Podchaser Logo
Home
UNLUCKY 13 | Brittany Killgore's Tragic Betrayal

UNLUCKY 13 | Brittany Killgore's Tragic Betrayal

Released Monday, 6th May 2024
Good episode? Give it some love!
UNLUCKY 13 | Brittany Killgore's Tragic Betrayal

UNLUCKY 13 | Brittany Killgore's Tragic Betrayal

UNLUCKY 13 | Brittany Killgore's Tragic Betrayal

UNLUCKY 13 | Brittany Killgore's Tragic Betrayal

Monday, 6th May 2024
Good episode? Give it some love!
Rate Episode

Episode Transcript

Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.

Use Ctrl + F to search

0:00

Hello dear listeners, whether you're just finding

0:02

us or have been with us for

0:04

a while, Welcome. At Dreams

0:06

and Crimes, We've got a treasure trove

0:08

of stories waiting to be discovered. We

0:10

like to describe them as a cozy

0:12

blanket after a long day of work.

0:15

Or. A ticket to a thrilling adventure before

0:17

bed. If. You're a long

0:19

time listener. Thanks for sticking with us.

0:21

Your support means the world. Want.

0:24

To take it up a notch. Consider. Subscribing

0:26

to dreams and crimes on Apple podcasts?

0:28

Are you tube? Were cooking up something

0:30

special, Turning these stories into videos. We've

0:32

put a lot of efforts into them,

0:35

and they're actually super good. A

0:37

Now let's dive into today story. Unlucky.

0:43

Thirteen. It

0:49

was a rainy Friday afternoon. April.

0:51

Thirteenth Twenty twelve when Brittany kill

0:53

go rest began packing her bags.

0:57

Britney online profile name was thirteen

0:59

my lucky number, but this Friday

1:02

the thirteenth was going to be

1:04

anything but lucky. Just

1:07

three days earlier, she had filed for

1:09

divorce from her husband, Lance Corporal Corey

1:12

Kilgore. Corey had

1:14

been a Marine station to Camp Pendleton

1:16

just north of San Diego, but had

1:18

recently been transferred for a tour of

1:20

duty in Afghanistan. Leaving Britain the

1:22

alone in the small military town of

1:25

Four Brooke, California. As

1:28

a teenager, Bring Me had dreamed of

1:30

marriage and wrote about it on her

1:32

blog. I want to be Married I

1:35

want to love that person. But.

1:37

The divorce rate is so high. She

1:40

also wrote candidly of her insecurities

1:43

and struggles with depression. Three.

1:46

Years later she was married, but the marriage wasn't

1:48

what she had hoped it would be. Both.

1:52

britney inquiry were only twenty when they

1:54

married but by the time they were

1:56

twenty two they mutually called it quits

2:00

Forbrook was a small town that sat

2:02

immediately east of the entrance to US

2:04

Marine Corps Base Camp Pendleton. With

2:07

a population of just 30,000 people,

2:10

most of the town was comprised of military

2:12

families. Brittany

2:14

lived at the La Galliana de Cortes Apartments

2:16

in a small upstairs apartment just a short

2:18

walk from the entrance to the base. She

2:23

had grown up in the Ozarks in Missouri,

2:25

but her family had since moved to Pennsylvania.

2:29

Once her divorce was finalized, she would have

2:31

no reason to stay in the military town,

2:34

so on that rainy afternoon she and

2:36

her friend Chani Tal were packing boxes

2:38

for her move to Pennsylvania. That

2:42

same afternoon, another of Brittany's

2:45

friends, Elizabeth Hernandez, had stopped by

2:47

the home of Dorothy Maraglino and

2:49

Louis Perez to return a camera

2:51

charger she had borrowed. In

2:54

casual conversation, Elizabeth mentioned that her

2:56

friend Brittany was moving away from

2:58

Fullbrook. She

3:00

told Dorothy that she was planning to take her

3:03

to the marina in San Diego and treat her

3:05

to a horn blower dinner cruise before she left.

3:09

Dorothy was familiar with Brittany. In

3:11

fact, she had a deep hatred of the girl.

