Podchaser Logo
Home
How the Antikythera Mechanism Works

How the Antikythera Mechanism Works

Released Tuesday, 15th December 2015
Good episode? Give it some love!
How the Antikythera Mechanism Works

How the Antikythera Mechanism Works

How the Antikythera Mechanism Works

How the Antikythera Mechanism Works

Tuesday, 15th December 2015
Good episode? Give it some love!
Rate Episode

Episode Transcript

Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.

Use Ctrl + F to search

0:00

Welcome to Stuff you Should Know from

0:03

House Stuff Works dot com.

0:10

Hey, and welcome to the podcast. I'm Josh

0:12

Clark, just Charles W. Chuck Bryant. So

0:15

this is the stuff you should know the podcast.

0:19

Yes, indeed, Um,

0:23

you know, archaeology was the first word,

0:25

first big word I could spell early,

0:28

because like two weeks old when

0:30

you're spelling archaeology. Yeah, I couldn't

0:33

spell anything else for years and years,

0:35

but I could spell archaeology. I love archaeology.

0:38

Yeah, me too. It's one of my favorite things actually

0:40

too, although I didn't list

0:42

that when I was asked what my favorite things were in that one

0:44

listener mail, and still it's up there. Um,

0:49

but you too, huh oh yeah, starting

0:52

with uh, well, starting with Indiana

0:54

Jones. Yeah, that definitely helps that

0:57

that we were alive and at the right age

0:59

when those came out. Um,

1:02

well, Chuck, there's a ship. It's

1:04

an unnamed ship as far as I know, that

1:07

went down in the g and c

1:10

off the coast of a tiny, teeny

1:12

little spit of land called Anti

1:15

Cathera in Greece, in between

1:17

Crete and the Greek mainland, I believe, and

1:20

um in nineteen o one or nine hundred

1:23

it was discovered and it actually ended up

1:25

giving birth to the field of um

1:27

marine archaeology. Actually it was the

1:29

first shipwreck that was ever excavated

1:32

archaeologically. Yeah, I think I wrote

1:34

an article on that way back in the day.

1:37

Underwater archaeology. It's

1:39

a very tricky, I

1:41

would imagine, so because most of the stuff

1:44

you find is falling apart, Like

1:46

the second you take it out of water, it

1:48

starts falling apart. Right, So they've gotten

1:50

really good now and imagine they were not as

1:52

good about it in nineteen hundreds about

1:54

bringing stuff up still in water, yeah,

1:57

and transporting in water, same

1:59

sea water, display it in water to

2:02

uh well know then they start poking around

2:06

in yeah, right

2:09

water. Yeah, with the water. It's

2:11

pretty sensible. Um

2:14

I could have come up with that, I think with

2:17

that method. Yeah, good

2:19

for you. Um well, So

2:21

okay, anyway, this shipwreck that

2:24

was discovered in discovered actually

2:26

by accident, right. Yeah.

2:28

There was some sponge divers. You

2:30

know, sponge diving. It's a big deal.

2:33

Apparently it wasn't Greece. It was.

2:36

That's where you had to get sponges back in the day.

2:39

Uh is in the ocean,

2:41

and they were the sponge divers who they

2:43

actually got blown off course by a bad storm

2:45

and ended up in that lovely part

2:47

of town, and they said,

2:49

boy, this is great, let's just dive here. One

2:52

guy dove down, came back

2:54

up and there. They weren't free diving at this point,

2:57

and actually had you can listen to her well, it wasn't

2:59

a diving bell, but underwater

3:01

breathing apparatus is. At this point. He

3:04

came back and he's like, oh my god, they're

3:06

dead horses and dead men everywhere.

3:09

Yeah, and the boss is like, I

3:11

don't know about that. Let me go dive down there. He

3:14

dives down and comes up with a bronze

3:17

hand and says, you big dummy. They

3:19

smacked the guy over the head with it. It's a statue,

3:21

a bunch of statues down there decomposing.

