Podchaser Logo
Home
"A seat at the table" isn't the solution for gender equity | Lilly Singh

"A seat at the table" isn't the solution for gender equity | Lilly Singh

Released Monday, 13th March 2023
Good episode? Give it some love!
"A seat at the table" isn't the solution for gender equity | Lilly Singh

"A seat at the table" isn't the solution for gender equity | Lilly Singh

"A seat at the table" isn't the solution for gender equity | Lilly Singh

"A seat at the table" isn't the solution for gender equity | Lilly Singh

Monday, 13th March 2023
Good episode? Give it some love!
Rate Episode

Episode Transcript

Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.

Use Ctrl + F to search

0:01

Ted Audio Collective.

0:06

Not sure if you know, but I lived in Massachusetts

0:09

for seventeen years, mostly

0:12

in Cambridge and Boston. And one

0:14

thing about these cities, there's cobblestone

0:17

everywhere. Cabblestone

0:19

streets, cobblestone alleyways, cobblestone

0:21

sidewalks, and it was beautiful,

0:24

but it also meant I spent a lot of

0:26

money pairing broken heels or

0:29

just pulling my heel out

0:31

of the little crevice between the cobblestones or

0:33

bricks. If you've ever walked

0:35

down a cobblestone street in a pair of heels,

0:38

you know what I mean. It's so

0:40

annoying. I recently

0:42

read the memoir of Indronui, the

0:44

former CEO of PepsiCo. And

0:47

she mentioned that many women ran into

0:49

similar and even worse problems injuries

0:52

from walking the cobblestone pathways on

0:54

their campus. She talked about

0:56

how for years, women were expected

0:58

to have heels as part of their professional wardrobe.

1:01

And they would get those heels caught in the

1:03

gaps between the stones like I did

1:06

or even have to walk on tip toes

1:08

between buildings to avoid getting

1:10

their shoes stuck. Today,

1:13

women aren't expected to wear heels to work

1:15

as much but cobblestones can

1:17

still be a pain for those who choose to

1:19

wear them. So you know one thing she did

1:22

as CEO? She got rid of

1:24

those cobblestones and replaced the pathway

1:26

with a smooth, heal friendly

1:28

pavement. For ENDRA,

1:31

This was important not only because it saved

1:33

her colleagues money on shoe repair,

1:35

but because it sent a bigger message to the

1:38

women of PepsiCo. That they

1:40

belonged. It's

1:42

one thing to tell women and other underrepresented

1:45

groups that they're valued in your workplace.

1:48

But it's another thing altogether to

1:50

show them how much their experiences matter.

1:54

So how can we make our organizations more

1:56

inclusive place is for all.

2:03

I'm Madhu Bakkenola. This is

2:05

Ted Business. Our speaker today

2:07

is Lily Singh. She's a comedian,

2:09

writer, and late night host. In all

2:12

her life, she thought what she wanted

2:14

was a seat at the table. But when

2:16

she finally got it, she saw just

2:18

how difficult it would be to find success

2:20

at a table that wasn't built for

2:22

her. In this talk,

2:25

Lilly shares why having a seat isn't enough

2:27

and outlines how we can make the table more

2:29

inclusive for everybody. Then

2:32

after the talk, I'll share a few more

2:34

examples of things we can do to make

2:36

our workplaces more

2:37

inclusive. But first, a

2:39

quick break.

2:47

So when I was born, on September twenty

2:49

six, nineteen eighty eight, My grandparents

2:51

and great grandparents back in India didn't

2:54

find out for two weeks. And it's

2:56

not because the phone lines were down

2:58

or because they weren't available. It's because

3:00

there was a complication with my birth.

3:03

And that complication was being

3:05

assigned female at birth. You

3:08

see, because my mom had been told that if she

3:10

gave birth to a daughter, it wasn't

3:12

worth phoning home about. After all,

3:14

she'd already given birth to my older sister,

3:16

and this time everyone had high hopes that she

3:18

would do right and have a son.

3:21

But she didn't. She had me.

3:25

And so there were no congratulations or

3:27

Indian sweets sent our way. Just

3:30

the reality that from the moment I came

3:32

into this world, I was already

3:34

a disappointment to so many people. It's

3:37

as if they had a time machine and already knew the

3:39

trajectory of my entire career and life

3:41

and decided that I had less to offer.

