Podchaser Logo
Home
Ireland lay down a marker and Eddie Jones in trouble

Ireland lay down a marker and Eddie Jones in trouble

Released Tuesday, 26th September 2023
Good episode? Give it some love!
Ireland lay down a marker and Eddie Jones in trouble

Ireland lay down a marker and Eddie Jones in trouble

Ireland lay down a marker and Eddie Jones in trouble

Ireland lay down a marker and Eddie Jones in trouble

Tuesday, 26th September 2023
Good episode? Give it some love!
Rate Episode

Episode Transcript

Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.

Use Ctrl + F to search

0:01

The Telegraph, podcasts.

0:14

Hello again everyone, I hope the feast of Rugby

0:16

World Cup action has kept you thoroughly entertained

0:18

over the weekend. You are joined once again

0:21

by Charlie Morgan. Alright Charlie. Morning Colesy.

0:23

And you're joined by Charles Richardson. Alright Charles.

0:26

Morning Ben. And I'm Ben Coles. The

0:28

three of us are here ready to unpack some fascinating games,

0:31

in particular, Islands of Africa on Saturday

0:33

in Paris, what a belter, and also Wales

0:36

Australia in Lyon on Sunday. Gents, where

0:38

were you? I was in and out of Lille.

0:41

Sorry, I jumped in there. That's how

0:43

quick you were. He loves Lille.

0:44

And it grew on me. It grew

0:46

on me. This is how pathetically

0:49

easy I am to manipulate. I arrived

0:51

in the sort of dreary weather, thought why am I

0:53

away from the south coast? But

0:56

then it grew on me over the weekend. A few

0:59

nice squares, nice bit

1:01

of interaction with fans in and around the

1:03

city. Cool stadium, nearly died

1:05

on the cab ride over there but once got

1:07

there, lovely. Tell us more. Just

1:11

a bit of naughty swerving across lanes

1:13

when

1:14

the driver didn't see the exit but we got

1:16

there fine. How much cheese? Loads

1:19

of cheese, mainly for breakfast now actually. I've pivoted.

1:22

Is that something that you've continued in England?

1:25

Yeah, being really, really, not in England, no, but I've been consistent

1:27

when I've been over there for sure. I

1:30

was in Lyon, had lovely three days there actually.

1:32

Good fun on Saturday night,

1:34

well done to all the Wales

1:36

and Australian fans who sort of packed into

1:38

this bit of Lyon with the

1:41

local cultural highlights like Little Welsh Beer

1:43

Bar

1:44

and King Arthur's Pub. You really

1:46

pushed the boat out and found local French places and

1:48

you had a nice time. No, it was great atmosphere

1:51

in Lyon on a Saturday night and yeah, fun

1:53

game on Sunday. Speaking of highlights

1:55

from the weekend, Charles

1:58

I'll come to you first, give me a highlight.

4:00

Matt Canson, Bundy Yaki

4:03

who has just been a revelation this this tournament

4:05

but also he spent a bit of time in the

4:07

island camp last year for the New Zealand

4:09

tour that actually started this run of 16

4:12

wins that they're on and I just kind of wanted

4:14

to speak to him a little bit about the

4:16

mentality within that within that camp

4:19

the blend of personalities if

4:21

you think about people like Andy Farrell and Paula

4:23

Connell are two of the most magnetic charismatic

4:26

guys in the sport over

4:29

the last few years and just how

4:31

that all works together and he was really interesting

4:33

on that because speaking speaking

4:35

from a coaches point of view he was saying that you

4:38

get real progress when it's a camp

4:40

that is prepared with individuals

4:42

within it who are prepared to challenge each other on

4:45

ideas and that was a big thing

4:47

that came away from what Pete was saying it was really interesting

4:49

stuff. And with Aki in particular we'll

4:52

chat more about him later but the fact that he

4:54

was kind of struggling to form a bit maybe

4:56

a year ago and not necessarily in

4:59

in Ireland's reckoning and not actually struggling to

5:01

get a game time for Connell as well just shows

5:03

what a fantastic turnaround it's been. Yeah

5:06

absolutely and undoubted first trust

5:08

me we had a discussion last week as to who island might pick

5:10

in the centres for this game and I think we all went Aki

5:13

completely obviously completely vindicated

5:15

that decision to start Aki alongside

5:18

Ringrose and have Henshaw on the bench obviously Henshaw

5:20

himself is a fabulous player but Aki is sort

5:22

of at the minute if you're picking a world 15

5:24

he's about 12 I can't

5:26

think of any but maybe him and Dontee would be competing

5:29

for an inside centre spot in a world 15 yeah just

5:32

what a what a renaissance from him. Yeah

5:34

it really has been great fun to watch actually loads

5:37

of good content on the website at the moment including Charlie

5:40

in great detail picking through Australia's

5:43

miserable night in Leon on Sunday

5:45

which I'm sure you did with absolutely no pleasure To

5:48

be fair that's a pervading feeling I think

5:50

people people were saying sort of online while they

5:52

were watching it this is just a bit sad.

5:55

Sad is the word. From around the 60 minute

5:58

mark we're gonna get into the game in more detail But

6:00

from around the 16-minute market, it was just

6:02

such an inevitable unraveling of

6:04

an inexperienced side who aren't very well

6:06

coached that Missing

6:08

some of their best players. Mmm. It was low

6:11

having said that You know Wales deserve

6:13

a lot of credit and hopefully even though that the

6:15

headline piece is pretty brutal There's

6:18

some it highlights some positive

6:20

things that Wales did as well I mean, it was a complete Australian

6:23

abomination wasn't it from from the 60th minute that

6:25

you're right unraveling is a really a really

6:27

really good word I mean there was But

6:31

you say from the 60th minute. I must admit

6:33

having watched that game from the first or the fifth

6:35

minute I didn't think Australia were gonna win I mean Eddie

6:37

had spoken about how how important

6:40

a positive fast start was for them and the opposite

6:42

happened They give away a penalty at the opening rug

6:44

didn't they with Dave Precke not rolling away?

6:47

And then at halftime, it was the same again They

6:49

got Australia got turned over from

6:52

the from the restart from the kickoff Held

6:54

up from the kick and it just it was it was a really

6:57

really sorry night and yeah It's

6:59

not nice to see actually it's it's nice

7:01

to see Wales You know sort

7:03

of proving some doubt is wrong But it's

7:05

not nice to see how far Australia have fallen

7:08

You know a lot of us will have very fond memories of

7:10

Australian rugby teams Look at the world

7:12

champions in 91 99 84 wallabies

7:15

one of the greatest teams of all time With

7:17

with with legends throughout and to

7:19

see where they are now basically a rabble I

7:22

mean, I know they were missing their two best players who are Not

7:25

my meaning to bang the world 15 trim again who

7:27

are they are touching world 15 status,

7:29

you know Tanya LaTuba and Will Skelton. I know they

7:31

were missing them but even so If

7:35

that if missing those two players meant that we

7:38

that we lose You know that they lose

7:40

that game to Wales and I think that's something that most

7:42

people could swallow But to lose in the manner that they did

7:44

they shouldn't be losing like that Yeah, we'll

7:46

unpack it a bit more later in the episode a couple

7:49

of columns as well on Eddie Jones Bizarre

7:51

situation after that news broke about him reportedly

7:54

having an interview with Japan Fianna

7:56

Thomas was down at Sandy Park see how the red roses go

7:58

on as well. So loads on the website have a look at. But

8:01

let's start our episode by diving a little

8:03

bit deeper into what was a cracking

8:05

game between Ireland and South Africa.

8:10

We hoped it would be a blockbuster in Paris. It

8:13

always was probably the fixture that we circled

8:16

when the draw was kind of made and looked

8:18

to when they were going to be playing each other. We were

8:21

probably the most excited by defending champions,

8:24

number one team in the world and Charles, we got...

8:26

we sort of belted, didn't

8:28

we? I mean, it sort of had everything that you would

8:30

have wanted that game to have, I think. Absolutely did. I mean, there

8:33

are very, very few criticisms that

8:36

I can level at the game as a whole, taking

8:39

all the different elements that we would dissect and

8:41

digest. I thought Ben O'Keefe, the

8:45

referee's job nowadays is very, very difficult and I know

8:47

he's had a lot of... copped a lot of flack. I

8:49

think that just happens now in big games. I just think that

8:51

is... that's just part of the course

8:54

now. But personally, I really

8:56

think that at the minute with the state that rugby union's

8:58

in, if the referee's not deciding

9:01

the outcome of the match, if there's not deciding the result,

9:03

then I think they've probably had a good game and I don't

9:05

think Ben O'Keefe decided the result of that game. I

9:08

was happy with his performance. I think there's probably a couple

9:10

of things that he might think

9:12

that he got wrong, but that's probably the case in every

9:14

single rugby match that's ever taken place. And

9:17

the two teams themselves were phenomenal.

9:19

You looked at Ireland. Ireland

9:21

looked a bit shell-shocked in the first 10. South

9:23

Africa came storming out the blocks. The

9:26

line-out went completely to pieces. Ireland's

9:28

line-out went completely to pieces. But then they

9:30

shored everything up and that is a sign of a good team, isn't it?

9:32

You know, backs on the ropes,

9:35

shoring it up, finding a way to win and actually

9:37

not just sort of grinding out a victory

9:39

either. They say that sort of good

9:42

teams can win even when they're playing poorly.

9:44

Well, this wasn't even the case. They still played well. They

9:47

played some lovely rugby. You know, we had Sexton's

9:50

timing of the pass to Aki often at 12

9:52

was just sublime. Like, it couldn't have been

9:54

better. And I

9:56

mean, you're looking at Aki against Dale Ende there

9:59

and I mean, Dale Ende played well. one of his best matches for

10:01

a good while and even so was still

10:03

sort of outplayed by Aki. It was an awesome,

10:06

awesome contest and if we saw it again

10:08

I don't think anyone would be unhappy. Really interesting

10:10

point on the refereeing. So I bumped into a bit of a

10:12

clang here. I bumped into Alid Walters at Leal

10:14

Station on my way back and one of the first things he said

10:17

was, what'd you think of that last mall turnover?

