Podchaser Logo
Home
[Bible] Episode 268: Pete Enns - Pete Ruins Chronicles

[Bible] Episode 268: Pete Enns - Pete Ruins Chronicles

Released Monday, 15th April 2024
Good episode? Give it some love!
[Bible] Episode 268: Pete Enns - Pete Ruins Chronicles

[Bible] Episode 268: Pete Enns - Pete Ruins Chronicles

[Bible] Episode 268: Pete Enns - Pete Ruins Chronicles

[Bible] Episode 268: Pete Enns - Pete Ruins Chronicles

Monday, 15th April 2024
Good episode? Give it some love!
Rate Episode

Episode Transcript

Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.

Use Ctrl + F to search

0:00

You're listening to the Bible for Normal

0:02

People, the only God-ordained podcast on the

0:04

internet. I'm Pete Enns. Jared B And

0:08

I'm Jared Bias. Pete

0:11

Hi everybody, Pete here to remind you

0:13

that this is the last call to

0:15

pay what you can for our April

0:17

class, taught by yours truly. It's called

0:20

Divine Violence in the Old Testament, Exploring

0:22

Violence in the Biblical Text. And in

0:24

the class, we cover key texts in

0:26

the Old and New Testament that condone

0:28

violence, why ancient writers' understanding

0:30

of God was tied to violence, and

0:33

how readers today can

0:35

interpret the Bible respectfully and

0:37

responsibly while still critiquing its

0:39

violent depictions of God. And

0:41

as part of our spring semester in

0:43

the Old Testament, our April class is

0:45

actually pre-recorded and comes with a study

0:47

guide meaning you can purchase it and

0:50

watch it on the same day regardless

0:52

of your schedule. There's also

0:54

going to be a live Q&A with me in

0:56

May to talk about all three of our Old

0:58

Testament classes. But you only

1:00

have one day left to pay what you

1:02

can. Starting tomorrow, April 16, the class will

1:04

cost $25. If

1:07

you're a member of our online community, the

1:09

Society of Normal People, you get

1:11

automatic access to the class

1:13

and study guide, plus a

1:15

bonus roundtable video featuring our

1:17

amazing nerds in residence. For

1:20

more info and to sign

1:22

up for the class, head

1:24

to thebiblefornormalpeople.com frontslash Divine Violence.

1:26

Before we get started with our episode

1:28

today, we have a huge announcement to

1:31

make. As you know, our mission at

1:33

the Bible for Normal People is to

1:35

bring the best in biblical scholarship to

1:37

everyday people. For seven years, we've done

1:39

that through podcasts, books, and classes, but

1:41

we've missed an important demographic. Kids. Yeah,

1:44

we get asked all the time, how do I teach

1:46

my children about the Bible without all the weird stuff

1:48

attached? That's why we're creating

1:51

a children's Bible called God's Stories

1:53

as Told by God's Children. With

1:55

this project, our vision is to bring the

1:57

best in biblical scholarship to everyday kids. Yeah,

2:00

and when kids have access to a Bible

2:02

that highlights the diversity, the nuances, and

2:04

the historical, contextual criticism in the text, rather

2:07

than trying to cover that all up,

2:09

they'll learn how to engage with God and

2:11

their faith instead of being pushed away from

2:13

it. This children's Bible has fun

2:15

features to show kids how the Bible was written

2:17

and reflection questions to help them draw wisdom from

2:20

the Bible for today, because if we're honest, kids

2:22

are some of the best critical thinkers out there.

2:25

This storybook Bible will feature a collection of 60

2:27

stories written by a diverse group of

2:29

biblical scholars, theologians, pastors and

2:32

ministers, writers, and activists from all over

2:34

the world. If this sounds like the

2:36

children's Bible you've been looking for all

2:38

your life, now's your chance to help

2:40

make this dream a reality. We've

2:43

just launched a Kickstarter campaign to raise $60,000

2:45

to fund this project, and we

2:48

really can't do it without you. Your money

2:51

will go toward paying our amazing team

2:53

of authors, illustrators, designers, offsetting our production

2:55

costs for printing and shipping, as well

2:57

as the cost of promoting the book.

3:00

So take a look at our Kickstarter page

3:02

to check out some sneak peeks into the

3:04

children's Bible, plus the rewards for supporters, which

3:06

we're pretty excited about. We would be so

3:08

honored to have you join our mission to

3:10

bring the best in biblical scholarship to the

3:12

next generation. One children's Bible

3:14

won't change the world, but the kids

3:17

who read it just might. Head to

3:19

thebiblefornormalpeople.com front slash Kickstarter to check

3:21

it out. Hey folks, welcome to

3:23

this episode on First and Second Chronicles.

3:26

Let me say right off the bat

3:28

that we're only doing one episode on

3:30

these two books. There's

3:32

a reason for that mainly because

3:34

Chronicles, it covers the same storyline

3:37

that Samuel and King's cover, the

3:39

period of the monarchy. So there's no need

3:41

to walk through that narrative from Saul to

3:44

David, and then to Solomon, and then the

3:46

divided monarchy, and then the two exiles of

3:48

North and South. No need to do

3:50

that. We've covered that already in the last several Pete

3:53

Ruins episodes. Chronicles

3:56

specifically is a retelling

3:58

of that story. that

4:00

we see in Samuel and Kings, but

4:03

from a very different perspective. So we'll

4:05

be focusing on what that perspective is.

4:09

See, when you read Chronicles, you're

4:11

reading one group's expression of the

4:13

nature of their existence as the

4:15

people descended from the ancient Israelites.

4:18

You're watching them put the pieces

4:20

together and how they see themselves

4:23

and their God. Chronicles is a

4:25

piece of contextual theology. Jews and

4:27

then Christians ever since have been

4:29

doing the very same thing the

4:31

chronicler does. How do we connect

4:34

today with those stories from

4:36

back then? You've

4:40

heard about microdosing from us before. Probably

4:42

too many times to count, but that's

4:44

because we've had great experiences with microdosing.

4:47

Microdose gummies deliver perfect entry-level doses of THC

4:49

that help you feel just the right amount

4:52

of good. And they really work for me

4:54

for sleeping through the night, which I've talked

4:56

about pretty extensively. But true story, our producer

4:58

actually texted me a couple of weeks ago

5:00

because she bought some with the podcast discount

5:03

after having trouble sleeping. Which makes a lot

5:05

of sense if you have to produce this

5:07

podcast that you'd have trouble sleeping. And she

5:09

texted me to tell me that they worked really

5:11

well for her. And I quote, I brought melatonin

5:14

to help me sleep and I hated how I

5:16

felt in the morning. So

5:19

I bought the Lumi Gummies with our

5:21

discount code and they have been amazing.

5:23

I feel super rested. Well, there you

5:25

go folks. Yes. Now get 30% off

5:28

your first order plus free shipping today

5:30

at microdose.com, promo code normalpeople. It's

5:33

available nationwide. That's microdose.com, promo

5:35

code normalpeople for 30% off

5:38

and free shipping. microdose.com, promo

5:40

code normalpeople. Typically,

5:43

Chronicles is not the most popular book in the

5:45

Hebrew Bible, am I right? Precisely

5:48

because after slogging through Samuel and

5:50

Kings were met with Chronicles, which

5:52

basically covers the exact same territory.

5:54

I'm not reading that again. And

5:56

I can imagine some of you might not be

5:58

terribly excited about that. whole episode on

6:01

Chronicles. Well, my goal here is to

6:03

convince you that this is not a

6:05

waste of your time, and that Chronicles

6:07

is actually a book worthy of your

6:09

very careful attention. All right, so

6:12

just let's start with some preliminaries as

6:14

we always do. The Hebrew title of

6:17

Chronicles is Divre Hayemim,

6:20

which means something like the words of the days

6:22

or the events of the days, and

6:25

probably implied the book of

6:27

the events of the days. That

6:29

doesn't mean this book was actually recording daily

6:31

events or something like that. It just means

6:33

this book is an account of the past,

6:37

and an interesting account it is.