3:15

Although she barely knew her, Dorothy

3:17

often called Brittany the disease or

3:20

the herpes. Dorothy

3:23

was in a polygamous open relationship

3:25

with US Marine Staff Sergeant Louis

3:28

Perez, a 16-year veteran of the

3:30

3rd Marine Aircraft Wing stationed at

3:32

Camp Pendleton. The

3:35

couple had agreed that they were free

3:37

to see other people, but despite the

3:39

open relationship, Dorothy felt threatened by Brittany

3:41

Kilgore. Brittany was

3:43

young and beautiful. Dorothy believed

3:46

she was too flirty with 45-year-old Perez.

3:50

She often asked Elizabeth why she hung out

3:52

with Brittany at all and once jokingly told

3:55

her, I could get rid of her for you.

3:58

Dorothy Maraglino was a young woman who had been in the military For a long time. Leno

4:00

and Louis Peres's relationship was far

4:02

from normal. The. Fact

4:04

that their relationship was polygamous, however, may

4:07

have seemed like the most normal part

4:09

of the relationship. The

4:12

To lived as master and slave

4:14

in a twisted Bdsm. Bondage.

4:16

And discipline/domination and submission

4:18

slush, sadism, the masochism

4:21

relationship. For.

4:23

Years Perez lived as the

4:25

dominant master of the household,

4:27

while Dorothy lived as the

4:29

submissive slave. Dorothy.

4:32

Was also a switch. Meaning. She

4:34

was submissive to per as, but would

4:36

also be a dominant mistress to her

4:39

own slaves. Together,

4:41

the two of them took part in

4:43

that Bdsm lifestyle with I Live In

4:45

Slave Jessica Lopez. Each

4:48

participant in the three way relationship

4:50

had their respective Bdsm name's. Louis

4:53

Perez was ivan. Dorothy.

4:55

Married Leno was d. And

4:58

Jessica Lopez was Roslin. Within.

5:02

The household Dorothy established strict

5:04

written rules, including the house

5:06

manual. Perfect. Slave check list

5:08

and a slave contract. Dorothy.

5:12

Day also had a contract that

5:14

professed others the sole property of

5:16

pariahs Ivan. The.

5:18

Contract entitled feed to d

5:20

was signed in Dorothy's bloody

5:22

some print. The.

5:25

Vanity License plate on Dorothy's truck

5:27

read I V M S Katie

5:29

and. Ivens Kitten. Dorothy.

5:34

Merrick Leno controlled everything the

5:36

Jessica Lopez Rosalyn did in

5:38

life. Both. Inside the home and

5:40

out. Jessica.

5:43

Wore a red dog collar at all

5:45

times with a heart shaped dog tag

5:47

engraved with a text Roslyn. Property.

5:49

Of Miss De. And eight her meals

5:51

out of a double. Louis

5:54

however as these master had

5:56

control over both Dorothy and

5:58

Jessica. Louis.

6:01

Perez was a sadist. He

6:03

lived to inflict pain on others. In.

6:06

Prior relationships, he choked his partner every

6:09

time they had sex either with his

6:11

hands or with a leather belt. Occasionally

6:14

he suggested having estate kidnapped

6:17

and a stranger's held prisoner

6:19

and tortured. Knives,

6:21

And chains were coming. Sex toys in

6:24

his relationships. Perez.

6:26

Can videos of himself beating women as

6:28

they begged him to stoop. One.

6:31

Such video showed him beating a

6:33

woman into unconsciousness. On.

6:36

Another occasion, Perez and Dorothy acted out

6:38

an abduction fantasy why they picked up

6:41

a young woman in a parking lot

6:43

and took her to that dungeon in

6:45

the basement of Dorothy's home for Bdsm

6:47

play. Later.

6:50

That rainy Friday at four thirty

6:52

eight pm, Louis Perez knocked on

6:54

the door of Britney department. Has

6:56

she enchanting? We're packing boxes. It

7:00

surprise Britney to see him considering she barely

7:02

knew him and she asked how he knew

7:04

where she lived. He

7:06

replied I asked around. Perez.

7:10

Explained that he had purchased two tickets for

7:12

a Hornblower dinner cruise later that night and

7:14

wanted to know if she'd like to go

7:16

with him. He

7:18

was an odd request considering they weren't

7:21

close friends. There

7:23

was a twenty three year age difference and

7:25

she knew he was in a relationship. Britney.