10:19

I actually said to him, I mean

10:21

I probably made a bit of an idiot myself, but I'd said to him,

10:23

well the thing about playing the box is all

10:26

of those contest areas are so

10:28

ferociously contested that you

10:30

sort of can be wrong both ways or you can be

10:33

right both ways and then realise I'm chatting to a guy

10:35

that coached the box for the last World Cup

10:37

and then I sort of realised at the end of my point, you

10:39

know, that's better than me. But no,

10:41

that was, I thought, I agree with you. I think you're

10:43

always going to be able to catalogue a load of things that

10:45

referees do wrong

10:48

in games because that's the nature of it, especially

10:51

more so heightened when South Africa team

10:53

that based, there's an amazing clip I think from the Chasing

10:55

the Sun documentary where Rosier

10:57

Azimah says, I don't want you to get into 80 contests

10:59

and win 60, I want you to get into 100 and 120 and win,

11:02

you know, win 90. And with

11:04

every player on the pitch doing that in that mindset

11:07

then it's absolutely, it's absolutely going to be difficult

11:09

for those officials and I thought O'Keefe put himself

11:12

in a good position to get a big

11:14

knockout game later on in the tournament. What

11:16

I found about the

11:18

game sort of more so

11:21

was thinking about it in the context of the whole tournament

11:23

and I kept thinking back to South Africa losing the

11:26

first game of the last World Cup against New Zealand

11:28

and now almost more so that

11:30

because they've won the last one, they're a team that won't

11:33

take too downhearted about losing

11:35

a game that essentially doesn't matter because they

11:37

get France rather than New Zealand, but it

11:40

doesn't matter in the grand scheme of things, they've still got to keep

11:42

winning all the way to the final. And I think those

11:44

subplots, so they didn't maul hardly

11:46

at all until the end. They're 100% doing

11:48

that in more important games.

11:52

There's just a few wrinkles. They won't go 7-1

11:54

again, I don't think, just because they

11:57

give themselves a look. Certainly Pollard will come back into

11:59

their gun 23. and they'll give themselves a little bit

12:01

more leeway because with the 7-1 they couldn't change

12:03

up their back line at all until the end because that's

12:05

too much of a risk. I

12:08

just found it really, really interesting knowing that

12:10

those sides knew that they could probably meet

12:12

again. Yeah. Because, and if you think, if

12:14

you talk about islands, sorry, if you talk about South

12:16

Africa's miskicks off the T, you have to talk

12:19

about island gaffing the line out. The

12:21

things that both sides will be, will

12:25

know that they can improve and that's what's so exciting. I'm

12:28

very nervous that the Telegraph will be podcasting the line out

12:30

because we've bigged it up against how it went against

12:32

Tonga and how effective it was to launch all their

12:35

attacking routes and they lost the first four, didn't they,

12:37

which was a bit of a mess. Absolutely. And

12:40

on the goal kicking, I've written about this. Manny Libet played beautifully

12:42

at Fly Half. Razi Erasmus made this

12:44

point in the post-match interview about

12:48

how excellent he was and people who were saying

12:50

that Andre Pollard should have started. Well, Erasmus made

12:52

the point that A, he wasn't 100% fit. And

12:55

B,

12:55

how do you know that, with how

12:58

well Libet played with the ball in his hand, how

13:00

do you know that we would have got to those positions

13:03

to win those penalties,

13:05

to win those kickable penalties if Pollard had

13:07

played? We might have been losing by more. You

13:10

know, you can't say, oh, the

13:12

goal kick has lost us the game because he missed

13:14

six points. You know, that just doesn't

13:16

work. It's just basic chaos theory. There

13:19

is, there is so many other variables

13:21

at play. Who's to say if Libet

13:23

could kick those three points, the island wouldn't have gone down the other

13:25

end and scored a try. You know, you just can't, you

13:28

can't boil it down to that. And

13:32

there is no shame, there is no shame whatsoever

13:34

for South Africa, for the Springboks to come within five

13:36

points and five metres of

13:39

beating or not losing to the

13:42

World's Number One ranked team in the ball stages of the World

13:44

Cup. They won't, they won't be down, they won't be sort

13:46

of dispirited by that at all, I don't think. No, I think that's

13:48

fair. I think you're kind of pleased in

13:51

some ways if you're both sides because there's stuff

13:53

there that you can rectify within

13:55

time for the knockout stages when it really matters. At

13:57

the same time, I don't think there was too much damage.

14:00

to be the team off the top of my head in terms

14:02

of injuries or knocks. I just wanted to mention Andrew

14:04

Porter's performance. He was fantastic for

14:06

Ireland and the way he's

14:09

one of many players who have kicked on in the last two

14:12

or three years within this team. They

14:15

play such an efficient brand of rugby Ireland and

14:17

he's certainly a big part of that with how he contributes

14:19

from a rut clear out and a carrying

14:21

and attacking perspective. He went 75 minutes

14:24

I thought as well. He's going pretty well as

14:26

well. I thought he was one of the standout

14:28

performers. What about James Loe tackle

14:30

on Eximeth as well? Why are we talking about the standout

14:32

performance? He's just... James Loe's defence,

14:35

full stop. He got a jackal turn over the knee. That

14:38

was obviously a big work on for him. I

14:40

think he's been totally open about

14:42

saying that and he was out of the side briefly

14:44

because of that. We led to believe. So

14:47

yeah, all the game. That's

14:49

his first time he's played to the African as well

14:51

which is quite cool. Quite a nice way to

14:53

get off the mark. I just wondered if it changed

14:55

anything you felt about in

14:57

terms of eventual

15:00

winners of this tournament and whether

15:02

watching South Africa wobble slightly

15:05

but not majorly or Ireland

15:07

putting away South Africa with kind of a statement World

15:09

Cup win in a way, whether that had made you,

15:12

Charlie, feel a bit differently about who might win it all. It

15:14

made me think Ireland are more likely to

15:16

now although having been on the South

15:18

Africa bandwagon for a long

15:21

time. The only way it went I

15:23

think was the hooker situation and how I

15:25

think if I was one of those grandmas I'd be worried

15:27

in training because

15:30

I think as soon as one of those, if there's a

15:32

hint of an injury to one of those we might see is Joseph

15:34

Dwebber would be the next... Yeah,

15:37

because I just think that gives them a little bit more

15:39

solidity but then again the South African coaching

15:42

team is extremely, he's been around the block,

15:45

they're extremely street wise and

15:47

they'll know various ways as to how they can get

15:49

over the line. So I'm still high on South

15:52

Africa but I'm a little bit higher on Ireland.

15:59

in the opposition but that continued against Africa

16:02

where he was

16:03

sensational. So to hear a bit more about him

16:05

and about Matt Hanson, we're going to hear from Pete

16:07

Wilkins at Connell who spoke to Charlie earlier

16:09

this week.

16:12

Pete, welcome to Togo

16:14

Off-Broadway Podcast. First off, how big

16:17

a change for you personally, Pete, is

16:19

going about your work now without Andy Friend

16:21

and talk us through you assembled a

16:23

team of really interesting characters there with John

16:26

Muldoon, Scott Farley, Mark Sexton, those

16:29

guys. It looks like a really kind of intriguing

16:31

blend you've got.

16:32

Yeah, it is. It is a big change.

16:34

It's funny, I had a fair amount of

16:36

input in the rugby that we played, the planning

16:39

of that rugby and I suppose the rollout of

16:41

it to the squad over the last two seasons really,

16:43

but especially last year, the last year under

16:45

Friendy. So I've had

16:47

my hands over the rugby

16:49

aspect but to be in control

16:51

of the whole show and I suppose having that

16:54

influence on what goes on off-field

16:56

in terms of trying to shape that environment and

16:58

I guess the culture that binds everyone together that enables

17:00

you to play that rugby, it's been fascinating for me.

17:02

It's been a great challenge but one I'd be really excited

17:05

about. So yeah, it's a little bit strange

17:07

not having a boss on the corridor to have to

17:09

run things by but that

17:11

sense of freedom and autonomy is pretty exciting.

17:14

So I'm enjoying the role. As

17:16

you said, we've got a pretty fresh coaching group

17:18

here as well. Cully Tucker is our

17:21

Scrum and Breakdown coach. Cully's renewed

17:23

to go round again but then we've got three

17:25

new guys, John Muldoon doesn't

17:27

need much introduction to Connick fans,

17:29

played over 300 games for the club, captain the size

17:31

for number eight. So he's a bit of a legend in these parts

17:34

but Muldoon is here doing line-out

17:36

and more for us. We've got

17:38

Scott Farley who's joined us as defence coach who

17:40

again doesn't need much introduction. He's had

17:43

a tremendous career especially there with the Wallabies and

17:45

the Brumbies and then coming over to Leinster

17:48

so he's well known in these parts too. And

17:50

then Mark Sexton, younger brother Johnny,

17:52

so Mark's here as a skills coach and also assisting

17:54

me with the attack. So we've got a really neat blend,

17:56

very different characters, very different

17:59

rugby backgrounds. but all of bringing their

18:01

take on the game and I'm really enjoying working

18:03

with them so far.

18:04

I wanted to get your insight, Pete.

18:08

You've been into the Island camp reasonably

18:10

recently on the tour

18:12

of New Zealand last July, at the

18:14

start of this 16 win run

18:16

that they're on. First

18:19

of all, can I just ask you about the blend of characters they've got?

18:22

If you think about Andy Farrell and Paul O'Connell,

18:24

they'd be two of the sort of most magnetic, charismatic

18:27

personalities you'd probably find in the sport.

18:29

Could you tell me about a few of your lasting memories

18:32

of

18:33

that time you had with them, maybe what you took

18:35

away and how it influenced you?

18:37

Yeah, I think there certainly

18:39

is a really interesting blend of characters there amongst

18:42

the coaching staff and I think that's something that certainly

18:45

adds to the success there. I think, as

18:47

you said, you've got Andy there and Paul O'Connell,

18:49

both legends of the game in their own

18:51

respects. Simon Easterby is

18:54

there as defence coach, also had a terrific

18:56

career himself and provides

18:59

another angle he took on the team defence once

19:02

Andy moved up to the head coach role.

19:05

So you've got John Fogarty there as scrum

19:07

coach and Mike Capp

19:09

there as skills and backs coach. So it's

19:12

a really interesting blend of guys. They're all hugely

19:14

respected in not just Irish rugby

19:16

circles but beyond that. But

19:18

again, very different personalities and

19:22

certain members of that group are very methodical in

19:24

the way they go about things. Others who are very much about

19:26

the feel and sparking

19:29

the sort of emotional and some of

19:31

the non-tangible aspects of coaching. So

19:33

I think they bounce off each other really well but I think

19:35

importantly they're not afraid to challenge each other and

19:38

all of them are very good at

19:40

parking their ego and looking for the answers

19:43

that give the team the best opportunity and the best

19:45

of rugby development. So I think that was really good

19:47

for me to see of how you blend a coaching group

19:49

and certainly something that we reflected

19:51

on quite heavily when we're looking to put together

19:54

this new coaching group for this new chapter

19:56

here at Connick as well. I think one

19:58

of their great strengths is a great team. group is

20:01

their ability to embrace

20:03

the chaos at times and just

20:06

accept that there are things that are going to be outside

20:08

of your control, whether that's within a game in terms

20:10

of how the opposition goes or the referee

20:12

or the weather or whether it's logistics around

20:15

the game in terms of travel and injuries and preparation.

