Episode Transcript
Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.
Use Ctrl + F to search
0:01
When you order a pair of sweatpants
0:04
online and don't want to keep them,
0:06
a colossal, mostly opaque system of labor and
0:08
machinery creaks into motion to find them a new place
0:10
in the world. From
0:14
the outside, you see fairly little of
0:16
it. The software interface that lets you tick
0:18
some boxes and print out your prepaid shipping label may
0:20
be the UPS clerk who scans it when you drop
0:22
the package off. Beyond
0:25
that, whole systems of infrastructure,
0:27
transporters, warehouses, liquidators, recyclers,
0:29
resellers, work to shuffle
0:32
and reshuffle the hundreds of millions of products
0:34
a year that consumers have tried and found wanting. And
0:37
deep within that system, in
0:39
a processing facility in the Lehigh Valley, a guy
0:43
named Michael has
0:45
to sniff the sweatpants. Michael
0:49
and the rest of the mighty
0:52
American returns machine, ahead on Today
0:54
Explained. Amanda
1:09
Mall, staff writer at The Atlantic. Who
1:12
is Michael? Michael
1:14
is a material handler. That's the type
1:16
of job that he does. He works for a company
1:18
called Inmar Intelligence, which is a
1:20
reverse logistics and returns liquidator
1:23
that has about more than a
1:25
dozen facilities across the country where
1:27
they handle stuff that comes back
1:30
from retailers, from online shoppers. But
1:33
he is an employee in that
1:35
Pennsylvania facility that I visited
1:37
in November. Yeah, you went
1:40
inside the returns machine, and
1:42
I would like you to take us there. I
1:44
think we all know how the first part of
1:47
this works. You get a thing, you decide
1:49
you don't want the thing, so
1:51
you go get your gift receipt, your
1:53
return receipt, you print out a return label, maybe
1:56
the package came with a return label, and
1:58
you send it back. You walk it
2:01
to FedEx or USPS or UPS or
2:03
they come pick it up and
2:05
that's it. You get a credit a day
2:07
or two later or maybe immediately. But what
2:09
happens to the package? Well, if
2:11
you're in New York City like I am, the
2:14
first thing that happens is the package gets on
2:17
78 out through New Jersey and to Pennsylvania.
2:19
There is a town
2:21
outside of Allentown called Briningville
2:24
and it is a town that
2:27
exists regionally in a lot of places in
2:29
the country, which is this sort of like exurban
2:31
area where a lot of logistics
2:33
that serves a larger, denser population
2:35
center happens. From
2:38
the outside in Mar Intelligence, this
2:40
particular facility that I visited is
2:42
sort of anonymous. It doesn't really
2:44
have a much outward branding on
2:46
it. There's just all these low-slung,
2:49
extremely large white or
2:51
pale gray building sort
2:53
of laid out over the course of acres
2:56
and acres of land. The
2:58
particular facility that I visited was 300,000 square feet.
3:00
The average regular Walmart, not a super center, is
3:02
105,000 square
3:07
feet. So it's three Walmarts? Yes. What you're
3:09
looking at is a facility that's the size
3:11
of three Walmarts and a lot taller. Okay.
3:14
And if you're driving down the
3:16
highway and you saw it, you might be like, hmm, wonder
3:18
what that is. But then like a song comes on and
3:20
you totally forget it. But you did
3:22
not forget it. You went inside. Right.
3:28
When you walk into the facility, the
3:30
first thing that hits you or the
3:32
first thing that hit me was that
3:34
it is just, there's just so much
3:36
cardboard. It's like walking into a cardboard
3:38
forest. Most
3:42
of the square footage is taken up with
3:44
storage of various types, either pallets
3:46
of returns that have come in and that
3:48
need to be processed or pallets of returns
3:50
that have already been processed and are waiting
3:52
to be shipped back out to their next
3:54
destination. And then
3:56
you hit these clearings in the cardboard
3:58
soils where people People are working
4:00
on sorting different types of returns. The
4:06
first set is drugstore returns.
4:08
They are the returns processor
4:10
for a large chain American
4:12
drugstore. When you go in
4:14
the fall and look at what has been
4:16
returned, you're going to see a lot of like,
4:18
styrofoam coolers, you're going to see beach chairs,
4:20
beach towels, seasonal merchandise that has
4:22
reached the end of its lifespan for that year
4:24
and is then headed out somewhere else to see
4:27
if it can find a new life. And
4:32
then the second section that you hit
4:34
after you walk in is rugs
4:36
in this particular facility. Drugs
4:38
and rugs. Yes, drugs and rugs.
