Episode Transcript
Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.
Use Ctrl + F to search
0:00
Wonder. A plus subscribers can binge new
0:02
seasons of Business Wars ad free
0:04
right now. Join Wonder He placed
0:06
in the Wonder He app or
0:08
on Apple podcasts. Twenty
0:21
fourteen Taylor Swift strides into a
0:23
boardroom of the Big Machine offices
0:25
in Nashville. The head of a
0:28
record label, Scott or Shadow sits
0:30
at a large meeting table with
0:32
other executives. They're here to discuss
0:34
the strategy for Swift's fifth album,
0:36
which she's just finished recording. but
0:39
More Shudder has some notes. Taylor,
0:42
thanks for flying in. Swift nods
0:44
graciously. She recently moved from Nashville
0:46
to New York City full time.
0:49
Bullshit. It continues. So.
0:51
He turned in some really great songs
0:54
I mean bravo, but I couldn't help
0:56
but feel something was missing. Swift.
0:59
Listens expectantly. Okay,
1:02
what are you thinking? What?
1:04
We really need is some country. Can you
1:06
give us three songs that can play on
1:08
country radio Dj? Love you but they're not
1:11
going to play this pop stuff. But.
1:13
Swift is not interested in that
1:16
she's done with country music. Listen.
1:19
Scott I read or of you have read
1:21
that really stuck in my mind. Read.
1:23
With Swift's last album. It
1:26
was a pop country hit that
1:28
immediately sold four million copies. But.
1:30
Even with that success. Swift.
1:33
Obsessive li tracks the criticism
1:35
she received. Their of
1:37
you Said read wasn't cohesive on this
1:39
album. I want them to sound like they
1:41
all belong together. A son will stick
1:43
out like a sore thumb. Or
1:46
shudder and the other executives exchange
1:48
looks. Swift is not backing
1:51
down. She's. Twenty five,
1:53
Now not the teenager she was when
1:55
she first sign. Morshed.
1:57
A tries another tack. Well.
1:59
okay Why don't we country
2:01
up what you've already got? Let's
2:03
add a fiddle and steal guitar solo on
2:05
Shake It Off. That'll work for
2:08
country radio. Right, guys? Uh-huh. You
2:10
bet. The room of execs nod in
2:12
agreement. They turn to Swift. She
2:15
shakes her head. Scott, you know
2:17
that's not going to match the production on the
2:19
rest of the album. Forshetta
2:21
starts to red-en with frustration. Listen,
2:24
if you want to do a bit of
2:26
pop, that's fine, but let's be smart and
2:29
capitalize on both markets. Swift
2:31
leans forward. I'm pouring my
2:33
heart into these songs, and I love these
2:35
songs. So if they're pop, they're pop.
2:38
I can't just shoehorn a country song in there.
2:40
It'd be so disingenuous. But
2:42
of course you don't get that, because you're not
2:44
an artist. Forshetta can
2:46
no longer bend her to his will, but
2:49
Swift makes him millions playing to a
2:51
country audience. He worries
2:53
she'll alienate those fans by going
2:56
full pop. He's got
2:58
to find a way to swear. You've
3:00
got an established, astronomically successful career
3:03
in country music. To shake that
3:05
up would be the biggest mistake
3:07
you ever make. Swift
3:09
is not having it. Exactly, Scott.
3:12
I've got an astronomically successful career in
3:14
country music, and I'm going to make
3:16
this decision. Not you! We're
3:19
done here. But
3:21
they're far from done. This
3:25
is just the opening salvo in the
3:27
savage battle to come. One
3:29
that will be fought in boardrooms, on
3:31
her music videos, on social media,
3:34
and on stage. This
3:37
fight will nearly destroy
3:39
Swift until she
3:41
deploys her most powerful weapon, her
3:44
rabid fans, and
3:46
acid-dipped lyrics. If
3:53
you're losing steam and working towards that.
3:55
New Year's resolution, well, I have just
3:57
the thing. Audible. No Matter what your
3:59
goals are, get re-inspired. with audible rich
4:01
variety of wellness content and categories like
4:03
physical, mental, spiritual, motivational, occupational and financial
4:05
wellness, I've got Audible app on my
4:07
phone and waiting in line for school
4:09
pick up. I had a book to
4:12
my list that everyone's been talking about.
4:14
It's called Atomic Habits by James Clear.
