Episode Transcript
Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.
Use Ctrl + F to search
0:00
Wondery Plus subscribers can listen to
0:02
USA Today's The Excerpt ad-free right
0:04
now. Join Wondery Plus in the
0:06
Wondery app. The
0:08
Excerpt is sponsored by NetSuite. NetSuite
0:11
is the number one cloud financial
0:13
system with 25 years of helping
0:16
businesses do more with less. Stay
0:19
tuned after the show for a special offer
0:21
just for our listeners. Good
0:28
morning, I'm Taylor Wilson and today is
0:30
Thursday, March 14th, 2024. This
0:33
is The Excerpt. Today,
0:39
the murky future of TikTok in the
0:41
U.S. Plus, a Georgia judge
0:43
dismisses several charges in the Trump election
0:45
racketeering case and we take a look
0:48
at how some school districts are helping
0:50
teachers with housing. The
0:53
House has approved a bill targeting TikTok, putting
0:56
the future of the popular app in the
0:58
United States up in the air. I
1:00
caught up with USA Today Congress and
1:03
campaigns reporter Riley Beggin for the latest.
1:05
Riley, thanks for hopping on The Excerpt today. Of course.
1:08
So the House approved this TikTok bill
1:10
yesterday. What would it functionally
1:12
do, Riley, and why do proponents say
1:15
it's necessary? It's been described often
1:17
as a ban, but that's not
1:19
exactly what it would do. It
1:21
would essentially force the parent company
1:23
of TikTok, which is called ByteDance,
1:26
to sell the app within around
1:28
six months. And if they do
1:30
not do that, that would be
1:32
banned in the United States. And
1:34
essentially it would be deplatform, prevented
1:37
from being shared on the app
1:39
stores and stuff like that. And
1:41
the argument for it, ByteDance is
1:43
a Beijing-based company. It's a Chinese
1:45
company. So TikTok
1:47
has an American subsidiary,
1:49
but lawmakers that have
1:52
concerns about this are worried
1:54
about the Chinese government's potential
1:57
influence over Americans' data
1:59
here. Some people are worried
2:01
about propaganda going through the app
2:03
and influencing Americans, and then other
2:05
sort of national security risks. And you know,
2:08
this vote passed overwhelmingly in the House, but
2:10
a group of House lawmakers have warned against
2:12
a ban like this. What's their
2:14
argument, Riley? There were about 65 people
2:17
who voted against the bill in
2:19
the House. Their explanations really run
2:21
the gamut. So something that
2:23
we hear a lot is First Amendment concerns,
2:26
you know, worried that it would be restricting
2:28
Americans' freedom of speech. People
2:30
have said that this process was rushed. It
2:32
just passed through committee late last week. People
2:36
have said it's bad policy, that instead we
2:38
should have actual standards for social media companies,
2:40
that we should be doing more for data
2:42
privacy. And then another thing
2:45
is concerns that it could hurt small businesses,
2:47
because a lot of people make money on
2:49
TikTok. The people who
2:51
voted against this really sort of
2:53
ran the gamut. We had really
2:56
progressive lawmakers like Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez and
2:58
Ilhan Omar, and really
3:00
conservative members like Marjorie Taylor Greene
3:02
that voted against it. The House
3:04
Intelligence Chair, Jim Himes, voted against
3:06
it. Nancy Mace cited constitutional issues.
3:09
So a wide range of people.
3:11
You don't see them all agreeing
3:13
that often. So what does
3:15
TikTok say about these concerns over
3:17
user data? And what does this
3:19
lobbying campaign from them look like
3:21
in recent weeks? TikTok has
3:24
been really pushing back. They have prompted
3:26
their users to call members of Congress
3:28
and tell them to oppose the bill.