4:41
They process an enormous amount of
4:43
rug returns for a major
4:46
online retailer. Something
4:48
fascinating that I found out in the facility is
4:50
that, you know, bracketing, which is the practice of
4:52
buying like a size down or size up from
4:54
the size that you think you might need. It's
4:56
called bracketing. Yes. Okay. That
4:59
is really a well known practice in clothing. A lot of people do that. Like
5:01
you buy two pairs of jeans or three pairs of
5:03
jeans because one of these sizes will fit probably. Wait,
5:06
a lot of people buy three pairs of
5:08
jeans and then just return to. Oh yeah.
5:10
Yeah. Super, super common. So
5:13
much easier to go to the gene store, isn't
5:15
it? I don't know. Yes, yes, it is. What
5:17
I learned in IMAR is that
5:20
a lot of people also apparently do that
5:22
with rugs. What?
5:25
That's insane. Absolutely insane. Yeah,
5:28
it's wild behavior to do that. And that's why
5:30
a bare chunk
5:32
of this IMAR facility is dedicated
5:34
to rugs. Yes, yes. A
5:37
really large part of it is dedicated to rugs.
5:39
Like bigger than I expected it to be, even
5:41
though rugs themselves are big and therefore take up
5:43
more space than like shoes, it
5:45
is such a volume of returns that it takes up
5:47
like a decent chunk of the 300,000 square
5:50
feet of this facility. Is
5:53
shoes taking up another fair chunk? Because shoes I
5:55
would predict. Shoes? I didn't see
5:57
that many shoes when I was there. Shoes do get returned.
6:00
But they are lumped in with the apparel
6:02
section, which is the next section you hit
6:05
after rugs. You know, they're
6:07
significant. Apparel of all kinds, whether it's
6:09
shoes, accessories, clothes, whatever, is
6:12
a really, really high return rate category. And
6:14
so you get a lot of people processing those
6:16
returns. And that's where I encountered Michael. So
6:21
what you see are these, there's a series
6:24
of stations. There's about two dozen of them.
6:26
And each station is staffed by a single
6:28
worker. And in front of them, they have
6:30
a table. They have a
6:32
lot of bright lights so they can
6:34
see the fine details of everything they're
6:36
looking at. They have tools. They have
6:38
sanitizing wipes. They have box cutters. They
6:40
have scissors. They have all kinds of
6:42
things that you might need in order
6:45
to get a piece of clothing into
6:47
good condition. They have lint rollers, stuff
6:49
like that. And then they have a
6:51
monitor that tells them what they have to
6:53
do with every particular item of clothing
6:55
that they're evaluating based on what the
6:58
particular brand of clothing requires of Nmar.
7:01
There's like this whole decision tree
7:03
that workers like Michael have to
7:05
go through, depending on the retailer
7:07
that sold this product and what
7:09
they will allow. Did
7:14
you ask him what the craziest stuff he's ever
7:16
seen was? Well, I did get
7:18
some interesting stories in general from the various people
7:20
that I talked to. The
7:23
most common item that comes back
7:25
with pants is underwear. Well,
7:30
like not new underwear. Someone's underwear.
7:33
Like stowaway underwear. Somebody
7:36
whipped on a pair of jeans that they had pulled
7:38
out of the package that they just
7:40
received. They put them on over whatever undies
7:42
they were already wearing. And they decided,
7:44
oh, I don't like these. So they just took
7:47
the whole thing off. The underwear stayed in the pants.
7:49
They at least they were wearing undies, you know? Yeah,
7:51
at least the undies were present at
7:54
some point in the process. They were present for
7:56
too much of it. But at least they were
7:58
introduced into the equation. point,
8:00
which is why the individual humans
8:02
have to ensure that the underwear
8:05
does not make it back to
8:07
a new buyer. And
8:11
they've found wedding rings in pockets,
8:13
you find random jewelry, you get
8:15
an errant vape here and there.
