Episode Transcript
Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.
Use Ctrl + F to search
0:05
Hello from Wonder Media Network. I'm
0:07
Jenny Kaplan and this is Wamanica.
0:11
Historically, women have been told to make themselves smaller,
0:13
to diminish themselves. Some of
0:15
used that to their advantage, disappearing into
0:18
new identities. For others,
0:20
a disappearance was the end to their stories, but
0:22
the beginning of a new chapter in their legacies.
0:25
This month, we're talking about disappearing acts.
0:28
Today we're talking about a writer whose legal
0:30
woes kreemed her career and life off
0:32
the map and out of the public eye. Let's
0:35
talk about Ida hillis Attis. Ida
0:41
was born in Kansas around eighteen fifty seven.
0:44
After the American Civil War began, her
0:47
family moved to Mexico. Her
0:49
father was a photographer. His
0:51
work took him all over the country. Ida
0:54
often accompanied him on these
0:56
trips. She got to see Mexico through a different lens,
0:59
a lens that uplifted the country's indigenous
1:01
cultures, history, and the oral
1:03
tales one generation passed down to the next.
1:07
When she was fifteen years old, Ida's family
1:09
moved to Los Angeles. Ida
1:12
graduated high school there and got a job teaching.
1:17
In her spare time, she wrote fictional prose
1:19
for a San Francisco paper called The Argonaut.
1:22
Because of her upbringing in Mexico, Ida
1:25
was fluent in Spanish, so she also
1:27
wrote and contributed to Mexican newspapers
1:29
and periodicals. She was
1:31
possibly the first American writer to translate
1:34
Mexican legends into English.
1:36
Her work told tales of the supernatural
1:39
and centered women protagonists adventuring
1:41
through love and romance. She
1:43
wrote about life in California and in Mexico.
1:47
Her story depicted cross cultural understanding
1:50
and introduced US audiences to the traditions
1:52
and history of Mexico.
1:55
Ida's work gained momentum, and soon she was
1:57
writing for publications like Harper's Monthly,
2:00
The Los Angeles Times, and the Chicago Times.
2:05
Her wit and charm translated off the page
2:08
into real life. With her success
2:10
came the attention of many men.
2:13
In eighteen eighty seven, Ida accepted a
2:15
marriage proposal from former California
2:17
Governor John G. Downey, but
2:19
they never made it to the altar. His
2:21
family disproved of the relationship, and
2:24
the governor called it off. I'da
2:26
sued him for half a million dollars for breach
2:28
of promise, and so
2:30
began Ida's life in court. To
2:35
take the heat off of her After going to court,
2:38
Ida went back to Mexico, but
2:40
trouble managed to find its way below the border.
2:43
While there, the wife of Ida's editor
2:45
accused Ida of stealing her husband. Ida
2:48
was named as a co defendant in the wife's lawsuit
2:51
against her husband. With
2:53
two scandals to her name, Ida
2:55
tried her luck again in California. She
2:58
was working on her book, A History of sis southern
3:00
California Counties. Her
3:02
research led her straight into the arms of attorney
3:04
Charles Stork. The couple
3:07
married on September tenth, eighteen ninety.
3:09
Ida finished writing her book and retired
3:11
to take care of her new husband's teenage son.
3:14
So when Charles cashed the four hundred dollars check
3:17
from Ida's book deal and didn't give her a dime,
3:19
Ida was particularly hurt.
3:22
She left him and told her story to an La
3:24
Times reporter. According
3:27
to Ida, her husband began abusing
3:29
her three weeks after the marriage. The
3:32
story prompted an angry letter from Charles
3:34
back to the La Times. He
3:36
tried to discredit Ida, saying
3:38
she tried to take her own life, took
3:41
extreme dislike to his son, and threatened Charles's
3:43
life twice. It
3:45
was an arduous process. The
3:48
case moved up through court after court
3:50
for years until the divorce was officially
3:52
granted in eighteen ninety five. Charles
3:55
was ordered to pay alimony and Ida's
3:57
attorney fees. Unfortunately,
4:00
the nightmare didn't even end there. Charles
4:03
continued to appeal. It
4:05
wasn't until eighteen ninety seven that the California
4:07
Supreme Court forced Charles to pay
4:10
up. During this debacle,
4:12
Ida moved to San Francisco and resumed
4:14
writing stories. Her writing
4:17
was sharper than ever. Her
4:19
stories always had themes of feminism, but
4:21
now they were stronger and more focused.
4:25
In eighteen ninety eight, the Santa Barbara News
4:28
Press, the paper Charles published, and
4:30
a few local officials, received anonymous letters.
4:34
These letters accused one doctor Winchester,
4:36
of engaging in a moral and scandalous
4:39
conduct. The
4:41
doctor in question had testified against
4:44
Ida in her divorce case, and
4:46
the handwriting on the letters looked just like
4:48
Ida's. All
4:50
signs pointed to Ida.
4:53
Ida denied her involvement and insisted
4:55
she was set up by her ex husband's employee,
4:58
a man named Teddy Grant Jackson. But
5:01
despite her protests, Ida was charged
5:04
with criminal libel. While
5:06
awaiting her sentence, Ida took matters
5:08
into her own hands. She broke
5:10
into Jackson's home. She
5:13
said all she did was beg him to confess
5:15
to framing her. He said
5:17
she tried to kill him with chloroform while he was
5:19
sleeping. Either way,
5:21
Ida was thrown in jail for eight months with an
5:23
attempted murder charge hanging over her head.
5:26
The case was eventually dismissed, and
5:28
months later she won an appeal on her libel
5:31
case too.
5:35
After she was released, Ida disappeared from
5:37
California and the public eye completely. Her
5:41
name ceased to appear in newspapers and public
5:43
records. Some stories
5:45
say that after years of legal battles persecuting
5:48
her on the grounds of insanity, she
5:50
did check herself into a mental institution. According
5:53
to another story, her only planned
5:56
post incarceration was to leave Santa Barbara
5:58
for good and go somewhere she wouldn't be persecuted.
6:02
The truth about her post incarceration life
6:04
largely remains unknown. What
6:07
we know for sure is that in her
6:09
disappearance, she left an impressive body
6:11
of written work and a whirlwind of
6:13
tabloid stories in her wake. All
6:17
month we're talking about disappearing acts. For
6:19
more information, find us on Facebook and Instagram
6:21
at Wamanica Podcast special
6:24
thanks to Liz Kaplan, my favorite sister and co creator.
6:27
Talk to you tomorrow
Podchaser is the ultimate destination for podcast data, search, and discovery. Learn More