6:39

Now, that's all well and good, but the

6:41

Greek title is different from

6:43

the Hebrew title and

6:45

has had an undue influence, I

6:47

think, on how people today might

6:50

look at Chronicles. So

6:52

you may recall from past episodes that

6:54

the Hebrew Bible was of

6:56

necessity translated into Greek, and that

6:58

happened after the conquest of Alexander

7:00

the Great in the late 4th

7:02

century BCE. The

7:05

Greek title given

7:07

to Chronicles is

7:09

Ta Paralei Po-mena, which

7:12

means something like the things missing

7:14

or the things left over, namely

7:17

from Samuel and Kings. Now,

7:19

that's not the best bit of marketing if

7:22

you want people to actually read this. The

7:24

sense given is that Chronicles contains some

7:28

details that were left out of Samuel

7:30

and Kings, and frankly, who cares? I

7:32

mean, who wants to go through this

7:34

after having just read Samuel and Kings

7:36

just for a few leftover crumbs? But

7:38

here's the thing, Chronicles is not simply

7:40

things that didn't make the first cut.

7:43

Rather, it is itself an independent,

7:47

ideologically independent. It's not independent in

7:49

other ways, we'll get to that.

7:51

But it's an independent, focused,

7:54

intentional, purposeful

7:57

retelling of Israel's past from...

8:00

their own time from the time in

8:03

which this was written. Folks, and

8:05

that's the key, it's a retelling of the

8:07

past for their own

8:09

time. Now unfortunately,

8:12

the fact that it

8:14

appears right after Samuel and Kings

8:16

clearly discourages people from seeing it

8:18

as an independent work. In

8:21

the Jewish canon however, Chronicles

8:23

is not just tucked away after

8:25

2 Kings, it's placed

8:27

last. And boy is

8:29

this telling. See it's not grouped with

8:31

the other, as Christians call

8:34

them, historical books. It's

8:36

grouped with those books referred to in

8:39

Judaism as the writings.

8:42

Sort of a general category which

8:45

includes things like Psalms, wisdom literature,

8:47

and other books that Christians place

8:49

among the historical books but Jews

8:51

don't, namely Esther and

8:54

Ruth. So even Daniel which

8:56

is a prophetic book in the

8:59

Christian Bible is in

9:01

the Jewish Bible categorized in

9:03

this third group called the writings.

9:06

And that's where Chronicles is placed

9:08

last. Why? Well

9:11

placing it at the end of the

9:13

canon signals that Chronicles is

9:15

a final summation of Jewish experience at

9:17

the time it was written. It's

9:20

a way of closing out the Hebrew Bible.

9:23

It's a final statement of here's where

9:25

we were and here hopefully is where

9:27

we're going. It recounts

9:29

the past but in such a way

9:31

that it gives a hope for the

9:33

future and we'll get to the nature of that

9:36

hope a little bit later. But

9:38

see placing it last ensures that

9:40

it is taken as a statement

9:42

in its own right, not

9:45

just a collection of things simply

9:47

left out of the Deuteronomistic history

9:49

that we should just ignore because we just read

9:52

it. And by the way folks, while

9:55

we're on the topic, if you ever

9:57

want evidence that the Bible is absolutely

9:59

an indeed multi-vocalic,

10:02

that it speaks in

10:04

different voices on the same

10:06

subject. If you're convinced

10:08

that's not the case, and if you want

10:10

some evidence, just compare Chronicles to Samuel King's.

10:13

They tell the same story, but

10:15

they tell it very, very differently.

10:19

And our focus here in this episode is on

10:21

how the story in Chronicles

10:24

is a different story that this

10:26

author wants to tell his audience. It's

10:28

a different take on Israel's

10:30

past, specifically the monarchy. So

10:33

more preliminaries here. Let's talk about the date of the

10:35

book. Chronicles is a presentation

10:37

of the past that

10:40

begins, basically begins with

10:42

Saul. Now, if you're familiar

10:44

with Chronicles, you know right away that

10:46

I'm leaving out a very boring part,

10:48

the first nine chapters of 1 Chronicles,

10:50

which is a long genealogy. Yes, I'm

10:52

leaving that out just for the moment.

10:56

The historical story that it tells,

10:58

it begins with Saul, and it

11:00

goes all the way to the

11:02

Babylonian exile back in 586 roughly BCE.

11:06

And then it continues to

11:09

talk about the return from

11:11

exile. This

11:13

is a helpful clue as to the dating

11:15

of this book. See, Chronicles ends with the

11:17

release of the Judahites from Babylon in 539

11:19

BCE by the Persian King

11:23

Cyrus. In other

11:25

words, Chronicles was written after the

11:27

exile, after the

11:29

return from the exile at

11:32

some point during the Persian period,

11:34

and the Persian period is 539 to 322 BCE.

11:40

More specifically, the date range typically given

11:42

by scholars is the late fifth to

11:44

the early fourth century BCE. So let's

11:46

just say for argument's sake somewhere between

11:49

450 and 350. One

11:52

reason for the specific date range is

11:55

the fact that the genealogy, we're back

11:57

to the genealogy here that opens the

11:59

book. right in chapters 1 through

12:01

9. That genealogy gives

12:03

seven generations of names

12:06

beyond the governor of

12:08

Judah, whose name was Zerubbabel,

12:11

who was appointed by the Persian

12:14

king Cyrus, and he

12:16

governed Judah in the late sixth

12:18

century. And Chronicles

12:21

includes seven generations of

12:23

names after Zerubbabel. So

12:27

we're well into the fifth century, but

12:29

probably before the Greek period, which started

12:31

around 332 with Alexander the Great,

12:34

right? So we're probably before

12:36

the Greek period since there's no

12:38

evidence of Greek influence in Chronicles,

12:40

and Greek influence would be

12:43

something relatively easy to

12:45

see because we actually do see

12:47

Greek influence in later books of

12:49

Judaism that were written under

12:51

Greek influence, right? So anyway,

12:54

the date range for Chronicles is

12:56

before the Greek period, but in

12:58

the Persian period and pretty much

13:00

in the latter half of

13:02

the Persian period. So again, between 450

13:05

and 350 BCE, that's the

13:08

standard date range given to

13:10

the book, although, you know, there's

13:12

always debate among scholars. So

13:14

anyway, but that's what we're sticking with that

13:17

time period. So Chronicles gives

13:19

a later perspective on Israel's history.

13:21

That's the point of this. It

13:23

gives a later perspective of the

13:26

mid fifth to the mid fourth century, and

13:28

that's later than what we find in Samuel

13:30

and Kings. Those earlier

13:32

books, Samuel and Kings, are united

13:35

by an earlier

13:37

theological perspective, namely, the

13:39

theology of the book of Deuteronomy. And here,

13:41

I just want to ask if you're not

13:43

familiar with some of this stuff, and that's

13:45

fine. We spent a lot of time in

13:47

the last few episodes talking about the

13:50

theology of the book of Deuteronomy and

13:52

how it affects the books of

13:54

Samuel and Kings. And that's why,

13:56

as you may recall, the author of Samuel

13:58

and Kings, is referred

14:00

to in modern scholarship as the Deuteronomistic

14:05

historian, the historian who writes from a

14:07

Deuteronomistic point of view. The

14:09

author of Chronicles also

14:11

has his own perspective on that

14:13

same history, and this perspective

14:15

is signaled to us throughout his

14:18

retelling by what he includes and

14:20

what he doesn't include, and also by

14:22

the many slants that he gives

14:25

to many of the stories we

14:27

find in Samuel and Kings. And

14:29

this author is usually referred to

14:31

as the chronicler, which is shorter

14:33

isn't it than Deuteronomistic historian, but

14:35

that's good. So he's referred to as the

14:38

chronicler, and I'll stick with that in referring

14:40

to this author. So what

14:42

is the chronicler's relationship to

14:44

these older texts Samuel and Kings?