20:18

I think that New Zealand tour was a really great

20:20

way. Andy talked about it himself at the

20:22

time, but a way of taking people out of their

20:24

comfort zone and having

20:26

some of those unseen obstacles that come your

20:29

way on a tour like that, three test matches against

20:31

the All Blacks and the two midweek games

20:33

against the Maori, how the guys

20:35

approach those challenges, how

20:38

do they accept what they can and can't control

20:40

and see who can actually handle that and who

20:42

can come out of those situations stronger or who

20:45

finds it all a bit too stressful that it inhibits

20:47

their performance. That's not just players, that's

20:49

coaches, it's backroom staff, it's the whole

20:51

family, I suppose. That was really interesting,

20:54

the way they just prepare to embrace those difficult

20:56

situations and as I said, see who

20:59

thrives in that sort of environment because you know when you

21:01

get to any sporting contest, but particularly a World

21:03

Cup, there's going to be a few of those curve balls that come your

21:05

way. So their ability to,

21:08

I suppose, keep an open mindset and a positive

21:10

attitude with that, but take the learnings and the growth

21:12

from it as well. It's pretty powerful and

21:15

that was prominent in that New Zealand trip and I

21:17

think you're seeing it now in the World Cup as well. I was

21:19

going to say, speaking of chaos, facing

21:22

a 7-1 bench or facing the World

21:24

Champions with a 7-1 bench who

21:26

are trying to squeeze you in a way that you've lost games

21:28

previously, I guess, in Ireland's case.

21:32

Could I ask you about your thoughts

21:35

on the weekend watching that and how

21:37

impressive it was that Ireland managed

21:39

to get through?

21:40

Yeah, I think it's really

21:42

interesting and it's a key bit

21:44

of their mindset as a group but also

21:47

directly impact some of their rugby decisions and

21:49

the rugby success on the back of it. As

21:52

you said, there was a fair amount of feedback

21:54

and judgement on Leinster's performances

21:57

against La Rochelle and having come and stuck against them a couple

21:59

of years ago. times and when you're up against real

22:01

physical opposition and would

22:03

Ireland be able to handle that this World Cup

22:06

and I understand why those question marks.

22:09

That said, that game the other night

22:12

it shows that not

22:14

just that they can survive against those physical

22:17

teams but they can find a way to thrive and it might

22:19

not be having a massive amount of ball and play time

22:21

or a massive amount of possession but

22:23

they can still be really effective for what they do get

22:26

and at the same time muscle up and

22:28

stop the power game that comes up. So it's

22:31

only one game and both South Africa and

22:33

Ireland obviously have tremendously challenging

22:36

knockout games when they get to that stage but

22:38

I think it was a really important part and not so

22:40

much proving themselves but probably proving to the outside

22:42

world that they're able

22:44

to handle that physical challenge and still assert

22:46

themselves on our position in a slightly different way.

22:50

You've got four players at the tournament I think I'm

22:52

right in saying. Finley, Mack and Bundy

22:54

with Ireland and Leve for Fita with Tonga.

22:58

Can I ask you about a couple of the guys

23:01

in the Ireland squad back specifically?

23:03

First of all, Matt Canson, he just seems to

23:06

be a

23:07

total breath of fresh air both as far

23:09

as his character and the way he plays

23:12

and he really embodies, we've spoken before

23:14

about the free-spirited sort of way that you

23:17

want or open-minded way sorry that you want

23:19

Connick to play,

23:20

he seems to embody that. Yeah he does

23:22

as you said, Mack's a terrific character and I think

23:25

the more people get to know him and the more air time

23:27

he gets you see just

23:29

what a unique guy he is and I

23:31

think he's really enjoyable

23:33

to work with from a coaching

23:35

perspective partly because he's just a really great human

23:38

being but has that kind of mindset

23:40

that he does embrace

23:42

the challenges and he's not afraid to look for different

23:44

ways to get success on the field.

23:48

He's got a pretty good balance I think of being

23:50

really true to himself, there's no airs

23:52

and graces, he wants to

23:54

let that character shine through which is part of his rugby

23:57

identity as well as him as a person but

23:59

he also understands what the team needs from him. And

24:01

I think that South Africa game was really interesting because it

24:03

was a game where he didn't necessarily

24:06

get a lot of opportunity to carry in a

24:08

lot of open space. But

24:10

he made sure he did what the team required. And

24:12

if he had to catch a high ball and take a big tackle, he did.

24:15

And he had to do his work at the breakdown, he

24:17

did, or carry through some heavy traffic, he did. And

24:19

I think that understanding of the importance of

24:22

not going into your shell of really expressing yourself,

24:24

but at the same time understanding how you fit into

24:26

the team's framework for success. I think,

24:28

you know, Max got a great ability to manage that balance

24:31

and certainly he's done it really well in his

24:33

island career so far. And it's something we're

24:36

trying to really encourage, you know, back here at Conux as

24:38

well.

24:39

Excited to watch. Bundy,

24:41

you arrived at Conux, I think I'm right in

24:43

saying, in 2017, which is the year

24:45

that

24:46

Bundy made his test debut. So having

24:49

been as close to him as you have for I guess

24:51

his entire test career,

24:54

how has he developed in that time as a player? One

24:56

thing that has, I

24:58

get, I must have struck, I hope it

25:00

struck everybody, it certainly struck me watching, is placing

25:03

open field both over the warmups,

25:05

he had that,

25:06

scored that try against England, but then in a few

25:08

games and you think, oh, he's doing that against Romania,

25:10

oh, he's doing that against Thailand, on the night he's done

25:13

it against the Springboks as well. It's

25:16

been so impressive. No, it

25:18

really has, it really has. And I think what he's

25:20

done over, you know, certainly

25:22

these two World Cups now, he's just

25:24

got himself in unbelievable physical condition.

25:27

You know, he's naturally a warrior.

25:30

He will carry through brick walls for you, he won't

25:32

shirk any challenge. And we've

25:34

always known that abrasiveness and

25:36

robustness has been there and I suppose that

25:39

power game. But to get himself in the

25:41

condition where, as you said, he's getting those

25:43

high speed involvements as well and not just one

25:45

offs, but back to back, he's staying in the game after

25:47

that. He's not just having a big sprint or a big

25:49

carry and then drifting off to the end

25:51

of the back line for a rest. He's looking

25:53

to be in the moment, he's looking to

25:56

get those back to back contributions

25:58

to the team. I think that's enormous. He's

26:01

a great character to work with. Another

26:04

one we talk about is free spirit. He's

26:06

got a big personality and his energy

26:09

has such a big impact on the group. Even

26:12

the days where he might not be getting much ball or the

26:14

game might not be going your way, he's a constant

26:17

voice and a constant menace to the

26:19

opposition, whether that's in terms of

26:22

his influence on the game or just

26:24

the energy that he brings to his side. So he

26:26

is great to work with. I think again, he thrives in

26:28

that Irish environment. It keeps him on his toes

26:31

constantly. I just

26:33

think the amount of minutes he's played for them and the impact

26:35

he's obviously had in this World Cup shows how important

26:37

he is to the country. To

26:40

get 50 caps, 50 international caps for anyone,

26:42

but particularly for him with the journeys taken

26:45

to move across the conics and improve himself at

26:47

provincial level, get his opportunity

26:49

with the national team. I've just got so much respect

26:51

for that. So, a long way to continue

26:54

and certainly through this World Cup. Do

26:57

you sense a sense of perseverance

27:00

with him as well? Because I think I'm right in thinking

27:02

around January he was struggling to get in the provincial

27:05

side with you guys and this

27:07

is a serious response to that, I

27:09

guess. Yeah, it

27:11

really is. I think

27:13

he's someone who has enormous personal

27:15

pride in his own performances. Like

27:19

anyone, in terms of those performance levels

27:21

across a career or across a season, it can ebb and

27:23

flow at times. I

27:26

think the thing that's never gone away from Bundy is a

27:29

real passion for the group to succeed and

27:31

to help push the group. Certain

27:35

groups need that at certain times. I

27:37

think he just wants to see the team do well. It

27:40

was a challenging time for him when he wasn't on the field

27:43

very much for Connick, but he worked through that period.

27:45

I think seeing him come

27:47

back into a Connick jersey later last season, and then,

27:50

as we said, the performance is now for Ireland, it

27:53

shows that he is someone that is resilient.

27:55

But also perseveres. I think that's his whole rugby

27:57

journey. I was over at the Reds. when

28:01

he was at the Chiefs and he wasn't a regular

28:03

starting player there at the Chiefs and he came across the

28:05

Conect and probably a bit of an unknown to many people

28:07

and became such a key cog

28:09

in that Conect team that went on to win the Pro 12. The

28:13

legend has grown from there so I think the

28:15

fact he's still training as hard as he is

28:18

and still contributing the way he has, he's

28:21

not the man who's going to give up his opportunities

28:23

in his jersey easily in any team. So I'm

28:25

just excited for him and I'm excited

28:27

the rest of the world are getting to see the best of him as well

28:29

and it's a great reference point for him moving forwards

28:32

because hopefully there's still plenty of rugby

28:34

in him beyond this season and again

28:36

he's laying down a marker of what he can achieve

28:38

and what he can bring to an environment. It's brilliant. Speaking

28:41

of legends growing, Pete, being part

28:44

of Ireland's success

28:47

in the last few years, from

28:50

the vantage point that you've had, is there

28:52

a sense of maybe destiny is a too

28:54

cheesy way of putting it but certainly the

28:57

stars are aligning quite nicely at

28:59

this World Cup and for this group of players

29:01

because it's a special group? Yeah, it's

29:03

an interesting one. I guess my first insight into

29:05

that was that talk to New Zealand

29:07

last summer and it

29:10

struck me that the group was quite prepared.

