Episode Transcript
Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.
Use Ctrl + F to search
0:00
When it comes to work, communication
0:02
is key, even if you don't have a writing
0:04
job. Sounding unconfident, indecisive,
0:07
or passive aggressive can hold you back professionally
0:10
and hurt your team's productivity. Grimly
0:12
premiums advanced tone suggestions make
0:14
sure you're always sending the right message,
0:17
sound clear and confident in your writing, and automatically
0:19
replace negative leaning language with solution
0:22
focused alternatives. With Grimly's
0:24
help, you can build stronger relationships
0:26
at work, be constructive in the face
0:28
of challenges, and help your team get
0:30
things done. Grimly works where
0:32
you do so your team's projects get done
0:35
before the deadline, and with features like comprehensive
0:37
spelling grammar and clarity focused
0:39
sentence rewrites, Grammily helps keep your
0:42
writing efficient and mistake free.
0:44
The right tone can move any project forward.
0:47
Get it just right with Grammarly. Go
0:49
to grammy dot com slash podcast
0:51
to sign up for free, then get twenty
0:53
percent off when you upgrade to Premium.
0:55
That's twenty percent off at gramley dot
0:58
com slash Podcast. Welcome
1:10
to Unexplained Extra with me Richard
1:13
McClain smith, where for
1:15
the weeks in between episodes, we look at
1:17
the stories that for one reason or other didn't
1:19
make it into the show. In
1:22
last week's episode, Always Already
1:25
we found ourselves journeying deep into
1:27
the Amazonian rainforest with the Maya
1:29
Runa tribe and acclaimed photojournalist
1:32
Lauren McIntyre. McIntyre
1:35
had traveled into the forest in the hope
1:37
of making contact with the tribe, only
1:39
to find himself hopelessly lost and
1:42
unable to return to his camp. Only
1:45
after an epic three weeks living
1:47
side by side with the Maya Runa,
1:50
during which he believed he might be communicating
1:52
telepathically with their chief, did
1:55
McIntyre finally succeed in
1:57
finding a way out. Sum
2:00
That McIntyre had taken it on himself
2:03
to locate the tribe in the first place might
2:05
smack of a certain kind of arrogance
2:08
that speaks to a bygone age of colonial
2:10
self importance. Certainly,
2:14
McIntyre's ambition to be the first
2:16
to photograph these people took
2:18
precedent over the tribe's evident desire
2:20
to avoid all contact with outsiders,
2:24
Though MacIntyre had never intended to
2:26
intrude in their lives quite to the degree
2:28
in which he claimed to have done. The
2:31
notion of wanting to make contact with such
2:33
a self isolating community remains
2:36
an immensely complicated one for
2:46
the Maya Runa. As it transpired
2:48
when they were first contacted in nineteen
2:51
sixty nine, after living in relative
2:53
isolation since nineteen ten, they
2:56
were grateful for it. The
2:59
word Maya Runa translates
3:01
to people of the river. After
3:04
getting embroiled in skirmishes with the
3:06
Peruvian government, they had been
3:08
forced to leave the riverside lands
3:10
where they thrived and moved deeper
3:12
into the jungle. Through
3:15
a combination of napalm and machine
3:17
guns, the Peruvian government,
3:20
with the support of the US Army's Southern
3:22
Command, had sought to annihilate
3:24
the tribe. When
3:27
they were finally located by Harriet Field
3:29
and Hattie Neeland in August nineteen
3:31
sixty nine, they were tired
3:33
of running. After
3:36
subsequent negotiations were set up
3:38
with the Peruvian government, the tribe
3:41
were able to return to their homeland. Although
3:45
it was contact with outsiders that threatened
3:47
their existence in the first place and
3:50
still does, it is also arguable
3:52
that this later contact is what has
3:54
kept them alive. In
3:57
the main. However, the clash of a
3:59
more dominant in culture against one
4:01
lesso rarely tends to end well.