14:47

Right? If it's pretty much covering the same territory,

14:49

is he using these books? What's going on? And

14:52

that is a very good question, and there

14:54

is room for some debate here, but there seems

14:56

to be little question on at least one point,

14:59

and that is that the chronicler not

15:01

only knew of the existence of

15:03

Samuel Kings, but used

15:06

these books and then

15:08

consciously diverged from them to tell

15:10

his own story. Now

15:12

if it helps, especially if you're

15:14

not familiar with, you know, grappling

15:16

with these historical narratives of the Hebrew

15:18

Bible, I can offer an analogy

15:20

if it helps from the New Testament, and it's only

15:23

a rough analogy, but here it is. It's

15:25

essentially still a consensus and biblical scholarship.

15:28

The author of Matthew's Gospel used

15:30

the earlier Gospel of Mark, Mark

15:32

is earlier than Matthew. He used

15:34

it as his basis, but

15:36

then intentionally augmented it, changed it,

15:38

and then adapted it for

15:41

his own purposes, to tell his own story

15:43

of Jesus, which is

15:45

not the same as Mark's telling of the

15:47

story. And sticking with this

15:49

analogy for a moment, we should remember that

15:52

there is much more to Matthew's Gospel

15:54

than simply a reworking of Mark and

15:56

making some changes. There are other influences

15:59

that New Testament Testament scholars talk

16:01

about. There's also Matthew's personal

16:04

genius and ingenuity and creativity

16:06

and things like that. But

16:09

generally speaking, something like

16:11

that which is happening in the

16:13

Gospels is also at work with

16:15

Chronicles and his relationship to Samuel

16:18

and Kings. He is repurposing an

16:20

earlier version. He is adapting it for

16:22

a new purpose. As

16:24

I've been saying, Chronicles does not simply

16:26

repeat Samuel and Kings and fill in

16:29

some missing details, but it

16:31

is its own distinct presentation

16:33

of Israel's history. It

16:35

is a piece of theology, and we

16:37

need to treat it as that. Now

16:39

do we know who wrote Chronicles? Well, no.

16:42

Like every biblical book at least, I would

16:44

argue that we don't know

16:47

who wrote Chronicles. One traditional view

16:49

is that Chronicles was authored by

16:51

the same person who wrote

16:53

Ezra and Nehemiah. And the reason for

16:55

making that claim is that the

16:57

last verses of Chronicles, and that would be

17:00

2 Chronicles 36 verses 22 to

17:03

23, this is where we read of

17:05

the decree of Cyrus, the Persian

17:07

king, in his order to release the captives and

17:09

let them go back home. Well, these

17:12

verses are repeated verbatim in

17:15

the opening verses of the book of Ezra. Again,

17:17

if I can just offer a New Testament

17:19

analogy we might be more familiar with, it's

17:22

like the ending of the Gospel of

17:25

Luke is repeated

17:27

in a certain sense, not quite verbatim,

17:29

but it's repeated in the sense at

17:31

the beginning of the book of Acts,

17:33

and that is alerted, scholarship, that the

17:36

same author is at work there. So

17:39

you have something similar here going

17:42

on in Chronicles with Ezra, Nehemiah,

17:45

and that's led people to conclude

17:47

that whoever wrote Chronicles wrote

17:49

Ezra and Nehemiah as well. Now

17:52

another reason for this hypothesis is

17:55

that the genealogical

17:57

information in Chronicles

18:00

a lot of it, right, those first nine chapters. The

18:02

genealogical information in both Chronicles and

18:05

Ezra and Nehemiah are similar. Now,

18:08

all that is well and good, but

18:10

just again to get to more of

18:12

the scholarly consensus, despite these similarities, this

18:15

view that the author of Chronicles and

18:17

Ezra and Nehemiah are the same person,

18:20

that has fallen out of academic favor.

18:23

Why? Well, there seem

18:25

to be too many differences in

18:27

theological themes and writing style

18:29

between the books to suggest one

18:31

person is responsible for both. And

18:34

here's the thing too, even if we could surmise

18:37

that they were written by the

18:39

same person, we still wouldn't

18:41

know who that person is. So

18:43

to say it's one author or multiple

18:46

authors doesn't tell us who

18:48

wrote it. And as I said,

18:50

with most books of the Bible, I think

18:53

we have to agree to

18:56

say we don't know who wrote some of this stuff. We

18:59

just don't. Chronicles is an anonymous text. Did

19:07

you know fast growing trees is the biggest online

19:09

nursery in the US with more than 10,000 different

19:12

kinds of plants and over 2 million

19:14

happy customers in the US? They have

19:16

everything you could possibly want like fruit

19:18

trees, palm trees, evergreens, house plants, and

19:20

so much more. Whatever you're interested in,

19:22

they have it for you. Find the

19:24

perfect fit for your climate and space.

19:27

Fast growing trees makes it easy to

19:29

order online and your plants are shipped

19:31

directly to your door in one to

19:33

two days. And along with their 30

19:35

day alive and thrive guarantee, they offer

19:37

free plant consultation forever. We have a

19:39

handful of acres. So landscaping is something

19:41

I dread every year. It's just a

19:43

pain to do, especially on my own,

19:45

but I also don't want to pay

19:47

that much for a landscaper. So I

19:49

was excited to try fast growing trees.

19:52

This spring, they have the best deals

19:54

online up to half off on select

19:56

plants and other deals and listeners to

19:58

our show can get an additional

20:00

15% off their

20:03

first purchase when using the code

20:05

normalpeople, that's one word, at checkout.

20:07

That's an additional 15% off

20:10

at fastgrowingtrees.com using

20:12

the code normalpeople at checkout.

20:15

fastgrowingtrees.com, code normalpeople. Offer is

20:17

valid for a limited time.

20:20

Terms and conditions may apply.

20:26

All right, so Chronicles, let's get into

20:29

an outline of Chronicles. And as you

20:31

know, I love outlines. So Chronicles can

20:33

be divided into five sections. That's

20:36

just my scheme. The first

20:38

is the genealogy in

20:40

1 Chronicles chapters 1 to 9. The

20:43

second section is very brief.

20:46

It's chapter 10. And this is

20:48

a note basically on the death of Saul,

20:51

the king who preceded David. The

20:53

third section is all about the reign of

20:56

David, which covers the rest of 1 Chronicles.

20:58

This is chapters 11 through 29. 2

21:02

Chronicles begins with the reign of Solomon

21:04

in chapters 1 through 9. That's

21:06

the fourth section. And then chapters

21:08

10 to 36 make up the

21:11

fifth section, which deals with the history of

21:13

Judah from the

21:15

division of the monarchy, that's after the

21:17

death of Solomon, to the

21:19

fall of Jerusalem, and then the decree

21:21

of Cyrus, the Persian king, to

21:24

allow the people to return. So roughly

21:26

speaking, 1 Chronicles deals

21:28

with Saul and David and

21:31

follows the very broad subject matter of 1

21:33

and 2 Samuel. 2

21:35

Chronicles focuses on Solomon

21:38

and the divided kingdom, which

21:40

is the subject of 1 and 2 Kings. You

21:43

can think of it that way. 1 Chronicles corresponds

21:45

to the Samuel books. 2 Chronicles

21:47

corresponds to the Kings books. Now,

21:50

not to complicate things, but we could

21:52

divide Chronicles into three historical sections. That's

21:55

the genealogy, that's chapter 1 to

21:57

9 of 1 Chronicles. And

22:00

then we can just combine the stories

22:02

of Saul, David, and Solomon and

22:04

just put them under the heading

22:06

of what? Well, united monarchy. That

22:09

would be 1 Chronicles 10 to 2 Chronicles 9. And

22:13

then the last part, 2 Chronicles 10

22:15

to 36, is the divided

22:17

monarchy. Some people like

22:19

three, some people like five. I'm just sticking with

22:21

a five-part outline for the purposes of this podcast.