3:30
There are a lot of members who
3:32
have told us that they think that
3:34
that approach backfired. Top influencers on the
3:36
platform have come to the Capitol to
3:39
speak with lawmakers. There was a protest
3:41
outside the Capitol yesterday when the House
3:43
bill passed. And then this
3:45
week, the CEO of TikTok came to the
3:47
Hill to speak with lawmakers. And there are
3:49
some senators who have said, no, I'm
3:52
not going to meet with him. And then TikTok says,
3:55
your data is safe with us. They say
3:57
TikTok stores its American user data in the
3:59
United States. that is managed solely
4:01
by a US-based data security team
4:04
since mid-2022. There
4:06
has been some reporting that has indicated
4:08
that that may not be the whole
4:10
picture. The data of paid
4:12
content creators is stored on servers in
4:14
China, according to reporting by Forbes from
4:16
last year. So there
4:18
are a couple ways to sort of look
4:20
at that claim. So Riley, the bill
4:22
now, of course, needs the Senate to pass.
4:25
What are you hearing about its chances there
4:27
in that chamber and what's next going forward?
4:30
I would say for the most part, senators
4:32
share the concerns of the folks in the
4:34
House about the national security vulnerabilities here. But
4:37
there's definitely less of a
4:40
unanimous agreement for the bill.
4:43
The two top senators on the Intelligence
4:45
Committee, Mark Warner and Marco Rubio, conservative
4:48
Senator Josh Hawley, the number two
4:50
Republican in the Senate, John Thune,
4:53
have all said that they are for this.
4:55
But at the same time, there are a
4:57
lot of senators who have raised other concerns.
4:59
They're worried that the House bill might not
5:01
be legal for President Trump. Try
5:03
to ban TikTok when he was president and
5:05
the courts blocked him. So that's sort
5:07
of the backdrop of a lot of people's thoughts about this. There's
5:11
conversations about alternative solutions, like making
5:13
it easier for the Commerce Department
5:15
to regulate foreign apps. And
5:18
then Senator Rand Paul of Kentucky has said
5:20
he would block speedy passage. They need unanimous
5:22
consent, all 100 votes in
5:25
the Senate, to avoid moving
5:27
through the multi-day process of
5:29
considering legislation. He said to
5:31
me, in a free country, you don't take people's
5:33
companies. He thinks it violates the First Amendment. So
5:35
he is, at the very least, going to do
5:38
his best to stop it. President
5:40
Biden has said that he would sign this
5:42
bill if it got to his desk. So
5:44
if it makes it through the Senate, then
5:46
the indications are good that the president would support
5:48
it. Riley Bagan covers Congress and
5:51
campaigns for USA Today. Great
5:53
update for us here. Thanks, Riley. Of
5:55
course. Thank
5:58
you. Georgia judge
6:00
presiding over former President Donald Trump's
6:03
case for allegedly trying to steal
6:05
the Twenty Twenty election dismiss six
6:07
charges yesterday. Fulton County Judge Scott
6:09
Mcafee did so because they were
6:12
not specific enough against Trump and
6:14
several codefendants. It is miss.
6:16
Charges allege a mass public officials
6:18
to violate their oath of office
6:20
by switching presidential electors from those
6:22
for President Joe Biden the one
6:24
Georgia to Trump. Still, The
6:27
judge less thirty five charges and place
6:29
in the indictment. And you attacks
6:31
described in the indictment like Trump's call to
6:33
Georgia Secretary of State Brad Rapids Burger when
6:35
he asked him to find the votes needed
6:37
to give him victory in the state. The.
6:40
Judge said the ass could still be alleged
6:42
as part of the conspiracy. Is.