4:05
Often, even just the language used
4:07
when discussing the idea of it can
4:09
be quite revealing. In
4:11
November twenty seventeen, self
4:14
professed adventurer Benedict Allen
4:17
faced criticism after he allegedly went
4:19
missing in Papa, New Guinea while
4:21
searching for the Yifo tribe. Much
4:25
like the Mayoruna in the nineteen sixties,
4:27
the Yifo also tried to maintain
4:30
little contact with the outside world. Some
4:34
media outlets, however, reveled in
4:36
what they saw to be Allan's plucky, adventurous
4:38
spirit, describing the Jaifo
4:41
as a lost tribe who were little
4:43
more than dangerous headhunters. Such
4:46
communities are also often described
4:49
as having been discovered, as
4:51
if they were rare precious metals with
4:53
no agency of their own. Such
4:57
groups are also often referred to as
5:00
being remote or worse, uncivilized,
5:03
as if there being anywhere other than
5:05
closed to an urban center classifies
5:08
them as being external to civilization,
5:12
and yet remoteness is only
5:14
ever a case of perspective. As
5:18
Lauren McIntyre came to understand
5:21
for the Mayoruna, at least
5:23
in the time he was making contact with them,
5:26
the concept of remoteness would be completely
5:29
incomprehensible if,
5:32
like them, you consider yourself
5:34
to always be a part of nature, as
5:36
opposed to separate from it.
5:39
To ever be remote in the purest sense
5:42
is an impossibility, since
5:44
nature is both everywhere and
5:46
always. For
5:55
self isolating communities and cultures,
5:58
such as the Mayoruna, there is good
6:00
reason to want to avoid contact with outsiders.
6:04
Indeed, history is littered with the blood
6:06
and lost ideas of those people
6:08
whose cultures were deemed inferior
6:10
and weaker than others, and
6:13
the damage can occur in many ways, from
6:16
the contracting of a disease that a community
6:19
had not previously experienced, to
6:21
becoming the victims of deliberate genocide
6:23
campaigns, and there
6:26
are more subtle ways too. The
6:29
extinction of a different culture or community
6:32
when it clashes with another is rare
6:34
in the modern age. However,
6:37
a culture considered less worthy by
6:39
a more dominant one will at
6:41
best run the risk of becoming significantly
6:44
diluted over time, while
6:46
at worst could be systematically
6:49
erased. Though
6:51
it is not strictly in the same sense, and
6:54
I can't claim to have any idea what
6:56
it's like to experience that level of
6:58
erasure. I couldn't
7:00
help but be struck by something related to
7:02
this when trying to write the last episode.
7:06
It occurred whenever I attempted
7:08
to search something online related
7:11
to the natural world. If
7:13
I typed glade, for example, the
7:16
first thing I'd see was not something
7:18
about a majestic forest opening of
7:21
dappled light and fresh dew drops,
7:24
but a domestic cleaning product specifically
7:27
designed to mimic the smell of the outdoors.
7:33
When trying to find anything with the word
7:35
Amazon in it,
7:37
it wasn't information about the largest
7:39
and most biodiverse tract of rainforest
7:42
on the planet that I found first, but
7:45
links related to the world's largest e
7:47
commerce company. And
7:50
when I searched the word jaguar, the
7:52
Mayoruna's own ancient god, it
7:55
wasn't information on the majestic felines
7:58
of the wild that I came across, but
8:01
information about a certain type
8:03
of car. Finding
8:06
this happening again and again, it
8:09
was hard to resist the sensation that
8:11
a different world was being mapped out around
8:13
me and slowly but surely
8:16
laid over the one I thought I knew.
8:21
This experience brought to mind a wonderful
8:23
book called The Lost words
8:26
written by Robert MacFarlane and
8:28
exquisitely illustrated by Jackie
8:30
Morris, inspired in part
8:33
by this very idea of vanishing
8:35
worlds, or rather
8:37
our seemingly blase acceptance
8:39
of it when it occurs,
8:42
even right in front of our eyes.
