Date: March 4th, 2020

Reference: Radonovich et al. N95 Respirators vs Medical Masks for Preventing Influenza Among Health Care Personnel. A Randomized Clinical Trial. JAMA 2019 The Respiratory Protection Effectiveness Clinical Trial (ResPECT)

Guest Skeptics: Dr. Christopher Patey is an Assistant Professor with Memorial University Medical School in St. John’s, Newfoundland Canada. Over the past seventeen years he has practiced as a rural emergency and family physician and Clinical Chief of Emergency at Carbonear Hospital.

Paul Norman is a registered nurse working as a frontline emergency nurse in Eastern Health, Newfoundland, Canada. Paul has greater than ten years of experience working in Emergency Nursing and Critical Care. His focus is implementation of LEAN strategies, quality and process improvement. Paul's work has been extended to reach emergency services throughout Canada and he has contributed on many platforms including local, regional, provincial and national speaking engagements.

Disclaimers: This episode is about influenza not coronavirus (Covid-19)

Dr. Patey's Disclaimer: I am not an expert on PPE (Personal Protective Equipment), Influenza/HINI/Coronavirus, Journal Reviews or Emergency Department management of pandemics.

Paul Norman's Disclaimer: We (Dr. Patey and I) are experts on asking questions on the frontline of a Rural Emergency Department to ensure quality, and most importantly, effective patient care.

Dr. Ken Milne's Disclaimer: I am an expert on critical appraisal but do not know what mask (if any) is best for preventing the Covid-19 virus.

I think we can all agree on a few general recommendation: Get a flu shot if possible, wash your hands well (at least 20 seconds with soap and water), try not to touch your face, avoid people who are sick, stay home if you are feeling ill, cough into a tissue and throw it out immediately or cough into your elbow, disinfect objects or surfaces with a regular household cleaning wipe or spray, people who are well do not need to wear a facemask, people who are feeling ill should wear a facemask, and reach out to your local health authority if you think you might have the COVID-19.

Covid-19 Information:

This story is evolving quickly, and people should go to official websites to get the latest update on the Cover-19 situation:

Centre for Disease Control and PreventionHealth CanadaPublic Health OntarioWorld Health OrganizationFood and Drug Administration

Case: With the potential global impact of the coronavirus (COVID-19) and our rural emergency departments (ED) having an extremely low compliance rate for N95 mask fit testing, our ED administration sends an urgent request for everyone to have N95 mask testing as soon as possible (ASAP). The urgent email also request shaving facial hair. You wonder about the evidence supporting the initiative and if there is any recent evidence surrounding N95 masks usage for preventing health care workers getting acute respiratory illnesses.

Background: Many hospitals had their health care workers fitted with N95 masks in response to the 2009 H1N1 pandemic. The N95 masks were known to prevent small particles and therefore thought to be more effective. What was not known is whether or not this better effectiveness would translate into less viral respiratory infections acquired in hospital compared to regular disposable surgical medical masks. In other words, would N95 masks have a healthcare provider-oriented outcome.

When it appeared that the transmission of the pandemic H1N1 was not different from seasonal influenza the recommendation for medical masks in most settings was reinstated.

With the potential for an epidemic/pandemic outbreak of coronovirus, there is the demand for increased vigilance in preventive measures to prevent and contain the outbreak of this communicable disease.

There have been a number of other studies discussing masks in pre...