, but they're

21:56

still looking to change it and use it.

22:00

In April twenty twenty three, a federal judge

22:02

appointed by Trump and Texas ruled that

22:04

when the FDA approved mifipristone

22:06

two decades ago, they did so

22:09

illegally, pointing to what

22:11

they called serious safety concerns,

22:13

which he has is bull The Biden administration

22:16

and the judge. Manufacturer appealed,

22:18

we've talked about this before. At

22:20

the same time, a judge in Washington ruled

22:23

that the government must allow for access

22:25

to this drug. Attorney generals

22:27

and over twenty states have warned companies

22:30

like Walgreens and CBS they could

22:32

get in legal trouble if they mailed the drug.

22:35

The same judge from the Texas ruling Casmeric

22:38

claimed that fathers have

22:40

the constitutional right to control their daughter's

22:44

access to birth controls.

22:46

Which were the mother, even though the matriarch

22:49

is supposed to be raising the children.

22:51

Hey, it is very strange

22:54

from Fox who's a quote? Because

22:56

Marek has claimed that being transgender is

22:58

a quote mental disorder and that gay people

23:00

are disordered. In a twenty fifteen article,

23:03

he denounced a so called sexual revolution,

23:05

which sought public affirmation of

23:07

the lie that the human person is an

23:09

autonomous blob of silly putty, unconstrained

23:12

by nature our biology, and that marriage,

23:14

sexuality, gender identity, and even the

23:16

unborn child must yield to the erotic

23:18

desires of liberated adults.

23:21

So this is what we're talking about. The people who

23:23

are making these rulings here what

23:26

they think.

23:28

And for him to name children as like being

23:31

erotic for adults again, I'm like, I'm

23:33

really thinking you might be telling on yourself,

23:36

which is what we see too often.

23:39

We do, indeed, we do.

23:40

Indeed, So

23:43

that whole this whole thing started

23:46

after a drag fundraising event to

23:49

prevent LGBTQ plus suicide

23:51

was shut down and the students running the event sued,

23:53

saying it infringed on their First Amendment

23:56

free speech rights. But this judge

23:58

argued there was a historical legal

24:01

president against sexualized

24:03

speech, citing the Comstock Act.

24:06

YEP, a different guy

24:08

in Texas again this I

24:10

was like, this is a story for another episode. But

24:12

briefly, he led this charge to make

24:14

his city a quote sanctuary for the unborn

24:18

and twenty nineteen, which

24:20

was unanimously agreed upon amongst the all

24:22

male votees. As

24:25

part of the effort, he contacted attorney

24:27

Jonathan Mitchell and, according to Miss Magazine

24:30

quote, Mitchell submitted an amachust cure.

24:32

A friend of the court brief in Dabbs

24:34

on behalf of Texas Right to Life,

24:37

which he denied that women need access to

24:39

abortion in order to have control over their reproductive

24:41

lives, arguing instead that they can

24:43

simply refrain from having sex.

24:46

This was also a part of the whole bounty

24:48

hunter thing in Texas that rewards people

24:51

for reporting anyone even remotely potentially

24:53

involved in an abortion.

24:56

Yep.

24:58

The quote continues as

25:00

Mitchell expounded to a town commission meeting

25:02

in Edgewood, New Mexico. Such a victory

25:05

quote would be a defeat far more catastrophic

25:07

than dabs for the supporters of abortion access.

25:10

A ruling of that sort would effectively ban abortion

25:13

nationwide, making it possible for abortions

25:15

to be performed even in blue states, because

25:17

even though the Comstock law

25:20

does not ban abortion literally, it bans

25:22

the shipment or receipt of any abortion

25:24

related equipment. This ruling was limited

25:27

to mifipristone, but providers

25:29

did say that they would pivot to another drug,

25:32

misaprostol, if necessary, which is typically

25:34

prescribed for things like stomach ulcers but

25:36

can be used for abortions. Also

25:38

safe. However, it's also under

25:41

a threat.

25:41

Right so from the Guardian,

25:44

But in practice, a ban on sending

25:46

abortion tools through the mail or commercial

25:48

transit is a ban on having those abortion

25:50

tools altogether, both for medical

25:53

and surgical abortions. After all, the

25:55

pharmacists who dispense abortion pills at a

25:57

CVS or a community clinic, even

25:59

in illegal state, does not manufacture the medicines

26:02

herself. She receives them in a shipment

26:04

from a pharmaceutical distributor, usually

26:06

in the mail or in the delivery shipment. Similarly,

26:09

the doctor, nurse or midwife who performs

26:11

a dilation and a cure tach surgical

26:14

abortion does not weld her own speculums

26:16

or forge her own cures. She does

26:18

not manufacture her own syringes

26:20

to administer antibiotics or painkillers,

26:23

and she does not mold her own plastic

26:25

hot water bottles to give to her patients

26:27

for aftercare. She buys these

26:30

as she buys all other medical supplies,

26:32

through the system of commerce through which Americans

26:35

fulfill most of their knees and conduct

26:37

most of their lives. It is the anti choice

26:39

movements aimed to remove abortion

26:42

from that system of normal commerce,

26:44

requiring providers to create alternative

26:47

supply chairs the same

26:49

way the anti choice movement has removed

26:51

abortion from the broader system of normal

26:53

medicine, requiring providers to create

26:56

alternative clinics. The anti choice

26:58

movement wouldn't need an Act of Congress

27:01

or even a judicial ruling. All

27:04

it would need is to say it was enforcing

27:06

a law already on the books.