4:16
These are easy and practical steps we
4:18
can all take to overcome moods and
4:20
emotional distraction. And as an Audible member,
4:22
well, you get to keep one title
4:24
a month from their entire catalogue including
4:26
best sellers, a new releases new members
4:29
can try Audible right? Now for thirty
4:31
days, head on over to audible.com/b
4:33
W or text be doubled you
4:35
to five hundred Five hundred That
4:38
audible.com/b W or Text B w
4:40
Two five hundred Five hundred to
4:42
try Audible Free for thirty days.
4:45
Applecart is the credit card created by
4:47
Apple. You. Earn three percent daily cash
4:50
back when you use it to by the
4:52
new Apple Vision Pro or any products at
4:54
Apple. And you could automatically grow
4:56
your daily cash had four point five, zero
4:58
percent annual percentage shield. Would you open a
5:00
high yield savings account? Apply. For
5:02
Applecart in the wallet app on I phone.
5:05
Applecart subject to credit approval Savings
5:08
available to Applecart owners subject Eligibility:
5:10
Applecart in Savings by Goldman Sachs
5:12
Bank Usa Salt Lake City Branch
5:14
member Ft I see terms apply.
5:20
From wondering, I'm David Brown and this
5:22
is business. In
5:49
the last episode, Taylor Swift signed
5:51
on to Scott Moore said his
5:53
label and quickly rose to startle
5:55
Scooter Braun. Discovered Justin Bieber who
5:58
went on tour with Swift's. But
6:00
as Swift started pivoting to pop
6:02
her relationship with more shudder began
6:05
to sour. In this episode Swift
6:07
make so bold move that bullshit
6:09
as sees as a threat to
6:12
his business so he teams up
6:14
with brought to protect his and
6:16
best. This
6:19
is episode. Fab
6:22
Live. In
6:32
westerly Rhode Island. Swift
6:35
stretches out on a son lousy
6:37
or by the pool. She's wearing
6:40
a floppy hat and dark sunglasses.
6:42
nearby actor Emma Stone. We apply
6:44
sunscreen while her boyfriend doctor Andrew
6:47
Garfield sips a cold beverage. Tv
6:49
star Lena Dunham floats languidly on
6:52
an inflatable bad is it a
6:54
list gathering of actors or models?
6:58
Sweatshops, Our. Ideals.
7:03
Are a few jump at the suggested
7:05
they run into switch giant kitchen and
7:07
just to work. With
7:10
Baftas a bedroom vacation home last
7:12
year for seventeen million dollars. I
7:16
got it. It's
7:18
not Swift's only property. Earlier in
7:21
the year, she bought Peter Jackson's
7:23
former Try Back a penthouse for
7:25
nineteen million dollars. She spent two
7:28
million dollars on a Nashville apartments.
7:30
Most is rarely they're. All
7:33
right, there's this said. or
7:35
ah, I'm years and measuring
7:37
flowers. It's
7:39
no accident that her home is
7:42
swarming with female celebrities. After getting
7:44
flack on social media for being
7:46
boy assist with guys like John
7:48
Mayer and Jake Gyllenhaal, she cultivated
7:50
a group of female friends the
7:52
frescoes with her pearls. These
7:55
days, Swift is less likely to be photographed
7:57
with a new boyfriend then she is. The
8:00
money for like much rather they
8:02
could see with musicians like hi
8:04
I'm and Floors she's embrace them
8:06
as best friends and pictures of
8:08
her with them probably make her
8:11
more likable to were mostly see
8:13
mail fan base. Mix
8:15
it up. All
8:20
right is ready to go now than
8:22
the women high five. For.
8:26
Swiss the weekend is a much needed break
8:28
from working on or album in fighting with
8:30
her label. Swift once
8:32
the record to be called Nineteen
8:34
Eighty Nine the year she was
8:36
born and she wants the cover
8:38
of the album to be a
8:41
faded Polaroid of herself and her
8:43
shirt featuring flying sea gulls. The
8:45
picture cuts off her face just
8:47
below the eyes for initials T
8:49
S and Nineteen Eighty Nine or
8:51
the bottom. She wants to ditch
8:54
the typical country cover she's going
8:56
for edge and unpredictable for most
8:58
female celebrities, their faces a saleable
9:00
asset. But with his
9:02
album cover, Swift wants to prove
9:04
that she's so well known that
9:06
fans will recognize or from just
9:09
one blurry body parts for read
9:11
lists. Shudder, Sexist
9:13
Crypt and once or to name
9:15
the album after one of the
9:17
song titles typical of country music
9:19
Alex he wants her to show
9:22
or full face that Days sells
9:24
out. But
9:26
this is more than a debate out.