6:44
Not yet scheduled the trial and
6:46
is also considering whether to disqualify
6:48
Fulton County District Attorney Funny Willis
6:51
and Special Prosecutor Nathan Way from
6:53
the case. The
6:58
portion of Us adults who identify
7:00
as other than heterosexual as more
7:03
than doubled since Twenty Twelve. According
7:05
to a Gallup poll, about seven
7:07
point six percent of adults in
7:09
the country identify as Lgbtq plus
7:11
or something other than heterosexual. That's
7:14
compared to around five and a half percent
7:16
for years ago, and three and a half
7:18
percent in Twenty twelve. Now. Was
7:20
the year the National Polling
7:22
Agency began measuring sexual orientation
7:24
and transgender identity. The. Authors
7:27
said that if trends continue, the share
7:29
of Lgbtq plus adults in the U
7:31
will exceed ten percent within the next
7:34
thirty years. Branded. Robinson and
7:36
associate professor and Department chair of
7:38
Gender and Sexuality Studies at the
7:40
University of California Riverside said the
7:43
growing numbers show that people sense
7:45
greater societal acceptance. And. Or
7:47
support systems for those who
7:50
identify as Lgbtq plus. with
7:56
rising rents some school districts around
7:58
the country are trying to find
8:00
teachers affordable housing. I spoke
8:02
with USA Today breaking news reporter Claire
8:05
Thornton for more. Claire thanks
8:07
for hopping on the excerpt today. Thanks for
8:09
having me Taylor. So Claire
8:11
how big of an issue is unaffordable
8:13
housing for teachers? It is
8:15
a quite
8:17
enormous issue. Housing
8:20
prices have gone up everywhere
8:22
and even in school districts where
8:24
teacher salaries have increased in the
8:27
last couple of years, economic
8:29
data shows that the salary
8:31
increases have not increased nearly
8:34
enough to keep up with
8:36
rising housing costs. And so
8:38
districts are having a
8:41
hard time recruiting teachers
8:43
and at the same time rising
8:45
housing costs are pushing teachers out
8:47
of some school districts. So
8:50
Claire some school districts are now building
8:52
housing for their teachers. What
8:55
does this look like and what are some of the districts
8:57
that are doing this? It is
8:59
a very complicated process but
9:01
in the end when a
9:03
school district is actually able
9:06
to have some rental apartment
9:08
units available for district staff,
9:10
not a lot but some,
9:13
they're able to offer it at less
9:16
than half of market rate. So
9:18
that means paying as little as $800
9:20
a month or a thousand dollars
9:25
a month for a one-bedroom
9:28
in California. But it
9:30
takes years to get to that point.
9:32
Districts have to cobble together
9:34
different funding from anything they
9:36
have that they can use
9:38
to build and get
9:41
money often from the city and
9:43
other non-profit sources. Very
9:45
very few school
9:47
districts, a very small minority,
9:49
actually have teacher housing in
9:52
the U.S. but many more
9:54
are considering it. And Claire you talked
9:56
about some of the complications here. In particular,
10:00
It's curious when a teacher's employer
10:02
then becomes their landlord as
10:04
well. Can you talk about that complication? One
10:07
district leader who I spoke to
10:09
in California said, Oh,
10:12
it's like a dorm for teachers, but
10:14
he said that that criticism, he has
10:16
only ever heard that from teachers who
10:18
don't live in the teacher housing, who
10:21
have their own housing. And
10:23
he said that because of
10:25
the below market rates that
10:27
their district is able to offer
10:30
the people who are in those
10:32
units are really glad they're there.
10:34
School districts have not historically been
10:36
in the business of
10:39
creating housing and housing
10:42
advocates and education advocates
10:44
have said, it's
10:46
not good that we've gotten to
10:49
this point that school districts have
10:51
become the backstop against America's insane
10:54
housing crisis. Schools
10:57
don't really have extra time
10:59
and energy to be creating
11:01
housing, but they're doing
11:03
it because they feel like they have no other
11:05
choice. So Claire, what other
11:07
solutions are on the horizon? Is this
11:09
a matter of just paying teachers more
11:12
or what else is being discussed? It is
11:14
a yes and scenario.
11:16
Advocates and experts and district
11:19
leaders who I spoke to
11:21
said that teachers' salaries
11:23
across the board absolutely
11:26
need to be raised. Teachers
11:29
are not making enough to make ends
11:31
meet, but because of
11:33
the way school districts are funded
11:35
in the U.S., in many cases,
11:38
teachers' salaries are set and
11:41
allocated based on a limited
11:43
amount of tax revenue. So
11:46
even if a district had all the
11:48
intention in the world of raising teacher
11:50
salaries, there's only so much they can
11:52
do to put more money in the
11:55
hands of teachers because of the way
11:57
our education system is structured.
