Episode Transcript
Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.
Use Ctrl + F to search
0:01
Hey listeners. From Cavalry Audio,
0:03
the studio that brought you the devil within and
0:05
the murder chronicles comes a riveting
0:07
new true crime podcast that you won't want
0:09
to miss. That's by Southwest.
0:13
Each week, I joined myself, Margo
0:15
Carmichael. And my sister and co host,
0:18
Jenna Gerald, as we take you on a journey
0:20
into a different Grizzly murder story,
0:22
unique to the American Southwest.
0:24
We'll
0:25
use a blend of narrative storytelling and
0:28
conversational commentary to explore shocking
0:30
murder stories that range from the utterly bizarre
0:32
to
0:33
the downright bone gel.
0:35
Unpacking both the lives and minds of
0:37
the murders and their victims.
0:40
Check out this brief sample from episode
0:43
one of death by Southwest that I'm about to play
0:45
for you. And while you're listening, please
0:47
go follow death by Southwest on Apple Podcasts,
0:50
Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts.
0:53
Death by Southwest is also available
0:55
as a premium listening experience with access
0:58
to tons of bonus content by subscribing
1:00
to Cavalry Plus. Only on
1:02
the Apple Podcasts app. Click the link
1:04
in the show notes to listen and follow.
1:12
So sometime after this is when that
1:14
front that family friend of Prestopino's
1:16
Tricia Ott, she came forward and told
1:18
police that during those two days that Christopher
1:21
had that you haul rented, he
1:23
called her to come over because he
1:25
needed help with something is what he said to her.
1:27
And according to Tricia. When
1:29
she arrived at his house, he began
1:31
to tell her a story about an unnamed female
1:34
that came over to hang out. And
1:37
they got high amethamphetamines. And
1:39
this female started freaking out and
1:41
apparently talking in quote,
1:43
the devil's tongue. And threatening
1:46
to call the cops on Christopher. So
1:48
he didn't want the cops calling him. He obviously
1:50
has several felony drug charges already.
1:53
So he tied her up to a
1:55
chair according to Tricia to calm
1:57
her down. And when she he went to untie
1:59
her, she
1:59
punched him in the face, things
2:02
escalated,
2:03
and he strangled her. To
2:06
the point where she passed out, he thought she was
2:08
dead. Oh, and I should have mentioned this earlier. She's
2:10
tiny. She's I showed
2:12
you her Instagram. We didn't even describe her. It's hard
2:14
to tell though. Like, I mean, she's not a big
2:16
human, but -- Right. -- I couldn't
2:18
tell her she tall. Like, she's five foot tall.
2:21
Five foot tall. About a hundred and ten pounds. Okay.
2:23
Very tiny human. So
2:25
he went to untie her. I can only assume
2:27
which is not a good thing to do, but I'll just
2:29
do it anyways. Mhmm. Assume
2:32
that he had thought, okay, it's been
2:34
an hour or however long. Mhmm. Maybe
2:37
fifty hours? Hopefully not. She's
2:40
calmed down. Right? Let me untie her.
2:42
Right? He and then she punched him
2:44
in the face. And he was like, oh, she's
2:46
not calm. Right? So I'm gonna
2:48
wrestle her back down. And at this point, she is
2:50
fighting back. And they physically
2:52
fought to the point where then he started
2:54
to strangle her. Now again, this is
2:56
allegedly according to Tricia. She
2:58
then told police that Chris had a UHOL
3:01
truck And in the back of the truck, there was a
3:03
cement mixer and a freezer that
3:05
was apparently taped and strapped
3:07
shut. Joseph claimed that inside
3:09
his garage, he saw a large concrete
3:12
block sitting on some type of
3:13
wooden pallet. Then
3:15
Chitra believes that Chris asked her for help
3:18
moving the concrete structure, this
3:20
concrete block, who was on the pallet
3:23
inside the back of the UHOL truck, but it was
3:25
too heavy to move. So instead,
3:27
Tricia just got in the UHOL truck because Chris
3:29
said, let's go for a ride. So Tricia
3:31
said that they stopped two times
3:33
on this little U Hall joyride they
3:35
were taking, but they didn't have the concrete
3:37
pallet. They did not. They could The freezer wasn't
3:40
there. The freezer was in there. So they
3:42
won with the first stop, they stopped behind
3:44
him. Some random business where she said that
3:46
Prestopino disposed of the freezer.
3:48
In
3:49
a dumpster and then they stopped
3:51
behind the Paris hotel
3:53
and casino where he tried
3:55
to take a forklift but
3:58
was
3:58
unable to take it for
3:59
one reason without their aunt said
4:01
to him, you're supposed to have clearance
4:03
to be in this area. But somehow,
4:06
CRISPR was able to enter that area,
4:08
tried to get the forklift, couldn't get it,
4:11
and then drove away. OTTA
4:13
that at this point, Prestopino was scaring her
4:15
which, like, really, at this point, are you kidding?
4:18
But fine. And she said that
4:20
Chris was acting strange and kept
4:22
turning the radio up so loud because
4:24
he kept saying he thought the FBI was listening.
4:27
So once they got back to his house, apparently
4:30
she left. Who
4:31
has paranoia now? I'll tell
4:33
you who doesn't, Trish.
4:35
Like, what are you doing? Did did
4:37
you show up at his house, Trish?
4:39
And he told you this story about this woman
4:41
that came over. He fed her methamphetamine.
4:42
She freaked out. He
4:44
tied her up. That he beat her and strangled
4:46
her. And then he says, oh, hey, by the
4:48
way, Can help me move this concrete
4:50
block into the back of my u haul with the
4:52
freezer I have back there? Like, what the
4:55
fuck? Maybe Trish had a
4:57
thing for cristipino. I
4:59
don't care if you are the
5:01
most I get a spectacular man
5:04
in the world. If you tell me that you
5:06
strangled a woman, and then you don't
5:08
finish the story and you're like, anyways, I'm
5:10
hoping you family move this concrete
5:12
into my rented you haul and we
5:14
could go for a little ride. Like,
5:16
I'm out
5:17
of there. Fucking run away so
5:19
fast. I wouldn't. Guess what I'd ask
5:21
before I run away. What? What's the
5:23
end of the story man. Like,
5:26
you're gonna end there. I tied
5:27
her up. I hit her. I
5:30
shut we ate methamphetamine. However,
5:32
people take meth and then Okay.
5:34
Hey, can I
5:36
Well, they're you for a lifting
5:38
muscle. You know, like, no,
5:40
that's a regu point. So
5:42
Earlier you pointed out murderers. I
5:46
said murderers. And
5:48
you were so right. CRISPR was not the
5:50
only person involved in this crime. Painter
5:54
Cassandra Garrett, or
5:57
Cassandra Pascones, or
5:59
Cassandra Tran, or Nikki Hart.
6:02
This woman went by many aliases.
6:06
Cassandra was pressed to Peyno's thirty nine
6:08
year old roommate at the time of the incident with
6:10
Esmeralda. And I
6:12
don't know much about her, except for that
6:14
Cassandra apparently had a really
6:17
big mouth.
6:27
You
6:27
just listen to a preview of cavalry
6:29
audio new podcast,
6:30
death by Southwest. If
6:32
you wanna
6:33
find out how that big mouth eventually
6:36
spelled the end for these cold blooded
6:38
killers? You can listen to the entire
6:40
episode on Apple Podcasts, Spotify,
6:43
or wherever you get in podcasts. Be
6:45
sure to follow death by Southwest today,
6:47
so you never miss an upcoming episode.
Podchaser is the ultimate destination for podcast data, search, and discovery. Learn More