9:29
She's making a statement about says
9:31
she wants to least and what
9:34
she wants to put see may
9:36
not realize is that she's about
9:38
to touch the third rail of
9:40
the music business. Streaming.
9:48
November Twenty Four Teas Charlottesville, Virginia
9:50
A teenage girl sits in her
9:52
bedroom talking to her friends and
9:54
snap for Mac. Book is open
9:56
on are bad Blasting one of
9:58
the Taylor Swift's old albums. Spotify.
10:00
She saw Swift in concert
10:02
last year as The Commission's
10:05
fast. All the
10:07
sudden. The. Music Cuts: What's.
10:11
The spot a five shows an error
10:13
message. That's
10:15
weird. She navigates to
10:18
Swift's artist page. Is
10:23
blank. There's nothing there. Not a
10:25
single Taylor Swift album is on
10:27
spotify. she keeps clicking. This must
10:29
be some sort of mistake for
10:32
she supposed to listen to Swift
10:34
Sauce. She
10:36
quickly goes to our immediately
10:38
stocks. A mess with. The
10:41
responses or if it's not just
10:44
her, it looks like Swift is
10:46
removed all her music from spotify.
10:50
Smithy closes or laptop stiver hurt
10:52
ago the Target and by the
10:54
new Swift Cd. Swift's
10:57
decision to pull her catalog from
11:00
Spotify isn't a surprise. Few months
11:02
ago, Swift wrote an op ed
11:04
in the Wall Street Journal where
11:07
she denounced streaming saying it doesn't
11:09
compensate artists. Fearless Spot of I
11:11
quickly response noting that Swift is
11:14
actually been paid millions of dollars
11:16
were shadow hits back on Swift's
11:18
behalf, saying that they haven't seen
11:21
that much money. Lots
11:23
of artists have protested the
11:26
paltry sums the streaming platform
11:28
gives performers must. She's the
11:30
biggest star so far. The
11:32
fact the company actually response
11:34
is a sign of just
11:36
how powerful she is. Taylor.
11:40
Swift doesn't realize it in the
11:42
moment, but her decision to yank
11:44
her songs from spot A Fine
11:46
will actually pit her against Mega
11:48
Talent agent Scooter Braun, who owns
11:50
a stake in the company. but
11:54
he's preoccupied was trying to save
11:56
neighbors career after a drunk driving
11:58
arrests It
12:00
won't be long before all
12:02
of them, Porchetta, Braun, and
12:04
Bieber, close in on her.
12:14
November 2014, New York City. Swift
12:18
is in her Tribeca apartment, sitting on the
12:20
couch in a red plaid flannel shirt with
12:22
her two cats. It's
12:25
a text from Swift's publicist with a link to
12:27
a Business Week article. Swift clicks
12:30
on it. The headline reads, Taylor
12:33
Swift is the music industry. Well,
12:36
that's nice. She pulls
12:38
one of her cats close to her and keeps going.
12:41
Big Machine Records founder Scott Porchetta
12:43
and his little-known pop act attain
12:45
mass success in an ailing industry.
12:49
Little known? They've been
12:51
sarcastic? From the headline,
12:53
it sounds as though this is going to be a
12:56
story about her. It
12:58
does talk about how her albums actually
13:00
sell copies in an industry where that's
13:02
less and less common. But
13:04
really, it's a profile of Porchetta. And
13:08
he's taking a lot of credit for
13:10
her success. And
13:12
her decisions. She
13:14
calls her publicist. Wait, did you
13:16
read this? He says he's the
13:18
person who decided to take my music from Spotify.
13:21
He's trying to take credit for my decision, as if
13:24
it was his idea. Yep, taken
13:26
care of. We had a,
13:28
quote, source close to Swift. That
13:31
would be me. Say, Scott is exaggerating
13:33
his involvement because he's trying to sell the
13:35
company. Swift nods,
13:38
satisfied. She'd heard rumblings
13:40
that Porchetta's trying to sell the label before
13:42
she leaves. Do you think
13:44
I need to make any comment myself? No.