3:45

And it sucked. So

3:47

why am I telling you this heavy story? After all,

3:49

supposed to be a funny person, I have been nerfed come

3:51

out here and hit you right in the fields. How dare I?

3:55

Tell you this because although this is my lived

3:57

experience, It's also the reality

3:59

that millions of girls face every day

4:02

across every culture and in every

4:04

country. And I'm telling you this

4:06

because being born into this reality set

4:09

me on a lifetime mission of

4:11

trying to prove myself and just

4:13

feel like was enough. What

4:15

did I want to be? When I grow up?

4:18

I wanted to be treated equally. And

4:21

I'm not alone in this mission. In

4:23

fact, us girls, what we desperately

4:26

want is a seat at the table.

4:28

It's what every motivational poster,

4:30

Tumblr post, Instagram account to

4:32

follow business model tells us success

4:34

is a seat at the table. You

4:36

know? And if they wanna be extra spicy, they

4:39

say if there is no seat drag your own

4:41

seat. I'm sure you've heard this. Alright.

4:43

And so my marching orders were clear. Get

4:46

a seat at this coveted table

4:48

by any means necessary. And

4:50

that's been the driving force behind

4:52

my entire career. Now

4:55

in two thousand ten, I noticed that

4:57

no one on YouTube looked like me. You

4:59

know, there was no South Asian woman who's

5:01

very loud and uses her hands a lot. Giving

5:04

her take on the world. There was no me

5:06

in front of a camera. I

5:08

saw a seat up for grabs. So

5:10

I've got to work and I started a channel

5:12

under the name superwoman. Yeah.

5:15

Because although I'm smart enough to do a

5:17

TED talk, I'm not smart enough to understand

5:19

copyright, I

5:24

taught myself how to write, shoot,

5:27

and edit my own content. And

5:29

I worked really hard. When

5:31

I finally got the hang of it, I committed to posting

5:34

two comedy videos a week. And I found

5:36

success. With a backward snapback

5:38

on my head, I gave my take on relationships,

5:41

pop culture, tab and subjects, and

5:43

most popularly, dressed up

5:45

like my parents. Now,

5:49

fast forward to twenty fifteen and I'm

5:52

on stage in India announcing my

5:54

first world's tour. As

5:56

fate would have it the day after this monumental

5:59

milestone, I was set to

6:01

fly up in job India This isn't

6:03

my grandfather for the first time

6:05

in my adult life. And,

6:07

whoa, nothing could have prepared

6:09

me. Or what was about to happen? I

6:12

vividly remember it. I was in the

6:14

car driving to his house. He was standing outside.

6:17

I nervously got out of the car.

6:19

Walked up to him. You walked up to me. He looked me right

6:21

in the eyes and you raised

6:24

his hand and

6:26

decorated me with a flower garland. Adjust

6:29

your fit for people of importance. He

6:32

then proceeded to welcome me into his home

6:34

my mom by my side and proceeded

6:36

to show me all the newspaper clippings he had

6:38

saved with my name and face on them.

6:41

He said the words he

6:43

was wrong. Words

6:45

I had never heard a man say before

6:47

to me. He said that I had done

6:50

what no one else could have done and I'd name

6:52

made the family name proud. Me,

6:55

Lily, the baby born a girl.

6:58

That's right. Now in

7:00

that moment, I truly felt

7:02

like superwoman. I did. You know, through

7:04

my YouTube videos, I've amassed almost

7:07

fifteen million subscribers and

7:09

three billion views. But more

7:11

important than all of that, I

7:13

managed to change one view. I

7:16

challenged my grandfather's entrenched gender

7:19

beliefs. And for the first time in

7:21

my life, I remember thinking in that moment, I

7:24

finally got a seat at the table, hello

7:26

props. Alongside

7:29

the men in the industry, I

7:31

felt like that and encouraged

7:34

by my grandpa's approval, I became more

7:36

confident in my influence. I remember

7:38

thinking, oh, I'm gonna talk at this table. I'm gonna join

7:40

the dinner conversation. You know,

7:43

a lot of my male mentors make

7:45

comments and posts about box office

7:47

numbers and salaries and titles

7:49

and those dollar dollar bills. So I

7:51

thought a chime

7:53

in here. I

7:55

learned very quickly that whenever

7:57

I spoke of money, people got

7:59

a little uncomfortable. Like

8:02

the time I pointed out, the gender gap

8:04

and the Forbes list for online creators,

8:07

a list I'd previously been on. I

8:09

remember wanting to start a critical conversation

8:11

because I saw this article and I was heartbroken.