8:46
At first we lose the word, then
8:48
its meaning, and in some cases,
8:51
finally the very thing itself
8:54
can vanish too. It
8:57
is hard to know exactly what to make of all
8:59
this. Is it something natural
9:02
or something to be resisted, Although
9:05
it feels sad on one level that to think
9:08
one day the word jaguar might
9:10
only bring to mind the model of a car.
9:13
Much more so to think that in forgetting
9:16
its name, we forget to
9:18
care about it, while
9:20
on another level, the animal
9:22
was never ours to name in the first
9:25
place. To
9:27
day, sadly, tribes
9:29
like the Mayoruna are likely
9:31
to only be able to survive in isolation
9:34
for as long as the land they occupy is
9:37
deemed of little value to others.
9:41
This is one of the reasons given for the continued
9:43
survival of a small community of
9:45
people living on North Sentinel
9:47
Island, which forms part of
9:49
the Andaman Islands that lie between
9:51
the Bay of Bengal and the Andaman Sea.
9:55
Though it isn't known how the tribe refers to
9:57
itself, outsiders have labeled
9:59
the group the Sentinels in
10:04
order to protect them from the corrupting influence
10:06
of outsiders. Their island
10:08
homeland, which falls under the jurisdiction
10:11
of the Indian government, has been
10:13
declared an island reserve. All
10:16
travel is prohibited within a three mile
10:18
radius, while the area is
10:20
also patrolled twenty four hours a
10:22
day, and this patrol is
10:25
not only for the tribe's protection. Like
10:29
many self isolating tribes, the
10:31
Sentinels are fiercely and unequivocally
10:35
protective of their territory. In
10:38
November twenty eighteen, despite
10:41
knowing this, twenty six year
10:43
old missionary John Alan Chow
10:46
traveled to the island intent on
10:48
converting the people to the Gospel of Jesus
10:50
Christ. There
10:53
was only one way it was going
10:55
to end. Are
10:58
you always taking care of your family?
11:01
Do you often take care of others and not yourself?
11:04
Now it's time to take care of yourself. To
11:06
make time for you you deserve
11:08
it. TELEDOC gives you access
11:10
to a licensed therapist to help you
11:12
get back to feeling your best, to feeling
11:15
like yourself again. With teledoc,
11:18
you can speak to a licensed therapist by
11:20
phone or video. Therapy appointments
11:22
are available seven days a week from
11:24
seven am to nine pm local time.
11:27
If you feel overwhelmed sometimes
11:29
maybe you feel stressed or anxious,
11:32
depressed or lonely, or you might
11:34
be struggling with a personal or family issue,
11:36
teledoc can help. Teledoc
11:39
is committed to facilitating great therapeutic
11:41
matches, so they make it easy to change
11:44
counselors if needed. For free. Teledoc
11:47
therapy is available through most insurance
11:49
or employers. Download the
11:51
app or visit teledoc dot com
11:53
forward slash Unexplained podcast today
11:56
to get started. That's t e
11:58
LA d C dot com
12:01
slash Unexplained podcast. Very
12:09
little is known about the Sentinels,
12:12
with some estimates suggesting their specific
12:14
ancestry could date back anywhere
12:17
between thirty to sixty thousand years.
12:21
Current population estimates have been
12:23
anything from forty to four hundred.
12:26
In twelve to ninety six, explorer
12:29
Marco Polo saw fit to describe
12:31
the general population of the Andaman Islands
12:34
as a most brutish and savage race,
12:37
having heads, eyes, and teeth like
12:39
those of dogs. They
12:41
are very cruel and kill and eat
12:44
every foreigner whom they can lay their hands
12:46
upon, he wrote. However,
12:49
in what is often par for the course when
12:52
describing others, it is
12:54
thought that Polo never saw or
12:56
interacted with these people himself, and
12:59
merely based the estment on rumor
13:01
alone. For
13:04
many years, the Andaman Islands were largely
13:06
ignored by others until the
13:08
eighteen fifties, when they fell under the
13:10
colonial rule of the British Empire and
13:13
were used in part as a penal colony.