13:47
I don't think it's a good look for you to get into a
13:49
public fight with Scott. Not right now. Scott
13:52
used a business magazine as his mouthpiece.
13:54
But remember, you have the
13:57
most powerful weapon of all. What's
14:01
that? The.
14:03
Swiss These. Swift
14:06
does is her publicist, suggest
14:09
and doesn't say anything publicly.
14:11
Get. He
14:13
won't be long before she sticks
14:16
system or said and to all
14:18
the other man who she thinks
14:20
have wronged her when it happens
14:22
he will be an abrupt a
14:24
break from her past emotionally and
14:27
artistically. And it
14:29
will be dawn of far
14:31
bigger stage in spectacular fashion.
14:37
Do. You ever wonder where all your
14:39
money went? Like every single time
14:41
you look at your bank account?
14:44
Honestly, it's probably all those subscriptions.
14:46
I felt that way till until
14:48
I got Rocket Money. Rocket Money.
14:50
Help me see all the subscript
14:52
since I'm paying for us and
14:54
it was eye opening. Between streaming
14:56
services, fitness apps, delivery services. it
14:58
all adds up so quickly. Rocket
15:00
Money as a personal finance apps
15:02
that fines and cancels your unwanted
15:04
subscriptions, monitors you're spending and health
15:06
floor your belts, Rocket Money
15:08
has over five million users and as
15:10
helped Save It's members an average of
15:13
seven hundred twenty dollars a year with
15:15
over five hundred million utensil subscriptions. Stop.
15:18
Wasting money on things you
15:20
don't use? Cancel your unwanted
15:22
descriptions by going to Rocket
15:25
Money that Pounds. Last wonder
15:27
it's that's Rocket money.com/laundry Rocket
15:29
money.com/laundry. Shopify.
15:31
Is already taken the cash register online.
15:33
Helping millions save billions around the world?
15:35
We did. You know that shopify can
15:38
do the same thing at your retail
15:40
store? Give. Your point of
15:42
sale system. A serious upgrade
15:44
was shopify. Shopify is the
15:46
commerce platform, revolutionizing millions of
15:48
businesses worldwide. With. Shopify. You
15:51
get a powerhouse selling partner that
15:53
effortlessly unites you're in person and
15:55
online sales into one source of
15:57
truth. Track every sail across your.
16:00
This in one place and know exactly
16:02
what's in stock. Do retail
16:04
right with Shopify! Sign.
16:06
Up for a one dollar
16:09
per month trial period at
16:11
shopify.com/wondering all lowercase. Go.
16:13
To shopify.com/wonder he did
16:15
take your retail business
16:17
to the next level
16:19
today? Shopify That com/wondering.
16:35
February. Twenty sixteen: The Staples Center
16:37
in Downtown Los Angeles. Swift's it's
16:39
Front row with a Grammy awards
16:41
and a Red Cross top and
16:43
magenta skirt for hairs cut in
16:45
a sleek straight bob. no more
16:48
loose country curves. She's
16:50
waiting nervously the hear the results of album
16:52
of the year. The
16:55
announcer opens ya the live
16:57
and says to magic words
16:59
Killer Flip. Flops
17:02
mousetrap sofa. she stands up.
17:05
And hugs her friends Selena Gomez. She
17:07
embraces producer Jag Antar know who made
17:09
the majority of this record with it.
17:12
And then she strides onto the stage.
17:16
For the last year. The
17:20
Recording Academy. For getting us is
17:23
unbelievable. Honor. She begins by
17:25
thanking her collaborators and then.
17:28
She. Gets serious? And
17:30
as the first. Woman:
17:33
To win. I
17:38
wanna say to all the young women
17:40
out there. They're
17:42
going to the people along
17:45
the way to let's try
17:47
to undercut your success or
17:49
take credit for your accomplishments.
17:51
Are your same. The
17:54
crowds years Seems like she's talking about
17:56
rapper Kanye West and the way he
17:58
destroyed during the two that. The nine
18:00
be a Male was a flap
18:02
which he claims made her famous,
18:04
And then there was the hugely
18:06
public scuffle over whether she agreed
18:08
to allow kind to use a
18:10
lyric in a song about her
18:12
sweat keeps going that he cheated.