8:14

You know, the digital space had always been a

8:16

place that I thought was without gatekeepers. And

8:18

here it was looking just like old Hollywood.

8:22

But let me tell you, the Internet was

8:24

not interested. I

8:26

don't know how it's possible, but it literally

8:29

felt as if Twitter leaked through my screen

8:31

and body slammed me onto

8:33

my desk. And the message was

8:35

cleared. You can be on this

8:37

list, but don't try to start any

8:39

conversations about the inequality on

8:42

this list. I have

8:44

thousands and thousands of videos. One

8:46

of my most disliked videos is

8:49

why I'm not in a relationship.

8:52

Yeah. A lot of the men at the table

8:54

did not like me telling them why I didn't

8:56

need a boyfriend. I

8:58

quickly learned that there's an invisible

9:01

gatekeeper called culture. And

9:03

the table is smack dab in the middle

9:05

of it. Now,

9:09

in two thousand nineteen, I

9:11

made history with my late night show,

9:13

a little late with Lilly Singh. Thank

9:16

you. Thank you. Where

9:20

I was? Lilly, the baby born a

9:22

brown girl, rubbing elbows or at least times

9:24

lots with comedy royalty. And I

9:26

gotta give a huge shout out to NBC. For

9:28

boldly trying to break late night tradition.

9:31

I remember when this show came out. I remember all

9:33

the articles because it looks practically identical.

9:37

Bisexual woman of color gets late

9:39

night show. I

9:42

almost legally changed my name to bisexual

9:44

woman of color. Because that's

9:46

what people called me so often. And

9:48

you know, as strange as that sentiment

9:50

was, I thought, okay, The silver

9:53

lining is that we'll finally get a different

9:55

perspective in late night. Now little bit

9:57

of melanin, a dash, a queer, a different

9:59

take on things. Let's do this. And

10:02

I remember thinking now, oh, now,

10:05

I've been invited to the big table.

10:08

And now, things will be different.

10:10

So I took my seat.

10:14

Now, unfortunately, the budget

10:16

wasn't based on the importance or

10:18

significance or historic nature of the show.

10:21

It was based on the one thirty AM time slot

10:23

that we had. So to say

10:25

the budget was small, the writing

10:27

staff even smaller, And to do

10:29

the first season, I had to shoot ninety

10:31

six episodes of late night television

10:33

in three months. Now

10:36

who was right? To put that

10:38

into perspective, that is shooting

10:40

two to three episodes a day versus

10:43

the network standard of one a day,

10:45

maybe two on Thursday. We

10:47

did all with a writing staff of about

10:50

half a dozen writers versus

10:52

the network standard. That's about double

10:54

that. Words

10:57

cannot explain to you how exhausting,

11:00

emotionally, and spiritually challenging

11:02

that was. And I start

11:04

to feel like, think this chair

11:06

is a little wobbly. Now,

11:08

I think we can all agree that the beauty and

11:10

magic of late night is its timeliness.

11:13

You know that no matter what's happening in the world,

11:16

you can turn on late night television and hear

11:18

all about it. When you shoot

11:20

ninety six episodes in three months,

11:23

It kind of lose that magic. I

11:26

was the only show talking

11:28

about hooking up, partying,

11:31

cuddling, traveling in front of a live audience

11:33

during a literal global pandemic.

11:37

Still, I thought If the budget

11:39

doesn't celebrate the historicness of the show,

11:42

then the creative can. Now I can bring some

11:44

much needed spice to late night.

11:46

And sometimes I was successful. But

11:49

other times, I would receive notes

11:51

like, don't be so loud.

11:54

Don't be so big. Don't be so angry.