8:18
Clothing is such an intimate thing. It is so close
8:20
to us. It interacts with so much about
8:23
our daily lives, even if all you're
8:25
doing is trying something on, that the
8:27
process of figuring out if it's brand
8:30
new or if anything is wrong with it
8:32
or what might be wrong with it is
8:34
just really hands-on intimate work. So it's pretty
8:36
clear what's going to happen here if the
8:38
piece is perfect. It's going back to the
8:40
retailer, it's getting resold, but I imagine it
8:42
gets much more complicated when there
8:44
are some sort of imperfections here. Well, even
8:47
if something is perfect, it might not necessarily
8:49
go back to the original retailer. Clothing
8:54
is a highly seasonal, high
8:56
turnover product category. So
8:59
even if something comes back and is totally pristine,
9:01
the tags are on, maybe it's the secret
9:03
size that somebody bought of an item and
9:05
they tried on the first one and it
9:07
fit, so they didn't even take the second
9:09
one out of its wrapping. If it's toward
9:12
the end of that product cycle, if they've
9:14
bought those two things because they were on
9:16
sale at the end of the season, then
9:18
probably in a lot of circumstances, the retailer
9:20
isn't going to want that back because then
9:23
it will just have to send it back
9:25
to Inmar again in a
9:27
few weeks to be processed again to go out
9:29
to a liquidator, to go out to a recycler,
9:32
depending on what their preference is. Over
9:35
10,000 brand-name fall fashions arrive
9:37
at TJ Maxx every week, so it's
9:39
never the same place twice. So depending
9:41
on what the type of product is,
9:43
if it's in great shape or perfect,
9:45
but it's just not cost-effective for the
9:47
retailer to take that back or they
9:49
know they don't want it back, even
9:51
if it is perfect, a
9:53
lot of times that stuff will get put into
9:55
the bin behind Michael,
9:57
behind the material handler that is... that
10:00
is designated for liquidation. What
10:03
that means is close our souls in
10:05
bulk to retailers that
10:07
deal with overstock. At the
10:10
very high end of the market, you do
10:12
get the brand names that consumers know. You
10:14
get the TJ Maxx and the Marshalls and
10:16
things like that. The Maxx for the minimum,
10:19
minimum price. Never over
10:21
the price. Never over the
10:23
price. Never over the price. And
10:27
then there's a whole ecosystem of
10:30
middlemen, wholesalers, resellers beneath that that
10:32
will take other kinds of products
10:34
that aren't necessarily fit for a
10:36
sort of branded American
10:40
consumer facing retailer like that. The
10:45
next sort of tier of stuff is
10:47
things that are either donated or recycled.
10:50
So donation happens, you
10:52
know, not dissimilarly to how it happens when
10:54
you clean out your closet and take a
10:57
bunch of stuff to Goodwill. It just happens
10:59
on a much larger scale. Donation is like
11:02
recycling, is a little bit difficult
11:04
to say what exactly happens to any
11:06
of that stuff after it's donated, because
11:08
then it's sort of off the books. The
11:11
retailer's books, it's off in Mars books. It's
11:13
the job of the donation handler to figure
11:15
out exactly how much of that stuff can
11:18
actually be used by people in need. Available
11:20
Intel suggests that a lot of that
11:23
stuff does end up ultimately
11:25
in a landfill or otherwise disposed of, but
11:27
it's really difficult to say how much because there's so
11:29
many layers of middlemen that
11:31
it becomes impossible to track like
11:33
what happens to a particular garment
11:35
after a certain point. And is
11:37
there destruction happening in the
11:40
Inmar facility itself? Is there a
11:43
category of stuff that just can't
11:45
go anywhere? There is a
11:47
category of stuff that just can't go anywhere. For
11:49
multi-brand retailers, according to Inmar's data,
11:51
it is about 15% of
11:53
stuff that they receive back that is
11:56
disposed of in various ways. much
12:00
destruction that goes on in Mars
12:03
facility itself. Like they don't really
12:05
incinerate stuff there. There are separate
12:07
facilities for that, which is of
12:10
course another layer of middle man, which is
12:12
what makes it so difficult to figure out
12:14
what happens to any particular product is that
12:16
most things pass through many hands before
12:19
they meet their ultimate end, whatever that might be.
12:28
When we return, on today's explained,
12:30
Amanda is going to tell us
12:32
why you probably had no idea
12:34
how complicated this process was, why
12:37
retailers would rather you know not
12:39
of this whole wide world of
12:41
reverse logistics. Support
13:01
for today's explained comes from Noom. There
13:03
is a whole big weight loss industry. It can be
13:05
hard to figure out what works for you. Noom
13:08
wants to tell you a bit about Noom.
