Podchaser Logo
Home
Six Impossible Episodes: Deja Vu in the U.S. and Canada

Six Impossible Episodes: Deja Vu in the U.S. and Canada

Released Monday, 10th December 2018
Good episode? Give it some love!
Six Impossible Episodes: Deja Vu in the U.S. and Canada

Six Impossible Episodes: Deja Vu in the U.S. and Canada

Six Impossible Episodes: Deja Vu in the U.S. and Canada

Six Impossible Episodes: Deja Vu in the U.S. and Canada

Monday, 10th December 2018
Good episode? Give it some love!
Rate Episode

Episode Transcript

Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.

Use Ctrl + F to search

0:01

Welcome to Stuff You Missed in History

0:03

Class from how Stuff Works dot com.

0:11

He hello, and welcome to the podcast. I'm

0:14

Tracy V. Wilson and I'm Holly Crying.

0:16

It's time for some Six Impossible Episodes.

0:19

If you are new to the show. A couple of times

0:21

a year, we do an episode that looks at six

0:24

different stories that, for whatever reason,

0:26

we can't really do as a standalone

0:28

show. A lot of the time it's because there's

0:30

not enough information to fill out a whole

0:32

show, or because there are six stories that

0:35

have some similar themes in common.

0:37

Back in we did an episode

0:39

called Six Impossible Episodes Deja

0:42

Vu Edition, and that was on topics that were

0:44

so similar to things we had already covered

0:47

that if we had done a whole episode, it would have sounded

0:49

almost like a rerun, just with different names

0:51

and dates. Just swap those out. It's the exact

0:53

same story, and today we're doing something

0:56

a little bit similar to that.

0:59

Several times over the past few years,

1:01

we've done an episode about something that happened

1:03

in the United States, and then afterward

1:05

we've gotten lots of notes from listeners about the same

1:08

thing happening in Canada.

1:10

Although the first story that we're going to get into is

1:12

actually the reverse of that. Also, I

1:14

do want to note that these are mostly not happy stories.

1:16

Apparently mostly people tell us that also happened

1:19

in Canada about really

1:21

appalling incidents in history. So

1:24

we saved the most heroic one

1:26

for last. So starting out on

1:28

July, we

1:31

published a podcast on Le fi Duchroix,

1:33

or the King's Daughters, And this was an

1:35

effort by Francis, King Louis the fourteenth

1:38

to send eligible young women to New France.

1:40

In the sixteen hundreds, francis

1:42

focus in northern North America had been

1:44

on the fur trade, not on establishing

1:47

permanent settlements with families, and

1:49

as a consequence, by sixteen sixty three,

1:52

there were six frenchmen for every

1:54

frenchwoman in what is now Canada.

1:57

So the monarchy recruited French women

1:59

and paid for their transport to North America

2:02

in an effort to try to balance things out.

2:04

A very similar scenario also

2:06

played out in French Louisiana.

2:09

At first, authorities had expected that

2:11

French men would go to Louisiana and

2:13

marry Native women, and then they

2:15

also expected that these brides would

2:17

assimilate into French colonial society.

2:20

That is not how it worked out, though. It turned out

2:22

that the women in question had their own opinions

2:25

on this subject, which was to do essentially

2:27

the opposite. By the late seventeenth

2:29

century, French officials were actively

2:31

discouraging colonists from marrying

2:34

native women to try to preserve the frenchness

2:36

and the whiteness of the colony. But

2:38

then that meant that they needed more French

2:41

women because there weren't enough to marry these

2:43

men. The first group to arrive

2:45

by order of King Louis the fourteenth came

2:47

aboard a ship called the Pelican and

2:50

are nicknamed the Pelican Girls as

2:52

a consequence. The ship arrived

2:54

at Dauphin Island in what's now Mobile

2:56

County, Alabama in seventeen

2:58

o four. It's passengers included

3:01

twenty three frenchwomen and two families.

3:03

Sent after repeated requests by

3:06

Governor Jean Baptiste Lemoine de Bienville

3:08

and other colonial officials. The

3:11

Chancellor of France wrote to the governor

3:13

about these women, and this is what the letter said,

3:15

quote. Each of these girls was raised

3:18

in virtue and piety and knows how

3:20

to work, which will render them useful

3:22

in the colony by showing the Indian girls

3:24

what they can do for this, there

3:26

being no point in sending other than a

3:29

virtue known and without reproach,

3:31

His Majesty entrusted the Bishop of

3:33

Quebec to certify them in order

3:35

that they not be suspected of debauch.

3:38

You will take care to establish them

3:40

the best that you can, and to marry

3:42

them two men capable of having them

3:44

subsist with some degree of comfort.

3:47

Although most of these women got married

3:50

very quickly beyond that,

3:52

this first effort did not go well. Recruiters

3:55

had described Louisiana as an amazing

3:57

and wealthy paradise, which was not

4:00

even remotely true. The women

4:02

arrived during a persistent and severe

4:05

food shortage. Diseases

4:07

were rampant, and the terrain. If you've

4:09

ever been to Louisiana you know

4:11

this was swampy, and the French

4:13

colonists faced ongoing and justified

4:16

threats from the region's enslaved and indigenous

4:18

populations. Conditions were

4:21

so bad and so different from

4:23

what they had been promised that in seventeen

4:25

oh six a lot of these women launched

4:27

a protest trying to get passage

4:29

out of the colony. And back to France. This

4:32

uprising was given the disparaging nickname

4:34

the Petticoat Insurrection. Today,

4:37

this protest is folded into the lore

4:39

about the origins of Creole cuisine.