7:29

Was noticeably uneasy about the proposition

7:31

and politely declined his offer, explaining

7:33

that she needed to pack boxes

7:35

for her move. Perez.

7:39

Wrote down his phone number and handed it

7:41

to her. Call. Me if

7:43

you change your mind. When.

7:45

Perez left the apartment complex. He

7:48

sent a text to Dorothy reading

7:50

that wasn't successful. She

7:53

replied. Tomorrow is another

7:55

day. Just

7:57

minutes later, Perez got a text

7:59

message from Britney. She

8:01

wanted to know if he knew anyone that could

8:03

help her with her move. Perez.

8:06

Was quick to reply. Party.

8:08

With me tonight and you'll have five guys there

8:11

in the morning. Still,

8:13

Uncomfortable Britney messaged him saying that she

8:15

would love having help with a move,

8:18

but felt weird parting with him because

8:20

she knew he was in a relationship

8:22

with Dorothy. He.

8:24

replied. She's. Okay with

8:26

it, his her phone number. Give.

8:28

Her coal. Twenty

8:31

cents. A brief texts to Dorothy to

8:33

immediately called her back. On

8:36

speakerphone, Britney friend Johnny heard

8:38

the conversation. Dorothy.

8:41

Encouraged her to go on the dinner cruise with

8:43

Per as. She.

8:45

Told her they'd already paid for the

8:47

tickets and explain not as she was

8:49

pregnant with perez baby. Being on a

8:51

boat would probably make her sea sick

8:53

anyway. After

8:56

hanging up with Dorothy, Britney told Tiny

8:58

that she still didn't feel entirely comfortable

9:00

with it and had no interest in

9:02

Paris romantically but really liked the idea

9:05

of champagne and a three course meal

9:07

sailing on a yacht beneath the Coronado

9:09

Bay Bridge. By.

9:11

Six ten Pm for it Me had

9:13

changed her mind. She.

9:16

Sent a text to Per as agreeing to

9:18

go with him to which he quickly responded.

9:21

Be. Ready at seven thirty. More.

9:24

Brittany didn't know was that the home blow it

9:26

in a cruise. Left the doc at seven pm.

9:29

And the doc was an hour away from full brooke.

9:32

There was no chance they would make it. But.

9:35

That didn't matter, Perez. Never

9:38

had tickets. Know any intention

9:40

on taking her on the cruise. He

9:43

had other plans. Britney.

9:46

Borrowed to evening dresses from Chinese for

9:48

the dinner and decided on a dark

9:50

purple one with a glittery purple flower

9:52

pot and. still

9:55

feeling awkward about the situation she gave

9:57

channy the cell phone numbers of both

9:59

parade and Dorothy. Just

10:01

in case. At

10:05

6.38pm, Brittany messaged Elizabeth Hernandez to

10:07

let her know about her date

10:09

with Perez. Elizabeth

10:12

was confused. She

10:14

had planned on being the one to take Brittany on

10:16

the dinner cruise as a gift. She

10:18

had even mentioned her intentions to Perez and

10:21

Dorothy earlier in the day. She

10:24

also thought it was strange because she knew

10:26

that Brittany barely knew Perez. Brittany

10:30

received a text at 7.31pm

10:32

from Perez. I'm running

10:35

late. Be there in five minutes. Can

10:37

you meet me at the curb? Brittany

10:40

replied, At the curb? It's

10:43

raining, you know. I'd appreciate

10:45

it if you drove into the complex. It's

10:48

not. I don't want to miss our boat.

10:51

Perez responded. He

10:54

knew there were security cameras throughout the

10:57

complex and wanted to avoid them but

10:59

drove through anyway. At

11:02

7.36pm, surveillance cameras showed his

11:04

white Ford Explorer entering the

11:07

complex. One minute

11:09

later he texted, I'm here. At 7.39pm,

11:12

Brittany messaged

11:15

another friend, Jessica Perry, that lived

11:17

in her same apartment complex. I'm

11:20

going on a dinner cruise with Louis Perez tonight.