3:24

And then he went, wait, why are there a bunch of statues

3:26

down there? And they they

3:29

said, well, let's figure out, let's remember

3:31

where the spot is and we'll just head off to North

3:33

Africa and do our sponge diving like we were

3:36

going to initially. Yeah, they still have to make some

3:38

dough, right, But when they came back, they took

3:40

the bronze arm and the location

3:42

of the ship to the Greek government.

3:45

And the Greek government said, you know what, this

3:48

could be a big deal. We

3:50

have a lot of antiquities out there

3:52

under the sea and this might be some

3:54

sort of treasure troups. So they hired these sponge

3:56

divers to go back and excavate

3:59

this place, and they found some pretty

4:01

amazing stuff. In addition to the bronze arm,

4:03

they found all sorts of marble statues. Um.

4:07

They found a bronze statue of

4:09

a young athlete. I

4:11

think it was like six ft tall, a little bigger

4:13

than life is what they call it. Um

4:16

they found a bust of a cynic,

4:18

a philosopher, a very detailed

4:20

lifelike bust that's really neat. And um

4:23

that was the guy whose arm. That was his arm,

4:25

Oh, it was his arm. Okay.

4:27

Um. And they found all manner

4:29

of stuff, some really cool stuff and

4:32

brought it up and they displayed it in the museum.

4:34

And among this trove, um

4:36

there was a greatly overlooked

4:39

item item number one five zero

4:41

eight seven. And um,

4:43

it was this weird kind of

4:46

it looked almost like a kind of a clock face

4:48

in a wooden frame and no

4:50

one knew what it was, and compared to the

4:53

amazing art that had been brought

4:55

up, it looked like a pile of garbage

4:58

basically, So they just piled

5:00

it away um and it languished

5:02

for a while until it was um

5:05

kind of rediscovered again. Yeah, and

5:07

giving credit where credit is due. The Sponge

5:11

Team captain, I think that's

5:13

what they called themselves. He was captain,

5:16

Yeah, Sponge Team Captain,

5:18

Demetrius Kantos. And

5:21

then the cry baby who dove

5:23

down there and thought he saw dead people was

5:25

Elias Stadiatus. And

5:28

if there's one thing I love, it's Greek

5:30

names. Love

5:33

the names. Do you like those as much

5:35

as archaeology? Greek

5:38

archaeologists that you're pretty much flying

5:40

in the upper atmosphere for me. Uh

5:44

So those were the dudes that led the Sponge team, and

5:46

all those antiquities, they're scattered

5:48

about a little bit, but most of them are in the National Archaeological

5:51

Museum in Athens, Greece. Uh

5:54

and also some in Switzerland, oddly

5:56

enough, and then some more in a different museum

5:58

of underwater antiquity in Greece. And

6:00

the reason the Greeks went to this trouble

6:03

and didn't just say whatever.

6:05

Who cares about a bronze arm. Apparently

6:07

they'd been defeated recently

6:09

by the Ottoman Turks within the last few

6:12

years, and we're looking for a way

6:14

to restore some national pride. And what

6:16

better way to restore national pride than raising

6:19

two thousand year old statues of your

6:21

you know, ancient gods that

6:24

were made by your predecessors. And

6:26

not only statues, but um, lamps

6:29

and bowls and utensils

6:31

and tools and just all sorts of stuff. It was a treasure

6:33

trove. Yeah. So, um, this this

6:35

site still is basically

6:38

intact. Um. It's a it's

6:40

the shipwreck is over Um

6:43

a couple of I think about

6:45

three d foot span, about the length of a football

6:47

field. And there's actually for

6:49

a long time they thought it was two ships, but

6:52

they think actually no, it was an enormous, massive

6:55

ship that broke into two and

6:57

is um they've only just found the

7:00

front. They found like the cabin, they haven't even

7:02

found the hold. And that it was a huge grain

7:04

ship that had been converted to basically a

7:06

treasure ship that was taking

7:08

Greek antiquities to Rome

7:11

around sixty b c. E um.

7:13

And it's sunk. So they there's

7:16

all these treasures that they haven't even found yet.

