In this episode, Erinn, Ethan, and Scott discuss the nature and origin of some of the conspiracy theories in the case. They highlight what is perhaps the most prominent (and enduring) conspiracy theory, which is that local law enforcement in Ne

21: Why Maura Went to New Hampshire: New Info and a New Theory

Dec 31st, 2019 49m 57s

In this episode, Erinn, Ethan, and Scott review the prominent theories surrounding the question of why Maura Murray left Amherst, MA and drove to New Hampshire on February 9, 2004. They present new information regarding a speeding ticket Maura

20: "True Crime Terrorism" and the Problem with "White Noise"

Nov 3rd, 2019 55m 39s

In this episode, Erinn and Scott address the “white noise” and miscellaneous drama that has distracted attention away from finding Maura.

19: The Black Box (Part 2)

Oct 5th, 2019 48m 47s

In this episode, Erinn, Ethan, and Scott discuss the second half of the forensic report of the 1996 Saturn that Maura drove from Massachusetts to New Hampshire the day she disappeared. The analysis was conducted in May of 2010. The topics di

Bonus Episode: "Witness C" and Damage to the Saturn

Jun 22nd, 2019 27m

This is a segment of audio with Erinn, Ethan, and Scott that was recorded in late March of 2019 and includes information about a third witness (“Witness C”), as well as well as a discussion about what may have caused the damage to the Saturn.h

18: The Black Box (Part 1)

May 26th, 2019 40m 34s

In this episode, Erinn and Scott discuss the black box data and corresponding forensic report of the 1996 Saturn that Maura had driven from Massachusetts to New Hampshire the day she disappeared. The analysis was conducted in May of 2010.The

Announcement: CrimeCon 2019

May 22nd, 2019 3m 36s

This is a brief message from Erinn, Scott Wahl, and Julie Murray to announce that they will be attending CrimeCon 2019, which is taking place June 7-9 in New Orleans, LA. For tickets, visit https://www.crimecon.com/home.

17: Julie, Kurtis, and Sara & Reaction to Latest Search

Apr 16th, 2019 42m 26s

In this episode, Erinn and Scott talk to Maura’s sister Julie, her brother Kurtis, and Kurtis’s girlfriend Sara. They discuss the excavation of basement near Maura’s crash site in Haverhill, NH, conducted by the FBI and New Hampshire State Poli

16: "Witness B" and a New Lead in the Case

Feb 15th, 2019 39m 44s

In this episode, Ethan and Erinn discuss “Witness B,” and what she saw when she drove by the scene of Maura’s accident the night she disappeared.They also discuss the Bear Brook podcast, as well as the new lead in the case, and how law enforc

15: Lies, Damn Lies, and Statistics

Dec 24th, 2018 41m 21s

In this this episode, Erinn and Ethan look at the nature and origin of several of the rumors and misconceptions that have persisted in the case, including the supposed “affair” with the UMass Men’s track coach. They also look at data from the B

14: The First Officer on Scene

Aug 23rd, 2018 53m 33s

In the first half the episode, Erinn and Ethan discuss some of the information learned from the recent Q&A with Guy Paradee. In the second half of the episode, they discuss the interview that Cecil Smith did for the Oxygen show. The transcript

13: Q&A with Guy Paradee - Part 2

Jul 30th, 2018 51m 51s

In this episode, Erinn plays Part 2 of a Q&A session with former law enforcement officer and private investigator, Guy Paradee. He continues answering questions that were proposed by members of the “The Disappearance of Maura Murray Discussion

12: Q&A with Guy Paradee - Part 1

Jul 14th, 2018 51m 48s

In this episode, Erinn plays Part 1 of a Q&A session with former law enforcement officer and private investigator, Guy Paradee. As a member of the New Hampshire League of Investigators (led by John Healy), Guy began looking into the case shortl

11: The 911 Call Transcripts

Jun 18th, 2018 54m 20s

In this episode, Erinn and Ethan review Faith Westman and Butch Atwood’s 911 call transcripts that were released as a result of a public “Right-to-Know” request filed earlier this year. They discuss Maura’s UMass dorm photos that were displayed

10: The Timeline

May 19th, 2018 50m 9s

In this episode, Erinn and Ethan discuss the timeline and respond to some of the arguments heard on Episode 75 of the Missing Maura Murray podcast (made by Maggie and Art of “The Disappearance of Maura Murray” on the Oxygen Network). They discu

9: A Prosecutor’s Perspective [Part 2]

Apr 16th, 2018 47m 2s

In this episode, Erinn and Ethan continue their interview of Katharine, a prosecutor and Assistant Attorney General in the state of Missouri. The second half touches on several of the topics brought up in the Oxygen series ("The Disappearance o

8: A Prosecutor’s Perspective [Part 1]

Apr 3rd, 2018 55m 8s

In this episode, Erinn and Ethan speak to Katharine Dolin, a prosecutor and Assistant Attorney General in the state of Missouri. This is the first of a multi-parter, and in this episode, some of the topics we discuss include the suspects implie

7: Conversation with Fred Murray - Part 2

Mar 5th, 2018 42m 29s

In this episode, Erinn plays an audio recording of the second half of her interview with Maura’s father, Fred Murray. Some of the topics that are discussed in Part 2 include the red truck, the police interviews that took place on the Oxygen ser

6: Conversation with Fred Murray - Part 1

Dec 22nd, 2017 45m 44s

In this episode, Erinn plays an audio recording of the first part of her interview with Maura’s father, Fred Murray. Part 1 touches on a variety of topics that were covered in the Oxygen series, “The Disappearance of Maura Murray.” Mr. Murray’s

5: The Missing Hour. The $4000. Witness Statements: A Review of E3 of Oxygen's “The Disappearance of Maura Murray”

Nov 15th, 2017 39m 5s

In this episode, Erinn and Ethan go over some of the topics covered in Episode 3 of the Oxygen series, “The Disappearance of Maura Murray.” First, they talk about the show’s theory for what Maura could have been doing during the “missing hour”

4: E4 Addendum: Words Matter

Nov 7th, 2017 13m 9s

This is a short addendum to the fourth episode and it addresses two points. The first pertains to the response I received from the NH State Police regarding James Renner’s claim that “the police think she was pregnant” on Episode 2 of "The Dis

4: Out with the Old [Rumors]: Reviewing New Information from E2 of Oxygen's “The Disappearance of Maura Murray”

Oct 13th, 2017 58m 39s

Erinn and Ethan discuss Episode 2 of the Oxygen series, “The Disappearance of Maura Murray.” Topics include the interview with Erin, a fellow nursing student that Maura had borrowed scrubs from before she disappeared; evidence that Maura was pr

3: Frederick J. Murray v. Special Investigation Unit of the Division of State Police et al.

Sep 23rd, 2017 55m 54s

This episode discusses the civil suit that Fred Murray filed against the “state” of NH after the police refused to release any of the documents they had in their possession pertaining to Maura’s disappearance. Erinn and Ethan are joined by an a

2: The Alcohol. The Timeline. Bruce McKay

Sep 11th, 2017 48m 29s

Ethan and I discuss the conflicting statements by the Haverhill Police Department and the NH State Police regarding what alcohol was recovered from Maura's car. I offer my theory for why there could be conflicting accounts. We also discuss the