11:23

I might stop by to see you when I get back. One

11:27

minute later, the apartment security cameras

11:29

showed the Explorer leaving the apartment complex

11:32

with Brittany in the passenger seat. Just

11:36

10 minutes after Brittany left the apartment

11:38

complex, Chani received a one-word

11:40

text message from Brittany's phone. It

11:44

simply read, Help. At

11:47

approximately the same time, Perez

11:49

messaged Dorothy. Kitten?

11:54

The message gave Chani Powell a sudden

11:56

twinge of fright. She

11:59

immediately replied, to Brittany. What?

12:02

Are you okay? There

12:04

was no reply, so she messaged

12:06

again. Brittany, are

12:09

you okay? I'm freaking out here. Still

12:12

no reply. Chani

12:15

messaged one more time before she finally got

12:17

a reply at 8.05pm. Yes,

12:21

I love this party. Chani

12:24

knew the reply was not genuine. Brittany

12:27

would never have used the word yes in

12:29

a text message. She had always just used

12:32

yeah. After

12:34

trying to call Brittany several times with no

12:36

answer, Chani sent another message

12:38

demanding her to call back. Call

12:41

me back now. I need to hear

12:43

your voice. At

12:46

8.07pm, Chani received another text.

12:49

In a few. Hot guys. Chani

12:53

was certain this wasn't Brittany and insisted

12:55

that she call her immediately. At 8.09pm

12:58

and 8.10pm, Chani received two

13:01

short phone calls. Both

13:04

calls were only a few seconds long with

13:06

loud music in the background. The

13:09

calls were followed by another text message.

13:12

It's okay. Music too loud.

13:17

Over the next several minutes, Chani

13:19

contacted Brittany's other friends, Jessica

13:21

Perry and Elizabeth Hernandez. After

13:25

trying Brittany's phone with no answer, Elizabeth

13:28

called Perez's girlfriend, Dorothy. Dorothy

13:32

Maraglino told Elizabeth she knew nothing about

13:34

a dinner cruise and hadn't spoken to

13:36

Brittany at all that day. An

13:39

obvious lie. At

13:41

8.40pm, Jessica Perry

13:43

called Perez, who answered the call.

13:47

He told Jessica that he and Brittany

13:49

had driven to downtown San Diego and

13:51

went to the Whiskey Girl Club in

13:53

the Gaslamp District. He

13:56

told her that Brittany had met a couple of Marines

13:58

there and he'd left her there. Jessica

14:01

Perry knew this couldn't possibly be true.

14:04

That would have been completely out of character for

14:06

Brittany. The

14:08

truth was that she never made it out of

14:10

Fullbrook. Louis

14:13

Perez and Dorothy Maraglino took efforts

14:15

to cover their tracks. Dorothy

14:18

had worked for a cell phone company in

14:20

the past and knew that cell phones were

14:22

traceable. She

14:24

instructed Perez to drive toward downtown

14:26

San Diego with Brittany's phone. During

14:30

the drive, he sent text messages to

14:32

her phone reading, Where

14:34

are you? and Your friends are

14:36

calling me worried. He

14:38

also messaged Dorothy asking how her night

14:41

was going, to which she replied, Just

14:43

having a quiet night at home. At

14:48

10.10pm, Chani tried to call

14:50

Brittany one more time. When

14:52

she got no response, she sent a

14:55

text. Should I just call the

14:57

cops? Chani

14:59

received a text reply, I'm

15:01

okay. Perez

15:03

then dumped Brittany's phone on the streets

15:05

of downtown San Diego. As

15:09

he drove back to Fullbrook from

15:11

San Diego, Perez called Brittany's friend,

15:13

Jessica Perry. Trying

15:15

to establish an alibi, he told her

15:18

he had been driving around the Gaslamp

15:20

District looking for Brittany, but finally gave

15:22

up. Saturday

15:25

morning was agonizing for Chani,

15:27

Elizabeth and Jessica Perry. There

15:30

was still no word from their friend. Jessica

15:33

called Dorothy and told her she knew she

15:35

had lied to her. She

15:38

knew that she had spoken to Brittany the previous day.