11:56

Smile more. And my all time

11:58

favorite, don't over

12:00

index on the South Asian stuff. After

12:04

all, everyone else at the table who's been sitting

12:07

there for years, you know, people are used

12:09

to them. I might be a little jarring

12:11

to audiences. Now

12:13

during season two of my show, I remember

12:16

I went into overdrive. And I found all

12:18

the loopholes, I did all the necessary jobs

12:21

to try to make the show more timely. And

12:23

I and I was excited to and I felt

12:25

compelled to because for the first

12:27

time in history, we had a woman not to

12:29

mention half South Asian woman become

12:32

vice president of the United States. Now,

12:34

we witnessed one of the greatest protests

12:36

in human history with the farmer protest

12:39

in India. And was excited to finally

12:41

give my take on these things. But

12:44

my take was almost never included

12:47

in topical media news coverage

12:49

roundups. You know, we still got the same

12:51

voices the same perspectives even

12:54

though someone and something different was literally

12:56

in the next time slot. I

12:59

kept trying to pull up my suit. Now, I kept trying

13:02

to join the dinner conversation. I kept trying

13:04

to ask for a more supportive seat. But

13:06

every time I would be told that I should

13:08

be grateful to have a seat in the

13:11

first place. After all, everyone

13:13

else that looks like me is still waiting

13:15

outside the restaurant in the cold. You

13:17

know, the strange thing about having a Wobbly

13:20

seat is that you spend so much time

13:22

trying to keep it upright that

13:24

you can never bring your full self to the table.

13:28

So now, why

13:30

am I telling you all this? Well,

13:33

because my therapist calls two hundred dollars an hour

13:35

and this is way cheaper. But

13:38

also because I just experienced

13:41

one of the most notorious boys clubs

13:43

ever in late night television. And

13:46

I'm here to offer solutions. I

13:49

don't always follow-up a venting session with

13:51

solutions, but when I do, it's a TED Talk.

13:55

That's right. You

14:00

see, my goal was always a

14:02

seat at the table. It's what women

14:04

are conditioned to believe success

14:06

is. And when the chair

14:09

doesn't fit, When it doesn't reach the table,

14:11

when it's wobbly, when it's full of splintures, we

14:13

don't have the luxury of fixing it

14:15

or finding another one, but we

14:18

try anyways. We

14:20

take on that responsibility and we shoulder

14:22

that burden. Now,

14:24

I've been fortunate enough to sit at a few

14:26

seats at a few different tables. And

14:28

what I've learned is when you get the

14:31

seat, trying to fix the seat

14:33

won't fix the problem. Why?

14:36

Because the table was never built for us in

14:38

the first place. The solution,

14:41

build better tables. So

14:48

allow me to be your very own IKEA

14:51

manual. I would like to

14:53

present to you a set of guidelines. I very eloquently

14:55

call how to build

14:57

a table that doesn't suck. I've

15:00

been told I'm very literal. Now,

15:03

right off the bat, let me tell you, this assembly is

15:05

gonna take more than one person or

15:07

group of people, it's gonna take

15:09

everyone. Are you ready? Should be diving?

15:12

Let's do it. Up first,

15:15

don't weaponize gratitude. Now,

15:18

don't get me wrong. Ratitude is a great

15:20

word. It's nice. It's fluffy,

15:22

a solid eleven points in scrabble. However,

15:26

let's be clear. Although gratitude feels

15:28

warm and fuzzy, it's not a

15:30

form of currency. Women

15:32

are signed ten percent more work,

15:35

and spend more time on unawarded, unrecognized,

15:38

and nonpromoted tasks. Basically,

15:40

what this means is all the things men don't want

15:42

to do are being handed to women.

15:44

And a lot of those things largely include

15:47

things that advance inclusivity, equity,

15:49

and diversity in the workplace. So

15:52

hear me when I say, a woman

15:54

should be grateful to sit at a table.

15:56

She should be paid to sit at

15:59

a table. Especially

16:03

once she largely helped

16:06

build and a woman say she shouldn't be

16:08

threatened if she doesn't seem grateful enough.

16:11

In other words, corporations, this

16:13

step involves a woman doing

16:15

a job. And being paid in money,

16:18

opportunity, and promotion, not

16:20

just gratitude. And

16:23

women. Now go ahead. Live it up. Dude,

16:25

live it life. And

16:28

women, a moment of real talk. Trust

16:30

me, I've been there and I know it is so

16:32

tough, but we have to understand

16:35

and remember. That being grateful

16:37

and being treated fairly are not

16:40

mutually exclusive. I can be grateful

16:42

but still know exactly what I deserve.