27:08

Right, which is why we've

27:10

heard Republicans start to bring up the

27:12

Comstock Act more and more because

27:15

this is what they're talking about doing. Just

27:17

a reminder, all of

27:19

this is hugely unpopular. A majority

27:21

of American support access to safe abortions.

27:24

The Comstock Act was hugely unpopular

27:27

even then, but

27:30

he got it through using the same tactics that we're

27:32

seeing now. Also, I know we say

27:34

this every time, but those drugs we've been discussing

27:36

are safe. They've been proven safe.

27:37

They're safe, They're completely completely safe.

27:40

Literally the level of side

27:42

effugs is along with Thailand all.

27:44

Yes, completely safe,

27:48

and you can still

27:50

get them.

27:51

So don't don't think

27:54

that that's what we're saying.

27:55

That's just something we need to be vigilant

27:57

about because this is what they're

28:00

they're looking at doing. There is

28:02

a push to repeal the Comstock

28:04

Acts, but given

28:07

our current political climate, it's an uphill

28:10

battle. And another note,

28:12

it wouldn't ban abortion drugs

28:14

outright, it would just pretty much again

28:16

they're not thinking this through because you use surgical

28:18

gloves for other things like but

28:22

it would make it very, very very difficult to get

28:25

them. And this is all connected.

28:27

This is all linked, like what we've been talking about, banning

28:29

books, banning abortion, the role

28:31

of police, the role of surveillance, like this is

28:33

what we're saying when we talk about intersectional feminism

28:36

and why it is all connected. And

28:38

on top of that, it is really distressing that we've

28:41

gotten these numbers about burst from rapes

28:43

because people were not able to access abortion, which

28:46

is frightening in terms of lack of access, but

28:48

also in what it suggests about

28:51

rape numbers. And you

28:54

know, to be clear, if

28:56

you want an abortion, a safe abortion, you should

28:58

be able to get one. This is very

29:00

troubling data. But

29:04

there have been some wins

29:06

for reproductive rights in the US, including

29:08

in conservative states and

29:11

elsewhere, because of people doing the work and fighting

29:13

back. So that's something else like it can be

29:15

very disheartening

29:19

to hear something like this, and it is

29:22

it is, but there

29:24

are also so many people fighting and

29:26

who aren't giving up and who are doing these things,

29:28

and it does matter, so keep

29:31

that in mind. And also outside

29:33

of the US, for instance, France

29:36

just enshrined abortion rights into their constitution

29:39

in March of twenty twenty four. As we record

29:41

this, and a lot of people

29:43

said that we're interviewed about it that in

29:45

part.

29:46

After seeing what happened in the US.

29:47

So exactly, Yep, we're a

29:49

cautionary tell wonderful.

29:51

Wonderful Yes.

29:55

As we said at the top, I'm

29:57

sure we'll be revisiting this a lot. There's a lot

29:59

of that we need

30:01

to go back to that's happened around abortion in

30:03

the US. But also, listeners,

30:06

if you have any resources,

30:09

if you live anywhere in

30:11

the US or outside of the

30:13

US, where you've been involved in something

30:15

around abortion, or there's something going on you think we

30:18

should know about, please please please

30:20

let us know.

30:21

That is so.

30:21

Valuable to us. You

30:24

can email U at Stephania mom Stuff at iHeartMedia

30:26

dot com. You can find us on Twitter at mom Stuff podcast,

30:28

or on Instagram and TikTok that stuff. I never told

30:30

you. We have a tea public store and we have

30:32

a book that has a whole chapter on

30:35

abortion productive rights

30:37

that you can get wherever you get your books.

30:40

Thanks as always to our super ducer Christina, executive

30:42

ducer Maya, and our contributor Joey. Thank you

30:44

and thanks to you for listening. Stefan ever told

30:47

you the prodection of iHeartRadio. For more podcasts from my heart Radio,

30:49

you can check out the heart Radio app Apple Podcasts wherever

30:51

you listen to your favorite show

Unlock more with Podchaser Pro

  • Audience Insights
  • Contact Information
  • Demographics
  • Charts
  • Sponsor History
  • and More!
Pro Features