22:24

So, you ready, folks? Let's take each

22:26

of these five sections and look at

22:29

what is distinctive about them compared to

22:31

Samuel King's. And remember,

22:33

it is the distinctive elements

22:35

that clue us in to

22:38

the chronicler's theology to

22:40

answer the question of why he even wrote

22:42

this book. And rather than

22:44

putting us all on a fox chase, let

22:46

me just say at the outset what the

22:49

big difference in perspective is between the chronicler

22:51

and the deuteronomistic historian. And

22:54

I think knowing at the outset will help make sense

22:56

of some of the things we're going to look at.

22:59

Simply put, our two authors are

23:01

asking different questions and therefore giving

23:03

very different takes on the history

23:05

of the monarchy. The

23:07

deuteronomistic historian is asking the

23:09

question, why are we in

23:11

exile? Why did it happen? How

23:14

can we reconcile this tragic event

23:16

with the goodness and justice of God? The

23:19

answer that author gave, you may

23:21

recall, is that exile is

23:24

not a sign of God's weakness

23:27

or God's distractiveness or God's abandonment,

23:30

but of God's sovereign just will.

23:32

See the exile, why are we

23:34

in exile? It's punishment. It's

23:36

punishment for failing to maintain

23:38

the covenant, namely the laws

23:41

about the exclusive worship of the

23:43

God of Israel named Yahweh and

23:46

the exclusive worship in the temple itself. And

23:49

according to the deuteronomistic historian,

23:51

the failure to uphold this

23:54

is why the two exiles happened, the exile of

23:56

the north in 722 and of the south of

23:58

the south of the south in 586.

24:02

The chronicler, however, is living at

24:04

a different time, and he

24:06

is asking another question entirely. After

24:09

all that has happened, our

24:11

deep past, and all the struggles, are

24:14

we still the people of God, or

24:16

has God forgotten us completely? Is

24:18

God merciful? Has God forgiven us? Is

24:21

God going to punish us forever? Do we

24:24

have a future? See, his

24:26

answer to those questions is basically

24:28

that God is just, and

24:30

God will treat his people justly, and

24:33

the future looks bright. See, in other

24:35

words, the Deuteronomistic history

24:37

is an explanation for why

24:39

the exile happened. Chronicles

24:41

is an expression of faith in God's

24:43

continued care for the people of Judah

24:46

despite their past. The

24:48

chronicler tells the history of Israel in

24:51

a creative way to drive

24:53

home that very practical theological

24:55

point. That's the heart of it, folks. So

24:58

let's now look at each of those

25:00

sections and highlight some points that illustrate

25:03

the chronicler's theology. So first,

25:05

the genealogy. Several observations, if I

25:07

may. First, the

25:10

genealogy begins with Adam,

25:13

and this is the only place Adam is

25:15

mentioned after Genesis 5. By

25:17

the way, I know the word Adam appears

25:19

in Joshua, it appears in Hosea, but it's

25:22

a place name. It's irrelevant. It's not the

25:24

name of the character, right? So

25:26

we begin this genealogy with

25:28

Adam. He hasn't been mentioned since

25:30

Genesis 5, and the

25:32

chronicler begins, see, his story

25:35

at the beginning. That's the point. He

25:37

begins at the very beginning of Israel's

25:39

story, because he's going to trace a

25:41

genealogy that goes from there to his

25:43

own time. It's as if

25:45

he wants to remind his people that

25:47

their pedigree goes way back,

25:49

that they are part of an ancient story, and

25:52

that God has not forgotten them. They

25:54

are connected to the past. They are

25:56

connected to the very beginning. So

25:59

he traces the lineage. lineage from Adam

26:01

to Israel, also known as Jacob. But this

26:03

is in basically chapter 1 of

26:06

the genealogies. Then we move

26:08

on to the lineage of Israel

26:11

and the 12 tribes, the

26:13

sons of Jacob. And that takes up most

26:15

of the genealogy. This takes us to

26:17

the very beginning of chapter 9.

26:20

But here's the thing. In chapter 2, when

26:23

he's going through the lineage of the 12 tribes, the

26:25

focus is immediately on the lineage of

26:28

one of Jacob's 12 sons. Which

26:31

one is that? Glad you asked. Judah.

26:34

Who the heck cares? Here's why. Why single

26:36

out Judah? Well, this is our first

26:38

clue about what makes

26:41

Chronicles distinctive, its focus

26:43

on Judah, meaning the nation

26:46

of Judah, the southern

26:48

nation. Remember how first

26:50

and second kings go back and forth

26:52

between the kings of the north and

26:54

the kings of the south, sort of

26:57

telling alternating stories. Well, not Chronicles. He's

26:59

focusing on the story of one tribe,

27:01

that nation, that southern nation that

27:03

survived exile and return. And

27:06

that tribe is highlighted in

27:08

the genealogy. The author is

27:10

bringing his own people into this story

27:13

front and center because this is the

27:15

story of their survival and

27:17

this is the story of their continued existence

27:20

and the hope that they want to have for

27:22

that future. Now, the chronicler, he's

27:24

not ignoring by any means the other

27:26

tribes. He gives their lineages as well.

27:29

He gives a lot of space to the

27:31

Levites, for example. Those were

27:34

from Levi, one of the sons of

27:36

Jacob. And the Levites are those who were

27:38

in charge of the temple. Why spend

27:40

time on this? Because this was too

27:42

important to the author to not talk

27:44

about. He's very interested in temple

27:47

worship. It is huge for him. So

27:49

the Levites, they dominate chapters six and

27:51

seven. Tucked into

27:53

chapter six also is a list

27:55

of the temple musicians that David

27:57

appointed focused on temple worship. As

28:00

we'll see, David has a connection to the

28:02

temple that is simply missing

28:04

from Samuel King. That's

28:06

a side issue, but we're going to get to that big time in

28:08

just a few minutes. See, next,

28:10

we're still in the genealogy here, folks. Next

28:13

we see a list of names of those

28:15

who returned to Jerusalem after the exile. And

28:18

this is chapter 9, basically starts in

28:20

verse 2 and it goes to verse 34. And

28:23

the list of those who returned to

28:26

Jerusalem after the exile is very important

28:28

for the chronicler. His

28:30

genealogy, as I said before, it

28:33

links the present post-exilic,

28:35

fifth century community to

28:38

Israel's deep past.

28:40

Again, I just really want to

28:42

underscore that. This is a practical theological

28:45

pep talk for his

28:47

people, and this is the purpose of the

28:49

genealogy. Remember your pedigree. Have

28:52

hope. The same God is

28:54

still active and has not abandoned his

28:56

people. Now, the genealogy

28:58

ends with the line of

29:00

Saul, and it bridges, therefore,

29:03

the genealogical section to

29:05

his actual treatment of Saul, which is

29:07

our section 2. That's chapter 10.

29:10

And the chronicler takes care of Saul's

29:12

story pretty quickly, though, and he focuses

29:14

on Saul's death. He's really not

29:16

that interested in Saul. Saul is

29:18

more an entrance ramp to get us onto

29:21

the David Highway, and

29:23

that's now section 3, and

29:25

we'll occupy the rest of 1 Chronicles,

29:28

just chapters 10 through 29. And

29:31

folks, this is where things get interesting,

29:33

and we need to slow down just

29:35

a bit and look at some of

29:37

the details about how the chronicler handles

29:39

the reign of David. As

29:41

a way of getting into that, let

29:44

me give a related concrete

29:46

example. It's not one of the things I

29:48

want to focus on too much. It's just

29:50

a very succinct way of getting

29:52

into the mindset

29:54

of the author of Chronicles

29:56

concerning how he handles what

29:59

he reads. in Samuel Kings and how he

30:01

adapts it for his own reason. And

30:04

that example is from 2 Samuel 7.16.