15:41

Nervous, Dorothy stammered an excuse and

15:44

handed the phone to Perez. He

15:48

hadn't planned his alibi very well and

15:50

mumbled several conflicting scenarios of what had

15:52

happened the previous night. Chani

15:56

and Elizabeth went to Brittany's apartment, but there

15:58

was no trace of her. and they

16:00

called the sheriff's department. When

16:03

the sheriff's deputy called Perez, he was

16:05

clearly startled, but offered to come to

16:07

Brittany's apartment to talk. When

16:10

Perez arrived at the apartment, Chani

16:12

and Elizabeth were still there speaking to

16:14

the deputy. Perez

16:17

claimed that when he had picked Brittany up

16:19

that night, she had already been drinking and

16:21

was very flirty with him. Chani

16:24

and Elizabeth immediately rebuffed this and let the

16:26

deputy know that this was a lie. Perez

16:30

claimed that he had left Brittany at a

16:32

club in the Gaslamp district, where she flirted

16:34

with a few Marines. He

16:37

said that when he couldn't find her, he

16:39

texted her before he left, and she replied

16:41

with a text saying, I'm okay. The

16:46

deputy's suspicion grew when he asked Perez to

16:48

show him the text on his phone, where

16:50

the text wasn't there. There

16:53

was also the question if his white Ford

16:55

Explorer was parked outside. The

16:58

bumper and running board of the vehicle were caked

17:00

with mud. The

17:02

deputy asked for his consent to a voluntary

17:04

search of the vehicle, and Perez agreed. Inside

17:08

the vehicle was an AR-15 assault

17:10

rifle, which had been stolen from

17:12

Camp Pendleton and was illegal in

17:14

California. Perez

17:16

was arrested on the weapons charge. That

17:20

Saturday afternoon, Brittany's mother, Michelle Rest,

17:22

got a phone call from her

17:25

daughter's cell phone. Her

17:27

stranger on the other end of the phone explained

17:29

that a homeless man had found her phone on

17:32

the streets of San Diego and was attempting to

17:34

sell it. Brittany's

17:36

mother was unaware that her daughter was missing,

17:39

but assumed the worst and called authorities.

17:43

On April 15th, deputies began their

17:46

search of the home at 317

17:48

East Fullbrook Street, where Louis Perez,

17:50

Dorothy Maraglino, and Jessica Lopez lived.