29:12

I mean players here and management staff quite

29:14

prepared to articulate

29:16

what they wanted to achieve. They talked last

29:19

summer about making a nation proud. They

29:21

talked about wanting to be the number one team in

29:23

the world. They didn't hide from that. At

29:27

the same time they had that balance

29:29

with understanding it wasn't going to be a smooth journey to get

29:31

there. I just think there's a neat balance in

29:33

terms of that ambition and not being afraid to

29:36

walk towards that. At the same

29:38

time accepting you're not going to have everything your own

29:40

way and sometimes you've got to

29:42

find your way out of difficult situations. I

29:45

think that's their strength if anything. I don't know if

29:47

it's a feeling of destiny but I do think it's a feeling

29:49

of absolute determination

29:52

but also the adaptability that's required if you're

29:54

going to get there. It's going to be

29:56

fascinating to see how the next few weeks play out

29:58

for them and obviously the teams as well. Pete,

30:01

thank you so much for your time and I hope you're super busy

30:04

and good luck for the rest of the season. I appreciate it

30:06

Charlie, thanks for having me on and all the best. Charlie,

30:09

can I just ask you a bit about Matt Canson actually and

30:11

how he's kind of developed

30:13

into this excellent player who the Wallerbeez are just watching

30:15

each week and tearing the air out of it, he

30:17

somehow slipped through the net. Such a, so suited

30:20

to how Ireland play, we spoke last week about Andy

30:22

Farrell wanting his attack to be messy

30:25

and his wingers to be a big part of that as far as how they

30:27

roam around the field, pick up touches and I believe

30:29

Matt Canson back in Australia was sort of a

30:32

could play ten, you can really see that, you

30:34

know he's a lovely distributor,

30:37

he's quick, he's deceptively

30:40

wiry and pretty strong, certainly in the Tonga

30:42

game, he was just so,

30:44

there was so much conviction about his carrying despite

30:47

all that heavy traffic and the same was true I thought

30:51

in the South Africa game. I'd sort of

30:53

suggested before South Africa game that

30:55

those wings would be really important to

30:57

South Africa and how they outflanked the blitz.

31:00

I think they were for that one

31:02

big Hugo Keenan break in the first half but

31:04

Matt Canson didn't actually get the ball, he came off his

31:07

wing when Ringrose had it, got absolutely smoked

31:09

without the ball but then the ball, then that gave...

31:11

Was that, was that the triple ball that we got in

31:13

the ball? Yeah, that gave the space, that presented the

31:15

space over the top and you know

31:18

that's another thing we're not talking about really,

31:20

that's a big chance for Ireland to score

31:22

and change the complexion of the game

31:24

and to have South Africa chasing it but

31:27

yeah, Matt Canson's a fantastic player with

31:30

guys like Dan Sheer and Jamison

31:32

Gibson-Park, James

31:35

Lowe, they've really kind of come in this World Cup

31:37

cycle and enhanced Ireland

31:40

and those guys, the impact of those guys

31:42

is the reason for what you see now.

31:45

I say naturally skillful as well and so he's

31:48

aerially so good, he does all those sort of silky

31:50

bits that you look, the sort of cherry on the

31:53

cake as it were for an international winger

31:55

like, so naturally skillful as you said, he's

31:57

deceptively stringed, deceptively fester the ball

31:59

in his hand. and has a really good feel for the game, but

32:01

he also does the nuts and bolts really well, the kick

32:03

chase, the

32:06

jumping and aerial dynamics

32:09

are just brilliant. You

32:11

don't see him drooping too many high balls and I

32:13

think that's become a massively important

32:16

component of modern wing play and

32:19

he does that very well. He's sort of Anthony Watson-esque,

32:21

Anthony's probably a little bit quicker

32:25

than Hanson, but Hanson's probably got a slightly

32:27

better feel for the game, as you said, I don't think

32:30

Anthony Watson's ever played ten, apologies Anthony

32:32

if you have. You're

32:35

right, you could envisage him playing fly half, maybe

32:37

not for Ireland, but maybe at a

32:39

slightly lower level. Sometimes it's

32:41

useful to see the numbers just to back up if you feel a player

32:44

is playing quite well. For Bundyacke,

32:46

he's second for clean breaks in the tournament on

32:48

eight. He's tied second for tries,

32:50

obviously on four, because Henry Arendelle's just had a

32:53

blind difference and it's called five in one game.

32:55

The one that is blowing my mind slightly is that he's

32:58

first for runs or carries on 53 and

33:01

the next best is David Ninias, on 33. He's

33:04

made 20 more runs than any other player in

33:06

the tournament, that is bamboozling.

33:08

I think that also shows how

33:10

much Ireland, when things are

33:13

to create that width that we saw when they did make this

33:15

break, they do just need someone to truck

33:17

up in the middle and particularly against Tonga, for

33:20

a lot of the game he was just doing that, just bashing into

33:22

carries, bashing into contact, tiring out defenders

33:24

to create space. There's

33:26

almost two ways that they've used him. They've used him

33:28

as someone who's breaking the game line and showing sneaky

33:31

speed to get round defenders for tries, but

33:33

also just the work rate he gets through, his sensation

33:35

isn't it? He'd be among Ireland's most valuable

33:37

players and if he said that in January when he

33:39

was struggling to get into the

33:42

conic side, which is what I spoke to Pete

33:44

Wilkins about, that

33:46

would have sounded ridiculous. It shares your work quite

33:48

now for Ireland because they have that gap before the game

33:50

against Scotland at the end and

33:53

also good for the players and

33:55

getting some time in the family. It's good for our comrades and the Irish

33:58

press back as well, you'll get a few days off as well. well

34:00

for your days break. How useful

34:02

is that going to be, do you think

34:04

for them, well it's tricky isn't

34:06

it, would you rather have the momentum coming out of Saturday

34:09

and just get Scotland done? Or

34:11

actually is it quite a nice time after such a physical game

34:13

to just recuperate and then go into the

34:15

game? I was going to say they'd be pretty sore wouldn't

34:18

they? That's quite a nice week off to have.

34:20

Maybe refocuses them as well for Scotland because

34:23

they lose that by more than eight points they're out, which

34:25

is unthinkable because they've won 12 of the

34:27

last 13 against Scotland and they beat the

34:29

McMurray Field by 15 points. Just repeat that

34:32

for the fans at home. Well

34:34

I hope I'm right but I'm pretty sure they've won,

34:36

it's won in the last 13. No no

34:38

before that about if they lose by what? More

34:41

than if they lose by eight points or more. So

34:44

if Ireland don't get any sort of bonus against Scotland

34:46

and they lose then I'm fairly sure they're

34:48

out on the head to head. So

34:51

nothing changes for Scotland despite they've

34:53

just got to keep winning. I think in ordinary circumstances

34:56

Ireland probably would want to play Scotland this Saturday.

34:58

I think ordinarily to keep that momentum

35:01

to not risk sort of slipping into a lull

35:03

but I think you're right with how physical and

35:05

how intense that game was on Saturday night against the Spring

35:08

Rocks I think they might on this occasion treat

35:10

it as a unique fortnight

35:12

and a unique Saturday whereby actually recuperation

35:15

and recovery of those bodies ahead of, as

35:18

you say, it's not a foregone conclusion

35:20

that game at the front. Ireland obviously will go in

35:22

as large favourites but

35:25

with a lot of pressure on them potentially to

35:28

not lose by eight points, if Finn Russell turns up

35:30

and starts pulling strings you know stranger things have

35:32

happened. We've seen much far stranger things happen in the

35:34

world. I almost want it now. We

35:36

haven't really had our upset

35:39

yet. Fiji Australia was a sort

35:41

of semi upset I think. Georgia

35:45

drawing with Portugal is a semi upset

35:48

maybe. I don't think you can really cast that as a full upset because they

35:50

didn't win. So we haven't had our upset

35:52

yet. I think maybe Scotland beating Ireland

35:54

by over eight points. I don't

35:57

know, I'm being disrespectful to Scotland by

35:59

suggesting.

35:59

I'd

36:01

say we've had surprise results without having shock

36:03

results. So Wales blowing out winning

36:06

by that much against Australia is a

36:08

big surprise but yeah as far as a kind

36:10

of big turning over of a big

36:13

favourite I don't think we've probably had that yet. No I mean obviously

36:16

similarly but even more scarily if

36:19

Italy beat France, Le

36:21

Bleu, pack your bags, you are

36:23

very nervous about that. The Charlie

36:25

Morgan millions from the first episode. That's

36:28

what it's it? What was it Italy to get

36:30

through? No France cannot get

36:32

through. It was 33's. I didn't pay any money

36:34

and obviously because I'm not an idiot but well done

36:36

if you did and it happens but you won't.

36:40

You never know the very final

36:42

thing about the Arn Saffirica game. We

36:44

mentioned Ben and Keith earlier but no cards

36:47

and no sort of sightings

36:49

and I want to say no TMO referrals

36:52

for foul play. Like for another podcast

36:54

here I listened to the 42 and Dan Levy was

36:56

on there and he went on a really really interesting

36:58

sort of monologue about cards

37:01

and how bigger games

37:04

potentially like that really focus players

37:06

just into going low because you know how

37:09

much trouble you're putting the

37:11

rest of your team in if you do if you do concede

37:13

it well even a penalty but a card

37:15

sort of on top of that and he actually was saying

37:18

I just can't understand how pros

37:20

are being as lazy to stay up right now

37:22

and some of the cards we've seen in the

37:25

warm-ups maybe a little bit in the well maybe sort

37:27

of the Ethan DeGroote one in against Namibia

37:30

that players can be precisely

37:32

players can be more diligent than that and

37:35

I think I think the game the magnitude

37:37

of the game the Arn Saffirica game just

37:40

must have focused those players so much. It's

37:42

a real complement to their skill and ability

37:44

to perform under pressure I thought that we

37:46

got that they managed to get through that without any cards so

37:49

full credit to both of them. On

37:52

to next a bit more of a lopsided

37:54

scoreline Leon on Sunday night where

37:57

oh Australia what are you doing?

38:01

Ok

38:05

Wales 40, Australia 6, record

38:07

breaking scenes in Leon.

38:10

One of his biggest World Cup defeat, Wales

38:12

biggest winner of Australia, most points

38:14

Wales have ever scored against Australia. That

38:17

last bit is quite funny though because the record that they broke

38:19

was won from last November in Cardiff for

38:21

the most points, so it's not stood for very

38:23

long. But hey, a record is a record.

38:26

Had

38:28

the honour of being there, sat up at the

38:30

very, very, very top of the stadium. Cool

38:33

stadium? Yeah, it is. Do you want

38:35

all the roof for you? It is. Not

38:37

far off. If I'd touched an armour, I'd probably could have grabbed

38:39

onto a rafter and gone swinging. Yeah, it was

38:42

pretty high. Yeah, very

38:44

cool stadium, particularly from

38:47

pitch level if you're doing captain's runs or whatever and getting

38:49

a look around. Yeah, very, very good.