13:10
Noom uses science and personalization to try to
13:12
help you manage your weight over the long
13:14
term. Noom says that their psychology
13:16
based approach helps you build new habits
13:18
and behaviors. And you can decide
13:20
how Noom fits into your life and not the
13:22
other way around. Noom offered a sample
13:24
of 4,272 Noomers. And
13:28
98% of them said Noom helped them
13:30
change their habits and behaviors for good. Sarah Frank
13:32
is my colleague here at Vox who works on
13:34
the business side of things. She had a chance
13:36
to try out Noom and tell us how it
13:38
went. There were days where I was overeating based
13:40
on my goal and days where I was under
13:43
eating. And Noom had a very clever
13:45
way of also matching my mood to those
13:47
days so I could actually see after
13:49
about a week that I tend
13:51
to eat less on days that I'm
13:53
a little anxious or stressed and days that
13:56
I'm more relaxed eating
13:58
more. And I know some people. The avatar the
14:00
opposite of that. Even find a pretrial
14:03
today it noom.com that's N. O
14:05
M.com to sign up for a
14:07
today. Super.
14:13
For today's clean comes from believes
14:15
me. Delete Me is a subscription
14:17
service. The things information you don't want
14:20
online and then tries to make
14:22
sure it does not go or sell
14:24
online. Delete Me will hunt you personalize
14:26
policy reports showing you what they found
14:29
on you when he found it was
14:31
a kid down. Sir Frank who works
14:33
with us here at Vox on the
14:36
business side of things. Try it out!
14:38
Delete Me. Delete Me scoured the internet
14:40
and sent me a reports highlighting dozens
14:43
of sites where my name, address,
14:45
age, or phone number, Listed and
14:47
instead of me having to take
14:49
action, Deleteme as actively removing these
14:51
on my behalf. You may be
14:53
able to take control of your
14:55
data and keep your private life
14:57
private by signing up for Deleteme
14:59
now at a special discounts and
15:01
today explained listeners, cities and twenty
15:03
percent off your delete. New plan
15:05
when you go to join deleteme.com/today
15:08
and news the promo code today,
15:10
it's etc Wicked Twenty percent off
15:12
his to go to join Deleteme
15:14
that com/today and enter code. Today
15:16
at checkout. once
15:18
again join deleteme.com/today.
15:21
Code to deck. Support.
15:27
for today screen comes from net
15:29
Sweet. Curious. And minutes and next
15:31
week thirty city size and businesses
15:33
have uploaded to know people. Local
15:35
couldn't look football or cold snap
15:38
flu this class financial system or
15:40
come up harm your conquer financial
15:42
management food and point o Tome
15:44
more. Local turns Twenty five this
15:46
year, and according to Net, keep up
15:49
Twenty Five rules. Of helping businesses do
15:51
more with less cause the books and days
15:53
instead of. Weeks and drive down
15:55
expenses. The last number is one.
15:57
It is your business is one of the
15:59
kindness. You can get a customized solutions
16:01
for all of your T P eyes.
16:03
You know what that means. I don't
16:05
have to tell you in one is
16:07
Vincent system all your data in one
16:10
place you can better manageable what the
16:12
law before cloth improvements. And everything you need
16:14
to go own and pulled. At
16:16
the moment that you can download movies
16:18
popular Tp Our whole post. To.
16:21
Own to did you are performed
16:23
A formal offer is not see.
16:25
Com fast explained look
16:27
fleet.com Fast explain to
16:29
get. Your. Own T p I
16:31
chuckle. I
16:43
explained back with Amanda Mile from
16:45
the Atlantic a matter if he
16:47
feels like Michael's a real hard
16:49
work and for guys, why is
16:51
it that so many retailers would
16:53
prefer to pretend like he doesn't
16:55
exist? Well. The entire
16:57
process of reverse logistics and returns,
16:59
liquidation, and Michael's jobs. All these
17:01
things are sort of our inconvenient
17:03
realities. For retailers, you know the
17:05
general public is concerned about sustainability.
17:07
They're concerned about wastes. They feel
17:10
like fair being constantly prompted to
17:12
buy things. Knowledge of this sort
17:14
of behind the scenes system ends
17:16
in exactly how large it is
17:18
and how large it must be
17:20
in order to deal with. all.