17:55

Maraglino and Lopez stood in the front yard

17:57

and watched. When

17:59

police... arrived the following day to continue the

18:01

search, Maraglino and Lopez were

18:04

gone as was Maraglino's truck. Detectives

18:08

noticed that several items that were in

18:10

the house the previous day had been

18:12

removed. Law

18:15

enforcement throughout Southern California were alerted

18:17

to be on the lookout for

18:19

Maraglino's Nissen Titan with the license

18:22

plate IVNS-KTN. Meanwhile,

18:25

forensic teams were analysing Perez's

18:27

Ford Explorer. Inside

18:30

his SUV police found blue latex

18:32

gloves, a large piece of

18:34

clear plastic sheeting with smeared blood on

18:36

it, a plastic bag and a stun

18:38

baton. Brittany

18:41

Kilgore's DNA was found on the plastic

18:43

sheeting and latex gloves. Perez's

18:46

DNA was found on the strap and handle

18:48

of the stun baton, while more

18:50

of Brittany's DNA was found on the prongs. The

19:20

morning of April 17th, Maraglino's truck was spotted in the parking lot

19:22

of the Romada Inn near the

19:38

San Diego Airport. According

19:41

to the front desk, room 105

19:43

was registered to Dorothy Maraglino. When

19:47

police knocked on the door, there was no

19:49

answer, but officers could hear

19:51

faint sounds. It

19:53

sounded like the liked cries of a woman. When

19:57

the door was forced open, they found a naked

20:00

woman wearing only a red skirt and

20:02

combat boots. She was

20:04

bleeding from several deep, self-inflicted wounds on

20:06

her neck and wrist. The

20:09

bedsheets were soaked with blood. Several

20:13

large knives and an orthodontic scalpel were

20:15

found near the sink next to an

20:17

empty bottle of Chambord liqueur. At

20:20

the foot of the bed was a red dog collar

20:22

with a tag that read Rosalyn, property

20:25

of Ms. D. It

20:28

wasn't Dorothy, it was

20:30

Jessica Lopez, Dorothy's slave. Lopez

20:34

was rushed to the hospital and

20:36

subsequently arrested. In

20:39

the room was a clothes hanger above the

20:41

vanity desk with a note clipped to it

20:43

that read, Pigs, read this. Below

20:47

the notes were three envelopes. One

20:50

was addressed to Master Ivan, another

20:52

to My Parents and the

20:54

third to a local television station. Each

20:57

envelope contained a copy of a seven

21:00

page suicide note penned by Lopez. In

21:04

the suicide note Lopez claimed it

21:06

was her that killed Brittany, not

21:08

Perez or Maraglino, stating, You've

21:10

got the wrong fucking person. The

21:14

letter claimed that Maraglino and Perez

21:16

were asleep upstairs while she alone

21:18

murdered Brittany. She

21:20

described Brittany as a miserable cunt that

21:22

came between Perez and Maraglino and went

21:25

into detail of how she killed her.

21:29

According to Lopez, she used a

21:31

taser to knock her down, then

21:33

restrained her legs and wrists before gagging

21:35

her mouth. She

21:37

then claimed to have tied a rope around

21:40

her neck where she repeatedly applied and released

21:42

pressure until she was dead. She

21:46

then attempted to dismember her body with power

21:48

tools, washed her body with bleach

21:50

and dumped her on the side of a road near

21:53

Lake Skinner. Officers

21:55

were immediately dispatched to the Lake Skinner

21:57

area. Lopez's

22:00

letter went on about her love

22:02

for Dorothy Maraglino, her mistress. Using

22:06

the hotel's surveillance cameras, police were able

22:08

to see that Maraglino had been in

22:10

the room when Lopez wrote the notes.

22:14

Lopez took the first copy of the notes to

22:16

the hotel receptionist to make the copies. Maraglino

22:20

left the hotel that morning and boarded

22:22

a plane to Virginia. Certain

22:26

statements in the note, however, made

22:28

no sense. Lopez

22:30

wrote that the murder happened after 11.15pm. From

22:35

the string of text messages, police already

22:37

knew that was unlikely. Lopez

22:40

also claimed that Brittany, who

22:42

didn't drive, suddenly appeared at

22:44

the house at 317 East

22:46

Fullbrook Street unannounced and demanded

22:48

sex from Perez. Later

22:52

that day, a maintenance worker clearing

22:54

brush about a mile south of Lake Skinner

22:56

found the nude body of Brittany Kilgore dumped

22:59

in a ditch. The

23:03

bruising on Brittany's wrists revealed that she had been bound

23:05

with handcuffs. Five

23:08

small marks on the left side of her face were

23:10

an exact match for the pins of the stun baton.