38:52

And you said

38:54

earlier Charlie, I think it was you, maybe it was you Charlie,

38:56

said that it was just quite sad, sad

38:58

watching it. And that was honestly how it felt with 20 minutes to

39:00

go because the contest was done. Wales

39:03

are knocking over a drop goal when they were

39:05

up 32-6 just to keep

39:08

the margin. Just in case of a comeback,

39:10

it was pretty desperate. It was kind

39:13

of the old school way to beat Australia

39:15

is if you can soak up their phase play to

39:18

the point where they don't have many ideas left.

39:21

You can squeeze them in malls, squeeze them

39:23

at the scrum. And Wales just did that. And

39:25

as well as Wales played, they

39:29

played so well because they didn't have to do loads.

39:31

There was just this confidence there that if they could, as

39:33

I say, just if they could absorb pressure

39:35

for a bit. And Australia had a couple

39:38

of chances in the first quarter, didn't they? Donaldson's breakaway,

39:40

he goes left instead of right where he's got a couple

39:42

of runners. That changes the game,

39:45

then it didn't happen. Bella got close

39:47

to me, Bella got close within five metres. And

39:50

then we're back for penalty. And then

39:52

obviously when they get another penalty and

39:54

go for touch, kick it backwards for a

39:56

start and then just run

39:58

the worst line out. Let's just do

40:00

a couple minutes on Ben Donaldson specifically because

40:03

there was a lot of talking to build up about Carter

40:05

Gordon going out, Donaldson coming in. Donaldson

40:08

has this just wild first

40:10

half an hour where, yeah, like you say, makes that break,

40:13

goes to a completely wrong option, chances gone. Before

40:17

that produced a brilliant sort of tactical hit

40:19

to touch which put Australia, pinned Wells back

40:21

in the corner and he thought, okay. But he also

40:23

at one point kicked a restart out on the full. He

40:27

made a sloppy error under the high ball against,

40:29

I want to say Josh Adams, but I can't

40:31

remember who, oh no, no, take me down and pass the

40:33

ball back for him to just do a really basic kick out of

40:35

his 22 with no one around him and just dropped

40:38

it, which was unforgivable. Potentially at fault for

40:40

switching off a little bit for Wells first try inside

40:42

ball as well. Yeah, that was it as well. He was chasing Jack

40:44

Morgan, wasn't he? But that's because he's not played there.

40:47

Right, this is the whole frustration, the whole, the

40:50

reason that Eddie Jones' sort of decisions has

40:52

set up the players to fail because Ben Donaldson

40:54

had a pretty iffy super rugby

40:56

season. He's come as a 10-15. I think

40:59

he's even categorised in the utility category

41:01

of Australia's squad. You've

41:06

purposefully left out tens like

41:08

Quaid Cooper and Bernard Foley who can,

41:11

even if they're back up, they can be a calming

41:13

influence. It's just throwing

41:15

sort of things and hoping they stick and

41:18

when they don't stick, you can't really be

41:20

surprised, you know. Especially if that

41:23

first quarter, if that first quarter everything goes well

41:25

for Ben Donaldson and he gets a pass away for

41:27

the try, you know, he doesn't make a

41:29

couple of those more elementary errors

41:32

and Australia are up, then it can

41:34

be a virtuous circle and he can go

41:36

on to have a really good tournament and steer Australia

41:39

deeper into it. But

41:42

no, because the errors compound themselves

41:44

and there's just less, there's

41:47

just less to go on for a coach, isn't there,

41:49

when you're sort of taking chances like

41:51

that and that's more

41:53

for me why I feel for the players in those situations.

42:00

Gordon got 50 against Fiji last week, so he

42:02

lasted ever

42:04

so slightly longer. Charles, the thing where it all

42:06

seemed to turn watching where I was

42:09

was in the scrum because the first couple of penalties

42:11

against Wales were kind of technical

42:13

offences where Gareth Thomas was getting pinged

42:15

for scrumming outside the tight head and Gareth Thomas

42:17

was sort of looking at him, Wayne Barnes was like,

42:20

sure.

42:21

And then it happened twice, but then as soon as that tweak

42:23

got corrected, Wales

42:25

scrum was just utterly rampant. Like,

42:28

the Wallabies took off James Slipper at half time to try and

42:30

bring on the replacement tight head to steady

42:32

it, and it had no effect, did it? A

42:34

really dominant scrumming performance. No,

42:36

no, no, in fact, if anything, it actually got

42:38

worse in the second half. It was more

42:40

emphatic. I mean, well, this has sort

42:42

of come, as we've already touched on

42:45

from Taniel Odupo not being fit and

42:47

James Slipper, who is nominally a loose head,

42:50

switching over to tight, he can do

42:52

that. Do you really want

42:55

given that the the two positions

42:58

are distinct, do you really want

43:00

in a do or die World Cup knockout,

43:03

basically a knockout match to

43:05

be playing a loose head at tight? No,

43:08

you don't. And it killed them. It really

43:10

did. It really, you know, they couldn't get a foothold

43:12

in the game anywhere at no point. You

43:16

know, when Australia was still in

43:18

the game on the scoreboard in that first half an hour,

43:20

at least they could rely on their scrum

43:22

a bit. Admittedly, they were for technical offences

43:24

that Wales were committing at scrum

43:26

time. But you did think, oh, OK, well, if this if

43:28

they carry on like this at the scrum, the Wallabies,

43:31

they might have a chance. They might have a chance. But

43:35

it did not carry on like that. And they got

43:37

obliterated. We've now had stay in the scrum

43:39

from Wayne Barnes a couple of weeks after Cardickson

43:42

told, I think one of the Wales, too

43:44

much scrummaging and they gave a cheek. Yeah,

43:47

it'd be a prop. I mean, the final penalty camp was nine

43:49

for Wales, 12 for Australia, but it felt more like 20

43:51

for Australia with the way the last quarter played

43:54

out and how they were just getting pained for everything at the scrum

43:57

and everything else where I sort of want to just get

43:59

all the Aussie. misery out of the way and then we

44:01

can throw some deserved flowers away.

44:05

With what happened in the post-match

44:07

press conference, this

44:10

might just be me sort of speculating, but

44:12

I was about three rows away from Eddie James.

44:14

He looked a bit watery-eyed as if the momentum

44:17

of what had just happened was hitting him as

44:20

he was going through it. He

44:23

was typically defiant when asked

44:25

about a pretty sensational story and

44:27

huge congratulations to Tom Deason from the Sydney

44:29

Morning Hill for getting that out on

44:32

Sunday morning, reporting that Eddie

44:34

Jones had allegedly had an

44:36

interview to become Japan's next head coach

44:39

because that process is currently underway

44:41

by the Japanese Rugby Football Union to find

44:44

a successor for Jamie Joseph. Now

44:46

Jones fiercely denied this in the press conference

44:48

and naturally was asked about whether

44:51

the story was true, but also

44:53

the ramifications of what it had meant

44:56

for his players' mentality going into the game.

44:59

There was a question to do for Parecki,

45:01

the Wallabies captain, about how

45:03

much it had affected the players. Then Jones

45:05

responded in typical defiant fashion

45:07

with this after that Parecki question.

45:10

Sorry Eddie, just to go through it and then move

45:12

on from it, did you do a

45:14

job interview with Japanese Rugby

45:16

a couple of weeks before the World Cup?

45:19

If so, what was the thinking? I

45:21

don't know what you're talking about mate. Eddie,

45:24

do you have a second interview lined up with the JRF

45:26

year? I said I don't know what you're talking about mate.

45:29

Can you give all of his fans your absolute 100% commitment

45:32

that you will not be coach

45:33

of Japan next year? I'm

45:35

committed to coach Australia. Next

45:38

year? I'm committed to coach Australia. That's

45:40

why I'm very defended Eddie. Thank you, next question please.

45:42

Dave, this morning a story

45:45

was printed that was

45:47

very well sourced about, as you've been hearing

45:49

about maybe Eddie joining Japan

45:51

next season, next year. He's already

45:53

said it's not going to happen but I just wonder from the point of view

45:55

of your team, what

45:58

kind of psychological impact did that have on you? on you today.

46:00

We didn't turn up tonight so it's got nothing

46:02

to do with the outside noise. It's just got through with our performance.

46:05

We weren't good enough. I

46:07

really take umbrage at the questioning that

46:09

people are questioning my commitment

46:12

to coaching Australia. I really take

46:14

umbrage at it. Yeah, I've

46:17

been working non-stop since I've come

46:19

here and I apologise for the results.

46:22

I keep saying that. But to doubt my commitment

46:24

to the job I think is a bit red hot. So

46:27

we're not going to deal with any of those questions any further.

46:30

So I'm happy to talk about Wales. I'm happy to talk

46:32

about Portugal. If you want to keep going down that

46:35

line I'll excuse myself. So

46:37

do you want to decide what you want to do? I

46:39

mean you'd kind of expect him

46:41

to say something along those

46:43

lines. I just couldn't

46:46

get my head around. It turned the

46:48

whole of Sunday into a circus and almost made the

46:50

game an afterthought because all of a sudden the

46:52

focus wasn't on whether Australia could beat Wales.

46:55

It was on this Eddie story. Myself

46:57

and Elgin Orland from the Times rushed

46:59

to this fan event at

47:02

a place called Wallaby House in Leon which was meant

47:05

to be like a nice fan park where fans

47:07

could hear from Chief

47:10

Executive for War and other dignitaries

47:13

from Rugby Australia spotted Bill

47:15

Pulver there, the old chairman as

47:17

well. The whole idea was it was meant

47:19

to be like a pet rally essentially

47:22

and it turned into this 20 journalists

47:25

turning up with phones, quizzing for war,

47:27

like the sports minister spoke first. I'm not sure.

47:29

Anyone was quite

47:31

listening to what she'd say even though it was all very pertinent because

47:34

everyone just couldn't wait to ask for war about

47:36

the situation. Basically the

47:38

day turned into a bit of circus and

47:40

it's no wonder that Australia's heads went because

47:43

I think the heads of everyone else had gone by the time we got

47:45

to kick off unless you were back in Wales.