16:45

And that's the way to do it. Up

16:50

next, invest in

16:52

potential. When investing

16:54

in women, don't invest in the one

16:56

thirty AM time slot. Invest

16:59

in empowering something different. Invest

17:01

in a new voice, given the support they actually

17:04

need. Cultural change takes

17:06

time. And money, heck it took my

17:08

grandfather twenty five years. To

17:10

see that I was worthy of born. So

17:13

a true investment is one that values

17:15

potential over proof.

17:17

Because so often that proof doesn't exist

17:19

for women. Not because we aren't qualified, but

17:22

because we haven't been given the opportunity. In

17:25

other words, if you're trying to be inclusive,

17:29

don't give someone new a seat made of straw

17:31

until they prove they deserve a better one.

17:34

Don't hold again something called a proven again

17:36

bias, which requires less privileged

17:38

people to constantly keep proving themselves

17:41

even though white men tend to get by on

17:43

just their potential. So give

17:45

them a seat that they can thrive in,

17:47

that they can do the job you hired them to

17:49

do in, allow them to contribute to

17:51

the table and they will make it better.

17:56

Up next, this is my favorite one. My

17:58

favorite one. It's quite common sense actually.

18:01

Make space for us. Now,

18:03

for every three men at a table,

18:05

There's only one place setting

18:08

for a woman. People are so

18:10

used to more men showing up that they planned for

18:12

it. There's an extra seat in the corner.

18:14

There's a stake under the heat lamp. When more

18:16

men show up, the table gets longer.

18:19

But when that extra RSVP is

18:21

a woman, more often

18:24

than not, she's encouraged to compete

18:26

against the only other woman that was invited

18:28

to the table. Instead,

18:32

we need to build multiple seats for

18:35

multiple women, not just one or

18:37

two. So that women are not sitting on top

18:39

of each other's lapsed fighting for one meal.

18:42

We already know that more diverse

18:44

teams perform better. A

18:46

recent study shows that corporations that

18:48

have more gender diversity under executive

18:51

teams were twenty five percent more

18:53

likely to experience above average profitability.

18:56

And more racially diverse companies had

18:58

thirty six percent more profit. So really no

19:00

matter how you look at it, it's time to build

19:02

longer tables and more seats. And

19:06

I I wanna say something and I wanna

19:08

admit something, I wanna be vulnerable for a second because

19:11

I fall in victim to this so many times. And women

19:13

let me know if you've experienced this. We

19:16

have to get rid of the scarcity mindset and

19:18

champion each other. Now because

19:21

I've learned what's the better win. Me

19:24

sitting at a table or us sitting

19:26

at a table. Don't be convinced

19:28

to fight for one spot. Instead,

19:31

fight for multiple spots. And

19:39

Last, it's time to

19:41

upgrade the table talk. Now

19:43

I believe stories make the world

19:46

go around. You thought it had

19:48

something to do with the solar system, jokes on you with

19:50

stories. Stories

19:52

are how we understand ourselves. How

19:54

we understand others and how we understand

19:57

the world. And arguably the

19:59

most important stories are those we

20:01

see in the media. Because we've seen

20:03

time and time that they control the narrative

20:05

and impact culture. Now

20:08

when it comes to genre, you can argue

20:10

that certain genres have certain target

20:12

demographics. When it comes to the

20:14

world news, the target demographic

20:16

is the world, and we know

20:18

half of the world is female. Yet,

20:21

women and girls make up only a quarter of

20:23

the people interviewed or that the news is

20:26

even about in the first place. Instead,

20:29

when it comes to issues that impact women,

20:31

we not only need to be included in the coverage,

20:33

we need to be driving those stories and dimensionalizing

20:36

our own experience. Inviting everyone

20:39

in on the table top isn't just a nice

20:41

gesture. It makes her better, more

20:43

productive, smarter conversation with

20:45

more than one point of view. And that's

20:47

you get better. So

20:51

this all sounds like a lot of work.

20:54

And it is. But I'm gonna

20:56

tell you why it's necessary and

20:58

worth it. To be honest, this

21:00

is about so much more than just

21:02

women in the workplace. Now in fact, I could probably

21:04

come up with many more guidelines across many

21:07

other industries. This is

21:09

about creating a world where

21:11

half of population can thrive.