18:15
On the work. Of
18:17
people to. Someday when you got what
18:19
you're going you'll look around and you
18:22
will know that you and the people
18:24
who love you to put you there
18:26
and that will be the greatest feeling
18:28
in the world. House.
18:37
And it's telling that Swift is
18:39
not once mentioned more shadow or
18:42
thank her label, And while many
18:44
assume it's address to West, it
18:46
could also be about bullshit. Nineteen
18:50
Eighty Nine goes on to become
18:52
not only the most successful album
18:54
of a career, was the top
18:56
three albums of the entire decade.
18:58
It sells five million copies in
19:00
it's first nine months, making it
19:02
the fastest selling album since two
19:04
thousand and four. But
19:07
even though Taylor Swift is
19:09
riding high, it's all about
19:11
the com crashing down. August
19:18
second: Twenty Sixty Nashville, Tennessee.
19:22
Has been lot of media attention lately,
19:24
so Swift is lying low in her
19:26
apartment. She's lounging in bed
19:28
with one of our cats on a large white
19:30
do they. Just. Than one
19:32
of her cat stands up right and
19:35
tux your ears backed. making a hilarious
19:37
expression. She snaps a video of the
19:39
cat standing up on it's hind legs.
19:41
She's been trying to stay offline lately,
19:43
but this clip is too cute. Not
19:46
the post. Scorn
19:48
on. Like
19:50
a girl today. She.
19:57
Adds to her instagram stories. Swiss
20:01
public image has been at an all
20:03
time low this summer. There
20:05
was a controversy over whether Swift agreed to
20:07
allow Con Yea to use a lyric one
20:09
of his songs In June, Kim Kardashians said
20:11
that her husband kind yeah I had call
20:14
Swift for approval of the lyric. When.
20:16
Script denied it. Kardashians uploaded a table
20:18
flip of the call that made it
20:20
sound as though swift and heard West
20:23
song and didn't object. For.
20:25
Dash in it with the a mogi of
20:27
a snake as if to say that. Swift
20:30
was that snake. And
20:32
then well. then it fell to swift
20:35
like the whole internet turned against her.
20:37
Anonymous. Masses calling her a liar
20:40
and saying the she's playing the victim.
20:42
So. She's been trying to stay off social
20:45
media and out of the headlines. But
20:48
just as she looks for her kitty
20:50
on her instagram feed, she sees a
20:52
picture from Justin Bieber. She.
20:54
Reads: Caps. Killer
20:56
Swift? What up? It's
20:59
a black and white face time
21:01
screenshot of Bieber with Scooter Braun and
21:03
Konya West. Swift's.
21:05
Heart sinks. As
21:07
a lot going on in this one screenshot.
21:10
The messaging is not that subtle. It
21:13
signals that Bieber, who she thought
21:15
of as a friend, is taking
21:18
sides kind gays and West is
21:20
now a client of Braun. Swift.
21:24
Throws her phone down. She's furious.
21:26
these guys are ganging up on
21:28
her when worst of all, Were
21:31
Shudder hasn't publicly spoken out in
21:33
support and that steam zur. Inside
21:38
the big machine offices own Music Row
21:41
in Nashville. He's
21:44
got a taylor has ago and.
21:47
She holds up her phone which is
21:49
open on the Bieber Instagram post. Is
21:52
you see this? Not
21:54
good. A half that thing
21:56
still kicking around. Yes,
21:59
Yeah, it is. I just wish
22:01
you would all go away. Puschetta
22:03
nods. Mmm, I
22:05
get that. So what did
22:07
you want to talk about today? Well
22:10
I've been thinking about what's next. This
22:13
is my last album on our deal. After
22:16
her next record, Swift's six album deal is
22:18
up at Big Machine. This
22:20
means she'll be able to sign to another label or
22:23
renegotiate at Big Machine. Right.
22:26
And you know we'd love to have you stay at the label. Pass
22:29
us home for you. Swift
22:31
wriggles in her seat slightly. Well
22:34
I'd be open to exploring that
22:36
possibility, but in order to
22:38
resign, I'd need my masters
22:40
back. Taylor,
22:43
I just can't do that. You know
22:45
I'm exploring selling Big Machine. Without
22:48
your masters, this label is worth a whole lot
22:50
less, and I need to take that into
22:52
account. Swift begins
22:54
to cry. Look, this
22:57
is the worst summer of my life. I
23:00
just want to be able to get my masters back
23:02
and move forward. Why is this
23:04
so hard for you to understand? Well
23:07
we can keep talking about it, but
23:09
maybe now is not the right time. Swift
23:15
is facing the fact that her reputation
23:17
is in shambles, and
23:19
she has no idea how to mend it. She
23:23
decides to disappear from public view. Swift
23:26
will use this time to gather her strength. She'll
23:29
use this sense of shame as
23:32
fuel to go through a painful
23:34
metamorphosis. And when she
23:36
returns to the stage, her
23:38
lyrics will be weapons, and
23:41
her new persona will be unrecognizable.