47:47

Have you ever seen body language like that from a

47:49

group of coaches during a game? Hands

47:52

over faces. You've seen anger

47:54

and obviously we've seen anger from Jones before in both

47:57

his even in charge

47:59

of England and in charge Famous

48:01

gifts, but to have that prolonged

48:04

hands-over-mouth by multiple

48:06

coaches, what do you look at? If you see that on the

48:08

big screen as a player, what are you thinking? Thinking,

48:11

jeez, yeah, we're really messing up here. These

48:14

guys think they can't help us. It

48:17

must just be totally demoralizing. It

48:20

means nothing now, but the mood that the captains

48:22

run the day before was very different and

48:24

very kind of defiant, not necessarily in the press comments,

48:26

but when the Wallabies sort of came out, they had Boombox,

48:29

playing two-pack really loud, two-pack tall eyes on me,

48:31

they could tell that the pressure was on them, they were relaxed,

48:33

they were chilled out, not in a casual

48:36

way that suggested they would lose, they just looked in

48:38

quite a good place. And then boom, that

48:40

story comes out, heads

48:43

obviously rattled as soon as they lost

48:45

the foothold in the game against Wales. It wasn't like

48:47

there was anybody on there, because we talked about the lack

48:49

of experience so much now, wasn't like there was an

48:51

on-field general who could rally them. I

48:55

think it's maybe been a little bit more defiant

48:57

since saying that story didn't affect

48:59

us, because they're not technically out yet. Fiji

49:03

could lose both of their next two games and then Australia

49:05

somehow scraped through into

49:07

a potential quarterfinal against England. I think pigs

49:09

can fly as well. I mean, telling

49:12

Lee, no denial,

49:14

no denial from Eddie, he wouldn't address

49:18

the story and sort of play dumb

49:20

almost with it, but no denial.

49:23

He did not say, no, that didn't happen,

49:25

and I will be the Wallabies coach next year, in terms

49:28

of maybe he's trying to

49:30

get ahead of the game because he thinks he might be sacked, because

49:32

as we've mentioned, this is the first time, this

49:35

is going to be the first time that Australia have failed

49:37

to progress from the pool stages at the World Cup. Also,

49:39

no denial from the Japanese Reunion who were approached yesterday,

49:43

they just refused to comment. Now, if you

49:46

were them and it absolutely didn't happen, then you

49:48

would say, wouldn't you? I don't know, am I being naive?

49:50

No, no, I think that's a fair point. To

49:53

pull back the curtain a little bit, both Charlie and

49:55

Charles texted me and said, please send us

49:57

the audio from the press conference as I was sitting

49:59

down into it. because we knew it would

50:02

be a good one. The reaction in

50:04

Australia has been as fierce

50:06

and despondent and miserable

50:09

as you might expect. Bernard Faley

50:11

was one of the people who was in

50:13

Nice I think last week was he?

50:15

So he's been in the country probably with a pair of boots

50:18

back just in case. He

50:20

tweeted for the first time in ages it didn't

50:22

have to be like this. You've had calls

50:24

for Jones to go, you've had former players

50:27

just decrying the lack of

50:29

experienced players in the squad and how unfair

50:32

it is and all these guys who were like in their mid-20s,

50:34

like one of these players who are going to be tarnished by this forever.

50:38

It's just all a bit desperate and Dan

50:40

Schofield has written a column on the

50:42

Telegraph sort of talking about

50:44

yes, like Eddie's

50:47

at fault here but there's such wide structural

50:49

issues in Australian rugby. There's

50:51

a line still going there in less than two

50:53

years. I mean I don't think

50:55

I've ever felt more sure about a 3-0 series

50:58

line to win in my entire life. I mean 3-0 and

51:00

the rest, I mean it's going

51:02

to be absolutely colossal and it does make you

51:07

wonder, I was talking with somebody about this over

51:09

the weekend, wouldn't it be beneficial?

51:13

It would never work from a commercial standpoint.

51:15

I'd rather watch three games between the lines and

51:17

Fiji in Suva or sort of

51:19

around Fiji than what is just going to

51:21

be a total drubbing in Australia.

51:24

Yeah, no I'm completely with you. Yeah,

51:27

just very, it's just an upsetting night, as

51:29

we've already touched on, a very upsetting night and

51:33

yeah, well it remains to be said, the landscape

51:37

of the sport in the country has sort

51:40

of been in recession for a number

51:42

of years anyway and this is not going to help. You

51:44

spoke to anyone who knew Australian

51:48

rugby last week, they said that that game against Wales

51:50

was absolutely massive, such

51:52

a big game, such a sort of titanic day

51:54

for the sport. in

52:00

the country and how important it is and how so momentous

52:02

for the sport to recover

52:05

and then for them to crumble like that is

52:08

just very sad. You see jibes

52:11

on social media which I know should always be taken with a pinch

52:13

of salt but also there's no smoke without

52:15

fire of how it's the fourth code

52:17

of a ball sport, of footy

52:20

in Australia. You've

52:22

got declining participation

52:25

numbers at grassroots level, you've got declining attendance

52:27

at Super Rugby. People don't really care

52:29

about Super Rugby. Yes the Wallabies' attendances

52:32

are still healthy

52:34

and seemingly the population still

52:36

get behind the Wallabies but you do fear that now

52:39

after this will the loyalty

52:41

and will the passion be

52:43

as fierce? Maybe

52:46

not. Obviously we're a long way away and

52:50

we're trying to predict the future so we have no idea but you

52:52

do fear for them a little bit don't you? We

52:54

do. You know it's bad when we all feel this bad for Australia

52:57

because they might

52:59

not necessarily feel the same way about England if

53:01

the tables were dead.

53:04

And also just as an aside I've

53:06

been the bigger man here, I've risen above the Eddie

53:10

Jones jibes. I've rarely addressed them

53:12

but I'm going to have to on this occasion just go where

53:15

are you Eddie? Whoa hey hey

53:17

hey oh my goodness

53:19

me. That's my moment in the sun. The

53:22

podcast studio is just shaking. If the mic

53:24

wasn't sort of fixed to the table I'd

53:26

drop it. You should have ripped it off and said that.

53:29

What do the Dan Cold Stone cold? Yes yes

53:32

that's something nice we'll have to talk about that.

53:35

Let's say nice things about Wales because we absolutely should

53:37

do. Charlie can I just ask you about how

53:40

impressed you were by Gareth Antsken when

53:42

he came on 12 minutes in. I mean Dan

53:44

Bigger goes down some of us wrote

53:46

really nice features about Dan Bigger in the build up

53:48

to the game so that was good

53:51

to see him go off really early with an injury.

53:54

But Gareth Antsken came in and

53:56

showed excellent control, admittedly

53:59

behind a steamroller. of a pack but he impressed.

54:02

Yeah he did, he got absolutely smoked in the air. From

54:04

that Donaldson break we were talking about, he got that interception

54:06

when Donaldson can link up with that inside support

54:08

and I think it was Cora Bette, absolutely

54:11

whack. It was one of

54:14

those really, again, like a

54:16

really demoralising moment for a player because

54:19

the ref came over and you could hear him talking,

54:21

I think it was talking with Tom Foley, the TMO,

54:23

and they were saying, is he alright? And he was like, yeah, he's just winded,

54:25

just a big hit. And it's Antcom

54:27

within a lot of bother and you

54:29

could see, I think players when they're, you could

54:32

see with the outburst of

54:34

emotion like there was for his

54:36

chip for Tompkins, Dry Tompkins, who was fantastic as

54:38

well by the way. Antcom just,

54:41

big celebration, he'd love to see that because

54:43

that's a player who's just so

54:45

much has built up to this point for him and

54:48

it must just be, feel fantastic. It did just

54:50

on that, he spoke about it in the mix and afterwards and how

54:52

he had that horrendous time out with his

54:54

knee injury, the amount of surgeries he'd

54:56

gone through and how that whole kind

54:58

of spell had just made

55:00

him have a better perspective to appreciate

55:03

the bigger moments in the game since he actually kind

55:05

of enjoyed them and he's getting taxed from home back

55:07

in New Zealand and Wales laughing at how

55:09

much he'd gone for it but he was actually like, you've just got

55:11

to appreciate it. Nice little

55:13

drop goal as well. I'm really intrigued by Wales'

55:15

attack and I wrote a piece a couple of weeks

55:17

ago that wasn't meant to be derogatory at all about

55:20

Wales' attack but linked to England's

55:22

attack which is if you can't be an Ireland and if you can't

55:24

have that intricate phase

55:26

pressure and loads of different runners and you'd be a

55:28

Wales because Wales are just very good at

55:30

getting the ball into the hands of their dangerous runners just

55:33

in quite a simple, straightforward way

55:35

which is just as incisive and they'll have

55:37

a couple of clever strikes like they did

55:40

for Gareth Davis try. Gareth Davis

55:42

is just an unbelievable support runner.

55:44

They've got a lot of good athletes, they've got

55:46

a lot of powerful players and

55:49

when they lose momentum they're not

55:51

afraid to go to the boot because they've got a good kicking game as well.

55:59

I was just wondering if that's a typical injured, who would

56:02

put it then? I was like, it could be Thomas Williams. Or

56:04

it could be Jack Morgan, because he's now,

56:06

for a flanker, come up with a lovely crossfield

56:08

assist for Reece Lamont against Fiji.

56:12

And then he's banged a, let's call it a 22-22, not

56:14

a 50-22 against Australia. Charles,

56:17

he's been, no, I wouldn't say a revelation

56:20

of the tournament, because I think people were appreciating

56:23

how good he was. But given where he sort

56:25

of, I mean, Warren Gatlin admitted afterwards, I

56:28

kind of threw him in the deep end a little

56:30

bit, Jack Morgan. But actually, he's thriving

56:32

in on, I thought, on Sunday night

56:35

when he was sort of, you know, bloodied nose, tackling

56:38

everything, scoring chives, he looked

56:40

great, didn't he, Charles? Absolutely, total warrior,

56:42

the beating heart of that Welsh team, has

56:45

really stepped up as captain. You know, all

56:48

the cliches about leading from the front are all,

56:50

you know, completely justified for him. But it's

56:52

not just the leadership, it's the fact that he's an

56:54

outstanding player as well. Virtually

56:56

the first player on the team sheet, and, yeah,

56:59

caused Australia. And

57:01

Fiji, he was amazing against Fiji as well,

57:03

and he was brilliant in the warm-ups. Yeah,

57:06

I mean, he looks, not,

57:08

few had high hopes for Wales in this tournament, but

57:10

I think through sort of sheer

57:13

grit and determination, embodied

57:15

by skipper Morgan, captain Jack, you

57:18

know, they really could be looking at a semi-final.

57:21

That siege mentality that Warren Gatlin,

57:24

I know, loves, seems to be, seems to

57:26

be installed there, they're looking very promising. Right, we're going to

57:28

get into the rest of the weekend's action now, including

57:31

how England get on against Chile up

57:33

in Lille.