7:18

They dove on it in nineteen hundred

7:20

and one, Jacques Cousteau hit it

7:22

up in nineteen fifty and then again in nineteen and

7:26

now there's the most sophisticated

7:28

dives that are being taken on it.

7:31

Yes, he's on it UM.

7:33

As of two thousand and fourteen, there's an

7:35

international team that includes some people from

7:37

Woods Hole Geographic Institute or Oceanographic

7:40

Institute UM who are really

7:44

starting to figure this out. Yeah,

7:46

and you know, one of the reasons you're still doing this

7:48

is because, like you said, it's just a great find

7:50

no matter what. But the other reason is

7:52

because item number one zero eight

7:55

seven a k A. The

7:58

h how's that pronounced again? Annikathera

8:00

anacathera mechanism is UM

8:03

one of the most mysterious finds ever

8:06

because nobody knows who made it. Uh

8:08

and until recently no one

8:10

knew exactly what it was. But now they pretty

8:13

much figured it out. Yeah. Well, so when they

8:15

when they first brought it up in N one

8:18

UM again, it just looked

8:20

like some weird kind of kind of

8:22

like a clock, but it was in a wooden

8:24

frame as the wooden frame was exposed

8:26

to the air, it's it split

8:30

and the stuff inside fell apart.

8:32

And when it fell apart, one of the

8:35

directors of the museum, I believe spirit

8:38

On Stais another great name.

8:40

Um, he looked inside and realized that

8:42

these are all like actually different bronze

8:45

parts, and they have inscriptions and

8:47

they appear to be geared teeth

8:49

like precision gears. Right, Except

8:52

that's impossible because that

8:54

technology didn't come along for well

8:57

over a thousand years later, yes, a

8:59

thousand plus, like maybe fourteen

9:01

hundred, two thousand years later, right, So it

9:03

pops up in the west about the

9:06

fourteenth century in Europe.

9:08

So yeah, like you say, it's totally impossible

9:11

that this could be what what he's looking

9:13

at, not fifty or a hundred years. So

9:15

some people said, Um, this thing

9:18

probably accidentally was dropped

9:20

over this wreck site and just happened to

9:22

nestle in and make it seem like it

9:24

was part of this ancient shipwreck. Nope,

9:27

No, it was found underneath other debris

9:29

in the shipwreck. So that's virtually impossible.

9:32

But it was so confounding, and it's so completely

9:35

undermined our understanding

9:37

at the time of technology

9:40

like that and just the understanding

9:43

of that kind of precision engineering. Um

9:45

that it was just set aside, like no one knows

9:47

what this says. Let's just pretend it doesn't exist.

9:50

Yeah. Uh, and that happened until about

9:53

the nineteen fifties. And uh, we'll take a little

9:55

break here and we'll get back to what happened

9:57

in the nineteen fifties right after this. Alright,

10:14

so it's nineteen fifties. Everyone's

10:17

drunk at lunch, smoking cigarette,

10:19

throwing trash out of their window, right, and there's

10:21

an impossible machine rotting

10:24

away in a museum

10:26

in Greece, that's right. And that's when a man named

10:29

Derek Dislo Price. Uh

10:32

so, you know what, this thing is pretty neat and

10:34

I think I'm gonna make this my new obsession.

10:37

So he spent years researching this thing

10:40

and basically said, I think it's

10:42

some sort of weird Uh he

10:44

said computer. He meant, well,

10:47

he didn't mean computer, because

10:49

it can't be a computer. Obviously it's

10:51

not programmable

10:53

now, so it can't be a computer. But it's

10:57

I mean that words not terribly

10:59

far off off. Yeah,

11:01

it's not a computer. So he's using

11:03

the wrong word there. But along with Dr c

11:06

uh Man another great Greek name Kara

11:09

Kallos, he's a radiographer.

11:12

He said, let's take some X rays of this thing. In

11:14

the nineteen seventy four he published as Findings

11:16

in Gears from the Greeks, which

11:19

he thought was gonna light the world

11:21

on fire. But it turns out

11:23

people were a little scared, uh

11:26

to say, Yeah, this thing is predates

11:29

these kind of precision gears by well over

11:31

a thousand years, So let's rethink everything

11:33

we know about this kind of technology.