23:52
Most weight loss plans are one
23:54
size fits all, not taking into
23:56
account each person's individual needs. Noom
23:58
takes into account Dietary
24:00
restrictions. Medical issues and other personal
24:02
needs to build a plan. That. Works
24:05
for you Everyone's journey. Is
24:07
different. So your daily lessons or
24:09
personalized to you and your goals
24:11
stay focused on what's important to
24:13
you. With news, psychology and biology
24:15
based approach, Sign up for your
24:17
free trial today at noom.com that's
24:20
an O M.com and check out
24:22
News! First ever cookbook. The New
24:24
Kitchen for one hundred healthy and
24:26
delicious recipes to promote better living
24:28
available to buy now wherever. Books
24:30
are sold, May
24:46
Twenty Seven Team: Los Angeles. Swift.
24:49
Is on says to film her first music
24:51
videos and she became persona non grata. The
24:54
said as a smoke filled graveyard
24:57
be camera zooms in on a
24:59
giant gravestone that reads here lies
25:01
Taylor Swift's reputation. All
25:04
of a sudden, a ghoulish looking Swift's
25:06
closer way out of the grave. She's
25:08
in zombie make up. Swift
25:11
start singing as she grabs a
25:13
shovel and refills the grave. In
25:23
this revenge video for her
25:25
album Reputation, the lyrics are
25:27
appointed reference to West Swift
25:30
performs the line and staccato
25:32
as though there's a period
25:34
after. Every single word for
25:37
voice punches across a minimum
25:39
drumbeat showcasing her new thrash
25:41
electronics. or
25:44
for is clear this is
25:46
not the old taylor is
25:49
soft blonde ways and as
25:51
aura sweeties this is the
25:54
new taylor hard edges ready
25:56
to strike and she's not
25:58
taking minister And
26:03
cut! Swift
26:05
hurries to hair and makeup to change out
26:07
of the zombie prosthetics. The
26:09
makeup artist leans in to Swift. I
26:12
love what you're doing. Making a whole artistic
26:14
statement about your public perception after all that.
26:17
You know, it's very brave. Thank
26:20
you. This
26:23
record, Reputation, is her chance to
26:25
address the haters. She
26:27
ended up writing a whole album about
26:29
her image. Now
26:31
dressed in a slinky orange outfit with
26:34
tall, skin-tight boots, she
26:36
watches as the prop people set up
26:38
a giant gilded cage. Swift
26:40
is going to swing inside it like a
26:43
caged songbird. It's a
26:45
callback to her old house in Nashville,
26:47
where she used to have a giant
26:49
gold birdcage. But it
26:51
also seems to be a visual representation
26:53
of her relationship with Borsettia. She's
26:56
his songbird, locked
26:58
into a cage. August
27:05
25, 2018.
27:07
Nashville's Nissan Stadium. Swift
27:10
is in her green room, getting ready to go
27:12
on stage. She's about to perform
27:14
the home leg of her Reputation tour, in
27:16
front of nearly 70,000 people. Her
27:20
sixth album sold two million copies
27:22
worldwide in the first week. Swift
27:25
is still selling records like it's the 90s, even
27:28
though streaming is decimated record sales
27:31
figures overall. And she's selling
27:33
out stadiums, too. Come
27:36
in. Swift looks
27:38
up. It's Borsettia. Hi,
27:41
Taylor. I just wanted to catch you quickly.
27:43
I know you wanted to talk about buying
27:45
your masters back. It's only
27:47
minutes before she has to be on stage. She's
27:50
annoyed, but she seizes the opportunity
27:52
to talk about her masters. Yes,
27:55
I do. What's your price? It's
27:58
not a question of price, Taylor. Look,
28:01
here's the way I see it. A deal
28:03
to deal. What we agreed to back in the
28:05
day was that I would own the Masters. And
28:07
you'd be signed to a six album deal. He
28:10
holds up a finger. Now, Reputation
28:12
was your last album on that deal.