23:15

Deep post-mortem wounds on her knee showed that

23:17

someone had unsuccessfully attempted to dismember her body

23:19

parts with a power saw. The

23:23

cartilage surrounding her trachea had been crushed. By

23:28

examining the hemorrhaging in her eyes, the

23:30

medical examiner could tell that pressure had been

23:33

applied and released repeatedly over a long period

23:35

just as Jessica Lopez wrote in her suicide

23:37

note. Ultimately,

23:40

the cause of death was ligature strangulation. As

23:46

lead detective Brian Patterson drove to the spot

23:48

where the body was dumped, he

23:50

received a call from Dorothy Maraglino, who was still on the run. Attempting

23:55

to establish an alibi, she told him that she and

23:57

Lopez were home that night and rented a house. the

24:00

adventures of Rin Tin Tin. Paterson,

24:03

however, was more interested in the

24:05

flaws in both Perez's and Lopez's

24:08

stories. When he questioned

24:10

her on the inconsistencies, she hung

24:12

up. Two

24:14

days after they found the body, police

24:17

searched Maraglino's house once again. This

24:21

time they found the roll of plastic that Lopez mentioned

24:23

in her note and a

24:25

blade from a reciprocating saw. Detectives

24:29

also found several BDSM

24:31

photos, videos, documents, sex

24:34

toys and bondage equipment. One

24:37

document recovered was a release of liability

24:39

form. It was

24:41

a contract stating that Dorothy Maraglino agreed

24:44

to voluntarily endure Luis

24:46

Perez's beatings, whippings and asphyxia,

24:49

and that he held no responsibility in the

24:51

case of injuries or loss of life. They

24:55

also found a document in which Maraglino

24:57

released her anger to Perez, encouraging

25:00

him to deliver justice on her

25:02

behalf. The

25:04

letter, riddled with strange spellings, was

25:06

written by Maraglino on the day

25:08

Brittany had been murdered. I,

25:12

D, do hereby give to Ivan all

25:14

my grudges and revenge from my birth

25:16

till now. I

25:18

release my anger and entrust justice into

25:21

Ivan's hands. I

25:23

accept Ivan will decide, design

25:25

and dispense the measure of

25:27

retribution he deems appropriate to

25:29

my enemies, tormentors and violators.

25:32

Signed, D. Another

25:35

document read, Please

25:37

consider accepting this gift. I

25:40

leave all methods of retribution to you. Please

25:43

destroy them all. Rape the

25:46

women. Destroy their reputation.

25:49

Take their possessions. When

25:51

you deem, take their last breath.

25:55

I release all I carry from

25:57

my rapist, abuses and tormentors to

25:59

you. you. I'll

26:02

join in where you direct me and allow,

26:04

but I rels my own will and

26:06

agenda in these matters." Signed,

26:09

Kitten. Yet

26:12

another document written by Maraglino detailed a

26:14

fantasy she had of coming up behind

26:16

a person and slitting their throat. Other

26:20

items found in the house included nylon rope

26:23

with hairs embedded in it, duct

26:25

tape, plastic bags, a rope

26:27

and pulley system, a blackened deca

26:29

sabersaw and a red skill saw.

26:34

Dorothy Maraglino was arrested on May 10th

26:36

2012 and returned

26:38

to San Diego. Perez

26:40

was still in custody on the weapons charge. All

26:44

three suspects were charged with

26:46

first-degree murder, conspiracy to commit

26:48

kidnapping, kidnapping, torture and

26:51

attempted sexual battery by restraint.

26:55

With the three defendants in custody, the

26:57

prosecution began their analysis of the evidence

27:00

to prepare for trial. Detectives

27:03

found profiles for both

27:05

Perez and Maraglino on

27:08

BDSM websites, bmehookups.com and

27:10

tsrenetwork.com where Ivan described

27:12

himself as Lord and

27:15

Master and Dee as

27:17

slave lover confidant and partner.

27:21

On another website he wrote, I

27:23

am Lord and Master, Dom and

27:25

Daddy of my house. My slave

27:28

Ms Dee is a slave to no

27:30

one but myself. Dee's

27:33

profile described herself as an

27:35

alpha slave to Master Ivan. Their

27:39

profiles showed that they were looking for additional

27:41

sex slaves and other couples to join their

27:43

family. We have

27:45

a poly home in which I own two slave

27:47

girls, life is good. Poly

27:51

is referring to a polyamorous relationship

27:53

involving multiple sexual partners, in this

27:55

case one which is open to

27:57

new individuals. Dorothy

28:01

Maraglino was pregnant with Perez's baby

28:03

when police arrested her. Perez

28:06

requested that when the baby was born, she

28:09

give custody to a friend of his named

28:11

Becky Zaga. Zaga

28:13

visited both Perez and Maraglino in prison

28:15

regularly before the baby was born and

28:18

Maraglino agreed to give custody of the

28:20

baby to Zaga. According

28:23

to Maraglino, the agreement was that

28:25

she would continue to live in the San

28:27

Diego area and bring the child in for

28:29

weekly jail visits. When

28:32

the baby was born, however, Zaga

28:34

took custody of the baby and moved

28:37

to Central California. The

28:39

prison visits stopped. Maraglino

28:43

tried in vain to regain custody of the

28:45

child and give custody to her family on

28:47

the east coast, but the courts sided with

28:49

Zaga. From

28:52

one of Zaga's visits to Perez, he

28:54

admitted to her that, Everybody had

28:56

a role to play that night, including

28:58

myself. Although

29:01

Perez later claimed he was referring to

29:03

the cover-up, not the murder, that

29:05

statement would later be used against all three of

29:07

them in court. The

29:10

prosecution had a dilemma. Jessica

29:13

Lopez's confession letter was an important

29:16

piece of evidence, but her intention

29:18

was to exonerate Perez and Maraglino.