11:36

Everyone, No one wanted to touch it with the tin footpole,

11:38

is what I gathered. It was kind of ignored

11:41

the at the time. The people who

11:43

were studying ancient Greece were

11:45

studying their written documents, right, they

11:47

weren't studying like artifacts,

11:49

like physical relics or anything like that, and

11:52

they certainly weren't really up

11:54

on the ancient Greek technology technology.

11:58

Um. And so yeah, he wrote this this

12:00

book and just expected it to change

12:02

the world because he really had approached

12:04

it from a very scientific standpoint.

12:07

When they finally released his book in the seventies,

12:09

right, his theory on what it was was correct. Yeah,

12:11

he theorized that It was a I'm

12:14

going to use the word computer alright,

12:17

a mechanism. It

12:19

was a mechanism with UM at

12:21

one point up to seventy two different

12:23

precise gears, two gears

12:26

that all interacted with one another to

12:28

track the movement of the celestial

12:31

bodies, the five

12:33

planets that were visible to the naked

12:36

eye, the Sun, the

12:38

Moon, It tracked eclipses solar

12:40

and lunar um.

12:42

And it also um

12:45

it tracked the Olympic Games

12:47

just as an added bonus. Well, if you're

12:49

gonna have a astronomical

12:52

calculator, you might as well throw in a

12:54

sports calendar. Yeah, you know, might

12:57

as well. Uh, and so

12:59

the whole thing again, this thing should

13:01

not have existed, like it wasn't

13:04

for another four years

13:06

before anything like this appeared

13:09

in the West. Um. So

13:11

it shouldn't have been which was another reason why

13:13

a lot of people weren't like, yes,

13:15

this is a great book Gears from

13:17

the Greeks. It changed everything.

13:20

They were like, you're totally full of it. And

13:22

this poor guy, Um Price was

13:25

not helped at all by a guy named Eric

13:27

van Danikin right. Yeah,

13:30

he wrote a book in uh nineteen

13:33

sixty eight called Chariots of the Gods, and

13:36

in that he proposed that, um, there are

13:38

aliens who have been bringing us technological

13:41

gifts to Earth and this is one of

13:43

them. And everyone this was

13:45

a really popular book, so he

13:47

got all the headlines with just

13:49

a completely fabricated story. Yeah,

13:51

it was like it was the birth of the interest

13:53

in ufology and the Bermuda

13:56

Triangle. The Naski lines

13:58

are um landing strips,

14:01

that kind of stuff. Right, So when this

14:03

guy came along and put his stamp

14:05

of um

14:07

nuttiness, I guess if

14:10

certainly interesting. That whole Time Life Mysteries

14:13

series definitely came out of

14:15

this von Dannikin's work kind

14:17

of thing, but it had nothing

14:19

to do with any kind of academy or scholarliness,

14:22

right, so he really helped put

14:25

the kai bosh on Price's

14:27

work. This gears from the Greeks,

14:29

and it languished for a while, um

14:32

for another couple of decades,

14:35

I believe, right, Yeah, that's right. It

14:37

wasn't until the mid two thousand's

14:39

that they decided, you know what, we had this

14:42

great technology now called CT

14:44

scanning, computed UH tomography,

14:47

and what we can do with this stuff? We can

14:49

actually get inside this thing. And

14:52

there are videos of this actually being done on

14:54

the mechanism. It's really cool looking.

14:56

You can like watch it unfold in real time. And

14:59

they basedly figured out from the inside out

15:02

how this thing worked and how it operated.

15:05

And it is as follows. There's a

15:08

picture like a a wooden box

15:11

about the size of a shoe box. Right, Yeah,

15:14

it looks bigger to me, but I guess um I saw

15:16

someone else to describe it like a thick

15:18

laptop size. Okay, again

15:20

with the computers, people just can't stop. It's the computer,

15:23

an ancient computer. On

15:25

one side of the box, if if it's standing

15:28

like a shoe box on end. On one

15:30

side, there's a crank like just

15:32

a small dial with a little handle they

15:34

would used to crank this thing up. The handles missing.