30:10

And how does Chronicles handle this verse? Well, here

30:13

is in this part of the story

30:15

in 2 Samuel, we have Nathan the

30:17

prophet. He's speaking

30:19

for God and he's prophesying to

30:21

David. This is all about

30:24

David, that Solomon, his next in

30:26

line, he will be the next

30:28

king. And that

30:30

David's line is firmly

30:32

established. His reign,

30:34

his kingdom, his lineage

30:37

will be forever. And

30:40

here's what 2 Samuel 7.16

30:42

says. This is again

30:44

God speaking through Nathan to David. Your

30:47

house, that's your meaning David,

30:50

your house and your

30:52

kingdom shall be made sure

30:54

forever before me. Your

30:57

throne shall be established forever.

31:00

See, this is a comment on David's

31:04

lineage and how there's

31:06

always going to be a son of David

31:08

sitting on the phone. And

31:10

that's your house, David. That's your kingdom.

31:12

It's your throne. Now, here's the

31:15

problem, of course, with all this in 2

31:17

Samuel 7. That's that David's

31:19

line did indeed come to an

31:22

end, at least functionally, in the

31:24

exile. That's the whole point of

31:26

it. So when telling this story of

31:28

David, and especially of 2 Samuel 7,

31:32

what the chronicler does is

31:34

he clearly changes Nathan's speech.

31:37

Here he says, I will

31:40

confirm him, and the hymn

31:42

here is Solomon. I will confirm

31:44

him in my house, whose

31:49

house is at its God's house. It's not David's

31:51

house. And in

31:53

my kingdom forever, and

31:56

his throne shall be established forever. A little

31:59

bit different. That's 1 Chronicles 1714. Just

32:03

notice the big picture. There are a lot of details

32:05

we could talk about here, but just keep an eye

32:07

on the big picture here. Notice

32:10

whose house and whose kingdom it is. Here

32:12

in Chronicles, it's God's. The

32:14

historical reality at the time is

32:16

that there is no one occupying the throne

32:19

of David. That hadn't happened since the

32:21

Exo. But here's the thing.

32:23

It's, according to the Chronicles,

32:25

it's not even David's throne. It's

32:27

God's throne. That's what

32:29

the chronicer wants to get across. See,

32:32

here's the practical piece of encouragement to

32:34

a people that finds itself

32:36

in the land, but without the blessing of

32:38

a king in the line of David, which

32:40

was the promise of 2 Samuel 7. Here's

32:44

the point. Despite what it looks like, folks,

32:47

Israel's throne and kingdom are

32:49

squarely in God's hands. It

32:52

is His throne and His kingdom. And

32:55

if no earthly king is involved,

32:57

don't let that detail discourage you

33:00

from the ultimate reality. See,

33:02

the lesson is this. A kingless

33:04

throne is not evidence of God's

33:06

abandonment. It's God's throne.

33:08

It's God's kingdom, and God is still in

33:10

charge. See, this is

33:13

just one example of the

33:15

way in which the

33:17

chronicler adapts his own

33:20

main source for writing his story,

33:22

which is Samuel King's. Anyway,

33:25

let's talk specifically now about

33:27

the chronicler's David, which

33:29

is a very different David than what

33:31

we see in Samuel King. I would

33:33

like to highlight four examples of how

33:35

the chronicler presents an idealized

33:37

portrait. That's really the term I'm

33:40

looking for here, an idealized portrait

33:42

of David. For example, it

33:45

is explicit in 2 Samuel 7 that

33:48

David will have nothing to do with building the

33:50

temple. That will be all

33:52

Solomon's deal. He's going to do it. And

33:55

then in 1 Kings, chapters 5 and

33:57

6, we see Solomon making

33:59

preparations. for the temple, like

34:01

gathering materials, and then

34:03

actually overseeing its construction. The

34:06

only thing David does in

34:08

2 Samuel that even remotely

34:10

ties him to the

34:12

preparation of the temple is

34:14

his last act in that book, which

34:17

was to erect an altar on

34:19

the threshing floor of

34:21

some dude named Arona, who

34:24

is a Jebusite. The Jebusites,

34:26

by the way, were the original

34:28

inhabitants of Jerusalem, and after David

34:30

conquered it, he made it his

34:32

city. There are Jebusites there. So

34:35

anyway, he offered sacrifices on this

34:38

altar to appease God, who is

34:40

currently plaguing the people because

34:43

of the census that David took. Okay,

34:45

so who cares? What's the tie of

34:47

this story to the temple? Well, it's

34:49

indirect, but it's still

34:51

there. This threshing floor, we

34:54

read in the story, would become

34:56

the site of Solomon's temple, which

34:59

David didn't plan. He just erected an

35:01

altar on this threshing floor of Arona

35:03

to offer a sacrifice. That's

35:05

where the temple would be built, but this is

35:07

not explicit. David's not thinking to himself, yeah, I'm

35:09

founding a site for the temple here. It's

35:12

a very innocent little story. It

35:14

connects to the temple, but it's not really David

35:16

going out of his way to make preparations or

35:18

anything like that for the temple. And

35:21

this is the only thing David does

35:23

in the Deuteronomistic history that is really

35:25

related to temple preparation at the temple

35:27

building. So anyway, the

35:30

next story of the temple

35:32

building is told very briefly. It's in two

35:34

chapters, 1 Kings 6 and

35:36

7, and all, again,

35:38

without involvement from David. The

35:41

chronicler, however, and you can see where

35:43

this is going, he has David very

35:46

involved in the temple. He doesn't build

35:48

it, but he does

35:50

everything but build it. Where

35:52

can you read this? Oh, I don't know. 1

35:55

Chronicles, chapters 22 through 29, eight chapters

35:57

of Deuteronomy. David

36:00

doing all sorts of stuff, he

36:02

gives the order to have the temple built,

36:05

and he gives a charge to Solomon. You

36:07

know, he's like the overseer of the

36:09

whole project. He assembles all the priests

36:11

and the Levites and gives them the

36:13

pep talk. He sets up

36:16

the musicians, gatekeepers, treasurers, and

36:18

others, and then he assembles

36:20

all Israel together and publicly

36:22

instructs Solomon to build a

36:24

temple. David, he's

36:26

not building it, but he's doing everything but.

36:29

See, the reason given for David's,

36:32

let's call it, helicopter parenting of

36:34

Solomon's temple project is

36:36

laid out in 1 Chronicles 29, 1 to 2. Let

36:40

me quote, King David said

36:42

to the whole assembly, My

36:44

son Solomon, whom alone God

36:46

has chosen, is young

36:48

and inexperienced, and the work is great,

36:51

for the temple will not

36:53

be for mortals, but for the

36:55

Lord God. So I have provided

36:57

for the house of my God, so far

36:59

as I was able, the gold

37:01

for the things of gold, the silver for the

37:03

things of silver, etc. You

37:05

see, Solomon can handle it, but he

37:08

can't handle it. So I've arranged

37:10

everything. You're welcome. It reminds

37:12

me of a parent telling their recent college

37:14

graduate that they need to live on their

37:16

own and make it on their own. So

37:19

the parent helps them along by finding them

37:21

a job, setting them up with an

37:23

apartment, and then giving them a new car. The

37:26

chronicler makes David

37:28

responsible for the

37:30

temple, not for building it, but

37:33

for doing everything but. Why?