29:22

Introducing the letter into evidence was risky.

29:25

They needed to establish that the letter

29:27

was evidence of Lopez's guilt, but also

29:29

proved that it wasn't evidence that Perez

29:31

and Maraglino were innocent. Another

29:35

document the detective seized was initially thought to

29:37

be useless, as it was written in some

29:39

sort of code. Using

29:42

a forensic document examiner and the

29:44

FBI cryptoanalysis unit to decipher the

29:46

code, it revealed a detailed

29:48

plan to kidnap, torture and

29:51

murder a friend of Jessica Lopez.

30:00

During jury selection, potential jurors were warned

30:02

of the unspeakable horrors they would

30:04

hear of during testimony. During

30:08

the jury selection process, many potential jurors

30:10

broke down in tears and asked to

30:12

be relieved of duty. The

30:16

murder trial started on September 8, 2015,

30:19

and all three defendants were tried together. The

30:23

prosecution was careful not to take Lopez's

30:25

admission of the murder as absolute truth

30:28

and never indicated who exactly was

30:30

responsible for Brittany's death. Instead,

30:34

they placed equal blame on each

30:36

defendant. Ultimately,

30:38

it was cell phone records that were the key

30:40

piece of evidence against the three of them. Cell

30:44

phone data showed that Brittany did not show

30:47

up at Maraglino's home unannounced, as Lopez claimed.

30:51

The text messages that were sent to

30:53

Brittany's friends that evening were all sent

30:55

from inside Maraglino's house. Video

30:59

evidence from the apartment complex also proved that

31:01

Perez picked her up that evening and she

31:03

never made it out of Fullbrook. She

31:06

was taken straight to their home at 317 East

31:08

Fullbrook Street. During

31:12

the trial, Perez took the stand in

31:14

his own defense. He

31:17

admitted that he tricked Brittany into believing they were

31:19

going on a dinner cruise. He

31:22

also admitted that he took her cell phone

31:24

to downtown San Diego and dumped it. He

31:27

denied, however, the accusation that he'd dumped

31:29

the phone to give Maraglino and Lopez

31:31

more time to clean up the crime

31:33

scene. Each

31:36

defendant eventually turned on the other. Jessica

31:40

Lopez claimed she was just playing the

31:42

role of the obedient slave and her

31:44

only crime was writing the suicide confession

31:46

letter to protect her master and mistress.

31:50

Dorothy Maraglino claimed that because she was

31:52

pregnant, she had put all of her

31:54

BDSM activities on hold. She

31:57

claimed that she only helped cover up the crime

31:59

and that Lopez was the sole killer. Perez

32:03

also blamed Lopez, citing the

32:06

confession letter. He

32:08

argued that he only helped with the cover-up. The

32:12

trial lasted six weeks and the jury

32:14

deliberated for three days. Eventually,

32:17

the jury found Dorothy Maraglino,

32:19

Louis Perez and Jessica Lopez

32:22

each guilty of first-degree murder,

32:24

torture and kidnapping. Perez

32:27

and Maraglino were also found guilty

32:29

of conspiracy to commit kidnapping. The

32:32

death penalty was initially considered but later

32:35

ruled out. All

32:37

three received two life sentences in

32:39

California State Prison without the possibility

32:41

of parole. Dorothy

32:44

Maraglino writes on prisonwriters.com of

32:46

her complaints of the California

32:49

prison system, bemoaning her bunkmates

32:51

body odor, bad food and

32:53

her suicide attempts. Maybe

32:56

she should have thought about what prison might be

32:58

like before she snuffed out the life of an

33:01

innocent girl. Years

33:03

later, the house at 317

33:06

East Fullbrook Street fell into foreclosure. It

33:09

later sold to a couple in their 30s for $212,000 who

33:14

had no idea that there had been a savage murder

33:16

in the house. Unfortunately,

33:18

there was nothing they could do once

33:20

they found out and kept the house

33:23

despite its brutal history. will

33:50

give you the peace of mind you desperately need

33:53

or not.

Unlock more with Podchaser Pro

  • Audience Insights
  • Contact Information
  • Demographics
  • Charts
  • Sponsor History
  • and More!
Pro Features