15:36

Now, by the way, this is what you're

15:38

describing is what it looked like originally. Right.

15:41

Oh yeah, Now it's just disintegrated

15:44

blobs and chunks of things. Yeah.

15:46

So the knob on the side is what wound it forward

15:49

and backward. And uh,

15:51

then you had a big front side

15:53

and a backside. All

15:56

the gears are in the middle contained their end. Yes,

15:58

and again these are gears with teeth

16:01

between fifteen and

16:03

twenty three of them on a

16:05

gear, and all of them. The number

16:07

of teeth that they have has to do with their

16:09

relationship to the other gears they interact

16:12

with, that's right. So they have all these different

16:14

hands. If you wound it up, it would engage these gears.

16:17

Uh. Each of the hands moves

16:19

at a separate pace and represents what you said

16:21

earlier, the five planets and

16:23

Earth in the moon basically Sun

16:26

and Sun and moon basically anything we can see

16:28

from Earth at this point, right, And these are the gears

16:30

inside, and the gears are physically

16:32

representing how the say,

16:35

the Sun and the Moon interact. Well,

16:37

now these are the hands, right, but then they're driving

16:40

the hands, and the hands have a representation

16:42

in the form of a colored orb on the face

16:44

of the actual mechanism the machine

16:47

exactly. So on the back side, you've got two more

16:49

dial systems. UH. One

16:51

is a calendar of the lunar and solar eclipse,

16:54

and another one UM,

16:56

basically, like you said, was the

16:58

sports calendar. The Olympics

17:01

are coming up than four years after that, there'll be more Olympics,

17:05

so four years. So on the front,

17:07

it was at tracked the day right. That

17:09

was the big the big front face of it.

17:13

I believe it did. Um. And then

17:15

on the back when it's when it's tracking eclipses

17:17

um that that actually

17:20

so chuck. When you make a clock, the

17:23

whole purpose of a clock is so any

17:25

guy can come along and be like, oh, it's

17:27

this day right. So you want

17:29

your clock to be accurate. The problem is if

17:31

you're tracking just the solar calendar,

17:34

you're tracking just the movement of the moon,

17:36

your clock is going to or your calendar

17:39

is eventually going to fall out a sink

17:42

and all of a sudden, something like one

17:44

of the solstic says, your summer solstice

17:46

is gonna show up in December after eighteen

17:49

years, right. So to

17:51

do that, and this has been like one of the

17:53

big things that clockmakers and calendar makers

17:55

have had to deal with forever. You

17:58

have to figure out how to reconcile the movement

18:00

of the sun and the moon with your

18:02

calendar so that it stays up

18:05

to date literally right and

18:09

mechanically but also mathematically

18:11

right. So several

18:14

great thinkers figured out that if

18:16

you take um

18:19

the tracking of the moon and

18:22

extrapolated by enough times, it

18:24

will eventually sync up years

18:26

down the line with the solar

18:28

calendar. I think over the

18:30

course of like nineteen years, and this

18:32

is what's called the metonic cycle. Right, there's

18:35

like five hundred and thirty four phases

18:38

of the moon in one nineteen

18:40

year period, and if you

18:42

can track that, then you can keep your calendar

18:45

in sync. This is the level of

18:47

sophistication that the

18:50

the antick, THEA mechanism

18:53

operates on. And to this

18:55

point, we did not realize

18:57

that the ancient Greeks had this level of

18:59

understanding of astronomy. Yeah, it was. It

19:01

was a big It was a big fine for a lot

19:03

of reasons, and that's one of them for sure. Yeah. And

19:06

one of the reasons that we know that they knew this

19:08

and we're not just kind of putting our

19:10

own ideas onto it is when

19:12

they use that computer tomography,

19:14

they found inscriptions on

19:17

all these different gears which basically said

19:19

how they work and what they track, which

19:21

is another reason this find was so amazing.