57:37

Right, Charlie, how many tries for Henry Arendelle in Lille? Five. To

57:41

put in top of the triscoring

57:43

list of the whole tournament. Outrageous. Outrageous.

57:46

You were there, as we know from your taxi

57:48

adventures, can you give us an idea of, first

57:51

of all, what the atmosphere was like, because I think

57:53

we've seen quite a few Chile fans have travelled over. How

57:55

was that? Yeah, before the game, really cool to see

57:57

loads of Condoros fans. their

58:00

team rewarded them in the first 20 minutes, didn't

58:02

they? England blew a

58:04

few chances as it's kind of become a trend

58:07

and invited pressure

58:09

upon themselves. But as Steve

58:12

Boffert mentioned afterwards, they were resilient in defence and

58:14

they were pretty quick with

58:16

the ball, quick to move the ball and tap for that first 20 minutes.

58:18

It actually, I'm freeing them to score 71

58:21

points in effectively an hour, is

58:23

actually pretty impressive to be fair. No,

58:27

it was quite a nice atmosphere, a few more

58:29

empty seats around the middle sort

58:31

of tier

58:33

which was quite odd, but generally

58:35

quite a nice atmosphere and

58:38

then when those sort of jitters

58:40

of the first 20 minutes had gone, England

58:43

settled in quite nicely. We've

58:46

had glimpses of Marcus

58:48

Smith at full back

58:49

during the warm-ups and

58:51

briefly in the World Cup so far when this was his first

58:54

start there. I appreciate

58:56

that maybe the quality of the opposition might

58:59

factor into your thinking about it and whether it's

59:01

a long-term ploy, but can you

59:03

see England

59:05

using that in the knockout stages and is that

59:07

actually quite a valuable weapon for them to have? I can,

59:09

I really like it. I think he's more,

59:12

certainly more likely to play at full

59:14

back than Henry Arendelle is on the wing.

59:16

To be clear, Henry Arendelle's fourth try was a

59:18

really nice finish. I think

59:20

that the chip and chase, that was, I think Dan

59:23

Cole's scoring the other four, to be honest. Maybe

59:25

not the fifth, but certainly a few of the others. The

59:29

third he ran on to a grubber as well, which

59:32

I don't think Dan Cole's outpacing anybody either,

59:37

but no, you know what I mean. I

59:39

think Smith is more likely to play at full back than Henry

59:42

Arendelle is playing on the wing in a big game

59:45

and I like it. It's not just I know

59:47

there are just caveats rounding the line. It's just

59:50

really boring to keep saying yeah, but the

59:52

plan against this team. But Smith has now gone well

59:55

against Ireland, against Fiji, against Japan

59:57

and now against Chile. And it's not necessarily

59:59

that he's going to He is beating players and

1:00:01

he is picking off kind of tired

1:00:03

defences against the worst team. But

1:00:06

it's as much of a mindset as anything. It's this urgency

1:00:08

and this awareness to play for space and help

1:00:10

there. He was saying he's

1:00:12

classically sort of

1:00:16

self-deprecating afterwards, but he said, look,

1:00:18

I've just got to tell those guys inside me that I want the

1:00:20

ball. Him having that urgency

1:00:23

can transform, that sort of urgency can transform

1:00:25

an attack and I think he's doing a good job

1:00:27

of that. And if it is only an option

1:00:30

off the bench, whether England go 6-2 or 5-3, I think it can

1:00:34

be really valuable. Who were, sorry,

1:00:36

I was just going to say Charles, who else kind of stood out

1:00:38

in that game that would maybe,

1:00:40

who wasn't in the team that played, I wasn't

1:00:43

teaming in Japan, who might have done enough

1:00:45

for the force of re-thing? Well I think that

1:00:47

the big sort of positives were, I was

1:00:49

on player ratings and I gave Arendelle Smith,

1:00:51

Theo Dan, Jack Willis and Owen Farrell

1:00:53

eight. I think

1:00:54

Farrell's return was a positive. I

1:00:56

think Willis has slid

1:00:59

down the pecking order so it's a real positive

1:01:01

that he's gone well. Like to see him on the bench,

1:01:03

I think. Yeah, well they're the big games. Well

1:01:06

for Smith, if Smith

1:01:08

is a live option, which we believe he is for bigger

1:01:11

games, and is a really,

1:01:13

that's a tactic that lends

1:01:15

itself to a 6-2 and if you're loading Willis

1:01:18

as well as another back rower, it's just a way

1:01:20

that England get the best out of the squad they've got

1:01:23

and the squad they've got is characterised by

1:01:25

positional flexibility, so that lends itself

1:01:28

to 6-2 and a lot of good back

1:01:30

five forwards. I'm going to slightly put

1:01:32

a dampener and I don't mean to be contrary

1:01:35

for the sake of it and grumpy and cynical, but

1:01:38

just in the opening 20 I think that,

1:01:41

I think Smith did butcher a couple of overlaps, he'll

1:01:43

be very disappointed with and I think that it's

1:01:45

easy to get lost in the hype

1:01:47

and lost in all the good stuff that he did,

1:01:50

but I think those two, if you're

1:01:52

butchering opportunities like that in a quarter-final or a

1:01:54

semi-final, that's verging on unforgivable and

1:01:56

I think that that will count against him maybe. Well you're only

1:01:58

getting one or two of those. in the quarter-final, aren't

1:02:00

you? So yeah, you need to take them. Right.

1:02:04

But if we are sort of doing the backline

1:02:06

thing, I mean, I would keep Stuart, I think, and

1:02:09

I would have Smith on the bench, and I would keep

1:02:11

Stuart. And I personally would have Arendelle. I

1:02:14

know we think it's unlikely, given

1:02:18

how well May's gone and sort

1:02:20

of how well he suits the

1:02:22

way that England want to play, but I think I would have

1:02:24

Arendelle. I think I'd start Stuart at 15,

1:02:26

just because I think that solidity at the back in

1:02:29

the bigger matches is very valuable.

1:02:31

And again, especially

1:02:33

with how England want to play, which is very kick-heavy,

1:02:36

having him there is

1:02:38

very handy. And I think

1:02:40

that if you went Ford Farrell, which I would go Ford

1:02:42

Farrell, and I think they're certainly leaning towards Ford

1:02:45

Farrell at 10-12, Smith at 15

1:02:47

is sort of playmaking overkill, isn't it? I would

1:02:49

have. Other than those wingers, I would

1:02:51

say I didn't mean to totally kind of cast

1:02:54

the thought of picking Arendelle out there. I think

1:02:56

he would be, I would like to see either one

1:02:59

of him march. It seems

1:03:01

to me like, unless they stick with Daley, which

1:03:03

he's a real safety

1:03:05

blanket as far as the positioning and the aerial

1:03:10

exchanges, the kicking exchanges. But I

1:03:12

think if England are really looking to lift

1:03:14

their ceiling, they'll probably want two

1:03:17

of Arendelle, Marchant or Daley.

1:03:20

Why is that fair to say? Yeah, I mean, it sounds like

1:03:22

he's pushing with Dan Cole on the wing. Yeah, I mean,

1:03:24

I'd have Marchant and Arendelle on the wings, Lawrence

1:03:26

at 13 as an out and out

1:03:30

threat at 13 with Ford and Farrell, 10-12, and

1:03:33

then I'd have Smith and Daley with Youngs on the bench

1:03:35

because that brings something different off the

1:03:37

bench and you've got a lot of positional reflectability there.

1:03:39

And I'd also have, like you said, and like we've just discussed,

1:03:42

Dan, Willis, Martin, these guys who played

1:03:44

very well coming off the bench and

1:03:47

attempting to wreak havoc. I thought

1:03:49

Chesham off the bench looked very good as well again.

1:03:52

He's becoming very important, quietly important

1:03:54

to this team, I think. He was in the

1:03:56

warm-ups, he was obviously coming back off a very

1:03:59

long time.

1:03:59

and was still finding his

1:04:02

feet a little bit, I think

1:04:04

he's been very very good in this tournament so far. Just

1:04:06

to finish off on England, Dan Scanford

1:04:09

had a good story about Arendelle's availability

1:04:12

long term because he's joined the United

1:04:14

team in France and obviously that always gets a bit tricky

1:04:17

with the logistics of when he's eligible and when he

1:04:19

isn't particularly given that the RFU

1:04:21

have quite rightly allowed the

1:04:23

players who are part of the country winning to administration

1:04:25

to be selected.

1:04:26

While they're based on France, Arendelle can play

1:04:28

in the Six Nations, why is it rapping?

1:04:31

But he, as things stand, he

1:04:33

will not be available for the summer tour to Japan and

1:04:36

New Zealand. So I wonder

1:04:38

whether, I think for the World Cup, it's

1:04:40

such a short term thing, you just pick who you

1:04:42

think is best for the World Cup, they won't be thinking about the long

1:04:44

term. But it will be interesting when it gets to

1:04:46

Six Nations time whether they think,

1:04:49

well, you're not going to be around in New Zealand this

1:04:51

summer, whether they still pick him or whether they don't.

1:04:54

That's something that we'll have to keep an

1:04:56

eye on next spring.

1:04:56

France against Namibia

1:04:59

on Thursday night was

1:05:01

all going along fairly nicely and everyone

1:05:04

was just checking their fancy points

1:05:06

for Damion Penno and then there

1:05:08

was a, sorry Charlie, can

1:05:11

you express that group as the inaudible? I

1:05:13

don't want to talk about it but I didn't have it. I had

1:05:16

Jalibare, I captained up Jalibare. Do you not

1:05:18

have Penno at all? No. Wow.