4:42

Supposedly everything was resolved when

4:44

the governor's housekeeper, Madame Langnois,

4:47

taught the women how to cook with local ingredients

4:49

and spices, because that would

4:52

solve all the problems shrug um.

4:54

But it is not clear whether Lanois

4:57

ever existed, and this story really

4:59

minimizes as indigenous and African

5:01

contributions to Creole cuisine. But

5:04

it is clear that this protest was about

5:06

a lot more than cooking ingredients.

5:09

Yeah, even in in accounts written

5:11

by like the male leaders of the time were

5:13

like, they're just unhappy because they don't like to eat corn,

5:16

and that was not That was like one

5:18

tiny piece of this whole situation. Regardless,

5:21

though, word got back to France about

5:24

what this Louisiana colony was really

5:26

like, and soon women were no longer

5:28

willing to go there. Unsurprisingly,

5:31

so authorities started recruiting women from

5:33

orphanages, hospitals, and prisons,

5:35

and especially when it came to women who had been convicted

5:38

of a crime. These migrations were forced,

5:40

they were not voluntary as that first

5:42

shipload had been, and even

5:44

for the ones that were technically voluntary,

5:46

the women in question a lot of the time did

5:48

not have many other options either

5:51

way. Many of these women died on

5:53

the way to Louisiana, and the ones

5:55

who survived often were not all that

5:57

eager to marry a colonist and start

5:59

keeping house for him. France

6:01

ended the formal migration program in

6:03

seventy but the most famous

6:05

group of women arrived in New Orleans early

6:08

the following year. These

6:10

are the ones most commonly known as

6:12

the Casket Girls. These

6:14

were eighty eight women recruited from a hospital

6:16

in Paris that wasn't just a medical

6:19

facility, but was also housing

6:21

for both orphans and prisoners. Although

6:24

nineteen of these women married quickly and

6:26

thirty one married later on, the

6:28

rest either refused to marry or

6:30

return to France. The

6:33

name casket was reportedly

6:35

from the boxes that these women

6:37

were using to carry their belongings as they

6:39

traveled. They'll see articles online

6:41

that variously explained the name casket

6:43

is coming from the French caskette

6:46

or cassette, even though

6:48

caskett is not a

6:50

box it is a hat the

6:53

story of the Casket Girls departs

6:55

from reality, though articles

6:57

all over the web describe a group of women

6:59

who arrived in New Orleans in seventy

7:01

eight, all meticulously chosen

7:04

to be attractive and virtuous,

7:06

but the migration program had been over for

7:08

years by that point, and according to Marcia

7:11

A. Zug, who has written a book on these programs,

7:13

the only ship carrying a group of women

7:15

that arrived in New Orleans in seventeen was

7:18

carrying ursuline nuns, not women

7:21

available for marriage. As

7:23

a side note, if you want to hear Zug talk

7:25

more about this, she is on episode

7:28

one twenty of the podcast Ben Franklin's

7:30

World that has titled Marcia Zug History

7:32

of Mail Order Brides in Early America.

7:35

This is not the only departure from reality

7:38

when it comes to the story of the Casket

7:40

Girls, though if you go on a ghost tour

7:42

of New Orleans, you might hear a story about

7:44

how these mythical seventeen eight

7:47

arrivals came with their caskets and were

7:49

immediately suspected to be vampires

7:51

because they sun burned easily and the trunks

7:54

they were carrying looked like coffins. This

7:57

just doesn't hauled up from the beginning

7:59

because it was completely

8:01

normal for new arrivals

8:03

in the colony to get sunburns and

8:05

the subtropical sun and to

8:08

carry their things in trunks and other

8:10

boxes. There's a whole story

8:12

about these women being taken to that ursuline

8:14

convent in the French Quarter and then their

8:17

caskets being found to be mysteriously

8:19

empty, after which point the nuns had

8:21

the attic windows nailed shut using

8:23

just an astounding number of silver nails.

8:26

All of this because vampires

8:28

shure. Uh.

8:31

These women's stories are not as well

8:34

documented as the King's daughters, though

8:36

possibly because there were far fewer

8:38

of them, and also because the program in Louisiana

8:41

was just not as successful as it

8:43

had been in Canada. Yeah. That and

8:45

we we talked so much and so much more detail about

8:47

the program uh in in what's

8:49

now Canada, where the women

8:52

had a lot of choices, they had a lot more freedoms.

8:55

Um. It was one of those circumstances where you're

8:57

like, Okay, people probably didn't have as many

8:59

options in Europe as they did in North

9:01

America, and in a lot of ways that life

9:03

turned out to be better, and in most cases

9:06

that was not the case. In Louisiana's women

9:08

showed up and we're not really appreciated,

9:10

and we're made fun of and called ugly, and

9:13

we're much smaller in number.