37:36

Well, see, he's not interested in painting a

37:38

rosy picture of David or something just

37:41

because he likes David. Rather,

37:43

the chronicler's David is

37:45

a model for what their

37:47

true and future king would look

37:49

like, a temple honoring

37:51

king. That's what it means

37:53

to be in the line of David, to have

37:56

an attitude towards the temple that David explicitly had,

37:58

at least explicitly, according to the temple. according to

38:00

the chronicler. Remember, at this time,

38:03

they have no king. The

38:05

chronicler's David points the reader

38:07

future in time. It's not a trip

38:09

down memory lane. And let me

38:12

add here that the chronicler –

38:14

I'm trying to avoid using modern

38:16

language and modern biases here –

38:18

but the chronicler is not distorting

38:21

the past. He's

38:23

using it. Let's call

38:25

it for pastoral purposes. He's

38:28

using it to establish for his

38:30

community a vision for their future

38:33

with a righteous, temple-honoring son

38:35

of David to rule them. So

38:38

David's awesome. Having said

38:41

that, how awesome David is and righteous,

38:43

let's talk about the David and Bathsheba

38:45

incident. This is our second example of

38:48

how the chronicler treats David. In

38:50

2 Samuel 11, we

38:52

read the famous story of

38:54

David's rape of Bathsheba. And

38:57

by the way, if you haven't

38:59

seen the brief three-part video series

39:01

on the David and Bathsheba story

39:03

by our very own Nerd in

39:05

Residence, Cynthia Shafer-Elliott,

39:08

you need to do that right away.

39:10

Please access your social media accounts and

39:12

take a few minutes and learn everything

39:14

you've wanted to know ever about

39:16

this story. Anyway, with

39:18

respect to the David and Bathsheba story

39:21

in 2 Samuel, this is

39:23

happening in 2 Samuel 11. That's

39:25

the rape of Bathsheba. And David

39:28

had been crowned king.

39:30

His opposition had been removed. He brings

39:32

the ark back to Jerusalem. He enjoys

39:35

battle victories. He offers a pious

39:37

prayer, etc. And this goes on through

39:39

chapter 10. So

39:41

here's a point. Chapters 5 through

39:43

10, those are the good times

39:46

for David. This is when everything is

39:48

as it should be. But that

39:50

comes to a screeching halt here in

39:52

chapter 11. His rape of

39:54

Bathsheba led to political trouble, which

39:57

marks the remainder of his career. See, David

39:59

has no peace but suffers

40:01

the consequences of his actions. So

40:04

how does the chronicler handle this

40:07

episode? One that makes

40:09

David look so imperfect. How

40:11

does he handle it? He doesn't. He

40:13

skips it entirely. This incident, the

40:16

effects of which would follow David for the remainder

40:18

of his life, according

40:20

to the Deuteronomistic historian, is completely

40:22

left out of the chronicler's picture.

40:26

Rather than smooth it over or give it

40:28

a good spin, which I think

40:30

is impossible to do in this story, he

40:32

just omits it. Let me

40:34

suggest that this incident is not

40:37

something he could easily fold into

40:39

his retelling of the David story.

40:42

He's giving us an idealized David, and

40:44

this idealized David

40:47

would come to dominate both Judaism

40:49

in the centuries to follow and

40:51

the early Christian movement. David,

40:54

the morally flawed character of

40:57

the Deuteronomistic history, would

40:59

become, thanks in large part to the

41:01

chronicler, the man after God's

41:03

own heart. See,

41:05

that nicer narrative eventually

41:08

dominates the Jewish and

41:10

Christian landscape, so

41:12

much so that well-intentioned Bible

41:14

readers today have some trouble

41:17

accepting the Deuteronomistic

41:19

historian's unflattering portrait of David,

41:21

especially in the David and

41:24

Bathsheba story. And by the

41:26

way, this is why the

41:28

chronicler's retelling of David's census is

41:31

what it is. You may remember David numbers

41:33

his troops, which displeases the Lord

41:35

greatly in both 2 Samuel 24 and 1 Chronicles 21.

41:40

The difference is that in 2 Samuel,

41:42

it is the Lord himself who incited

41:45

David to do this, to count the

41:47

number of his fighting men. So

41:50

God plagued everyone because of it, which

41:52

is an odd story. He plagues David

41:54

for a census that the Lord himself

41:57

incited him to do. One

41:59

of those weird stories in the book. the Bible. Anyway,

42:01

in 1 Chronicles, it's not

42:03

the Lord who incites David, it's Satan. Now,

42:06

just what is meant there at this point in

42:08

history by Satan is an interesting issue we can't

42:10

get into here. But the main

42:12

point is pretty clear. The troubling

42:15

relationship between David and God

42:17

that's implied in 2 Samuel is

42:19

sidestepped completely by the chronicler. The

42:22

plague is still there in Chronicles, but

42:24

not because God had a beef with

42:27

David. God and David get along. The

42:30

last example concerns the transfer of

42:32

power from David to Solomon. Another

42:35

really interesting moment here. In

42:37

1 Kings 1-2, the

42:39

transfer of power, you know, it

42:41

reads like a Game of Thrones episode, folks,

42:43

with intrigue and murder of rivals and all

42:46

sorts of stuff like that. In

42:48

1 Chronicles, the transfer, however,

42:50

is smooth and silk. It's hardly worth

42:52

a comment. 1 Chronicles

42:55

23, verse 1, when

42:57

David was old and full of days

42:59

he made his son Solomon king over

43:01

Israel. It's like, here's your crown,

43:03

boy, have at it. It's not a big deal. 1 Chronicles

43:06

ends, and here I'm talking about chapter 29,

43:08

verses 22-25, but

43:11

1 Chronicles ends by repeating the

43:13

sentiment and praising David at

43:15

his death, having lived a

43:18

life of fullness, riches, and honor. The

43:20

smooth transfer of power emphasizes

43:22

the unity of the nation, which

43:25

is a big theme in Chronicles, by the

43:28

way. It also emphasizes God's blessing on David

43:30

and then Solomon. That's what

43:32

this rewriting, this retelling of

43:34

the transfer of power in

43:36

Chronicles accomplishes. It

43:38

presents a very different picture of

43:41

the stability of the reign of David

43:44

and of God's presence

43:46

with David. factories,

44:00

schools, and power plants. They all depend

44:03

on you. No matter the weather, emergency,

44:05

or time of day, you're the ones

44:07

who get it done. At Grainger, we're

44:10

here for you, with professional-grade industrial supplies.

44:12

Count on real-time product availability and

44:14

fast delivery. Call, click grainger.com, or

44:17

just stop by Grainger

44:19

for the ones who get it

44:21

done. That's

44:27

so much for David. Let's move on to

44:29

the fourth section and talk briefly about Solomon.

44:32

And this is 2 Chronicles 1-9.

44:34

Now, he is, of course, David's son and the

44:37

last king of the United Monarchy.