19:24

It basically had an instruction manual engraved

19:26

on it. That's right, and we will talk more

19:28

about that right after this. All

19:45

right, So you're talking about the inscriptions, um,

19:47

Like you said, it was a user's guide. If

19:49

there's going to be a sophisticated piece of equipment,

19:52

like, uh, this computer, it's

19:55

gonna come with a book that says here's how you

19:57

use it. Uh. So the finding

20:00

I mean, they're doing a pretty good job of discovering the

20:02

stuff on their own, but then finding the user's guide

20:04

and piecing that together became even a

20:06

bigger part of the puzzle. It did. And then that user

20:09

guy. It also too if like you're an anthropologist

20:11

from five years in the future and you happened

20:13

upon a user guide to a mac

20:16

or something, right, it also

20:18

describes like the level of technology

20:20

that the people who built this computer had, Like

20:23

in writing, it says, this is what we know, this

20:26

is what we understand. So again,

20:28

this backdated the

20:30

understanding of astronomy among

20:33

the Greeks too, far earlier

20:35

than we'd ever given them credit for. And

20:37

it confirmed a lot of stuff that had been

20:39

thrown out over the years as flights

20:42

of fancy your imagination by writers

20:44

who had cited this kind of understanding

20:47

um of the people of their time, and

20:49

later historians were like, these people were just just

20:51

making up and it was a lucky guess. This

20:54

this mechanism has helped show No,

20:56

these these guys actually knew what they were talking

20:58

about. Yeah. One of those was UM.

21:01

There was a belief, uh, well

21:03

by some but not held by others,

21:05

that UM ancient Greeks had calendars

21:07

where they excluded certain days to

21:10

adjust the lengths of the months. A

21:12

lot of people like, no, no, no no, no, there's there's no

21:14

way that they were that sophisticated

21:17

this machine basically, and the accompanying

21:20

guide book proved it to be true,

21:22

which is pretty great. And because

21:25

of its sophistication, there a list of

21:28

people from that time that they think may

21:30

have had a hand in this UM. Of

21:32

course, Archimedes, he's gonna be in there

21:34

anytime something specialist found. Yeah,

21:36

and there's actually writing about Archimedes

21:39

creating a like a a sphere,

21:41

a three dimensional model that actually doesn't

21:44

really sound like the antithera

21:46

mechanism now, but it will be on any list

21:48

if you find something that, like any mechanism,

21:50

is sophisticated. Hipparchus,

21:54

who I think, I don't know if we talked about him

21:56

yet or not. He's a mathematician and

21:58

astronomer, and uh,

22:01

I think he the time period worked out for him,

22:03

so he could have been one of the people involved. My

22:06

money's on him, you know, yeah, or

22:08

his student Poseidonest Okay,

22:10

was that Posidonius?

22:12

Yeah, I like Poseidoness. I'm

22:16

sure he did too, because that makes him sound like a

22:19

Greek god. Yeah. Uh.

22:21

There are also some other hints,

22:23

you know, trying to piece together the mystery. UM.

22:26

One of the inscriptions refers to

22:29

an athletic event in Rhodes, which

22:31

is where Hipparcus taught,

22:34

where his school was. Yeah, and there's

22:36

a man named Alexander Jones. He's a specialist

22:38

at n y U and that's what he said.

22:41

My money's on roads. Is that that's where this thing

22:43

came from, Yeah, Hipparcus, Yeah,

22:45

maybe Poseidoness. The

22:48

other thing that helps is UM, well, it doesn't

22:51

help necessarily UM Hipparcus's

22:53

case, but it kind of excludes

22:56

Archimedes. Some researchers

22:58

um looked at all Babylonian

23:00

records of eclipses and tried to

23:03

sink this thing up, and apparently

23:06

they were able to exclude hundreds of

23:08

different possibilities and settled

23:10

on two oh five b c E

23:13

being the start date for the mechanism.

23:16

Yeah, I think it's a little older than they originally

23:18

thought, right, Yeah, they were thinking fifty two hundred

23:21

BC, and they're like, no, two

23:23

oh five is probably the date that

23:25

this thing was intended to be set to. Because

23:28

again, this thing's tracking the movements

23:30

of the bodies in the heavens based

23:33

on the movement of the sun in the moon,

23:35

and how do you track that by tracking eclipses?