9:15

So when you look at French

9:17

Canadian genealogy, so many

9:20

French Canadians are descended from

9:22

these these women in Canada, but it's

9:24

not um. There's not as much

9:26

of a through line in Louisiana, although an

9:29

astounding number of people say they were

9:31

descended from these um fictitious

9:34

seventeen twenty eight, meticulously

9:36

chosen to be virtuous and beautiful casket

9:40

Curl. I feel like that happens

9:42

in almost any mythology,

9:45

right, I mean, we've been to places that are

9:47

are famous for various reasons, and there

9:50

are often people who are like, yes, I am descended

9:52

from person X, Y or Z, and it's like,

9:55

um, I have some questions

9:57

that person did not live here though, right,

10:00

Like there's some possibilities

10:03

going on, But who am I to take

10:05

that away from them? Yeah, at least

10:07

were real and complicated women in their

10:09

stories have been really pretty heavily mythologized.

10:12

To move on.

10:15

On November seventeen,

10:17

We put out a two part podcast on the Fort

10:19

Shaw Indian School girls basketball

10:22

team, and a big part of that episode

10:24

was the system of boarding schools established

10:26

in the United States to separate Native

10:29

children from their cultures into so called americanized

10:31

them. Colonel Richard Henry

10:34

Pratt, who was a major figure in

10:36

establishing this whole system, summed it

10:38

up as quote, killed the Indian and

10:40

save the man. Canada

10:43

had a nearly identical system of boarding

10:45

schools known as residential schools, as

10:48

was the case in the United States. Mission schools

10:50

in Canada went all the way back to the early

10:52

colonization of New France, but

10:55

in terms of a more formalized, systemic

10:57

program that started in the eighteen thirty

11:00

expanding dramatically in the eighteen

11:02

eighties after changes to federal policy

11:04

regarding both education and Indigenous

11:07

people. By nineteen thirty one,

11:09

when the Canadian system was at its largest,

11:11

there were about eighties schools. With

11:13

the exception of Newfoundland, Prince Edward

11:16

Island and New Brunswick, every Canadian

11:18

province and territory had at least one

11:20

school. Over the course of the program,

11:23

about a hundred and fifty thousand

11:25

children were separated from their families

11:27

for months or years at a time,

11:30

and the last of these schools did not shut down until

11:32

nineteen ninety six. These schools

11:34

were part of a government program, but until

11:37

nineteen sixty nine they were run by churches,

11:39

primarily the Roman Catholic Church,

11:42

the Anglican Church, the United Church

11:44

of Canada, and the Presbyterian Church.

11:47

The Methodist Church also operated

11:49

some schools up until nineteen twenty five.

11:52

These schools had the same goals

11:54

as the ones in the United States did, to

11:56

separate Canada's first nations Inuit

11:59

and may teach children from their cultures, to

12:01

christianize them, to teach them English and French,

12:04

and to assimilate them into Euro Canadian

12:06

society. Conditions at the schools

12:08

were often very cruel. There were also documented

12:11

cases of physical and sexual abuse.

12:13

As many as six thousand children

12:16

died in these schools, including from disease

12:18

and malnutrition, and some of these

12:20

students were experimented on. There

12:23

was a series of experiments carried out in the

12:25

nineteen forties and fifties that studied

12:27

the effects of malnutrition,

12:29

and these were conducted with the government's knowledge.

12:31

Basically, somebody visiting the school had noticed

12:34

that the children were malnourished, and instead

12:36

of fixing the problem, only

12:38

supplemented the diets of parts of some

12:40

of the children to study what happened

12:42

with the others. In the nineteen nineties,

12:44

the Canadian government convened a Royal Commission

12:47

on Aboriginal Peoples in response to

12:49

a call from Phil Fontane, who

12:51

would later become the National Chief of the Assembly

12:53

of First Nations. Advocacy

12:56

had already been going on at that point, but

12:58

Fontane was really the key figure bringing

13:00

it to national attention. The

13:02

Commission issued a report about the schools

13:05

and recommended a public inquiry,

13:07

although the public inquiry never happened.

13:09

A later class action settlement resulted

13:12

in the Indian Residential Schools Settlement

13:14

Agreement, which came into effect in September

13:16

of two thousand seven. This agreement

13:19

included the Common Experience Payment,

13:21

which was a one point nine billion dollar

13:23

compensation program for people who had been

13:25

forced to attend these schools. Former

13:28

students were eligible for ten thousand

13:30

dollars for their first year or partial

13:32

year in attendance and three thousand

13:35

dollars for each subsequent year, and as

13:37

of September, one

13:39

point six billion dollars had been paid on

13:42

more than a hundred and five thousand cases.