28:14
So, what I propose is
28:16
this. Stay signed to Big Machine. Sign
28:18
a new deal with us. And
28:21
then we can figure out the right price for
28:23
your Masters. Taylor,
28:25
you're on a 20. Swift
28:27
turns to Borschetta. Look,
28:29
Scott. I gotta go. Of
28:32
course. Have a great show. But
28:37
Swift is frustrated. She
28:40
feels like for all she's done for
28:42
Borschetta, he should just let
28:44
her have her Masters at a reasonable price.
28:47
Why should she tie herself to him in
28:49
his record label for another 10 years? November
28:59
2018. Tribeca, New York
29:01
City. It's early morning and
29:03
Swift is at home getting ready to
29:06
make a big announcement. But
29:08
first, she types a message to
29:10
Borschetta. Scott, I
29:12
hope this finds you well. Since communication
29:14
ran dry on our negotiation, I've done
29:16
what I told you I would do
29:18
and gone out exploring other options. Owning
29:21
my Masters was very important to me. But
29:24
I've since realized that there are things that mean even
29:26
more to me in the bigger picture. At
29:30
the Big Machine offices in Nashville, Borschetta's
29:32
reading the message. I
29:35
also saw a rare opportunity to affect
29:37
positive change for a lot of other
29:39
artists with the leverage I have right
29:42
now. I wanted to
29:44
tell you first that I'll be
29:46
signing with Lucian. Holy,
29:49
Taylor's signing with Universal. He
29:52
reads on. I still view
29:54
you as a partner and friend and
29:57
I hope you feel the same, sending
29:59
you a hug. and my most sincere
30:01
gratitude and so much
30:03
love, Taylor." Borschetta
30:08
buries his head in his hands. But
30:11
back in New York, Swift is elated.
30:14
This is a huge day for her. She's
30:17
signing with Universal Music Group, and
30:19
as part of the deal going forward, she's
30:22
going to get to own her masters. Borschetta
30:26
digests the news slowly. He
30:29
thought this was coming, but still
30:32
it stings. He probably
30:34
feels like he discovered Swift and made
30:36
her who she is. For
30:39
her to leave, it almost feels
30:41
like a divorce. But
30:45
it poses a financial dilemma for Big
30:47
Machine, too. Swift was
30:49
their biggest artist. The
30:51
label doesn't have Swift anymore, but
30:54
it does still have her masters
30:56
for her first six hit albums.
30:59
And even without Swift, that
31:02
still makes the label a very
31:04
valuable asset. One that
31:06
an astute business person in the music
31:08
industry is very interested
31:10
in. Fall
31:15
2018 in the Big Machine offices
31:18
in Nashville. Scott
31:20
Borschetta is sitting at his desk. His
31:22
hair shows more gray than when Swift side with
31:24
him more than a decade ago, but he's
31:27
kept the same country music executive look.
31:30
Jeans, a black shirt, and jacket. In
31:34
walks his guest, mega talent
31:36
agent Scooter Braun, a
31:38
30-something in a t-shirt and bomber jacket.
31:40
Hi, Scooter. Great to see you. Thanks for coming
31:43
to Nashville. Well, I figured I needed to
31:45
come and find out what you guys are all about.
31:48
Borschetta spreads his hands. Here
31:50
we are, the best independent country label
31:53
and publishing company in the world. We're
31:55
doing $100 million in revenue and going strong.
31:59
Even without Taylor? Look, we still
32:01
have the masters for our first six albums, which
32:03
bring in a lot of money, as you know,
32:05
and we've got artists like Florida Georgia Line, Cheryl
32:08
Crow, Lady Yay, and they're nothing to
32:10
sniff at. Braun nods,
32:12
impressed. Well, let me tell
32:14
you a little bit about Ithaca Holdings. That's
32:17
Braun's company, which is even more impressive
32:19
than Big Machine. It
32:22
too has high profile artists like
32:24
Drake and Stakes in Music Technology.