23:38

So you would want to set it to an eclipse because

23:40

there has to be some starting point to set it to,

23:42

right, So they figured it was two oh five.

23:44

Well, Archimedes, as you remember, we did

23:47

a whole episode on him. We did

23:49

someone the Death Ray. Yes, um,

23:51

he was killed by a Roman soldier in two

23:54

twelve, um because he wouldn't

23:56

pay attention to the soldier who was telling him to

23:59

um, pay tension, I think. But

24:01

he was killed in two twelve, so that

24:03

probably excludes him. He was so

24:06

smart he knew that of an eclipse

24:08

was coming in seven years and wanted his

24:10

mechanism to start. Then he was so broke he

24:12

couldn't pay attention. Here

24:15

we hear that one. No, this is my first time

24:18

but hearing that joke. Yeah, yeah, those

24:20

are good, you know. In the burn

24:23

contest or whatever your mama

24:25

jokes. Yeah, yeah, kids,

24:28

it's a good one though. Uh what else?

24:31

What else you got here? Did not think that was going to make

24:33

an appearance in the UM.

24:36

Well since then, there have been uh ten

24:39

models, at least ten um that

24:41

have been built kind of recreating this thing.

24:43

Um. There was a watchmaker that um got

24:45

into it, and of course that was a pretty uh

24:48

the way the things put together, it seems like a watching

24:51

clockmaker would be an ideal, stand it.

24:54

Yeah, made one. Well, they made

24:56

three of this watch and

24:58

it's it's like a watch verse and of it. That's

25:00

pretty amazing. It's pretty cool. I wonder how much

25:02

they went for those three. Oh, I'm sure

25:04

they were pretty cheap. Somebody made

25:06

one out of Legos. Yeah.

25:10

Was it a Lego set or was it just someone made a

25:12

Lego model? Oh, they made a Lego

25:14

model. It was like an Apple engineer. I didn't

25:16

know. I thought it might have been a Lego set, like a very

25:19

obscure Lego set. Uh not yet.

25:21

I'll be the engineers, like, I'll

25:23

sell you these plans Lego if

25:25

you want them. Old Kirk check. There's

25:27

one thing that um, it's amazing

25:30

when we're like, wow, you know this, this knowledge

25:32

is even older than we we thought. And

25:36

a lot of people um point out that

25:38

in the West, Yes, it took until

25:41

the fourteen the fourteenth

25:43

century for this knowledge to come about. We

25:45

likely got it from um Muslims

25:48

Muslim scholars, but it's possible

25:50

that it came to the West via Muslim

25:53

scholars from the Greeks. So

25:55

this knowledge was around the

25:58

Muslims that were interacting with the Weeks gained

26:00

this knowledge and they had themselves

26:04

until they finally interacted with us in the

26:06

West in the fourteenth century.

26:08

Right, it's pretty amazing. But

26:11

other people are like, yeah, that's great. Why

26:14

didn't the Greeks build on this.

26:16

If they had this sophisticated and understanding

26:19

of how to track time and

26:21

the movement of the heavenly

26:24

bodies, why did

26:26

they stop there? Well, they may not have. They

26:29

did, that's the thing. Well, no, I

26:31

mean until we find the next

26:33

thing that was years

26:36

after that that we previously didn't know about. Now the

26:38

point is like, why didn't they build stuff

26:40

that survived and came down to this

26:42

day and they didn't, Like there's

26:44

there's incontrovertibly they did not build

26:47

on it or else we would have it today.