13:45

The agreement also set up an assessment

13:47

process for cases of physical, psychological

13:50

and sexual abuse. It established

13:52

a Truth and Reconciliation Commission, and

13:55

set up a commemoration fund. There

13:57

have been some criticisms of this settlement,

14:00

though, including unethical lawyers who

14:02

took advantage of people seeking restitution,

14:04

and the exclusion of Newfoundland and

14:07

Labrador from the settlement. Yeah,

14:09

the argument was that that wasn't

14:11

part of Canada yet during

14:13

a lot of this time, but there were still people

14:15

there who were affected. Prime Minister

14:18

Stephen Harper formally apologized

14:20

for the boarding school system on Jounal eleventh,

14:22

two thousand eight, and several churches

14:25

that were involved in these programs have apologized

14:27

as well. The Truth and Reconciliation

14:30

Commission that was established under the settlement

14:32

agreement issued its final report

14:34

in TWI. Its introduction

14:37

began quote for over a century,

14:39

the central goals of Canada's Aboriginal

14:41

policy were to eliminate Aboriginal

14:44

governments, ignore aboriginal

14:46

rights, terminate the treaties,

14:48

and, through a process of assimilation,

14:51

cause Aboriginal peoples to cease to

14:53

exist as distinct, legal, social

14:55

cultural, religious, and racial entities

14:58

in Canada. The establishment

15:00

and operation of residential schools were

15:02

a central element of this policy, which

15:05

can best be described as cultural genocide.

15:08

This report went on to make ninety four recommendations

15:11

to repair the damage caused by the schools.

15:14

This report also noted a related practice

15:17

that became known as the sixties scoop.

15:20

From the nineteen sixties through the nineteen eighties,

15:22

thousands of Indigenous children in Canada

15:24

were taken from their families and placed in foster

15:26

care, then adopted by white families,

15:29

sometimes white families who lived in the United States

15:31

or the United Kingdom between

15:33

nineteen fifty in the mid nineteen sixties,

15:36

these Aboriginal children went from making

15:38

up about one percent of the children

15:40

in care in Canada to making up more

15:43

than a third of the children in care. And

15:45

that also has parallels to another past

15:48

episode in our archives, which is Australia's

15:50

Stolen Generations. What's followed a really similar

15:52

pattern from about nineteen ten to nineteen

15:55

seventy And we should also note that

15:57

there are ongoing issues with Indigenous

15:59

and Aboriginal children in the child

16:01

welfare systems in the United

16:04

States, in Australia and

16:06

Canada, all all three nations.

16:09

Um we mentioned these boarding schools

16:11

really briefly in those in that

16:13

too part are about the Fort Shot Indian

16:15

School program. But I wanted to take the

16:17

opportunity to go in a little more detail here today

16:20

and we will talk about something else that

16:23

similarly happened in Canada. After a quick

16:25

sponsor break

16:33

on February fifteenth and seventeen seventeen,

16:36

we did a two part podcast on Executive

16:38

Order nineties sixty six and the mass

16:41

incarceration of Japanese Americans

16:43

during World War Two. When we

16:45

posted these episodes on our social

16:47

media, one of the comments that we got was

16:50

this happened in Canada to which is not something

16:52

we had mentioned in that episode at all. But

16:54

it's not just that this happened

16:57

in Canada to The Canadian

16:59

incarc ration of its Japanese citizens

17:02

and residents directly followed

17:04

what happened to the United States during

17:07

World War One. The Canadian government had

17:09

passed the War Measures Act, which

17:11

granted very broad authority when it came

17:13

to restricting civil liberties during wartime.

17:16

During World War two, the War Measures Act

17:19

was used to incarcerate about twenty four

17:21

thousand people in Canada, nearly

17:23

all of them Japanese Canadians.

17:26

Other people incarcerated included German

17:28

Canadians who were members the Canadian Nazi

17:31

Party or German sponsored organizations,

17:33

and approximately six hundred Italians

17:35

who were suspected of supporting fascism.

17:38

About three thousand refugees from Germany

17:41

and Austria were also incarcerated,

17:43

many of them Jewish, and many of

17:45

the Jewish refugees were incarcerated

17:47

along with Nazi prisoners of war.