17:22
this wasted product is just not
17:24
very good for the brands. Have
17:27
are all no matter what, branded as. Nobody really
17:29
wants to talk about this stuff. One thing that
17:31
really hit me when I was walking through this
17:33
facility is that. You realize how on
17:35
special all of this stuff is when it's
17:38
just. sort of like piled in
17:40
boxes waiting to be inspected ends
17:42
and deems worthy are unworthy by
17:44
you know a warehouse worker it
17:46
is stripped of a lot of
17:49
it's sort of like contextual power
17:51
that marketing ends that display in
17:53
stores or add good stock images
17:55
on web sites this is all
17:58
made up stories about the the
18:00
clothes that we're buying, the things that we're buying, and
18:02
pallets and pallets of stuff that
18:05
nobody wanted is a reminder
18:07
that a lot of that stuff doesn't work
18:09
out. How long has reverse logistics
18:11
been this sort
18:14
of integral part of our
18:16
capitalism? Is it sort of with
18:18
the advent of online shopping that
18:20
we get here? Reverse logistics as
18:22
an industry has on some
18:25
level existed as long as retail has existed. So
18:27
like since the 19th century for retail as we
18:29
know it. But
18:33
it was just as much smaller industry before the
18:36
internet because, you know, TJ Maxx existed when I
18:38
was a kid in the 90s when nobody was
18:40
buying things online. It
18:45
didn't have the enormous volume
18:47
of potential inventory that it
18:49
has now. Before online
18:51
shopping, the return rate overall in
18:53
retail was a single digit percentage.
18:56
Return rate at brick and mortar stores still is
18:58
a single digit percentage for things sold at brick
19:00
and mortar. But online, your
19:03
return rate is going to be between 20 and 30%
19:06
overall. And for some
19:08
product categories, it's going to be closer
19:10
to 50%. So online shopping
19:12
enables retailers to sell more things to
19:14
a larger audience. So you get more
19:17
inventory overall and more sales overall. And
19:19
then you get a much higher percentage of those
19:21
sales being returned. So you
19:24
just end up with a lot more extra stuff that
19:26
nobody wants. And then the
19:28
reverse logistics industry has sort of
19:31
had to expand and become much
19:33
more technical and much more data driven in
19:35
order to adapt to that in
19:37
order to accommodate all of this stuff and find
19:39
it a new place in the world. Retail
19:45
has changed so much in the past, I
19:47
don't know, 20, 30
19:49
years, you mentioned this phenomena
19:52
of bracketing where you buy
19:55
three pairs of jeans or
19:57
heaven forbid, three giant rugs.
20:00
Just to pick the favorite once
20:02
they're all delivered by some poor
20:04
sap to your domicile would
20:07
would any of this be happening
20:09
if if Retailers didn't
20:11
make it so easy and so cheap
20:13
to return stuff. I don't
20:16
think so I also don't
20:18
think that we can put the rabbit back
20:20
into the hat because what
20:22
basically happened at the beginning of Online
20:25
retail is that retailers had to set
20:27
these like super permissive policies Because
20:30
the consumers looked at shopping
20:32
online and went I don't think this
20:34
is a very good idea I don't
20:37
think I want to buy clothes or shoes
20:39
or bedding or Sofas
20:41
on the internet. I think that that is something
20:44
that I would rather see in person What a
20:46
time that inclination on consumers part was
20:48
correct. It is stupid to buy shoes online And it's
20:50
just a thing we all do now because retailers
20:53
have trained us to do it Part
21:01
of that is this die-off
21:03
of local stores a lot
21:06
of towns in America do
21:08
not have a healthy
21:22
retail landscape of their own a lot of
21:24
malls have have gone out of business or
21:26
are sort of sparsely populated because Online
21:29
retailers starting in the mid-2000s Started
21:32
offering really really low prices prices that were so
21:34
low that a lot of them weren't profitable and
21:37
then offering these Sort
21:39
of policies that allowed consumers to
21:41
feel like there was no risk
21:43
in buying online I thought we
21:45
totally get how a job kids and
21:48
a mean crochet habit could contribute to
21:50
forgetting to return those shoes For
21:52
nine months. That's why we have free
21:54
return for up to a year And
21:56
then you get brick-and-mortar retailers who have existed
21:58
for a long time and are
22:00
then under sort of existential threat from
22:03
Amazon and Zappos and this early set of
22:07
dot-com retailers. And they went,
22:09
well, if everybody is going to buy this
22:11
stuff on Amazon and Amazon's going to sell
22:13
it so cheap, I
22:15
guess we have to get on board with this. I
22:17
guess we have to do something to compete with them.