13:18
When the first British Superintendent was
13:20
dispatched to the Andamans in eighteen fifty
13:22
eight, he instructed
13:24
that the indigenous population be
13:27
treated with the greatest forbearance
13:29
and humanity by the British, insisting
13:32
that their intentions towards the people of the
13:34
islands were of the most friendly
13:36
character. Unfortunately,
13:40
this message didn't get across
13:42
since, unsurprisingly, when the British attempted
13:45
to take ownership of the islands, they
13:47
met with some fierce resistance. However,
13:51
this was soon quelled when after
13:53
one skirmish in which fifteen hundred
13:55
Islanders attempted to scare off
13:58
their foe, they were massacre by
14:00
the guns of a British warship. Prior
14:04
to the arrival of the British, the Andaman
14:07
Islands indigenous population was
14:09
thought to be around five thousand. By
14:12
the time they relinquished control ninety
14:15
years later, it was estimated
14:17
to have dropped to round four hundred
14:19
and sixty. As
14:22
Adam Goodheart wrote in the American Scholar
14:25
magazine in two thousand, the
14:27
history of the period can be summarized
14:29
as a series of epidemics. As
14:32
the local population were one by
14:34
one introduced to pneumonia,
14:37
syphilis, ophthalmia,
14:40
measles, mumps, Russian
14:42
influenza, and gonorrhea. We
14:46
can only speculate as to how sexually
14:48
transmitted diseases made their way
14:51
into the population. As
14:54
for the Sentinels specifically, though
14:56
there had been rumors of a tribe of people living
14:59
on North Sentinel Island, due
15:01
to its relevant size and inconvenient
15:03
location, it had been deemed
15:06
unimportant. Then
15:08
in eighteen seventy nine, one
15:11
young colonialist, recently appointed
15:13
to the position of Officer in charge
15:15
of the Andamanese decided
15:18
to take a closer look. Nineteen
15:22
year old Maurice Vidal Portman,
15:24
the grandson of a viscount, set
15:27
off for the island shortly after his appointment
15:30
with a team of armed escorts and trackers
15:32
from other Andaman tribes. When
15:36
they arrived, however, they found
15:38
the place completely deserted, save
15:40
for a few tracks and a series of small
15:42
villages that appeared to have been recently
15:45
abandoned. Having
15:47
given up on their search, they chanced
15:50
upon an elderly couple and four children
15:53
walking back to their village. Portman
15:56
had them abducted on the spot and
15:58
taken back to his home in Port Blair,
16:01
the Andaman Islands capital town, to
16:04
observe their behavior. Almost
16:08
immediately, the islanders grew sick,
16:11
and within weeks the elderly
16:13
couple died, and
16:16
so it was that Portman's amateur
16:18
anthropological ambitions came
16:21
to a swift end. Children
16:24
were returned to the island soon after. After
16:29
this brief encounter, the Sentinel
16:31
Leaves had virtually no contact with outsiders
16:34
until nineteen ninety one, when
16:36
Indian government anthropologists finally
16:39
succeeded in completing a non fatal
16:41
engagement with them.
16:44
After years of trying to establish a relationship.