17:50

When it came to the Japanese Canadians, though,

17:53

all Japanese Canadians, regardless

17:56

of their citizenship status, were required

17:58

to register with the government in March

18:00

of nineteen forty one, and then

18:02

after Japan attacked Pearl Harbor,

18:04

Hawaii in December of nineteen

18:06

forty one, events in Canada followed the

18:08

same basic pattern that they did in the

18:11

United States that we talked about in detail

18:13

in those two episodes. A small

18:15

number of Japanese nationals were taken

18:17

into custody right away, and then

18:19

white business owners, farmers, and political

18:22

leaders on the Pacific coast of Canada started

18:24

pressuring the government to remove their

18:26

Japanese neighbors. These arguments

18:29

and language that were used were just virtually

18:32

identical to what was used in the United

18:34

States. First Prime

18:36

Minister William Lyon Mackenzie

18:38

King ordered the removal of adult

18:40

men of Japanese ancestry from Canada's

18:43

West coast on January fourteenth,

18:45

ninety two. Then

18:47

on February nineteenth, nineteen forty

18:50

two, President Franklin Delano Roosevelt

18:52

signed Executive Order ninety sixty

18:54

six regarding the removal of all

18:56

Japanese Americans from the U s. West

18:58

Coast. Five days after

19:01

that, the Canadian Cabinet followed suit

19:03

in Canada and approved Order in Council

19:05

PC fourteen eighty six, which

19:08

the Prime Minister announced on February twenty

19:10

six. This broadened the earlier

19:13

removal to include everyone of Japanese

19:15

ancestry living within one hundred

19:17

miles of Canada's Pacific coast. The

19:20

British Columbia Security Commission was

19:22

created to oversee and manage the

19:25

expulsion and incarceration. About

19:28

sixty five percent of the twenty two

19:30

thousand Japanese Canadians who were

19:32

removed following this order had been

19:34

born in Canada, and in many cases

19:36

their property was confiscated and sold

19:39

or otherwise never returned to them. Japanese

19:41

fishers on the west coast of Canada were also

19:44

required to turn over their boats, which

19:46

was of course the source of their livelihood, and

19:48

these also were not returned. During

19:50

this removal. More than two thousand

19:52

single men were sent to work on road labor

19:55

camps, and about thirty five hundred

19:57

were sent to work on sugar beet farms

19:59

outside to British Columbia. Everyone

20:02

else was sent to segregated concentration

20:04

camps. As was true in the

20:06

United States, these Canadian camps were

20:09

very hastily built or were converted

20:11

from facilities like abandoned mining

20:13

camps. They were totally insufficient

20:15

to provide shelter from the elements and

20:17

the United States, the government had provided food,

20:20

clothing, and schooling for incarcerated

20:22

children, although overwhelmingly

20:24

these were inadequate at best. The

20:27

Canadian government provided the camps,

20:29

but no food or clothing, and no education

20:32

beyond elementary school for the incarcerated

20:34

children. There was also an organized

20:37

resistance to this in Canada, including

20:39

the creation of the niss A Mass Evacuation

20:42

Group. The incarcerations

20:44

in the United States and Canada ended

20:46

slightly differently. In the US,

20:48

many Japanese Americans returned to the

20:51

West Coast after the end of the war, even

20:53

though often they had to start completely over

20:55

and they faced ongoing prejudice and discrimination

20:59

in Canada. Japanese Canadians were

21:01

not allowed to return to British Columbia.

21:04

Instead, they had two choices to

21:06

settle somewhere in Canada outside

21:09

of British Columbia, or to return

21:11

to Japan. Although some people

21:13

did return to Japan voluntarily, thousands

21:16

were forcibly deported after refusing

21:18

to move out of British Columbia, which

21:21

had been their home. And I should also

21:23

note that some of them were not originally from

21:25

Japan. They were born in Canada and had never

21:27

been to Japan. Investigations

21:30

conducted after this incarceration was over

21:32

concluded that the property of Japanese

21:34

Canadians that had been sold during the war

21:37

was sold for far less than it was worth,

21:39

But the Canadian government really resisted

21:42

offering any kind of compensation or

21:44

acknowledgement for this, or in general,

21:46

for the incarceration. Then,

21:48

in September of Canada

21:51

reached a settlement agreement that included an

21:53

official apology and a redress payment

21:55

of twenty one thousand dollars for each person

21:57

who was affected, along with the estab

22:00

pulishment of a twelve million dollar funds

22:02

to create a Canadian Race Relations

22:04

Foundation. The United States

22:06

had taken similar steps in a law that was

22:08

signed in August tenth of the same year. So that

22:10

was another way that the two countries paralleled

22:13

each other and all of this so

22:15

moving on to our next uh

22:17

again not super delightful story.

22:20

UH. At the beginning of our podcast on

22:22

Executive Order ninety six, we

22:24

set the stage by talking about the history of

22:26

immigration from Japan and other

22:29

parts of Asia to the United States, as

22:31

well as the history of discrimination against

22:34

these immigrants. A big part

22:36

of that discussion was the Chinese Exclusion

22:38

Act of eighteen eighty two, and

22:40

that act has come up in other episodes as

22:42

well, including our episodes on Levi

22:45

Strauss, the Bisbee Deportation,

22:47

and the history of Foreign Foods in the US.

22:50

This act banned all immigration

22:52

from China for a period of ten years.

22:55

It was the United States first major law

22:58

restricting immigration and the first time time

23:00

that the US banned people from a specific

23:02

nation. Canada faced a very

23:05

similar trajectory in the late nineteenth

23:07

century. Large numbers of Chinese immigrants

23:10

arrived in Canada, first with the gold rush

23:12

and then to work on the construction of the Canadian

23:15

Pacific Railway. As the number

23:17

of Chinese people in Canada increased,

23:19

so did anti Chinese prejudice.

23:22

A lot of white residents resented

23:24

Chinese immigrants under the idea that they were

23:26

stealing jobs. Then this sense

23:29

increased as the railway was finished

23:31

and these laborers started finding work

23:33

in other industries. Emotion was

23:35

made in Parliament to enact a law prohibiting

23:38

all Chinese immigration into British

23:40

Columbia, just as the United

23:42

States had done. Rather than simply

23:45

passed the law, Parliament established

23:47

the Royal Commission on Chinese Immigration

23:49

to evaluate quote all the facts

23:51

and matters connected to the whole subject

23:53

of Chinese immigration. Although

23:56

the Commission had been established after a call

23:58

to ban Chinese immigration and

24:00

heard a lot of racist testimony,

24:03

the Commission found that these racist stereotypes

24:05

were untrue and that overall Chinese

24:08

labor was beneficial to Canada.