44:39

And the chronicler's focus differs from

44:42

that of the Deuteronomistic history, which

44:45

you probably have guessed by now, right? So

44:47

the story of Solomon's completion of

44:49

the temple dominates this section in

44:51

Chronicles. The chronicler leaves

44:53

out things that don't enhance Solomon's role

44:55

in the temple, like, you know, that

44:57

famous story of the two women who

44:59

each claimed that an infant was theirs,

45:02

and the true mother cried out in

45:04

horror when Solomon suggested he solve this

45:06

problem by just cutting the infant in

45:08

half, right? Remember that? Well, the chronicler

45:10

leaves that out. And he also leaves

45:12

out Solomon's apostasy

45:15

in 1 Kings 11. This is

45:17

where Solomon built high places for

45:20

his foreign wives to worship their foreign

45:22

gods on Israelite land. Bad

45:25

move, Solomon. And according to

45:27

1 Kings, this act was

45:30

the reason for the division of the

45:32

monarchy itself into north and south. See,

45:35

Solomon blew it. So

45:37

what does the chronicler do with all

45:39

this? Well, the chronicler focuses on

45:41

the temple as Solomon's only

45:44

act of note. And

45:46

this section, these first nine chapters

45:48

of 2 Chronicles, this section is

45:51

centered around that temple,

45:53

literally centered around it. The middle

45:55

section, chapters 3 through 7, are

45:58

all about the construction of the temple. the temple and

46:00

the dedication of the temple. Five

46:03

of the nine chapters. Framing

46:05

that section are chapters two and eight. Two

46:08

is about Solomon's preparations for the temple, and

46:10

chapter eight is about the final touches put

46:13

on the temple. And then

46:15

framing that entire section is

46:17

chapters one and nine. And

46:20

these are two sections about Solomon's kingly

46:22

reputation. Chapter one talks about his wisdom

46:24

and wealth, and chapter nine

46:26

talks about his international reputation. This is

46:29

the whole incident with the queen of

46:31

Sheba, and also about his wealth. See,

46:34

anyway, chronicler's focus is

46:36

on what is at the center

46:39

of this nine chapter section, which

46:41

is the actual temple building. Everything

46:44

before leads up to it. Everything

46:47

that comes after is a result of it. Now,

46:50

one thing I want to point out here

46:52

quickly about this section is chapter nine, verse

46:54

eight. Because here we

46:56

see a theme of chronicles that we've already

46:58

glimpsed, and this is why I want to

47:00

emphasize this. These are the

47:02

words of the queen of Sheba, what she says

47:04

to Solomon, right? She visits him and sees his

47:07

wealth, blah, blah, blah. And she says, blessed

47:09

be the Lord your God, who has

47:11

delighted in you and set you on

47:13

his throne as king for the

47:16

Lord your God. It's

47:18

so easy to miss folks, that little line there,

47:20

but the queen of Sheba says that the throne

47:22

is God's. And

47:25

it's just the one occupying it. And

47:27

this is one of these micro details, but

47:30

it is all part of the chronicler's

47:33

purpose, the chronicler's agenda for

47:35

penning this story of Israel's

47:37

history. And that purpose is,

47:39

among other things, to bring some comfort to

47:42

his generation and knowing that the throne is

47:44

occupied at all times, either

47:47

by God or by a king. Okay,

47:49

enough with Solomon here. Let's move to

47:52

the final section, and this is the

47:54

divided monarchy in chapters 10 to 36

47:56

of 2 Chronicles. The

48:00

big distinctive mark of this section

48:02

is that only the careers of the

48:05

southern kings are mentioned. Now,

48:07

northern kings are mentioned here and there

48:09

as they play roles in the dealings

48:11

of the southern kings, but they don't

48:13

get their own sections as they do

48:15

in first and second kings. The

48:18

chronicler is only interested in telling

48:20

the story of the southern nation of Judah

48:23

because they are the ones left standing. The

48:26

north, you may recall, was exiled in 722

48:29

BCE by the Assyrians, never

48:31

to return, about 350 years earlier. They're

48:35

all gone. What's left is the

48:37

south. And what's fascinating is not

48:39

just leaving out the northern kings,

48:41

but it's how the chronicler gives

48:44

his own twist to these narratives of

48:46

the southern kings. And in some

48:48

cases, there is more of a twist than in others.

48:51

And just to not bore you with

48:53

five examples, which would take too long

48:55

anyway, I just want to focus on

48:57

one illustration that really drives

49:00

home how thoughtful and creative

49:02

and intentional and

49:04

theological the chronicler is in

49:06

telling the story of

49:08

his people. And the one

49:10

illustration is the story of King Manasseh.

49:13

This is found in 2 Chronicles 33 and also in 2 Kings 21. Now

49:20

telling you folks, just printing them out – this

49:22

is what I do for my undergraduate students –

49:24

just printing them out and laying them side by

49:26

side is itself an

49:28

education in what Chronicles is all

49:30

about. So Manasseh, who

49:33

is this guy? Well, he is hands

49:35

down the worst king of Judah. The

49:38

story in 2 Kings goes like this.

49:41

The author tells us in

49:43

great detail all about Manasseh's

49:45

wicked reign, which includes

49:47

not only the worship of the

49:50

Canaanite gods Baal and Asherah, but

49:53

child sacrifice, and both are

49:55

major no-no's. And

49:57

after that, the author gives his

49:59

evaluation. of Manasseh, which

50:02

is this. Because of all this horrible

50:04

stuff that he did, here's what's

50:06

going to happen. God will bring

50:08

upon Judah the same fate

50:11

he brought upon the northern kingdom

50:13

of Israel, which is exile. See,

50:15

Manasseh's deeds and, as the narrator tells

50:18

us, the great amount of blood that

50:20

he spilled, those things are

50:22

too much for God to overlook in

50:25

several generations because of what

50:28

Manasseh did, Judah

50:30

will have to be exiled. That's

50:32

about as bad as you can get, folks,

50:34

in the Old Testament in terms of evaluating

50:36

a king. This guy is responsible

50:39

for you people losing your land, and

50:41

your king, and your temple. How

50:44

is the chronicler's version of

50:46

Manasseh different? Well, he

50:48

begins the same way by recounting

50:50

Manasseh's sins from 2

50:52

Kings and almost verbatim. There are

50:55

some small differences, but basically line

50:57

by line it reiterates all that

50:59

stuff. But that's where

51:01

the similarities end and where the

51:03

spin begins. To cut to the

51:05

chase, the story of Manasseh is

51:07

creatively rewritten by the chronicler in

51:10

such a way that

51:12

Manasseh now becomes an object

51:14

lesson for repentance for the

51:16

people of Judah. Right? Let

51:18

me lay this out. This is, I

51:20

think, a very important illustration for understanding

51:23

the nature of the chronicler's handling

51:25

of Samuel and Kings. See,

51:28

after recounting his sins, here's what we

51:30

read in 2 Chronicles. The

51:32

Lord spoke to Manasseh

51:35

and the people to try to get them to see the

51:37

error of their ways, but they

51:39

don't heed God's warning. So

51:41

God's next move – now, this is the

51:44

key point here, folks – God's

51:46

next move is to have the

51:48

Assyrians attack Jerusalem

51:52

and take Manasseh captive

51:55

and then bring him in chains to

51:57

Babylon. Now, there's a lot of going

52:00

on here. You know, for one thing, the

52:04

Assyrians attacking during this period. Manasseh

52:07

reigned mid to late

52:09

7th century BCE. And

52:12

Second Kings certainly knows nothing

52:14

of the Assyrians capturing Manasseh,

52:18

let alone taking him captured

52:21

bound to Babylon. They're

52:24

Assyrians. What are they

52:26

doing taking him to Babylon? This

52:28

is, in my opinion, historically

52:31

implausible. It seems more like

52:33

the chronicler is trying to

52:35

say something. Hold that thought.

52:38

Next, we read in 2 Chronicles

52:40

that while he was in Babylon,

52:43

Manasseh had a, basically, I'm going

52:45

to say a conversion experience. He

52:47

humbles himself and he repents before

52:49

God for all that he's done.

52:52

And as a result, God

52:54

rewards him by restoring him

52:56

to his throne. So

52:59

he not only was captured, he gets

53:01

back somehow and he sits

53:03

on the throne again. And after he got back,

53:06

Manasseh, among other things, he

53:09

cleaned the house of the Lord from foreign

53:11

gods and he led the people in the

53:13

proper worship of God. Right?

53:15

This is a major repentance about

53:17

face here for Manasseh. And

53:20

Second Kings knows nothing of this. Manasseh

53:23

learned his lesson. But here's

53:25

the problem. Why did the exile happen

53:27

if Manasseh is a good guy? Well,

53:30

the people kept sacrificing at

53:32

the high places. Now, they only

53:34

sacrificed to the Lord, mind you,

53:36

which is good. It's better, but

53:39

still, sacrificing at the high

53:41

places, even to Yahweh, was

53:43

simply forbidden. So for

53:45

the chronicler, the cause of

53:47

the exile was no longer Manasseh.