16:46
Their attempts were effectively abandoned in
16:49
two thousand and three, when it was
16:51
decided instead to enact a
16:53
policy of no contact with the group. In
16:57
two thousand and six, two Indian
17:00
fishermen drifted too close to North
17:02
Sentinel, Ireland and were promptly
17:04
captured and killed by the Sentinel
17:06
Leagues. Twelve
17:08
years later, missionary John Alan
17:11
Chow arrived to make his own
17:13
attempt at contact. Chow,
17:22
a missionary for the Missouri based organization
17:25
All Nations in the United States,
17:28
did not make his trip lightly. In
17:31
fact, he had been training for it for three years,
17:34
attending a missionary boot camp which
17:36
included undertaking role play exercises
17:39
of how to deal with hostile potential
17:41
converts. Chow
17:44
was enthralled to the Great Commission Jesus's
17:47
supposed injunction that Christians
17:49
must spread the Gospel to all people. Being
17:53
such a committed follower of this doctrine,
17:56
Chow became fascinated by the idea
17:58
of helping to convert the to the Lees,
18:01
whom he described as possibly representing
18:03
Satan's last stronghold on earth.
18:07
Having made his way to the Andamans
18:10
on November fourteenth, two and eighteen,
18:13
he took the next step and succeeded
18:15
in paying some local fishermen to sneak
18:18
him past the patrol boats and drop
18:20
anchor close enough for him to kayak
18:22
to the island. The
18:25
next morning, he assembled his
18:27
initial contact response kit, which
18:30
included picture cards for communicating
18:33
and dental forceps in
18:35
case he might have to remove any arrows,
18:38
the sentinels weapon of choice,
18:40
as well as some gifts which he hoped
18:42
to share with the islanders. Then,
18:46
after stripping to his underwear to appear
18:48
less threatening, he got into
18:50
his kayak and paddled toward the
18:52
shore. As
18:55
he drew closer, he was able to
18:57
make out a small hut and some wooden
18:59
canoes pulled up on to the beach.
19:03
Suddenly, a series of high pitched
19:05
voices rang out, followed
19:07
by the appearance of a handful of islanders
19:10
with faces painted yellow, rushing
19:13
down to the water line.
19:16
My name is John, shouted the missionary
19:19
from his kayak. I
19:21
love you and Jesus loves you. It
19:25
was only then that John noticed the bow
19:27
and arrows in their hands, watching
19:31
aghast as one of the group raised
19:33
one up and took aim.
19:36
John hurriedly flung them some fish
19:39
as a gift, and then paddled away
19:41
as fast as he could. Later
19:45
that day, he made a second attempt,
19:47
and this time succeeded in landing on
19:49
the island before being spotted.
19:53
Cautiously, he approached the hut
19:55
on foot, this time being careful
19:57
not to get within shooting range. Calling
20:01
out to them again. The islanders
20:04
suddenly emerged, whooping and shouting
20:06
for him to back off. Ignoring
20:09
them, John drew closer as
20:11
he attempted to parrot their words back
20:13
to them. When they laughed
20:16
scornfully in response, John
20:18
assumed the words were insults and
20:20
they were laughing at his ignorance. Undeterred,
20:26
John reverted to singing songs of worship,
20:28
and after a while the islanders appeared
20:31
to grow used to his presence. In
20:34
response, John's voice grew
20:37
in confidence. He
20:39
held up his Bible and began to
20:41
preach the gospel. Just
20:45
then he felt something
20:47
hit hard against the good book, turning
20:51
it round. He looked on in horror at
20:53
the sight of an arrow now sticking
20:55
out of it. Holding
20:59
his nerves as best he could, John
21:02
slowly pulled it out and then
21:04
offered it back to the boy who had fired it,
21:07
and made his retreat. When
21:10
he turned back, however, his kayak
21:12
had gone. With
21:15
no other option, John dived
21:17
straight into the ocean and swam
21:19
back to the fishing boat. That
21:24
night, John wrote in his diary
21:26
about how scared he was, fearful
21:29
that the beautiful sunset that was
21:31
occurring before him, as he wrote, might
21:34
be the last he ever saw. In
21:38
his final entry, he asked
21:40
God to forgive any of the people on the island
21:42
who might try to kill him,
21:45
especially if they succeeded. Shortly
21:49
after first light the following day, he
21:52
took another kayak back to the island. Later
21:56
that morning, as the fisherman waited
21:58
for John to return, they saw
22:00
movement on the beach. It
22:03
appeared the tribes people were burying
22:05
something in the sand. John
22:09
allan Chow was never seen
22:11
alive again. If
22:19
you enjoy listening to Unexplained and would
22:21
like to help support us, you can now go
22:24
to Unexplained podcast dot com forward
22:26
slash support. All
22:28
donations, no matter how large or small,
22:31
are massively appreciated. All
22:34
elements of Unexplained are produced by
22:37
me, Richard mc lane Smith. Please
22:39
subscribe and rate the show on iTunes,
22:42
and feel free to get in touch with any thoughts
22:44
or ideas regarding the stories you've heard
22:46
on the show. Perhaps you
22:48
have an explanation of your own you'd like to share.