24:11

It did recommend implementing a ten

24:13

dollar duty on immigrants from China

24:15

to pay for health inspection at the port and

24:18

other administrative costs. Some

24:20

of the study was actually conducted in San

24:22

Francisco, UH specifically

24:24

with officials from the Chinese consulate there,

24:27

but the Chinese Immigration Act

24:29

of eighteen eighty five ignored the findings

24:32

from the Commission and instead instituted

24:35

a duty of fifty dollars a person

24:37

specifically to act as a deterrent.

24:40

The act did allow some exceptions from

24:42

this duty, including diplomats, government

24:44

officials, tourists, and students.

24:47

It also imposed restrictions on the vessels

24:49

that were carrying Chinese immigrants

24:52

to Canada. There could be only

24:54

one Chinese person for every

24:56

fifty tons of the ship's weight. Ships

24:59

carrying European immigrants, on the other hand,

25:01

could have one immigrant for every two tons.

25:04

This was Canada's first major immigration

25:07

lots and to target immigrants based

25:09

on their nation of origin. The fifty

25:11

dollar fee did reduce the number of Chinese

25:14

people who tried to enter Canada, but

25:16

not for long. As the economy

25:18

of British Columbia continued to expand,

25:20

there was more and more demand for labor. There

25:23

weren't enough people in British Columbia to

25:25

meet this demand, so within five years

25:27

the number of Chinese immigrants to Canada

25:30

was increasing again. In response,

25:32

the Canadian government kept increasing

25:34

that duty, which had been fifty dollars,

25:37

and it rose all the way up to five hundred

25:39

dollars in nineteen o three. Then

25:41

twenty years after that, the Chinese

25:43

Immigration Act of banned

25:46

nearly all Chinese people from entering

25:48

Canada at all, with the exception

25:50

of students, merchants, diplomats,

25:52

and Canadian born people who were returning

25:55

to Canada. There were also

25:57

some exceptions to the exceptions.

26:00

Urchants excluded, laundry, restaurant

26:02

and retail operators. The three

26:05

Act also required everyone of Chinese

26:08

descent to register for an identity

26:10

card, regardless of whether they were Canadian

26:12

citizens. This Act was repealed

26:14

in ninety seven, although there continued

26:17

to be traces of these restrictions in Canadian

26:19

immigration law until nineteen sixty seven.

26:22

We're going to get to some more Canadian history after

26:24

we pause for a little sponsor break.

26:33

In eleven, previous hosts

26:35

Sarah and Dablina released an episode on the

26:37

New York Draft Riots. We

26:39

rereleased that episode as a Saturday Classic

26:41

on July seven, eighteen,

26:44

and, like its name suggests, the

26:46

New York Draft Riots of eighteen sixty three

26:48

started because of the Civil War draft.

26:50

But the riot was not only

26:53

about the draft. Another big

26:55

factor was discontent among working

26:57

class people who were facing increasing

27:00

competition for jobs as escaped

27:02

slaves and other people of African descent

27:04

were moving into New York. Race

27:06

also was a huge part of it, and the

27:08

rioters primarily targeted the black

27:11

community. The Shelburne

27:13

Riots of seventeen eighty four weren't

27:15

identical to the New York Draft riots,

27:17

but they had a lot of similarities

27:20

and parallels, including connections to war,

27:23

labor, and race. During the Revolutionary

27:25

War, roughly a fifth of the black

27:27

residents of the British colonies fought

27:29

on the side of the Loyalists, who

27:31

wanted American colonies to remain part

27:33

of Britain. The vast majority

27:36

had been enslaved and expected that after

27:38

the war was over they would be granted their

27:40

freedom in exchange for their service.

27:43

But when the loyalists side lost the war

27:45

and the colonies became independent, some

27:47

of those people were recaptured and returned

27:49

to slavery. Many of those that weren't

27:52

ultimately made their way into Canada. In

27:54

particular, in seventeen eighty three, about

27:57

fifteen hundred black Loyalists

27:59

settled in Nova Scotia, many

28:01

of them concentrated in Shelburne County,

28:03

which was home also to about sixteen

28:06

thousand white loyalists. Most

28:08

black Loyalists made their homes in a community

28:10

that was not far from the town of Shelburne

28:13

called Birchtown, and soon that became

28:15

the largest community of free black people

28:17

in North America. However, slavery

28:20

also existed in Canada, including

28:23

in Shelburne. Slave owners

28:25

in Shelburne felt threatened by the free

28:27

black community in Birchtown and the effects

28:29

that it might have on their enslaved workforce.

28:33

Nova Scotia's white residents also tended

28:35

to view all people of African descent as

28:37

slaves, regardless of whether

28:39

they were enslaved or free. Working

28:42

class white residents also faced increasing

28:44

competition for paying work from this growing

28:47

black community, especially since

28:49

people who needed to hire labor could

28:51

do it much more cheaply by exploiting

28:53

the black population. Another

28:56

complication in all this was soldiers who

28:58

were returning home from the Revolutionary a

29:00

War who no longer had employment

29:02

or income. A lot of people in the area

29:04

had also been promised land grants,

29:06

but those grants had been repeatedly delayed,

29:09

and a lot of the land turned out not to be

29:11

suitable for farming. So in both New

29:13

York in eighteen sixty three and Shelburne

29:15

nearly eighty years earlier, white

29:17

residents were increasingly resentful of

29:20

a growing population of free black

29:22

residents as a result of a war and

29:24

the effect it was having on their lives and income.