21:14

You see because the work we do today can

21:16

create a world where future generations

21:18

of girls can have equitable access

21:20

and opportunity. And here's the best part.

21:23

Are you ready for everyone listening today?

21:25

All the men, the women, everyone in between,

21:27

the big companies, the small ones, the media outlets,

21:29

all of you, You can help create

21:31

the future, a future

21:34

where we have longer tables and more

21:36

seats that actually work. Instead

21:39

of fighting for a seat at the old ones that

21:41

don't. A future where

21:43

everyone is seated at the table equally.

21:47

And a future where being assigned

21:50

female at birth is not a

21:52

disappointment or disadvantage because

21:55

girls are encouraged empowered

21:58

and expected to do great

22:00

things. And I can't wait

22:02

to make that a reality. Thank

22:04

you so much.

22:19

Lily's call to action is pretty clear.

22:22

We all need to take an active role

22:24

in building a sturdier and more inclusive

22:26

table. Just like India with

22:28

the cobblestone walkway at PepsiCo, If

22:31

we all just looked around, we

22:33

might notice the ways our workplaces aren't

22:35

designed with everybody in mind.

22:38

One example, the closed captioning

22:41

feature on video conferencing platforms

22:44

like Zoom or Google Meet. I

22:46

remember in the earlier days of the pandemic,

22:49

Zoom didn't even have a closed captioning

22:51

feature, which meant that non native English

22:53

speakers or folks who had hearing impairments

22:56

often had a more difficult time keeping

22:58

up. Especially if the WiFi

23:00

was bad. I was really

23:02

pleased when Columbia Business School and other organizations

23:06

decided that they would include captioners to

23:08

facilitate this process. They

23:10

looked around, saw a need, and

23:12

addressed it. And my guess

23:14

is since so many organizations did

23:16

this, these platforms like Zoom

23:18

were responsive, creating these captioning

23:21

features within the technology. Or

23:24

another thing that comes to mind, the temperature

23:26

in office buildings. I remember

23:29

reading an article a couple of years ago.

23:31

About how most office buildings set their temperatures

23:33

based on what's comfortable for men.

23:36

As a petite woman, I'm always

23:38

cold at work. I keep a heater under

23:40

my desk and a scarf nearby at all times.

23:43

If you feel this regularly and know

23:45

your colleagues do too, Why not

23:47

talk to those in charge to see if they can

23:49

adjust the temperature to make it more comfortable

23:51

for everyone? And if they

23:54

can't, Given how fancy

23:56

the HVAC systems are these days,

23:58

maybe together, you can brainstorm ways

24:01

to address this issue. So let's

24:03

take a few moments to really think about

24:05

what others around us need to feel welcome

24:07

at the table I'm describing. One

24:10

thing I just realized is that

24:12

people might need us to know the difference

24:15

between closed captioning and subtitles.

24:18

Because I didn't know before working on this

24:20

episode. Subtitles assumed

24:22

a viewer hears the audio, so there

24:24

are no additional cues of context.

24:27

Close captions do include

24:29

context cues like water

24:31

running or music playing

24:34

or laughter. Which allows

24:36

those who have hearing impairments to truly

24:38

experience what's happening in the video. Learning

24:40

this little fact help me have

24:43

a newfound appreciation for some of the challenges

24:45

associated with being deaf or hard of

24:47

hearing. So now, rather

24:49

than looking at those captions every now and then and

24:51

being like, why the heck are they including this information?

24:54

I get it. I finally

24:56

get it. And I'll make

24:59

sure that closed captioning is available

25:01

for the lectures and meetings I facilitate

25:04

from now on. That's

25:07

it for today. This episode was

25:09

produced by transmitter media with help

25:11

from Jordan Bailey and fact checked by

25:13

Matthias Salas. Special thanks,

25:16

to Anna Filan, Michelle Quint, Corey

25:18

Hay Jim, and Colin Hall. I'm

25:20

Madhu Bacanola. Talk to you again

25:22

next week.

Unlock more with Podchaser Pro

  • Audience Insights
  • Contact Information
  • Demographics
  • Charts
  • Sponsor History
  • and More!
Pro Features