32:27
More importantly though, one of the world's
32:29
biggest private equity firms, the Carlyle Group,
32:32
is behind it. And that
32:34
opens bold new horizons. We're
32:37
launching a film studio, we're acquiring
32:39
another music publishing company, and
32:42
we've started a music tech investment fund. We
32:44
have Stakes and tons of other management firms,
32:47
and you know, all of that creates synergy. We
32:49
can negotiate even better terms on any new
32:51
deal. Braun looks at
32:53
Borschetta. Who knows, he's just been
32:56
one up. Look, Scott,
32:58
I think you've got a great business here
33:00
with Big Machine, and I'd love to bring
33:02
you into the Ithaca Holdings fold. What
33:05
do you say? Borschetta
33:07
has half been expecting this. He
33:10
and Braun have been talking a lot recently
33:12
about how they might work together. But
33:14
now, Braun is saying he officially wants
33:17
to acquire his record label, which
33:19
means owning its current roster, and
33:22
Swift's old masters. Borschetta
33:25
leans back. Scooter,
33:27
I'm flattered. Let's talk
33:29
specifics. I don't want to leave
33:31
the company I built. I'm looking for a strategic
33:33
partner who can help me and my artists get
33:35
to the next level. And
33:37
I think that's us. I don't want
33:40
you to go anywhere. I want you to stay independent.
33:42
Keep running your label just as you have been. We're
33:45
positioned to lead the next generation of the music
33:47
industry, and I want you at my side. Borschetta
33:51
smiles. He stands
33:53
up and extends his hand. Scooter,
33:55
you've got a deal. A
33:58
pair of shank on it. Under
34:01
the deal they hash out, Borchetta will
34:03
take a stake in Braun's company. In
34:05
exchange, Braun is going to
34:07
own Big Machine and
34:10
the Masters to Swift's first six
34:12
albums. Taylor
34:17
Swift doesn't know a thing
34:19
about this deal, but when
34:21
she learns she's going to have to
34:23
battle both Braun and Borchetta for her
34:25
Masters, she's furious.
34:29
But the Young Pop superstar has an ace
34:31
upper sleeve. A negotiating
34:33
tool even the mighty Scooter Braun
34:35
can't match. The
34:38
most powerful fans in
34:40
the entire music industry. From
34:48
Wondering, this is the second episode of
34:51
Taylor Swift vs. the World or
34:53
Business One. A quick note
34:55
about recreations you've been hearing. In most cases
34:57
we can't know exactly what was said. Those
35:00
scenes are dramatizations, but they're based on
35:02
historical research. For more on
35:04
Taylor Swift, check out the Miss Americana
35:06
documentary. We also recommend reading
35:08
Taylor Swift, The Whole Story by Chaz
35:10
Nuki Burton. I'm your
35:13
host David Brown. Natalie Robomad wrote
35:15
this story, voice acting by Caroline
35:17
Kinley and Michelle Phillippe. Karen
35:19
Lowe is our senior editor and producer,
35:21
edited and produced by Emily Frost, sound
35:24
designed by Kyle Randall. Our
35:26
senior producers Dave Schelling, our executive
35:28
producers are Jenny Lower Beckman and
35:30
Marshall Louis. We're Wondering.
35:51
Okay, so if you had a time machine,
35:53
how far in time would you need to
35:55
go back to being a dominant basketball player?
36:00
was playing. The plumber game. 27-year-old
36:02
Shay would give Bob Coosey the business.
36:05
He's not guarding me. Hi, I'm Jason
36:07
Esepzion. And I'm Shay Serrano, and we
36:09
are back. We have a new podcast
36:12
from Wondering. It's called Six Trophies. And
36:14
that's the best. Each week, Shay
36:16
and I are combing through all of the NBA
36:18
storylines, finding the best, most
36:20
interesting, most compelling ones, and then
36:23
handing out six pop culture-themed trophies for six basketball-related activities.
36:25
Trophies like the Dominic Toretto, I Live My Life, a
36:27
Quarter Mile At A Time trophy, which is given to
36:29
someone who made a short-term decision with no
36:31
regard for future consequence. Or
36:34
the Christopher Nolan Tenet trophy, which is given to someone who
36:36
did something that we didn't understand. Catalina Wine Mixer
36:39
trophy. Ooh, the Lauryn Hill, you might
36:41
win some, but you just lost one trophy. Follow Six Trophies
36:43
on the Wondery app or wherever you get your podcasts. Give
36:45
us the Six Trophies ad-free right now by
36:48
joining Wondery Plus.
Podchaser is the ultimate destination for podcast data, search, and discovery. Learn More