22:19
If this is where people want to shop, and these
22:21
are the policies that they expect and the policies that
22:23
we have to offer in order for people to continue
22:26
to patronize our business, then I guess we have to
22:29
do this. Do you think the calculus
22:31
could change? Do you think there
22:33
could come a day where
22:35
shipping seven rugs
22:37
to someone is just
22:40
wildly unsustainable and
22:43
cost inefficient to the point where someone
22:46
says, you know what? You can't do that anymore. You
22:48
get your one rug, and if you don't like it,
22:50
you could buy a second one. What
22:53
we're seeing lately is that consumers are now going
22:55
to have to start subsidizing their own habits. I
22:58
think retailers have gotten to the
23:00
point where it's like, we can't just make prices
23:02
higher. The habits that we've
23:04
instilled in people and that we require in
23:06
order to figure out what your size is
23:08
in a new brand or figure out what
23:11
kind of rug you need or whatever, those
23:13
habits themselves have become deleterious to the
23:15
company because they create so much waste.
23:19
So, on the one hand, you do contract
23:21
with a third party that is supposed to
23:23
extract the maximum amount of value from that
23:25
unwanted merchandise as possible. But also,
23:27
I think we see retailers starting to try
23:30
to put incentives in place to
23:32
specifically discourage these behaviors. You
23:34
see a lot more retailers in the past couple of
23:36
years starting to charge for returns again. It's
23:39
happening? Yes, pretty much across the board.
23:42
Even Amazon, who is sort
23:44
of thought of as the industry leader
23:46
in these permissive policies, they
23:48
have started to implement little fees here
23:50
and there that are clearly intended, in
23:53
my opinion, to guide consumer behavior.
23:56
They want you to bring
23:58
back your... Amazon returns to
24:00
a Whole Foods or an Amazon Fresh or one
24:03
of their retailers. And
24:05
if you don't, then they'll charge you a dollar.
24:08
And like that dollar is a pretty
24:10
tiny fee relative to how much it costs to
24:12
take a return. But it is
24:14
clearly a signal that Amazon,
24:16
and therefore like all other retailers, if Amazon
24:18
is feeling this, then so is everybody because
24:20
they're about as well insulated from these issues
24:23
as possible. How are
24:25
consumers responding to those changes?
24:28
Actually they're responding by paying those
24:30
fees so far. There
24:33
has not been any significant decrease like industry-wide
24:35
in the return rate based on all the
24:37
data that I've seen across the board. And
24:39
then when I asked Nmar if they had
24:42
seen any difference, since a lot
24:44
of their retailers started implementing these policies designed to
24:46
reduce returns, they said that their volume was as
24:48
high as ever. So
24:50
I think a lot of consumers are still
24:52
in the process of realizing that these fees
24:54
have begun to return and realizing where
24:56
they're being nickeled and dimed in
24:59
a more explicit way. So I
25:01
think any behavior change that we see is probably a
25:03
year or two or so in
25:05
the future. But I'm not sure
25:07
exactly how much we can reverse this behavior
25:10
because the realities of trying to buy
25:12
things in person have just changed a lot. The
25:16
way we view the convenience versus the hassle
25:19
of having to go out into an errand
25:21
has changed. Those habits and
25:23
those perceptions might change again over
25:25
time. But it took us about
25:28
20 years to get to where
25:30
we are with the commonality of
25:33
buying things online and returning the four sizes
25:35
that didn't work. So this is not
25:37
something that happens overnight. And
25:39
Michael and people like Michael will
25:41
have work for the foreseeable future.
25:44
I'm happy for him. Yeah,
25:46
good for him. He said he used to work construction
25:48
and now he's doing this and this was easier. So
25:50
I'm happy for him. I'm
25:54
happy for him.
26:00
She wrote a piece called this
26:02
is what happens to all the
26:04
stuff you don't want you can
26:06
read it at the Atlantic calm
26:08
episode 1437 of
26:11
today explained was produced by
26:13
Amanda big dog Llewellyn She
26:15
had help from Amina al-sadi
26:17
Laura Bullard Rob Byers and
26:19
David Herman Take it easy
26:21
on the rug this year.
26:23
We return with more
26:25
today explained next week You
Podchaser is the ultimate destination for podcast data, search, and discovery. Learn More