53:50

He repented of his sins. It's

53:53

just that the people didn't follow the program. They

53:56

were to blame. See, this

53:58

episode as the chronicler tells... that

54:00

didn't happen. The Assyrians did

54:02

not take Manasseh captive to Babylon. That

54:05

historically is just fraught with all sorts

54:07

of unlikelihoods. But

54:09

he tells the story this way creatively

54:13

to make a point. And

54:15

it's not about Manasseh, but it's

54:17

about the writer's audience

54:20

and their situation. See, a

54:22

major theme of Chronicles is

54:25

the notion that God treats each

54:27

individual as they deserve. And if

54:29

you sin, folks,

54:31

forgiveness is just one

54:33

humble, truly heartfelt prayer

54:35

away. God listens.

54:39

See, probably the most famous line

54:41

in Chronicles is in 2 Chronicles

54:44

chapter 7. And this is where God

54:46

is speaking to Solomon after

54:48

his construction and dedication

54:50

of the temple. And

54:53

let me read to you verses 12 through 14. This is

54:55

a 2 Chronicles 7. And many

54:58

of you will recognize these words because

55:00

they're hugely used at election time every

55:03

cycle, but let's not get into that.

55:05

So, God is speaking. Here's

55:07

what he says to Solomon. I have heard

55:09

your prayer and have chosen this place, this

55:11

is the temple, for myself as

55:13

a house of sacrifice. When

55:16

I shut up the heavens so that

55:18

there is no rain, or command the

55:20

locust to devour the land, or send

55:22

pestilence among the people, if

55:25

my people who are called by

55:27

my name humble themselves, pray,

55:29

seek my face, and turn from

55:31

their wicked ways, then I will

55:33

hear from heaven and will forgive

55:35

their sin and heal their land.

55:38

See, this is a major theme

55:40

of Chronicles. Prayer, humility, repentance are

55:44

always available and they work. It

55:46

even worked for Manasseh, the

55:49

worst king on the planet, and so it

55:51

can work for you. As

55:53

God brought Manasseh out of

55:55

exile in Babylon on account

55:57

of his repentance, well...

56:00

God brought your ancestors out of

56:02

Babylon too. And

56:04

as for you, people stuck here in

56:07

Persian-run Judea, no matter

56:10

how bad things get for you, no matter

56:12

how much you might think that God has

56:14

abandoned us as His special people, no matter

56:16

how deeply you're worried that there is no

56:19

future for you and your people, we

56:21

like Manasseh can also become

56:24

fully restored. If it

56:26

happened to Manasseh, it can happen to

56:28

anybody. By the way, the

56:30

chronicler's version of the story of Manasseh

56:33

seems to have inspired a later writer

56:36

to pen something that we call today

56:38

the prayer of Manasseh, which you can

56:40

find in any version of

56:43

the Bible that contains the Apocrypha.

56:46

And I recommend reading it. It's great

56:48

stuff. It's a brief, it's

56:50

only 15 verses long, but it's a

56:52

brief but powerful statement of

56:54

Jewish piety during the late Second

56:56

Temple period. Well,

56:59

folks, I don't know. There's so much

57:01

to talk about with first and second

57:04

chronicles and can't get to all of it,

57:06

as you know, but I hope these highlights have

57:08

given you some sense of why chronicles is much

57:11

more than just some tidbits that

57:13

didn't make it into Samuel King's.

57:15

Rather, it is a thoughtful, work-out

57:18

piece of theology expressed by

57:20

means of a creative retelling of the

57:22

history of the monarchy. And

57:24

I understand that some listening might balk

57:27

at the notion that two

57:29

such very different stories of

57:31

500 years

57:34

of Israel's history can coexist in the

57:36

same Bible. That can't be.

57:39

That's a contradiction. And yet here they are.

57:42

And the differences between them are not

57:44

minor details to be ignored, nor

57:46

are they problems that need fixing.

57:48

Rather, it's not the

57:50

bug, right? It's actually the heart of

57:52

the matter. These episodes,

57:55

just the ones we've gone through, are

57:57

snapshots of how ancient

58:00

Israelites at a

58:02

different time understood differently their relationship

58:04

with their God. And

58:06

that understanding is affected by the

58:09

time and place and circumstances of

58:12

this author. Actually, the

58:14

same goes for both authors. The Deuteronomistic

58:16

Historian and the Chronicler are both people

58:18

writing and describing and talking about and

58:21

emoting the events that

58:24

are important to them and telling the story in a

58:26

way that gets across what they want to get across.

58:29

Their theology reflects their

58:32

setting. And frankly, folks, a

58:34

more obvious statement could not be made. And

58:37

yet this acknowledgment is still fraught

58:39

with controversy, at least in some circles.

58:42

See, when you read Chronicles, you're

58:44

reading one group's expression of

58:47

the nature of their existence as the

58:50

people descended from the ancient Israelites. You're

58:53

watching them put the pieces together

58:55

and how they see themselves and

58:57

their God. Chronicles

58:59

is, if I can use this expression,

59:02

it is a piece of contextual theology.

59:05

And it would not be the last. Jews

59:07

and then Christians ever since have been

59:09

doing the very same thing the Chronicler

59:11

does. How do

59:13

we connect today with those

59:16

stories from back then? That's

59:19

the question all faith traditions ask

59:21

sooner or later. How do

59:23

we today connect with the past? And

59:25

in Chronicles, we have one

59:28

early, and I'm going to

59:30

say thoroughly biblical example of this

59:32

living dynamic between past

59:35

and present. Well,

59:38

thanks to everyone who supports the show.

59:40

If you want to support what we

59:42

do, there are three ways you can

59:44

do it. One, if you just want

59:46

to give a little money, go to

59:48

thebiblefornormalpeople.com front flash give. And if you

59:50

want to support us and want a

59:52

community, classes, and other great resources, go

59:54

to thebiblefornormalpeople.com front slash join. And lastly,

59:56

it always goes a long way if

59:58

you just wanted to. rate the podcast,

1:00:00

leave a review, and tell others about

1:00:02

our show. In addition, you can let

1:00:04

us know what you thought about the

1:00:06

episode by emailing us at info at

1:00:08

thebiblefornormalpeople.com. You've just made it

1:00:11

through another episode of The Bible for Normal People. Don't

1:00:13

forget you can catch our other show, Faith

1:00:15

for Normal People, in the same feed wherever

1:00:17

you get your podcasts. This episode

1:00:20

was brought to you by the Bible for Normal

1:00:22

People team. Brittany Hodge,

1:00:24

Stephen Henning, Wesley Duckworth,

1:00:26

Savannah Locke, Tessa Stultz,

1:00:28

Danny Wong, Natalie Wyand,

1:00:30

Lauren O'Connell, Jessica Chou, and

1:00:32

Naomi Gonzalez. Pause

1:00:39

for a drink. What kind of drink, you

1:00:41

ask, Stephen, and or Brittany? Coffee.

1:00:45

It's eight in the morning here. Hey

1:00:48

there. Did you know Kroger always gives

1:00:50

you savings and rewards on top of

1:00:52

our lower than low prices? And

1:00:54

when you download the Kroger app, you'll enjoy over $500 in

1:00:56

savings every week with

1:00:58

digital coupons. And don't forget fuel points to

1:01:00

help you save up to $1

1:01:02

per gallon at the pump. Want to save

1:01:04

even more? With a boost membership, you'll get

1:01:06

double fuel points and free delivery.

Rate

Join Podchaser to...

  • Rate podcasts and episodes
  • Follow podcasts and creators
  • Create podcast and episode lists
  • & much more

Episode Tags

Do you host or manage this podcast?
Claim and edit this page to your liking.
,

Unlock more with Podchaser Pro

  • Audience Insights
  • Contact Information
  • Demographics
  • Charts
  • Sponsor History
  • and More!
Pro Features