22:52
You can reach us online at Unexplained
22:54
podcast dot com, or Twitter
22:57
at Unexplained Pod and
22:59
Facebook at Facebook dot com.
23:01
Forward slash Unexplained Now.
23:12
It's time to take care of yourself. To
23:14
make time for you. Teledoc
23:17
gives you access to a licensed therapist
23:19
to help you get back to feeling your best.
23:22
Speak to a licensed therapist by
23:24
phone or video anytime between
23:26
seven am to nine pm local time,
23:29
seven days a week. Teledoc
23:31
Therapy is available through most insurance
23:34
or employers. Download the app
23:36
or visit teledoc dot com, Forward
23:38
slash Unexplained Podcast Today
23:40
to get started. That's t e
23:43
ladoc dot com
23:45
Slash Unexplained Podcast. When
23:50
it comes to work, communication is
23:52
key, even if you don't have a writing job.
23:55
Sounding unconfident, indecisive, or
23:57
passive aggressive can hold you back professionally
24:00
and hurt your team's productivity. Grammily
24:02
premiums advanced tone suggestions make
24:04
sure you're always sending the right message,
24:07
sound clear and confident in your writing, and automatically
24:09
replace negative leaning language with solution
24:12
focused alternatives. With Grimley's
24:14
help, you can build stronger relationships
24:16
at work, be constructive in the face of
24:18
challenges and help your team get
24:20
things done. Grimly works where
24:23
you do so your team's projects get done
24:25
before the deadline and with features like comprehensive
24:27
spelling, grammar and clarity focused
24:29
sentence rewrites. Grammily helps keep your
24:32
writing efficient and mistake free.
24:34
The right tone can move any project forward.
24:37
Get it just right with Grammarly. Go
24:39
to grammy dot com slash podcast
24:41
to sign up for free, then get twenty
24:43
percent off when you upgrade to Premium.
24:45
That's twenty percent off at gramley
24:48
dot com slash Podcast. When
24:50
it comes to work, communication is
24:52
key, even if you don't have a writing job.
24:55
Sounding unconfident, indecisive, or
24:57
passive aggressive can hold you back professionally
25:00
and hurt your team's productivity. Grammily
25:02
premiums advanced tone suggestions make
25:04
sure you're always sending the right message,
25:07
sound clear and confident in your writing, and automatically
25:10
replace negative leaning language with solution
25:12
focused alternatives. With Grimley's
25:14
help, you can build stronger relationships
25:16
at work, be constructive in the face of
25:18
challenges, and help your team get
25:21
things done. Grimly works where
25:23
you do so your team's projects get done
25:25
before the deadline and with features like comprehensive
25:27
spelling grammar and clarity focused
25:30
sentence rewrites. Grammily helps keep your
25:32
writing efficient and mistake free.
25:34
The right tone can move any project forward.
25:37
Get it just right with Grammarly. Go
25:39
to grammy dot com slash podcast
25:41
to sign up for free, then get twenty
25:43
percent off when you upgrade to premium.
25:46
That's twenty percent off at gramley
25:48
dot com slash Podcast
Podchaser is the ultimate destination for podcast data, search, and discovery. Learn More