12:00
So it's a yes and situation because
12:02
even with teacher raises
12:05
that have been able to benefit teachers,
12:08
it's still not enough for them to afford market
12:11
rate housing. Claire Thornton covers poverty
12:13
and social services for USA Today.
12:16
Great insight as always, Claire. Thanks so
12:18
much. Thanks, Taylor. The
12:23
existence of menopause in humans has
12:25
long been a biological conundrum, but
12:27
scientists are now getting a better
12:29
understanding from whales. Findings
12:32
of a new study suggest that
12:34
menopause gives an evolutionary advantage to
12:36
grandmother whales grandchildren. A paper
12:38
published yesterday in the journal Nature
12:41
looked at 32 whale species, five
12:43
of which undergo menopause. In
12:45
those species, researchers' findings suggest that
12:47
menopause evolved so that grandmothers could
12:50
help their daughter's offspring without competing
12:52
with them for mates. Those findings
12:54
support what's known as the grandmother
12:56
hypothesis. It states that
12:58
menopause is evolutionarily useful because while
13:00
older women are no longer able
13:02
to have children, they can instead
13:04
focus their efforts on supporting their
13:06
children and grandchildren. This means
13:09
their family lines are more likely to survive.
13:12
You can read more with a link in today's
13:14
show notes. And be
13:16
sure to stay tuned to the excerpt
13:18
later today when my co-host Dana Taylor
13:20
talks with Kenneth Miller, professor of Earth
13:22
and Planetary Sciences at Rutgers University about
13:24
how living right on the water on
13:26
the eastern seaboard might be a
13:29
riskier venture than you thought. You
13:31
can find the episode right here on this
13:33
feed beginning at 4pm Eastern Time. And
13:36
today is Pi Day, celebrating the
13:39
mathematical constant known as pi. It's
13:41
marked on March 14th since pi is typically
13:44
rounded to 3.14. It
13:47
can actually go on forever, though the most
13:49
accurate value, according to Guinness World Records, is
13:52
more than 62 trillion digits.
13:55
Thanks for listening to the excerpt. You can
13:57
get the podcast wherever you get your audio. on
14:00
a smart speaker, just ask for the excerpt. I'm
14:03
Taylor Wilson, back tomorrow with all
14:05
of the excerpts from USA Today.
14:20
If you like USA Today's Be Excerpt,
14:23
you can listen ad-free right now by
14:25
joining Wondery Plus in the Wondery app.
14:28
Prime members can listen ad-free on
14:30
Amazon Music. Before you go,
14:32
tell us about yourself by filling
14:34
out a short survey at wondery.com/survey.
14:38
Your business gets to a certain size
14:40
and the cracks start to emerge. Things
14:43
you used to do in a day are
14:45
taking a week. You have too many manual
14:47
processes. You don't have one source of truth.
14:50
If this is you, you should know these three
14:52
numbers. 37,000, 25, one. That's
14:58
the number of businesses which have upgraded
15:00
to NetSuite by Oracle. 25,
15:02
NetSuite turns 25 this year. That's
15:06
25 years of helping businesses do
15:08
more with less, close their books
15:10
in days, not weeks, and drive
15:12
down costs. One, because
15:14
your business is one of a kind.
15:17
So you get a customized solution for
15:19
all of your KPIs in one efficient
15:21
system with one source of truth. Manage
15:24
risk, get reliable forecasts, and
15:26
improve margins. Everything you need,
15:28
all in one place. Right
15:30
now you can download NetSuite's
15:32
popular KPI checklist designed to
15:34
give you consistently excellent performance
15:37
absolutely free absolutely free, at
15:39
netsuite.com/whatismoney. That's
15:41
netsuite.com/whatismoney to get your
15:43
free KPI checklist. to
15:48
get your own KPI checklist. netsuite.com/excerpt.
Podchaser is the ultimate destination for podcast data, search, and discovery. Learn More