29:27

In New York, the draft tipped

29:29

this resentment into violence. In Shelburne,

29:32

that spark came from the intersection of religion

29:35

and racism. Baptist preacher David

29:37

George had been born in Virginia in seventeen

29:40

forty two and was enslaved from birth.

29:42

He escaped to South Carolina and lived

29:45

in hiding for several years before being captured

29:47

and sold back into slavery. He fled

29:50

to British occupied Savannah during the Revolutionary

29:52

War in seventeen seventy eight, and then traveled

29:54

to Charleston, where he was evacuated

29:56

along with about five thousand black residents

29:59

in seventeen eighty two. Although

30:01

most of these evacuees wound up being enslaved

30:04

again and sent to the Caribbean, George wound

30:06

up in Nova Scotia. He established

30:08

his church in Shelburne rather than in Birchtown,

30:11

and some of his congregation built their homes

30:13

on church property, and at

30:15

first the white residents of Shelburne

30:17

mostly left them alone, but

30:20

eventually George started baptizing

30:22

white loyalists. The idea

30:24

of a black minister baptizing white people,

30:27

especially at a church in quote

30:29

their part of town, outraged

30:32

many white residents. In July

30:34

sight four, a group of white loyalists

30:37

tried to forcibly remove a white

30:39

woman who was about to be baptized by David

30:41

George. Then, on the twenty sixth

30:44

of that month, a group of about forty white

30:46

loyalists attacked Georgia's house,

30:48

physically pulling it down using a ship's tackle.

30:51

They went on to tear down other homes that

30:53

had been built on the church property, destroying

30:56

about twenty houses. This

30:58

swelled into a riot that lasted

31:00

for about ten days, with the white residents

31:02

of Shelburne trying to drive the black residents

31:05

out of both Shelburne and Birchtown. Eventually,

31:08

four companies of the sevente Regiment

31:11

and later a naval frigate were dispatched

31:13

to restore order. The rioters did

31:15

not succeed in evicting the black community

31:17

from Nova Scotia, but that

31:20

community did continue to face racism

31:22

and discrimination in the years that followed.

31:25

Economic changes also made life more

31:27

difficult. Seven years after the

31:29

riot, when black residents were offered

31:31

the chance to relocate to a colony in Sierra

31:34

Leone, about half of them accepted.

31:37

We've talked repeatedly on this show

31:39

about how the term race riot is really

31:41

a misnomer because it makes it sound like

31:44

people of multiple races were equal

31:46

aggressors and some kind of mass violence.

31:49

Overwhelmingly, though, these incidents

31:51

of mass violence are really the result

31:53

of a white mob attacking members of

31:55

an already oppressed race or religion

31:57

or ethnic group. That said,

32:00

the Shelburne Riots are often described

32:02

as North America's first race riot.

32:04

This also has a connection to another previous

32:07

episode. Nova Scotia

32:09

is where a large number of Maroons wound

32:11

up after the Maroon Wars in Jamaica, which

32:14

we talked about in February of seen.

32:17

And now we will move on to our last and

32:19

less appalling, h impossible

32:22

episode on this show. For a long

32:24

time, every time we mentioned Paul

32:26

Revere on our social media

32:29

or whatever, folks would ask what about Sybil

32:31

Lettington? So we talked about her in our

32:33

second ever installment of six Impossible

32:35

Episodes on September six. There

32:39

were already episodes in the archive about Paul

32:41

Revere and his famous ride.

32:43

Now it is just as likely that mentioning

32:46

either Paul Revere or Sybil Lettington

32:48

will prompt people to ask what about Laura

32:50

c Cord. Paul Revere was one

32:53

of three men who rode to raise the alarm

32:55

of a British attack on Lexington, Massachusetts,

32:58

on April eighteenth, seventeenth seventy

33:00

five. Sybil Luttington

33:02

rode to raise the alarm of a British attack

33:04

on Danbury, Connecticut, on April

33:07

seventeen seventy seven, although,

33:10

as we noted when we talked about her, there

33:12

is no primary source documentation

33:14

of that ride. And in eighteen thirteen,

33:17

Laura see Cord raised the alarm of an

33:19

incoming American attack on British

33:21

forces on foot. This

33:24

was during the War of eighteen twelve. S Cord

33:26

was the wife of James c. Cord, who

33:28

had been serving as a sergeant in the First

33:30

Lincoln Militia when he was

33:32

injured in the Battle of Queenston Heights.

33:35

His wife rescued him from the battlefield

33:37

personally. After the fighting was over,

33:40

while Laura was nursing James back to health,

33:43

American troops occupied Queenston

33:45

in present day Ontario, where they lived.

33:48

After the c Cords were forced to house some

33:50

American officers, Laura overheard

33:52

them talking about a planned attack

33:54

on British forces at beaver Dam's,

33:57

who were under the command of James Fitzgibbon.