26:49

And Arthur C. Clark is saying, if they

26:52

had built on this level of sophistication

26:55

and it had continued uninterrupted

26:57

today, we'd be traveling amongst the stars

27:00

by now, after two thousand years of having

27:02

this knowledge. I don't see how anyone

27:04

can say that, though, How can you say that they'll never find

27:07

another mechanism after

27:09

this that built on that? You

27:11

won't. What I'm saying is that

27:14

knowledge wasn't built on, and built on, and built on and

27:16

built on uninterrupted. Oh so they

27:18

may have built on. They could have, but for

27:21

what from what we understand that they didn't. My

27:23

money's on finding something else that makes a little

27:25

more sense out of this. Well, they did find something else. In

27:28

three a man in Beirut was in a bizarre

27:31

and found some weird geared mechanism,

27:34

and they figured out that it was a sixth century

27:36

ce Um calendar,

27:39

like a geared calendar. It's the second oldest

27:41

geared mechanism known to humankind

27:44

for now, after the anti

27:46

Cathera mechanism. We may find an entire

27:50

civilization underwater. No,

27:54

but you never know, alright, you

27:56

never know, You never know. I'm

27:59

sure. Before they on this, they

28:01

were saying that they were never advanced enough to make

28:03

something like this. Yeah, the point is that that

28:06

they weren't advanced enough. The point is is they

28:09

didn't build on this advancement until

28:11

we find out that they have right. Well, whatever

28:14

whatever came in and broke that building

28:16

on it and interrupted it, that was That

28:19

sucks because we could be far more advanced

28:21

than we are. It could have been a volcano

28:24

that covered a laboratory and ash

28:27

that sunk underwater, and that's where

28:29

the underwater civilization has been. Yeah, you

28:31

never know in the lab Uh.

28:34

If you want to know more about the anti Kate Thera mechanism,

28:36

you just try your hand at spelling that. It's

28:39

fun to say, isn't it. Yeah, And it's easy to

28:41

spell if he sounds um and do

28:43

that in the search bar at how stuff works.

28:45

And since they said search parts, time for listener, ma'am,

28:49

I'm gonna call this mea culpa. Hey,

28:52

guys, absolutely love stuff you should know and have listened

28:54

to every episode many more than once. You

28:57

keep me company on many a long commute.

28:59

While I was listening to the Void That Manuscript

29:01

podcast, which was awesome, I noticed

29:04

Chuck said a possible explanation was mental illness.

29:06

Josh said, yes, like an autistic

29:09

monk. I'm sure you know this, but autism

29:11

is a developmental disorder, not a mental illness. Behavioral

29:14

therapist who worked with autistic children. That

29:16

makes me very sensitive these matters. Thanks

29:19

for your great work. My favorite ever was Berlin Wall

29:21

and then it's from Tricia Flowers, and I

29:24

think her subject line was I still love you guys.

29:27

Uh So, we've gotten quite a lot of feedback

29:29

on this, and I'll

29:32

let you take it away. It was a mistake. Yeah, it's

29:34

totally misspoke. Yeah, I don't think that

29:37

autism is a form of mental illness. What

29:39

I should have said and meant to say was or

29:42

an autistic monk or a

29:44

monk with autism, I think is the proper

29:47

way to put it. Yeah, so not like

29:50

yeah, sometimes in the heat of the moment, sure

29:52

like or as but

29:55

yes, no, I don't think that those two are the same.

29:58

Yeah, So all apologies people. We we certainly

30:00

don't think that, and I always want to correct

30:03

ourselves, so, especially when something

30:05

we'd say accidentally causes distress

30:08

among people. There's no and to let that stand.

30:10

Agreed, yeah uh yeah,

30:13

So thank you Tricia. We

30:15

appreciate you um writing

30:17

in to let us. We'll set us straight, call

30:20

us out, whatever you wanna call it in a very

30:22

nice way. Yes uh. And if

30:24

you want to set us straight or say

30:27

whatever, you can get in touch with us via

30:29

s y s K podcast on Twitter. You

30:32

can send us an email, the Stuff Podcast,

30:34

the House, Stuff Works dot com. You can hang out

30:36

with us on Facebook dot com, slash stuff

30:38

we should Know and has always hang out with us

30:40

at our home on the web, Stuff you Should Know dot

30:43

com For

30:48

more on this and thousands of other topics. Is

30:51

it how Stuff Works dot com

Unlock more with Podchaser Pro

  • Audience Insights
  • Contact Information
  • Demographics
  • Charts
  • Sponsor History
  • and More!
Pro Features