Popular Reviews of The Cellar Letters

So I started the show expecting a serious ghost chasing show, for some weird reason. What I got was two 'bros' freakin out over ghosts... I love it! It's got good story progression, keeps me interested, and I'm super interested in seeing what happens next! Keep it going!

so FUN and so SPOOKY. well acted, well written, and so perfectly eases you into the scares and i’ve been spooked by some jumps on more than one occasion. there are some moments that feel so real and charming. awesome vibe! but will definitely pause and think before stepping into dark basements now lol. absolutely recommend this show to anyone who enjoys having fun and being spooked!!! can’t wait for more. (also there’s a dog??? amazing)

Great fun! Genuine intrigue with some pretty charming humor to boot. Very curious to see where it goes.

Never enter the basement. Or the cellar. But if you do, bring this pod along to scare the bejeezus out of you. You will not be disappointed unless that's your thing.

This podcast scared me so bad! It was a lot of fun listening to it, I'm very excited for more! And there's a dog!!!!

Genuinely terrifying and hilarious, often at the same time. Between the jokes and the jump scares, this show grabs your attention and won't let go. The main characters' silliness endears them to the listener, and in a strange way lends authenticity to the haunting mystery they begin to unravel. I can listen to five episodes without blinking or noticing time has passed.

This is a really fun horror podcast. It's like a cross between a drunken Marble Hornets and the Dionaea House, but as a full cast audiodrama. You're doing yourself a disservice if you don't give it a listen.

it's an entertaining buddy horror with lots of pop culture references. The sound mixing is a little off though (apologies if that's the wrong term), turning up the volume to hear the main actors then getting blasted by a jump scare hurts the ears. Not against their use of jump scares but if you're listening I recommend being aware of that.Edit: looked over my initial words and wanted to add. I am excited to see where this project goes and any future productions. Also the relationship between the main characters is endearing, feels very natural.

Brilliant, spooky, well-acted. A must-listen in every regard.

This is such a gem! Spooky, funny, with relatable and utterly charming characters. I just binged the first 10 episodes of The Cellar Letters and I´m totally hooked!It´s so entertaining, with a witty dialogue, well acted and the story takes so many funny, unpredictable and scary turns.The sound design is a bit rough around the edges, and that´s actually absolutely perfect for this show.Update: after listening to more episodes I find this gets better with everyone. The sound design improves a lot, it gets even funnier (it has the best advertisement for patronage I've ever heard) and all in all this is just a blast and I enjoy every minute

It's been a long time since I've been this invested into a audio drama. Just the perfect horror story tempered with the right amount of humour! Loving it

Spooky and fun, with some really engaging characters. I quite enjoyed the musical interludes. I'm very worried about the dog....

The scares are quiet and subtle, which makes them more intense. There are really two mysteries at work here--the basement of the house, and the narrator's past. As the two become more intertwined, the story becomes more personal and more affecting. There are times you'll have to use headphones, but the softness is creepier.

What happens when some almost-bros move into a haunted house? Find out with the Cellar Letters. This is a hilariously different POV on the haunted house and I definitely recommend you give it a shot if you like comedic spooky

When I first listened, I wasn't prepared for how funny I'd find this podcast. It certainly falls within the realm of Horror, but there is a very healthy dash of comedy in the mix to help alleviate the stress of listening. You can sense the enthusiasm, Jamie the creator, has for storytelling and it's intoxicating to listen to, in the same way listening to someone enthusiastically tell you about anything they truly love.

This is hardly a masterpiece in either storytelling or a show of technical skills, but there's something really comforting about listening to the creepy audiofiction equivalent of two large easily-startled puppies trying to figure out how a door works. The acting is very endearing and it's easy to cheer these bros on as they continue to get spooped by architecture and bits of paper.

Ever want to eat steak on a steakout? Be serious...I am being serious. Creepy, scary and hilarious. Solid sound design and good voice acting keep you enthralled - don't go in the basement!

Truly, I have never felt so represented in horror as a forgetful goofyass dude. The way that this show tracked my exact emotional trajectory during The Rona is upsetting and impressive. Also, there's just not very much high quality horror comedy in podcasting right now, which I think is partly why The Cellar Letters has rightly become one of THE big-name horror podcasts right now! #JusticeForSteve

I love the story. I didn't expect to like it so much but its actually refusing.

A fun podcast but the episode lengths are so short it's almost half ads and it's hard to keep up with the story without binging it. Another problem is so much of it is not the story and just feels like silly filler