33:59

Since Ja names her husband James c Cord

34:01

was still recovering, Laura decided

34:04

that she would raise the alarm herself. Beaver

34:06

Dams was about thirty two kilometers

34:09

or twenty miles away, and

34:11

Laura Secord made this trip on foot through

34:13

occupied territory, taking a really winding

34:16

route over difficult terrain to try to

34:18

avoid detection. She arrived

34:20

on June twenty or thirteen,

34:24

and on the incoming American

34:26

force was ambushed by a First Nations

34:29

fighting force that was allied with the British. The

34:31

American force, which numbered about five hundred

34:34

men, ultimately surrendered before

34:36

British reinforcements arrived. As

34:39

was true of Sybil Luddington. There was no

34:41

mention of se cords warning in the official

34:43

report. However, unlike

34:45

Leddington, Secord petition the government

34:48

for a pension leader in her life. This

34:50

led James Fitzgibbon to testify that yes,

34:53

se Cord had warned him of the incoming

34:55

attack, so we do have an official

34:57

statement from someone who was actually there.

35:00

It's not clear whether c Cord's warning arrived

35:02

ahead of the indigenous scouts who also

35:04

brought fits given the same intelligence,

35:07

but her trip definitely did happen. The

35:10

petition for her pension was also

35:12

unsuccessful, but Albert Edward, Prince

35:14

of Wales, who would later become Edward the seventh,

35:17

did award her one hundred pounds. Another

35:20

parallel between Sybil Luttington and Laura

35:22

cie Cord is that they have both become really heavily

35:25

mythologized and commemorated, especially

35:27

in a whole lot of children's literature. There's

35:30

also a candy company that bears

35:32

laurasie Cords name. I think listeners

35:34

have sent us laurasie Cord

35:36

chocolate before that company was started in

35:38

nineteen thirteen by Frank P. O'Connor

35:41

who named it after her, And

35:44

those are our six things that also

35:46

happened in Canada, which I guess

35:48

is really five things that also happened in Canada

35:50

and one thing that also happened in

35:52

the United States, most of

35:54

them terrible. Yes, do

35:57

you have terrible email? I

36:00

mean it depends on whether you find Sir

36:02

Walter Raleigh's head funny,

36:05

terrible, or terrible. So

36:08

this is from Susannah, and Susannah says,

36:10

Hello, Holly and Tracy, thank you for your podcast

36:12

on Sir Walter Raleigh. I grew

36:15

up in a small English town that was home

36:17

to Sir Walter for a while, then immigrated

36:19

to the US and specifically to Raleigh,

36:21

North Carolina. Given this, if you would

36:24

think I would know more about him, alas

36:26

I did not. What you said you knew

36:28

in the opening was about all I

36:30

knew, with the addition of thinking that he

36:32

was beheaded for his marriage to Bess.

36:35

Thank you for filling in all my gaps. I

36:37

would like to take a moment to

36:40

pause and say, I am so glad

36:43

I'm not the only person who seems like I

36:45

should know a lot more about Sir Walter Raleigh

36:47

than I did when I started on that episode.

36:50

To return to the letter, I wanted

36:52

to let you know about a Sir Walter Raleigh

36:54

legend that I grew up with. Sir Walter

36:56

Raleigh was given Sherburne

36:59

Castles. Sent a link to

37:01

that website, which is in the town I am from.

37:04

Rumor has it that in the nineteen seventies

37:06

some Americans were working on the lake. As

37:08

they were working, Sir Walter in ghost

37:11

form, walked on the lake toward them,

37:13

holding his head under his arm.

37:16

The Americans ran and refused to finish

37:18

the work on the lake. I'm sure this is not

37:20

true, but it is a fun story. I myself

37:23

have had an experience with ghosts in this castle,

37:25

so maybe it was a different ghost and

37:27

not Sir Walter. Side note, my uncle

37:29

worked at this castle for his whole working career

37:32

and he has many many ghost

37:34

stories. Thank you for all your amazing episodes.

37:37

I also saw you live and rally a

37:39

few months ago, which I really enjoyed. Susannah.

37:41

Thank you Susannah for this note and for this

37:44

story that I found very funny. Just the

37:46

idea of some workers and lake being like no gooda

37:49

go that cracked me

37:51

up. A little bit, and also thank you for coming to our show

37:53

and rally. We had a very good time there. Indeed,

37:56

if you would like to write to us about this or any

37:58

other podcast where a history pie gasts at how

38:00

stuff Works dot com and then we are all over

38:02

the internet at missed in History. That is

38:04

where you will find our Facebook, our

38:06

Pinterest, our Instagram, our Twitter.

38:09

You can come to our website miss in history dot

38:11

com and find show notes on all the episodes

38:13

that Holly and I have ever done together in a searchable

38:16

archive of every episode ever and you

38:18

can find it. Subscribe to our podcast

38:21

in iTunes, the I Heart Radio app,

38:23

and wherever else to get your podcasts. For

38:30

more on this and thousands of other topics, visit

38:32

how stuff Works dot com

Unlock more with Podchaser Pro

  • Audience Insights
  • Contact Information
  • Demographics
  • Charts
  • Sponsor History
  • and More!
Pro Features