1:05:21

Or Arendelle. I'm not

1:05:23

sure. I'm not sure. That's how you say

1:05:25

it. So yeah, it was all going well and then Jairon

1:05:28

Duesle, he caught Antoine

1:05:30

Dupont on the cheek and France. France

1:05:32

went into meltdown on Thursday night

1:05:34

and into Friday morning. Charles, can you just give us

1:05:37

the latest on what's going on

1:05:39

with Antoine Dupont, when might he return

1:05:42

and will he have anything interesting

1:05:44

on his face when he does? Well this

1:05:46

is the million dollar question, isn't it? The latest

1:05:49

is that he's back with the squad

1:05:51

on Thursday. He'll return to

1:05:53

camp. He's currently at home

1:05:55

resting. He had surgery late on Friday

1:05:58

night. and

1:06:00

they're expecting him to return to training on Sunday,

1:06:03

which is really quite miraculous. That is, if he

1:06:05

continues showing those signs of concussion, because

1:06:07

obviously there's the cheek fracture at play here,

1:06:10

but there's obviously an HIA and a concussion

1:06:12

protocol and return to play protocol that he must follow

1:06:14

as well, because it was a really strong blow

1:06:17

to the face. And then

1:06:19

on Friday, he will go for an appointment

1:06:21

to explore the possibility of

1:06:23

having a Haranordike-style

1:06:26

mask fitted, which

1:06:28

presumably he will play with to

1:06:31

expedite his return to action potentially

1:06:33

for a quarterfinal is what the latest

1:06:35

reports in France are. They're saying that he's out of

1:06:38

the Italy game, which I think we all sort of

1:06:40

expected, which is still quite big

1:06:42

news, because as we've already mentioned, France have

1:06:44

to win that game, and they will have to win that

1:06:47

game now without their captain and their

1:06:49

talisman at scrim half, and Maxime Leuchou

1:06:52

is seemingly destined to start at scrim

1:06:54

half there, and then they might

1:06:56

even be without him for a quarterfinal against

1:06:58

potentially South Africa. But the hope is with

1:07:00

mask, he might be back for a quarter,

1:07:03

and I think it's looking very,

1:07:06

very, very likely that he'll be back for a semi

1:07:09

if France get there. That's your round up. Let's

1:07:11

get into your readers questions.

1:07:16

Thank you very much for your questions. As ever,

1:07:18

please do just send them in to us over on, oh,

1:07:21

I hate calling it X. Let's just

1:07:23

send them to us on Twitter on Sundays and

1:07:25

Mondays. I promise we will consider

1:07:27

them all carefully and then use them in the

1:07:29

podcast. Once we start with one that we had from

1:07:31

Mike, and he said, all this chat about Stuart or Smith,

1:07:34

how likely do you think it is that we see them on the field

1:07:36

together,

1:07:37

changing roles depending on circumstance? There

1:07:39

was a period, Charlie, where we were quite keen on pretty, Stuart,

1:07:42

as a winger, wasn't there? Oh, wait, were we keen

1:07:44

on it, or were England keen on it? I can't. I

1:07:47

don't mind it. Stuart and Slade

1:07:50

and Farrell and Smith were all on the pitch together

1:07:52

with Slade at fullback, I think, in

1:07:54

that last, in the finale of the game against New Zealand,

1:07:56

certainly possible the one reservation

1:07:59

I'd have. with it is

1:08:01

your defensive setup is going to be compromised

1:08:03

somehow even if it's with the backfield

1:08:05

and we saw messing around with the backfield what's just

1:08:08

stuck in my mind potentially because it's the best bit of

1:08:10

skill I think I've ever seen live is Antoine's

1:08:12

epence, left foot is 50-22, that

1:08:14

was when England were trying to muck around with the backfield a bit. So

1:08:17

there

1:08:18

are, they're going to

1:08:20

be sort of, trade offs England are going to have to

1:08:22

make everywhere to get the backline they

1:08:24

want, it's just about being smart. And I don't

1:08:26

think, I don't think Stuart is against the big

1:08:29

four nations, I think in a semi-final I don't think Stuart's

1:08:31

quick enough, I think they're back three, they're back three will

1:08:33

exploit him. He's quick enough to play fullback

1:08:35

and I'm not saying he's slow but if you look at the sort

1:08:37

of back threes of the other nations you look at the the

1:08:40

Colby Arendtzer, you look at France

1:08:42

who have got Penno and BLB are

1:08:44

a I don't think, I think they could

1:08:46

skin Stuart. They could skin Stuart.

1:08:48

Just to combine two

1:08:50

questions we had from one from Worcester

1:08:52

Faithful and another from Lance Browning who's the former,

1:08:55

the Gloucester Chief Exact, just basically both getting

1:08:57

at the same thing, how do we sort

1:08:59

of reduce these mismatches that

1:09:02

we're occasionally seeing where teams are getting pumped

1:09:04

by loads of points and also make sure that we're

1:09:06

giving the lights of Portugal and Georgia and

1:09:08

Spain and the other teams regular

1:09:10

game time by coming up with

1:09:13

a new tournament or more matches, what's your

1:09:15

solution Charlie? I think first it's dangerous to say that

1:09:17

it's been a

1:09:19

completely positive tournament for the emerging

1:09:21

nations because Romania and Namibia

1:09:23

have been disappointing. It's kind of Fiji

1:09:25

and Uruguay isn't it? Yeah, for sure. Portugal

1:09:27

as well although they, you know, although as we

1:09:30

said earlier that draw with Georgia isn't a massively

1:09:32

shock result. I think it's time certainly to

1:09:35

have a coherent strategy around it and whether

1:09:37

because it seems a bit haphazard whereby

1:09:39

the sort of positive things like the Fiji-Druer

1:09:42

side and the Moana-Pacifica side in

1:09:44

Super Rugby aren't necessarily part

1:09:46

of a wider plan or they don't seem to

1:09:48

be, maybe I'm being

1:09:49

unfair there.

1:09:50

So one positive

1:09:53

thing that keeps coming back on these

1:09:55

T2 Rugby on Twitter that's a sort of major advocate

1:09:57

of it is that it's just expanding that end of the tournament.

1:10:00

the six

1:10:02

nations competition. So those

1:10:05

teams in the Rugby Europe Championship can have

1:10:08

a grounding at age group level because that's

1:10:10

just gonna

1:10:12

be positive. It's gonna pay it forward,

1:10:14

hopefully. You'd hope that. And the age-old

1:10:16

thing as well, that always, you know, is the classic,

1:10:18

the cliche, that always rears its head, is

1:10:20

promotion and relegation to the six nations in some form,

1:10:23

even if that involves a playoff. They

1:10:25

are, the home nations and France

1:10:28

and Italy are staunchly against it. We are told

1:10:30

and we're told it's not gonna happen, but it's just such a surefire

1:10:33

way to ensure that, certainly

1:10:35

in Europe, anyway, in Europe, that those

1:10:37

emerging nations get, sort

1:10:39

of, that they have something to play for and they have a carrot,

1:10:42

a reason to improve and to continue

1:10:45

to this trajectory of improvement, which

1:10:47

has been mightily impressive. You know, you look at where

1:10:49

Portugal were and where they are now, and

1:10:52

certainly, you know, Spain had often

1:10:54

forgotten about in this because obviously they were booted

1:10:56

out of the tournament because they feel an ineligible player.

1:10:59

But they are beneath

1:11:02

Georgia, they're the emerging nation. They are the coming

1:11:04

nation. The club scene

1:11:07

there is thriving. And

1:11:09

the national team have seen vast, vast improvements and

1:11:12

they should really be at this World Cup in

1:11:14

place of Romania. So

1:11:16

that's the way, these nations need

1:11:19

more competitive fixtures against

1:11:23

better nations more regularly. I would open

1:11:25

it up, the World Cup, up to 24 teams as well. I

1:11:28

would be an advocate of that because the

1:11:30

main drawback seems that we get more hideings,

1:11:32

more thrashings, but we're getting them anyway now

1:11:34

with 20. So why not give

1:11:37

these teams some exposure, more

1:11:39

exposure, more exposure to high level rugby. I know

1:11:41

they need it between the tournaments as well,

1:11:43

but let's start somewhere, you know.

1:11:46

Might be one for our post-group stage, kind of

1:11:48

deep dive into the tournament so we could spend about half an hour

1:11:50

trying to work out how to fix

1:11:52

that. And just a final question from John about the All

1:11:54

Blacks who we haven't spoken about because they've

1:11:57

had a bit of time off and they've kind of been

1:11:59

able to watch our... in South Africa from

1:12:01

afar and he says,

1:12:04

they'll be a full strength through Italy so we're waiting to see their

1:12:06

intensity. No one's really talking about them.

1:12:09

What can we kind of expect from them? I

1:12:11

spoke to a couple of Kiwi journalists who were at the Wales

1:12:13

Australia game who were quite

1:12:15

downbeat actually on just

1:12:17

whether New Zealand have enough

1:12:20

to really trouble Ireland and South Africa and France,

1:12:22

which actually made me

1:12:25

take a bit of a step back because I'd sort of been wondering about

1:12:28

whether they were a threat. Charlie, what do you

1:12:30

think? To steal someone else's opinion

1:12:32

a little bit again, the, I was with Stuart

1:12:34

Barnes for a little bit of last weekend and he said

1:12:36

the difference with this A-B's team versus

1:12:39

previous iterations is that they've got

1:12:41

a horrible 15 minutes or 20

1:12:43

minutes in them, whereas other All

1:12:45

Blacks teams didn't have that and I think that's

1:12:47

fairly pertinent when you think about how they collapsed against

1:12:49

England for example at Tukinam. I

1:12:51

keep thinking about how they picked

1:12:54

apart South Africa in Auckland

1:12:56

fairly recently and how that can be their sort

1:12:58

of ceiling. However, they've

1:13:00

probably got more chunks in

1:13:02

their armour than other previous

1:13:05

sides. I agree with John that

1:13:07

the Italy game's gonna be quite interesting.

1:13:10

They're missing Ethan DeGroote for that, which is a big

1:13:12

loss and I agree

1:13:15

that Ireland will have to be 100% on for

1:13:17

that quarterfinal because there'll

1:13:19

be a bit of simmering resentment from New Zealand

1:13:21

about that series that kicked Ireland into

1:13:24

gear, but at the minute you'd say Ireland were kind

1:13:26

of fairly significant favourites, wouldn't you? And you'd

1:13:28

wanna see a bit more from New Zealand before

1:13:30

that quarterfinal.

1:13:31

Right, that's it for today. Thank you, Charlie. Thank you,

1:13:33

Charles. And a big thanks to Pete Wilkins as well for his

1:13:35

insight on Bandiaki in Ireland. There's

1:13:38

no game for England or Ireland all Wales

1:13:40

this weekend, so a bit of a quieter weekend

1:13:43

on the horizon, but still lots of games, still plenty to

1:13:45

keep up with from the Rugby World Cup on the website, so please

1:13:48

keep an eye out for all of our work and all of the work of

1:13:50

our colleagues as well. There's gonna be lots to dive into. Enjoy

1:13:53

all the action. We'll catch you next week, but until

1:13:55

then, thank you and goodbye.

1:14:00

you

Unlock more with Podchaser Pro

  • Audience Insights
  • Contact Information
  • Demographics
  • Charts
  • Sponsor History
  • and More!
Pro Features